Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Capital Expenditures" in M13173

Matter: Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) - 2027/2028 Proposed Expenses, Revenue Requirement and Fees Application
92 passages 6 documents

Capital Expenditures across all matters →

N-1Application - Redacted 87 passages
1.3 Material Changes in the Application p. p. 125
centre, as required to fulfil - the organization's mandate under the MAEA, enable independent Balancing Authority - (BA)/Transmission Operator (TOP) operations, and create defined physical and cyber - boundaries - Phase 2B Introduces provi...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Board approval for capital costs associated with Phase 2A ($40.91 million) and Phase 2B ($8.08 million) of the Phase 2 Control Centre project, along with forecast amortization for Phase 2A. These phases aim to fulfill mandates under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), including enabling independent Balancing Authority/Transmission Operator operations and establishing physical and cyber boundaries. Phase 2C, which focuses on grid optimization and an independent Energy Management System, is being deferred to allow for further validation and refinement based on future operating experience.

1.4 Process p. p. 125
1.4 Process - This Application reflects a more detailed budgeting process than was possible for IESO Nova - Scotia's first two revenue requirement applications. The organization has developed three - annual budgets within approximately 18...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia describes the evolution of its budgeting process, moving from high-level estimates to a detailed bottom-up approach for the 2027/2028 budget. The process integrates OM&A budgets with capital plans to ensure the revenue requirement reflects asset timing, amortization, and financing costs. Key improvements include revised OM&A cost categories to align with functional departments and the provision of multi-year indicative outlooks for 2028-2030 in response to Nova Scotia Energy Board requirements.

14 Figure 1: NSEB Direction p. p. 125
14 Figure 1: NSEB Direction NSEB Directive IESO Nova Scotia Response Accounting Policies Attached in Appendix 1 "The Net OM&A Deferral and Variance Account is approved. However, specific guidelines and accounting policies must be developed...

AI summary The document outlines a specific Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) directive regarding the Net OM&A Deferral and Variance Account (DVM). While the account is approved, the Board requires IESO Nova Scotia to develop and submit specific guidelines, accounting policies, and financial controls before any recovery of Net Ongoing OM&A amounts can occur. IESO Nova Scotia responds that its accounting policies, which govern capital expenditures and depreciation, have been finalized and are submitted for review to support the approval of variances under the DVM.

1.7 Requested Approvals p. p. 125
1.7 Requested Approvals - IESO Nova Scotia seeks the following approvals from the Board by March 31, 2027: - 1. Approval of Phase 2 Control Centre project Phases 2A and 2B and corresponding capital work in progress proposed expenditures in...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking several approvals from the Nova Scotia Energy Board by March 31, 2027. These requests include capital expenditures of $48.99 million for Phase 2 of the Control Centre project, the 2027/28 fiscal year revenue requirements of $15.19 million, and the adoption of DVM Guidelines and Accounting Policies. Additionally, the applicant seeks approval for a positive variance under the DVM for the 2025/2026 fiscal year and specific fee structures for 2027/2028.

1.8 Structure of the Application p. p. 125
1.8 Structure of the Application - The balance of the Application is structured as follows: - Section 2: IESO Nova Scotia Business Plan and Linkage to Proposed Expenditures and Revenue Requirement - Section 3: Proposed Expenditures and Rev...

AI summary This section outlines the organizational structure of the application submitted by IESO Nova Scotia. It details the content of six main sections, including the business plan's linkage to expenditures, specific proposed expenditures for the Phase 2 Control Centre project, amortization of IT and capital assets, and operational expenses (OM&A). Additionally, it covers the calculation of fees based on the revenue requirement and the specific reliefs sought from the Nova Scotia Energy Board.

2.1 Role of the Business Plan p. p. 125
2.1 Role of the Business Plan - IESO Nova Scotia's 2027/2028 Business Plan (Appendix 4) is filed with this Application in - accordance with the Board's direction in M12412. The Business Plan establishes the work IESO - Nova Scotia intends...

AI summary The text outlines the role of IESO Nova Scotia's 2027/2028 Business Plan in relation to its current Application. While the Business Plan and the 2027/2028 Plan describe the organization's intended work and objectives under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), the Application specifically details the capital expenditures, operating costs, and revenue requirements needed to achieve those goals. Together, these documents demonstrate how proposed expenditures support the organization's legislative mandate and annual enterprise priorities.

2.2 Legislative Mandate and Business Plan p. p. 125
ransition plan. It provides - for the continued delivery of IESO Nova Scotia's existing responsibilities while advancing the - further institutional and operational changes contemplated by the MAEA. - 2.3 Business Plan Priorities and Cost...

AI summary The document outlines the transition plan for IESO Nova Scotia to assume independent grid operations from Nova Scotia Power by 2027/2028. Key priorities include establishing a dedicated control center, implementing necessary IT and operational infrastructure, training a specialized workforce, and developing compliance frameworks for Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions. This transition involves updating Market Rules and the Open Access Transmission Tariff to support an independent operating model while maintaining system reliability.

2.3.3 Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access p. p. 125
2.3.3 Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access - The third enterprise priority is intended to improve how existing and prospective system users - connect to, participate in and receive information about Nova Scotia's bul...

AI summary The document outlines a priority to enhance engagement, transparency, and access for system users within Nova Scotia's bulk electricity system. Key activities include updating Transmission System Interconnection Procedures, completing interconnection studies, and revising Market Rules and the Open Access Transmission Tariff. These initiatives aim to support the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) by fostering competitive market development and efficient system planning. Associated costs are distributed across various categories, including technical resources, legal support, and capital investment for an interconnection portal.

2.3.6 Build a Strong Organization Where People Want to Work and Grow p. p. 125
2.3.6 Build a Strong Organization Where People Want to Work and Grow - The sixth enterprise priority recognizes that IESO Nova Scotia can discharge its mandate only if - it is able to attract and retain talented individuals with the requis...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its enterprise priority to build a capable workforce to fulfill its mandate under the More Access to Energy Act. The organization plans to implement leadership development, succession planning, and recruitment strategies, particularly as it assumes specialized operational responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power. The text emphasizes that a qualified workforce is essential for system reliability and safety. Associated costs are categorized under functional and Human Resources categories, with specific provisions for capitalizing employee costs related to the Control Centre project.

1. Proposed capital expenditures p. p. 125
1. Proposed capital expenditures These costs establish the facilities, systems and capabilities required to transfer real- time system operations and related settlement and market-administration functions to IESO Nova Scotia. They are prin...

AI summary The text outlines proposed capital expenditures required to transition real-time system operations, settlement, and market-administration functions to IESO Nova Scotia. These costs are primarily linked to the first enterprise priority and the completion of outstanding operational requirements mandated by the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA).

2. Amortization and financing-related costs p. p. 125
2. Amortization and financing-related costs These expenses reflect the use of capital assets in delivering IESO Nova Scotia's mandate, including information technology assets and one month of depreciation associated with Control Centre ass...

AI summary The text describes amortization and financing-related costs associated with IESO Nova Scotia's mandate. These costs include the utilization of capital assets, specifically information technology assets and one month of depreciation for Control Centre assets scheduled for March 2028. Additionally, the text notes that these expenses account for the financing arrangements necessary for a not-for-profit organization to execute a significant capital program in the absence of shareholder funding.

Proposed expenditure and revenue requirements p. p. 125
over projected operation, maintenance and administrative expenses, amortization expenses, taxes and payments in lieu of taxes, interest and other financing expenses, and a reasonable return on equity; - To date, IESO Nova Scotia has applie...

AI summary The text discusses the distinction between 'revenue requirement' and 'proposed expenditures' under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). It clarifies that while revenue requirements include OM&A expenses, taxes, and amortization, they do not include capital work in progress (CWIP). Because CWIP is not eligible for recovery through rates or fees, it must be sought as a proposed expenditure under s.29 of the MAEA. Specifically, IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Board approval for CWIP related to its Phase 2 Control Centre build-out.

3.1.1 Summary of Proposed Expenditures and Revenue Requirement p. p. 125
3.1.1 Summary of Proposed Expenditures and Revenue Requirement - The Application includes the following costs associated with Proposed Expenditures and - Revenue Requirement: - Proposed Expenditures associated with: - o capital costs (capi...

AI summary The Application outlines proposed expenditures and the revenue requirement for IESO Nova Scotia, specifically focusing on the Phase 2 Control Centre Project. It seeks approval for $48.99M in capital work in progress (CWIP) for 2026-2030. The 2027/2028 revenue requirement of $15.19M includes amortization for the Control Centre and other IT assets, alongside $14.76M in ongoing OM&A costs. OM&A costs are projected to decrease slightly due to the conclusion of the current IRP process and lower consulting costs, offset by higher interest expenses and public education costs.

3.2 Proposed Expenditures - Phase 2 Control Centre p. p. 125
3.2 Proposed Expenditures - Phase 2 Control Centre - IESO Nova Scotia's proposed expenditures in this Application are exclusively related to the - capital work in progress costs of its Phase 2 Control Centre8 build-out (the "Project"). Thi...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) approval for $48.99 million in capital expenditures to complete Phases 2A and 2B of its Phase 2 Control Centre project. These expenditures, spanning four fiscal years (2026-2030), are part of a $75.4 million project to transition system operations. The project was informed by a value analysis by FTI Consulting and IBM to determine the most cost-effective independent system operator model for grid operations.

11 p. p. 125
11 Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence Limited tactical investments Enhanced Independence Enhanced Capability Fit for future market evolution Contr...

AI summary The document presents a comparative analysis of five strategic scenarios for the evolution of the Independent Energy System Operator (IESO) and Nova Scotia Power (NSP) operational relationship. The scenarios range from 'IESO-Lite' (minimum independence) to 'Fit for future market evolution' (full independence). Each scenario is evaluated based on control center facilities, EMS/SCADA systems, dispatch capabilities, market mechanisms, and projected CAPEX and benefits. The 'Fit for future' scenario requires the highest investment ($167M mid-range) but offers the most robust market operation capabilities and highest projected benefits.

1 Figure 4: Strategy Scenario Scoring Results p. p. 125
1 Figure 4: Strategy Scenario Scoring Results Strategic scenario scoring results ( Scored dimensions Weight IES0-1,lle s red Operallons finimum lndtpendtnct Full Markel OJ)("ralions Reliability/ Operability/ Compliance 20% 1.5 3.0 3.0 4.1...

AI summary The document presents a comparative scoring analysis of various strategic scenarios based on several weighted dimensions. These dimensions include Reliability/Operability/Compliance, Independence/Transparency, Future Optionality, Implementation Risk, CAPEX Costs (Present Value), and Benefits (Present Value). The results are aggregated into a Total Weighted Score, which evaluates the net value delivery of different options, with the scoring results displayed in a comparative table.

Phased Approach p. p. 125
e, a phased - approach enables IESO Nova Scotia to establish an initial operating capability and assume key - responsibilities before completing the full build-out of the organization and supporting - infrastructure. Additional capabilitie...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia proposes a phased approach for establishing its organization and infrastructure, allowing for initial operating capabilities before full build-out. This strategy provides flexibility to refine cost estimates and project scope based on operational experience. The organization is currently seeking approval for expenditures related to 'Steady State 1' (comprising Phases 2A and 2B), which are designed as an integrated operating model. Capital costs for the Phase 2 Control Centre are estimated at approximately $75.4 million over five years.

1 Figure 6: Cost Breakdown p. p. 125
1 Figure 6: Cost Breakdown (All costs in $M) Total Phase 2A Phase 2B Phase 2C IT Costs $ 20.6 $ 0.8 $ 5.9 $ 13.9 Proqram lnteqration $ 11.4 $ 9.0 $ 1.0 $ 1.4 Control Center Build $ 9.0 $ 9.0 $ - $ - NERC Compliance $ 6.4 $ 6.4 $ - $ - Cybe...

AI summary The document provides a detailed cost breakdown for different phases (2A, 2B, and 2C) of a project, likely related to grid infrastructure or IT modernization. It categorizes expenditures into IT costs, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, cybersecurity, and NSP support costs. The table highlights that Phase 2A has the highest direct capital expenditures and program integration costs, while Phase 2C is significantly more weighted toward IT costs and direct capital expenditures.

Section 88 p. p. 125
3 The cost estimates are organized into two categories: (i) capital costs associated with - 4 establishing the facilities, technology systems, compliance framework, and supporting - 5 infrastructure required for Phase 2 implementation and...

AI summary The document outlines the organization of cost estimates for Phase 2 implementation, dividing them into two primary categories: capital costs and capitalized interest. Capital costs encompass the establishment of facilities, technology systems, compliance frameworks, and supporting infrastructure. Capitalized interest covers the financing of project expenditures during the implementation period, including contingencies. A proposed expenditure profile by fiscal year is provided in the associated figure.

8 Figure 7: Cost Profile by Year p. p. 125
8 Figure 7: Cost Profile by Year Future (All costs in $M) 26/27 27/28 28/29 29/30 Years Total Capex - Phase 2A $ 10.3 $ 30.6 - - - $ 40.9 Capex - Phase 2B - $1.3 $ 5.4 $ 1.4 - $ 8.1 Capex - Phase 2C - - $ 1.9 $ 7.9 $ 16.6 $ 26.4 Total Cape...

AI summary The document presents a cost profile for infrastructure projects, specifically outlining the capital expenditures (Capex) for Phases 2A, 2B, and 2C. The total Capex for Phase 2A is $40.9 million, while Phase 2B is $8.1 million. The project schedule shows a peak in spending for Phase 2B in the 2027/28 period and a significant long-term expenditure for Phase 2C, totaling $16.6 million over the future years.

IT Costs p. p. 125
IT Costs - IT Costs include the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, transferred - platforms, communications, interfaces, and other technology systems required to support - Phase 2 operations. This includes operational tec...

AI summary The text outlines the Information Technology (IT) costs associated with the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, communications, and interfaces required to support Phase 2 operations. These costs specifically cover the capabilities transferred to IESO Nova Scotia under Scenario 4, including settlement, reporting, and market administration functions. IBM developed the cost estimates using a capability-based assessment approach, incorporating EMS, SCADA, cybersecurity, and data analytics requirements based on vendor data, utility information, and analogous projects.

Interest p. p. 125
Interest - Interest reflects financing costs associated with capital deployed during the delivery period. It - represents the estimated carrying cost on capital expenditures incurred between the point of - investment and the point at which...

AI summary The text defines 'Interest' as the financing costs associated with capital expenditures during the delivery period. It represents the estimated carrying cost on capital incurred from the point of investment until the assets become operational. These costs were developed by IBM using an estimated project spend timing and a 5.0% interest rate. For Phase 2, these financing costs are capitalized as capital investment increases throughout the phased implementation until assets are placed into service.

Contingency p. p. 125
Contingency - A contingency of 15% is applied to direct capital costs to account for estimate uncertainty and - variation within the expected range of a Class 3 AACE estimate. Contingency is applied to direct - capital costs only and does...

AI summary The text outlines the application of a 15% contingency to the direct capital costs of a project to account for estimate uncertainty and variations typical of a Class 3 AACE estimate. Developed by IBM, this contingency reflects the project's current planning-level status, with an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20% post-contingency. The contingency is specifically excluded from operating costs and capitalized interest, covering uncertainties in procurement, design, and implementation across all project phases.

3.2.4.1 Class of Estimate p. p. 125
3.2.4.1 Class of Estimate - The Control Centre cost estimates were developed by IBM as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate in - accordance with AACE estimating standards. The estimate after contingency carries an - expected accuracy range of -15%...

AI summary IBM developed the Control Centre cost estimates as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate, adhering to AACE standards. The estimate, which carries an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20% after contingency, was derived from a mix of vendor data, Nova Scotia Power information, analogous projects, and industry benchmarks. IBM asserts the estimate is sufficient for current decision-making, with plans to refine precision to Class 2 and Class 1 levels as the project moves into detailed design and procurement.

3.2.5 Project Economics p. p. 125
3.2.5 Project Economics - While the Project is required to implement IESO Nova Scotia's MAEA mandate, IBM was engaged - to conduct an options analysis incorporating expected costs and benefits as part of identifying - the recommended solut...

AI summary The text outlines the economic analysis conducted for a project required by the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) mandate. IBM performed an options analysis and Net Present Value (NPV) analysis, utilizing benefit data developed by FTI Consulting. The analysis identifies eight areas of benefits and dis-benefits across four categories of customer-passed costs: generation capital, transmission capital, production, and carbon costs. Various scenarios were evaluated, with Scenario 5 showing a 25-year anticipated benefit of $1,010 million.

12 Figure 8: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Full Project p. p. 125
12 Figure 8: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Full Project Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios - Full Project NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$219M 37% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$328M 54% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% benefits) +$?3M 16% Cap...

AI summary The document presents a sensitivity analysis of the Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for a full project under various scenarios. It evaluates the project's financial viability against fluctuations in capital expenditures (Capex), realized benefits, and timing. The Base Case Scenario shows a positive NPV of $219M with a 37% IRR. Notably, a 'Low Case' involving a 20% Capex increase and 40% benefit reduction results in a negative NPV of -$3M, while a scenario with both 50% higher capital costs and 50% lower benefits yields a marginal NPV of $21M.

1 Figure 9: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Steady State 1 p. p. 125
1 Figure 9: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Steady State 1 Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios - essents: 1000000 Phases 2A and 2B NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$110M 30% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$173M 46% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% b...

AI summary The document presents a Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) sensitivity analysis for Phases 2A and 2B of a project. It evaluates various scenarios, including adjustments for capital expenditure (Capex) fluctuations, variations in projected benefits, delays in benefit realization, and the impact of carbon removal. The analysis shows that the project remains viable in most scenarios, though a simultaneous 50% increase in capital costs and a 50% decrease in benefits results in a negative NPV.

1. Costs and Timeline p. p. 125
1. Costs and Timeline - Risk: As with any major project, there is a risk of cost increases. The Project is complex, so - there is the potential for cost and/or timeline increases from actual circumstances differing - from assumptions, inte...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia acknowledges the inherent risks of cost and timeline overruns associated with the Project's complexity. To mitigate these risks, the project utilizes an AACE Class 3 estimate with a 15% contingency, aiming for an 80% confidence interval. Mitigation strategies include quarterly reporting of cost changes, price locking through procurement, and a governance structure for oversight. Furthermore, the phased implementation and annual budgeting under the More Access to Energy Act allow for adjustments based on real-world experience.

6. Funding p. p. 125
6. Funding - Risk: I ESO Nova Scotia has to raise significant funds to support implementation. As a new not- - for-profit entity, with limited credit history, no approved enduring fee recovery mechanism, - and no current approval for the P...

AI summary The document addresses the financial risks associated with IESO Nova Scotia's ability to secure sufficient funding for its project. As a new non-profit entity with limited credit history and no approved fee recovery mechanism, IESO Nova Scotia faces risks to project delivery and costs. Mitigation strategies include a $10 million line of credit from the Province, a phased implementation approach to manage cash flow, and a plan to seek commercial lending or potential pre-funding from the NSEB if commercial options fail.

3.2.8 Conclusion and Proposed Expenditures Updates p. p. 125
3.2.8 Conclusion and Proposed Expenditures Updates - As noted at the outset of Section 1.7, IESO Nova Scotia is requesting NSEB approval of Project - Phases 2A and 2B, regarding operational dispatch and market settlement functions respecti...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking approval for $48.99 million in proposed capital work in progress expenditures for Project Phases 2A and 2B. Phase 2A focuses on operational dispatch and Phase 2B on market settlement functions, both of which are required under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). The expenditures span fiscal years 2026/2027 through 2029/2030. IESO Nova Scotia argues that timely approval is necessary to meet in-service dates and secure external financing, while committing to provide updated costs in future s.29 applications.

3.3 Amortization p. p. 125
3.3 Amortization - This Application is the first to include amortization related to IESO Nova Scotia capital assets. - Amortization is related to the allocation of costs over the useful life of tangible and intangible - assets. As a System...

AI summary The text introduces the amortization of capital assets for IESO Nova Scotia, noting that this application is the first to include such costs. While IESO Nova Scotia does not typically have large capital expenditures like generation or transmission owners, it incurs costs for projects like the Phase 2 Control Centre and various IT assets. The amortization rates and treatment for these tangible and intangible assets are governed by the organization's accounting policy for Property, Plant and Equipment and Intangible Assets.

11 Figure 12: Control Centre Amortization Budget p. p. 125
11 Figure 12: Control Centre Amortization Budget Amortization Budget (MS) Estimated Capital Cost Amortization Period (years) 2027/2028F $15. 95 20 $0.06 $5.41 5 $0.09 $10.03 5 $0.15 $9.52 10 $0.08 $40.91 $0.38 12

AI summary The document presents a table detailing the amortization budget for a Control Centre. It breaks down the estimated capital costs and corresponding amortization periods for five distinct components, totaling an estimated capital cost of $40.91 million. The amortization values for the 2027/2028 forecast period are provided for each component, ranging from $0.06 million to $0.38 million.

Preamble p. pp. 61-196
13 Further details regarding the costs budgeted as part of this cost category are as follows: 14 Building: This involves the design, construction, renovation, fit-out, and commissioning of IESO 15 Nova Scotia's independent Control Centre....

AI summary The text outlines the budgeted costs for IESO Nova Scotia's independent Control Centre as part of a Phase 2 project. It details four primary cost categories: building construction and office space (20-year depreciation), computer hardware for IT and OT infrastructure (5-year depreciation), software solutions for market activities and system operations (5-year depreciation), and regulatory compliance costs to meet NERC standards (10-year amortization). All estimates are based on an IBM Report and align with IESO Nova Scotia's accounting policies.

1 3.3.2 Information Technology p. p. 125
1 3.3.2 Information Technology 2 Separate from the assets deployed in the Control Centre, IESO Nova Scotia will also need to 3 implement software and hardware assets to enable additional existing business functions. As 4 more employees are...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia identifies necessary investments in information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT) to support its foundational business functions and strategic priorities. This includes the procurement of hardware, such as computers and mobile devices, to accommodate new employees, as well as a specific software solution to manage transmission interconnection activities. The text emphasizes that these IT expenditures are essential for the organization's core operations and includes an amortization budget for these assets.

9 Figure 13: IT Amortization Budget p. p. 125
9 Figure 13: IT Amortization Budget Amortization Budget ($) Cost Category Estimated Capital Cost Amortization Period (years) 2027/2028F Computers $0.06 5 $0.01 Software $0.43 5 $0.04 Total $0.50 $0.05 10

AI summary The document provides a table outlining the IT Amortization Budget for the 2027/2028 forecast period. It breaks down the estimated capital costs and amortization periods for computers and software. The total estimated capital cost for these categories is $0.50 million with a 5-year amortization period, resulting in a total amortization budget of $0.05 million for the 2027/2028 forecast year.

Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget p. p. 125
Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget The costs in this category have reduced from 2025/2026 as the New Brunswick capacity contract moves to the project execution stage and the fast acting generation RFP gets closer to being awarded, but offset w...

AI summary The text compares the 2027/2028 budget to the 2026/2027 budget, noting a decrease in costs due to the New Brunswick capacity contract moving to the project execution stage and the progress of the fast-acting generation RFP. These savings are partially offset by new procurement costs for capacity and storage. The 2027/2028 budget specifically accounts for technical experts, legal, and communication support, while adjusting compensation from projections to actuals with a 4% allowance. One FTE has been reallocated to the Phase 2 transition project.

3.4.3 Information Technology p. p. 125
3.4.3 Information Technology - IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $2.1M in expenses as part of the Information Technology cost - category. This cost category consists of costs incurred for internal staff, Managed IT Services, - IT Application S...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $2.1 million for Information Technology costs to support its functional areas and business mandates. These expenses cover internal staff, Managed IT Services, IT Application Software, and other technology services. The organization's technology strategy is heavily influenced by the utilization of cloud and managed services, which are deemed necessary to execute its strategic priorities and meet future requirements.

4 Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget p. p. 125
4 Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget - 5 This cost category decreased from IESO Nova Scotia's 2026/2027 Revenue Requirement - 6 Application due to a decrease in consulting costs as a result of the prior year budget including - 7 work for the p...

AI summary The text compares the current budget to the 2026/2027 Revenue Requirement, noting a decrease in consulting costs. This reduction is attributed to the completion of Phase 2 transition planning in the prior year. For the 2027/2028 fiscal year, Phase 2 transition work is being reclassified from Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) expenses to proposed capital work in progress. These savings are partially offset by incremental increases in other cost sub-categories.

10 3.5 2027 – 2030F Outlook p. p. 125
10 3.5 2027 – 2030F Outlook - 11 Pursuant to the NSEB's direction in M12412, this section provides IESO Nova Scotia's three years - 12 of projected financial results. Figure 27 below provides 2027/2028F, 2028/2029F, and - 13 2029/2030F for...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia provides a three-year financial outlook for the 2027–2030 period, including projected expenditures, amortization, and OM&A total costs. The company notes that as a newly established not-for-profit entity with less than a year of operational experience, the accuracy of outer-year forecasts is subject to change due to the lack of historical operational data.

4.2 OM&A and Amortization p. p. 125
4.2 OM&A and Amortization - Consistent with section 29 of the MAEA, IESO Nova Scotia's revenue requirement represents the - costs necessary to carry out its statutory mandate and forms the basis for recovery through the - proposed Fee Reco...

AI summary The text outlines the components of IESO Nova Scotia's revenue requirement under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). It specifies that the revenue requirement consists of Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs and amortization expenses for capital assets. These costs are eligible for recovery through the proposed Fee Recovery Mechanism. Specifically, the OM&A reflects ongoing operational costs for the 12-month application period, while amortization includes costs for Control Centre assets and various IT assets.

1 Figure 28 - Control Centre Amortization p. p. 125
1 Figure 28 - Control Centre Amortization Control Centre Costs Cost Amortization Rate (Years) Annual Amortization 2027-2028 Amortization (1 month) Building $15.08M 20 $0.75M $0.06M Computers and Software $1 4.60M 5 $2.92M $0.24M Licenses $...

AI summary The document provides a cost breakdown and amortization schedule for the Control Centre. It details capital costs for buildings, computers, software, and licenses, totaling $38.68 million. The table specifies respective amortization periods ranging from 5 to 20 years, with an annual amortization total of $4.57 million. It also calculates the specific amortization for a one-month period in the 2027-2028 fiscal year.

5 Figure 29 - Total Amortization for all Capital p. p. 125
5 Figure 29 - Total Amortization for all Capital Capital Additions Cost Amortization Rate (Years) Annual Amortization 2027-2028 Amortization Computer Hardware $0.06M 3-5 $0.01M $0.01M Perpetual Software $0.43M 5-7 $0.09M $0.04M Control Cen...

AI summary The document presents a table detailing the amortization schedule for various capital additions, including computer hardware, perpetual software, and a control centre. It specifies the total capital cost of $39.18M, the respective amortization rates ranging from 3 to 12 years, and calculates the annual and 2027-2028 specific amortization amounts. The control centre represents the largest portion of the capital additions, accounting for the majority of the annual amortization.

5 Conclusion p. p. 125
to mature, - but submits that the evidence in this Application demonstrates meaningful progress and a - continuing commitment to prudent management, accountability and year-over-year - improvement. - Significant work remains. During the 20...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia submits that its evidence demonstrates a commitment to prudent management and year-over-year improvement. The organization emphasizes the necessity of completing Phases 2A and 2B of the Control Centre project to establish independent operational, settlement, and reporting capabilities. The proposed phased approach aims to balance operational independence with risk and cost management. IESO Nova Scotia requests Board approval for $48.99 million in capital work in progress, the 2027/2028 OM&A and amortization revenue requirement, and specific DVM Guidelines and Accounting Policies.

6 Relief Sought p. p. 125
6 Relief Sought IESO Nova Scotia seeks the following approvals from the Board by March 31, 2027: - 1. Approval of Phase 2 Control Centre project Phases 2A and 2B and capital work in progress proposed expenditures in the total amount of $48...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking five specific approvals from the Board by March 31, 2027. These requests include authorization for $48.99 million in capital expenditures for Phase 2 of the Control Centre project (Phases 2A and 2B), approval of the $15.19 million revenue requirement for the 2027/28 fiscal year, and adoption of DVM Guidelines and Accounting Policies. Additionally, the entity seeks a $343k positive variance via the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism and approval of 2027/2028 fees.

Definition of PP&E p. p. 125
Definition of PP&E Property, Plant and Equipment are tangible assets that are held by IESO Nova Scotia for use in its operations, or for administrative purposes. Property, plant and equipment are recognized when it is probable that future...

AI summary The text provides the formal definition of Property, Plant and Equipment (PP&E) for IESO Nova Scotia. It specifies that PP&E are tangible assets held for operational or administrative use, rather than for resale, with a useful life exceeding one fiscal year. Recognition criteria include the probability of future economic benefits and reliable cost measurement. Examples provided include leasehold improvements, computer hardware, furniture, fixtures, and construction in progress, with potential future categories including land, buildings, and software.

Capitalization Threshold p. p. 125
Capitalization Threshold To be capitalized, an item must have a useful life greater than one year and a cost that exceeds $3,000 per unit. Individual items below the threshold shall be expensed as incurred. Group purchases of assets that i...

AI summary The document establishes the specific criteria for capitalizing assets versus expensing them. To be capitalized, an item must possess a useful life exceeding one year and a unit cost greater than $3,000. Assets falling below these thresholds are to be expensed as incurred. However, the policy allows for the capitalization of group purchases even if the individual components within that group do not meet the minimum cost threshold.

Priority 5 - Progress Important Regulatory Outcomes p. p. 167
Priority 5 - Progress Important Regulatory Outcomes Key Activity/ Project Description Estimated Completion MAEA Linkage 2027/2028 Revenue Requirement, Proposed Expenditures, and Fees Application Application submitted in Q3 2026/2027. Q1 20...

AI summary The document outlines key regulatory activities and projects for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS) under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). Key priorities include the submission and processing of revenue requirement, expenditure, and fees applications for the 2027/2028 and 2028/2029 periods. Additionally, it details the development and stakeholder engagement for new Transmission Generation Interconnection Procedures, with expected submissions to the Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) by late 2026.

Why it matters: p. p. 180
Why it matters: - Achieves the long-term "North Star" operating model and long-term customer benefits - Postpones enhancement capex, allowing design l o be based on real operation;:il experiences, including seeing full functionality of NSP...

AI summary IBM recommends that IESO-NS adopt 'Scenario 4 – Enhanced Independence' as the preferred operating model for Phase 2 of the transition to independent operational control. This move aligns with the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) and aims to achieve long-term system value and reliability. The proposed phased implementation (2A, 2B, and 2C) is estimated to cost $75 million in capital over five years, with an expected net present value of $219 million and significant annual benefits starting in 2028/29.

Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence limited tactical investments nhanced Independence Enhanced Cap p. p. 186
Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence limited tactical investments nhanced Independence Enhanced CapabiUty Full Markel Operations Ftt for future mark...

AI summary The document outlines five strategic scenarios for the evolution of the Independent System Operator (IESO) and Nova Scotia Power (NSP) relationship. These scenarios range from 'IESO-Lite' (near-term planning role with shared operations) to 'Full Market Operations' (full market evolution). The table details specific operational components—including Control Centre facilities, EMS/SCADA systems, dispatch responsibilities, and market mechanisms—alongside associated capital expenditures (CAPEX), estimated benefits, and implementation timelines for each strategic path.

5.2. Basis of Cost, Benefit and Timeline Estimates p. pp. 188-189
5.2. Basis of Cost, Benefit and Timeline Estimates The strategic scenarios were supported by high-level Class 4 planning estimates developed to provide a consistent basis for comparing costs, benefits and implementation timelines across th...

AI summary The text describes the methodology used to develop Class 4 planning estimates for various strategic scenarios. IBM used a capability-based assessment to decompose requirements into workstreams like EMS, SCADA, and cybersecurity, utilizing a mix of vendor data, NSP information, and analogous projects. FTI Consulting independently developed the benefit estimates, focusing on operational independence and optimization. Timelines were established based on complexity factors such as procurement lead times, facility readiness, and NERC compliance obligations.

Why it matters: p. p. 192
Why it matters: - Achieves the long-term "North Star" operating model and long-term customer benefits - Postpones enhancement capex, allowing design to be based on real operational experiences, including seeing full lunctionality of NSP EC...

AI summary The text outlines a three-phase roadmap to establish IESO-NS as an independent electricity system operator in Nova Scotia. Phase 2A focuses on operational control, including monitoring and dispatching. Phase 2B introduces independent settlement capabilities and commercial transactions. Phase 2C provides enhanced independence through an independent Energy Management System and improved dispatch optimization. This phased approach aims to achieve long-term system value, postpone capital expenditures, and eliminate dependencies to accelerate the transition to an independent operator model.

7.2. Phase 2B p. pp. 194-195
7.2. Phase 2B Phase 2B remains within Steady State 1. It introduces additional independence and transparency enhancements without changing the core operating model. Phase 2B addresses the establishment of commercial arrangements under IESO...

AI summary Phase 2B of the project aims to establish the business and commercial capabilities required for IESO-NS to independently administer Nova Scotia's electricity system. While Phase 2A focuses on safe system operation and dispatch, Phase 2B focuses on participant workflows, settlement capabilities, reporting processes, and information exchange. These enhancements are designed to increase transparency and accountability by allowing stakeholders to interact directly with IESO-NS. The project has an estimated capital cost of $8 million and is subject to a formal decision gate review following Phase 2A.

9.Cost Summary p. p. 199
9.Cost Summary The Phase 2 program is estimated at $75 million over a five-year implementation period. The cost summary is as follows: - Total Capital Cost: $75 million - Incremental Operating Cost: approximately $6.3 million per year Phas...

AI summary The document provides a cost summary for the Phase 2 program, which is estimated to cost $75 million over a five-year implementation period. The program is divided into three phases: Phase 2A ($40.9 million capital cost), Phase 2B ($8 million capital cost), and Phase 2C ($26 million capital cost). Phase 2C is noted to provide expected additional benefits of approximately $20 million per year upon completion. Incremental operating costs for the total program are estimated at $6.3 million annually.

The estimated program costs are summarized in Fig 11 below, illustrating both the total investment and the allocation across each implementation phase. p. p. 199
The estimated program costs are summarized in Fig 11 below, illustrating both the total investment and the allocation across each implementation phase. (All costs in $M) Total IT Costs $ 20.7 Program Integration $ 11.3 Control Center Build...

AI summary The document provides a detailed financial breakdown of estimated program costs for Phase 2 implementation, categorized into capital expenditures (Capex) and operating expenses (Opex). It outlines specific costs for IT, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, and cybersecurity. The summary includes a 'Mid Case' total Capex of $75.4M, with low and high case variations, and allocates these costs across three distinct implementation phases (Phase 2A, 2B, and 2C).

1. IT Costs: p. p. 199
1. IT Costs: - Description: Assumes the configuration of shared platforms (EMS, etc.), transferred platforms, communications, interfaces, and other IT tools. This includes shared or partitioned EMS and SCADA environments, telemetry, and hi...

AI summary The document outlines the basis for estimating Information Technology (IT) costs associated with the IESO-NS project. It covers the configuration of shared and exclusive platforms, including EMS, SCADA environments, telemetry, and historian systems. The text emphasizes that shared systems with Nova Scotia Power (NSP) are preferred for ratepayer benefit. Cost estimates are derived from a combination of vendor quotes, NSP internal estimates, industry benchmarks, and historical project data.

3. Control Center Build: p. p. 199
3. Control Center Build: - Description: Covers the design, construction, fit-out, physical security systems, and commissioning of the IESO-NS control center. This includes the dedicated primary control centre facility and operating workfor...

AI summary The text describes the scope and basis for the IESO-NS control center build. This project encompasses the design, construction, fit-out, physical security, and commissioning of a dedicated facility. The primary objective is to provide the IESO-NS with an environment and workforce capable of conducting real-time operational control independently of Nova Scotia Power (NSP). The cost estimates for this project are derived from professional judgment and benchmarks from analogous control center projects and historical data.

8. Contingency (15%): p. p. 199
8. Contingency (15%): - Description: A 15% contingency is applied to direct capital to absorb estimate variation within the expected Class 3 range. Contingency is applied to direct capital costs only and does not apply to Opex or Capitaliz...

AI summary The document outlines a 15% contingency applied to direct capital costs to account for estimate variations within the expected Class 3 range. This contingency is specifically excluded from operating expenses (OPEX) and capitalized interest. The basis for this 15% contingency is grounded in standard industry practice for Class 3 estimates, utilizing professional judgment and established industry standards.

10. Capitalized Interest: p. p. 199
10. Capitalized Interest: - Description: Reflects financing costs associated with capital deployed during the delivery period. This reflects the estimated interest carrying cost on capital expenditures between the point of investment and t...

AI summary The document defines capitalized interest as the financing costs associated with capital expenditures deployed during the delivery period. Specifically, it represents the estimated interest carrying costs incurred from the time of investment until the associated assets become operational. The methodology for estimating these costs relies on financial models and professional judgment.

9.1. Cost Estimation Method and Assumptions p. p. 199
9.1. Cost Estimation Method and Assumptions The cost estimates for the Phase 2 program have been developed as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate as defined by AACE standards. This indicates an estimate developed at a level appropriate for strate...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology and assumptions for the Phase 2 program's cost estimates, which are classified as Class 3 Budgetary Estimates according to AACE standards. These estimates are intended for strategic decision-making and program approval rather than final execution, with an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20%. Key assumptions include a 2026 commencement date, a 15% capital contingency, approximately $6.3 million in annual operating costs, and a phased benefit realization schedule validated against benchmarks like the Ontario IESO model.

The economic analysis indicates that the recommended pathway delivers a positive long-term financial outcome, as illustrated by the Net Present Value analysis in Fig 11 below. p. p. 199
The economic analysis indicates that the recommended pathway delivers a positive long-term financial outcome, as illustrated by the Net Present Value analysis in Fig 11 below. Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios NPV IRR Key Assumptions Base...

AI summary The document presents an economic analysis of the recommended pathway, asserting that it yields a positive long-term financial outcome. This is supported by a Net Present Value (NPV) analysis showcasing various scenarios, including a Base Case Scenario with a positive NPV of $219M and an IRR of 37%. The analysis explores sensitivities such as capital expenditure (Capex) fluctuations, benefit variations, and timing delays, consistently showing positive financial returns across most modeled scenarios.

NPV Scenarios p. p. 199
NPV Scenarios - 1. Mid (Mid-case) Scenario : This scenario represents the expected or most likely outcome based on reasonable assumptions and estimates. It uses mid-case numbers for costs and benefits, reflecting a balanced view that is ne...

AI summary The document outlines three Net Present Value (NPV) scenarios used to evaluate project outcomes. The Mid-case scenario represents the most likely outcome based on balanced cost and benefit estimates. The High scenario assumes more favorable conditions, specifically a 15% reduction in capital expenditure and a 30% increase in benefits. Conversely, the Low scenario assumes less favorable conditions, featuring a 20% increase in capital expenditure and a 40% reduction in expected benefits.

4. Additional Stress Scenarios p. p. 199
4. Additional Stress Scenarios - Capex +50% : Assumes a 50% increase in capital costs, resulting in an NPV of +$188M and an IRR of 26%. - Benefits -50%: Assumes a 50% reduction in benefits, resulting in an NPV of +$52M and an IRR of 15%. -...

AI summary The text presents a stress test of the Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for a proposed program under various unfavorable scenarios. These include a 50% increase in capital costs, a 50% reduction in benefits, a two-year delay in benefit realization, and the removal of carbon benefits. The analysis concludes that the program maintains a positive NPV across all tested scenarios, demonstrating a robust and sound economic case for the investment, with primary value drivers being the timing of benefits and capital costs.

Cost Management p. p. 199
Cost Management A phased pathway allows capital commitments to be sequenced and enables updated information from earlier phases to inform later decisions. This is especially valuable where costs are planning-level and subject to the normal...

AI summary The document outlines a phased approach to capital commitment management, allowing for sequenced investment and the integration of updated information from early project phases into later decisions. This strategy is particularly useful for planning-level costs within the Class 3 estimate range. Key cost management mechanisms identified include a 15% contingency on direct capital to address estimate variations, decision gate reviews to compare actual costs against estimates before authorizing further spending, and annual reporting of actual versus forecast expenditures to ensure ongoing governance.

Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios – Phases p. p. 199
Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios – Phases 2A and 2B NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$110M 30% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$173M 46% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% benefits) +$26M 11% Capex +50% +$88 20% Benefits -50% +$16M 10% Capital...

AI summary The document presents a sensitivity analysis of Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for various project phases (2A and 2B). It evaluates the financial viability of the project under multiple scenarios, including a Base Case, High Case (reduced Capex, increased benefits), Low Case (increased Capex, reduced benefits), and scenarios involving delayed benefits, carbon removal, and significant fluctuations in capital costs and benefits. The findings indicate that the project's profitability is highly sensitive to capital expenditure and benefit realization rates.

Quantification of benefits of Phases 1 and 2 of the IESO p. pp. 21-24
Quantification of benefits of Phases 1 and 2 of the IESO - ES.15 In Chapter 4 we quantify a subset of benefits identified in Chapter 3 that can be organized in four groups leading to 12 benefit (and disbenefit) categories shown in Figure E...

AI summary FTI Consulting provides a quantification of the benefits and disbenefits associated with Phases 1 and 2 of the Independent System Operator (IESO) transition for Nova Scotia. Total benefits are estimated between $500 million and $2.4 billion (Present Value) relative to a baseline without the IESO. Key benefits include increased competition in resource procurement, improved timeliness of deployment for new generation and transmission, and operational efficiencies. The analysis also accounts for disbenefits related to lost synergies between planning, operation, and asset ownership. Benefits are measured against primary cost categories such as capital expenditure, energy production costs, and carbon emissions.

Table 3-1: Phase 1 benefits and underlying levers p. p. 52
Table 3-1: Phase 1 benefits and underlying levers Long-term security of supply Transmission planner (1) Shifting cost overruns risk ❷ Increased competition (2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement (3A) Red...

AI summary The document outlines the benefits and underlying levers associated with Phase 1 of a transmission planning initiative. Key benefits include long-term security of supply, increased competition, and improved timeliness. Specific levers identified include shifting cost overrun risks, reducing resource investment costs through competitive procurement, and accelerating capital expenditure deployment for both resources and transmission. It also highlights the avoidance of carbon costs through accelerated deployment and notes that the IESO-NS's independence supports its role in these initiatives.

Table 3-2: Phase 2 benefits and underlying levers p. p. 54
Table 3-2: Phase 2 benefits and underlying levers Direct benefits from Phase 2 Scheduler, residual energy system balancer and settlement Indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles from Phase 2 Long-term security of supply Transmission planner Scal...

AI summary Table 3-2 outlines the benefits and levers associated with 'Phase 2' of a project, categorized into direct benefits, indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles, and the scaling of Phase 1 benefits. Key benefits include improved operational efficiency leading to decreased production and avoided carbon costs, as well as increased innovation and diversity through reduced capital expenditures (CapEx). Additionally, the phase is expected to foster increased competition by facilitating greater entry into competitive procurement processes.

Phase 2 incremental costs p. pp. 56-58
Phase 2 incremental costs - 3.25 Much of the cost for Phase 2 falls into the same broad categories as Phase 1, but to a larger magnitude for one-off costs associated with the control room and other capital-intensive activities. The impleme...

AI summary The text analyzes the incremental costs associated with Phase 2 of a system operator transition, noting that costs are largely similar to Phase 1 but higher due to one-off capital-intensive activities like control room modernization. It highlights a tension between restored planning and operator synergies and the potential loss of operational synergies caused by unbundling asset ownership from operation. Specifically, unbundling may lead to increased transaction costs for activities like temporary line overloading due to information gaps and negotiation requirements.

Benefit (CADm) Low Mid. High p. p. 61
Benefit (CADm) Low Mid. High (1) Shifting cost overrun risk 47 67 87 (2) Reduced resource cost from competitive procurement - 67 135 (3A) Reduced production costs from accelerated deployment 186 274 363 (3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (f...

AI summary The document presents a quantitative benefit-cost analysis of Nova Scotia Power's 2025 Annual Capital Expenditure Plan, categorized into Low, Mid, and High scenarios. It evaluates various factors including cost overrun risk mitigation, competitive procurement savings, accelerated deployment benefits, and avoided carbon costs. The analysis also accounts for financial disbenefits such as lost synergies from planner-operator separation and accelerated CapEx deployment. Total estimated benefits range from $500 million in the Low scenario to $2,361 million in the High scenario.

Category Cost Category p. pp. 62-65
Category Cost Category Generation CapEx J_]~ ' ' Transmission CapEx ¥ - (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns - (2) Reduced generation cost from competitive procurement ) financial disbenefit ( deployment x E Cap Accelerated (3B) - (7) Increa...

AI summary The text analyzes the impact of various factors on Capital Expenditure (CapEx) for generation and transmission infrastructure. It identifies specific benefits and disbenefits related to competitive procurement, accelerated deployment, system planning advancements, and control room improvements. Notably, it discusses the potential for lost synergies between planners, procurers, and operators. Due to high uncertainty and long time horizons, the analysis utilizes a high and low case methodology to create a reasonable range for each impact, focusing on the midpoint for results.

(1) Shifting cost overrun risk p. pp. 65-107
(1) Shifting cost overrun risk - 4.18 Cost overruns are common in large capital projects, and when bor[n](#page-65-1)e by a utility with cost-based rates, these are typically passed on to ratepayers. Merchant facilities, however, are more...

AI summary The text discusses the potential for shifting cost overrun risks from ratepayers to merchant facilities through the IESO transition. Unlike cost-based utilities that typically pass overruns to customers, merchant facilities bear these risks due to pre-construction contract negotiations. The analysis estimates that the IESO could reduce capital cost overruns by up to 50% and the proportion of overspend passed to customers by up to 80% compared to a Variable Independent Utility (VIU) model. These benefits are expected to begin in 2026.

(2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement p. pp. 66-67
(2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement - 4.23 NSP, as a VIU, has historically built the majority of non-renewable generation assets. The IESO transition will allow for increased competitive procurement o...

AI summary Nova Scotia Power (NSP) argues that the transition to the IESO will facilitate competitive resource procurement, leading to lower capital costs for new generation assets. This shift is expected to attract firms with better access to lower-cost capital and create a more level playing field. The document quantifies potential savings on capital cost overruns (ranging from 8% to 18% depending on the scenario) and outlines a methodology for annualizing these savings over a project's lifetime, starting with the first realized savings in 2028.

(3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (financial disbenefit) p. pp. 68-69
(3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (financial disbenefit) 4.32 As discussed above, for both generation and transmission, we can expect faster construction timelines and a faster reduction of production costs relative to the counterfactual V...

AI summary The text discusses the financial implications of accelerated capital expenditure (CapEx) deployment resulting from the creation of the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). While faster construction timelines reduce production costs compared to the counterfactual Variable Independent Utility (VIU) scenario, they create a financial disbenefit due to the time value of money. Because costs are incurred earlier, their discounted present value is higher. This effect is expected to begin in 2026, with the first realized costs occurring in 2028.

(7) Scaling effect from independent system operation: increased entry in competitive procurement p. pp. 72-74
(7) Scaling effect from independent system operation: increased entry in competitive procurement - 4.44 In a Phase 1-only IESO, a dispatch run by the incumbent NSP may deter some participation of third-party competitors in IESO-led procure...

AI summary The document discusses the benefits of establishing an independent system operator (IESO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that separating the system operator role from the incumbent utility (NSP) reduces information asymmetries and conflicts of interest, which is expected to increase third-party participation in competitive procurements and lower capital costs for new generation and storage assets starting in 2027. Additionally, it highlights that control room modernization will enable more advanced system planning for transmission and generation by providing more detailed system information.

Core results p. pp. 76-79
Core results - 4.61 The results of the quantification described above sum to over $1.4 billion in the midpoint case, within a range of $500 million to $2.4 billion over the 2026-2050 period. The IESO transition has a diverse set of benefit...

AI summary The text quantifies the economic impacts of the IESO transition, estimating a midpoint benefit of over $1.4 billion between 2026 and 2050. Benefits are driven primarily by reduced capital expenditures and production costs, with Phase 2 accounting for two-thirds of the total. Significant benefits arise from accelerated decarbonization in Phase 1 and control room improvements in Phase 2. The analysis also accounts for specific disbenefits and the cascading positive impacts of improved control room operations on competitive energy procurement.

- 4.73 As shown in Table 4-2 below, when excluding this benefit category from the analysis, the cumulative benefits across the 2026-2050 period are $1,119 million in the midpoint case. p. pp. 80-82
- 4.73 As shown in Table 4-2 below, when excluding this benefit category from the analysis, the cumulative benefits across the 2026-2050 period are $1,119 million in the midpoint case. Unlike Figure 4-19 which shows Phases 1 and 2 as stack...

AI summary The document quantifies the transition benefits associated with the IESO (Independent Electricity System Operator) over the 2026-2050 period, excluding avoided emissions-related benefits. The analysis presents low, midpoint, and high cases, identifying key drivers such as reduced resource costs from competitive procurement, accelerated deployment of production assets, and control room improvements. It also accounts for disbenefits, such as lost synergies from planner-operator and owner-operator models, and notes negative impacts from accelerated CapEx deployment.

Competitive generation procurement p. pp. 87-88
Competitive generation procurement - A1.5 The creation of the IESO established a competitive procurement process for new energy resources identified through the IRP process. This increases access to the Nova Scotia energy market for IPPs,...

AI summary The text discusses the benefits of competitive generation procurement established by the IESO-NS. It argues that shifting risk from ratepayers to investors can mitigate the impact of cost overruns on consumers. Key benefits of competition include reduced resource capital costs through innovation, broader market participation, and access to cheaper capital from multinational firms. Additionally, competition is noted to reduce information asymmetry for regulators by incentivizing firms to reveal true costs during the bidding process.

Phase 1 supporting roles : the importance of independence p. pp. 88-90
Phase 1 supporting roles : the importance of independence - A1.14 Independence is the fundamental quality of an ISO that underlies most, if not all, benefits. However, many of the direct benefits of independence are less quantifiable. Inde...

AI summary The text discusses the fundamental importance of independence for an Independent System Operator (ISO), specifically the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). Independence is framed as a prerequisite for public trust, transparency, and attracting high-caliber staff. It argues that removing conflicts of interest inherent in Variable Independent Utilities (VIUs) fosters a level playing field for investors and developers. However, the text cautions that the benefits of independence are contingent on avoiding regulatory capture by incumbent utilities and acknowledges that Nova Scotia Power (NSP) retains significant functional decision-making over near-term capital expenditure delivery.

Generation CapEx p. p. 96
Generation CapEx - A3.1 Capacity additions (MW) are informed by two primary sources: (1) NSP's 2025 10-Year Outlook for the 2026-2035 period; and (2) the 2023 Evergreen IRP additions from the CE1-E1-R2 scenario for the remaining period up...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for determining generation capital expenditures (CapEx) for the 2026-2035 period. Capacity additions are derived from Nova Scotia Power's 2025 10-Year Outlook and the 2023 Evergreen Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The analysis excludes CapEx for non-emitting, dispatchable resources (e.g., nuclear, carbon capture, green hydrogen) due to uncertainty. Capital costs per technology are based on a weighted mixture of EIA, NREL, and Lazard estimates, excluding financing costs.

Transmission CapEx p. p. 96
Transmission CapEx - A3.5 Transmission CapEx was informed by NSP's annual Capital Expenditure Plans filed between 2020 and 2026. The most recent plan, filed in 2026, [122](#page-103-0) includes forecast spending through 2030. Our forecast...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for forecasting transmission capital expenditures (CapEx) through 2050. The analysis utilizes Nova Scotia Power's annual Capital Expenditure Plans (2020-2026) to establish a historic base spending Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR). It distinguishes between base spending and non-base spending, noting that non-base investments typically occur 1-2 years before new non-thermal resources come online. Figure A3-2 provides a visual comparison of historic and forecast CapEx against the 2020-2030 ACE and FTI forecasts.

Production costs p. pp. 96-104
Production costs A3.8 Production costs are short-run power production costs informed by primary confidential data sources provided to us by the IESO. Data sources include generation (GWh) for each major technology (coal, solar, wind, etc.)...

AI summary The text describes the methodology for estimating short-run power production costs for the 2026-2050 period. These costs are derived from confidential IESO data, including generation volumes, fuel costs, variable O&M, and startup/shutdown costs across various technologies. The analysis assumes negligible short-run production costs for wind and solar, noting that fixed costs are recovered through Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) and accounted for as capital expenditures. For accelerated deployment scenarios, the average production cost per unit is shifted while keeping total yearly generation constant as a demand proxy.

Appendix 4: Assumptions summary p. p. 105
Appendix 4: Assumptions summary Phase 1: Planning and procurement responsibilities Assumptions (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns 0-50% reduction in cost overruns from 16% historic overspend 50-80% reduction in pass-through to customers fr...

AI summary This appendix outlines the quantitative assumptions used to model the financial and operational impacts of shifting planning and procurement responsibilities. It categorizes these assumptions into two phases: Phase 1 focuses on planning and procurement, highlighting potential cost overrun reductions, competitive procurement benefits, and timeline differences for Capex and carbon emission targets. Phase 2 focuses on system operation, estimating production cost reductions from control room improvements, advanced system planning, and the resolution of synergies between planners, procurers, and operators.

Phase 2: Independent system operation p. pp. 107-110
Phase 2: Independent system operation - (5) Regained synergies from planner and operator - A5.22 This cancels out the disbenefit above. - (6) Direct control room improvements - A5.23 Innovation in control room design and management benefit...

AI summary The text outlines the financial benefits and cost reductions associated with Phase 2 of independent system operation. It details specific methodologies for calculating savings derived from regained synergies between planners and operators, control room design innovations, and scaling effects. Key benefits include increased entry in competitive procurement, decreased capital expenditure (CapEx) from advanced system planning, and reduced production costs. The document provides mathematical frameworks for calculating the Remaining Present Value (RPV) of these savings across newly and always procured resources.

(a) General Comments p. p. 110
neral Rate Application: Application filed by NSPI for approval of new rates impacting all customer classes. The Application also sought approval for the adoption of a new Cost of Service methodology. - M12600/M12273 Board Inquiry into NS C...

AI summary The document provides an overview of several pending and ongoing regulatory matters involving Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI). Key items include a General Rate Application, a cybersecurity incident inquiry, fuel cost adjustment audits, and capital expenditure plans. It also details specific disputes regarding a $500 million regulatory asset involving PHP, as well as assessment applications for NSPML and DSM plan extensions for EfficiencyOne.

Appendix A p. p. 110
Appendix A Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of 0490-097 Nova Scotia Power Incorporated NSPI - FAM SWG 0490-090 Nova Scotia Power Incorporated M11588 - NSPI - Update on ELIADC Tariff Development Review Proceeding: Review...

AI summary This appendix provides a detailed breakdown of professional fees and costs associated with various regulatory matters involving Nova Scotia Power Incorporated (NSPI). The table tracks expenditures for specific proceedings, including the ELIADC Tariff Development Review, the 2024 Annual Capital Expenditure (ACE) Plan, and the Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) compliance reporting. The entries detail specific stakeholder engagement activities, correspondence, and consultation costs associated with these regulatory filings.

(a) General Comments p. p. 110
(a) General Comments Over the course of 2025, the SBA participated in approximately 67 NSPI matters, 3 E 1 matters, 5 NSPML matters, 1 IESO-NS matter and 1 WTI matter. These included paper and oral hearings as well as Review Proceedings wh...

AI summary The Small Business Advocate (SBA) reports on its regulatory activities in 2025, highlighting participation in approximately 67 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) matters, including hearings, Review Proceedings, and information requests. Key activities involved specific assessments for the NSPML 2026 Assessment Application, NSPI FAM Audit, and NSPI 2025 ACE Plan. The SBA also engaged in various working groups and stakeholder sessions covering topics such as the Fuel Adjustment Mechanism, Demand Side Management, ELIADC successor tariff development, and grid interconnection processes.

Small Business Advocate p. p. 110
Small Business Advocate Company Total Hours for SBA and Consultants Sum of Fees for SBA Sum of Costs for SBA Sum of HST for SBA Total Sum for SBA Sum of Fees for Consultants (USD) Sum of Costs for Consultants (USD) Total Sum for Consultant...

AI summary The document outlines the professional fees and costs incurred by the Small Business Advocate (SBA) and their consultants across multiple regulatory proceedings. These include the 2025 Annually Adjusted Rates (AARs), the 2025 WACC and AFUDC, the 2025 ACE Plan, and various other matters such as the Dispatch Study Action Plan and a report on Renewables to Retail Update. The table quantifies hours worked, fees, costs, and HST for each proceeding.

104379Notice of Public Hearing 1 passage
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING _____________________________________________________________________________ The Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) has applied under s. 29 of the More Access to Energy Act , for app...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia has filed an application under the More Access to Energy Act seeking approval for its 2027-2028 fiscal year revenue requirement of $15.19 million, covering OM&A and amortization costs. The application also requests approval for capital costs related to the Phase 2 Control Centre over a four-year period, a positive variance for the 2025/2026 Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism, specific accounting policies, and fees under the fee recovery mechanism currently under consideration in Matter M13007.

104380Hearing Order 1 passage
HEARING ORDER
HEARING ORDER The Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) applied to the Nova Scotia Energy Board on November 5, 2026, under s. 29 of the More Access to Energy Act , for approval of its proposed expenditure and re...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia has applied to the Nova Scotia Energy Board for approval of its 2027-2028 fiscal year revenue requirement of $15.19 million, which includes OM&A and amortization costs. The application also seeks approval for capital costs related to the Phase 2 Control Centre for four fiscal years, a positive variance in the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism for 2025/2026, updated accounting policies, and a fee recovery mechanism being considered in a related matter.

104378Preliminary Issues List 1 passage
PRELIMINARY ISSUES LIST
PRELIMINARY ISSUES LIST The following issues will be dealt with in the public hearing about the application by the Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) for approval of its proposed expenditure and revenue requi...

AI summary This document outlines the preliminary issues for the public hearing regarding Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator's (IESO Nova Scotia) 2027/2028 fiscal year expenditure and revenue requirement. Key issues include the regulatory authority and approval requirements for Phase 2 Control Centre capital costs, the calculation of capitalized interest, and the determination of the total revenue requirement including OM&A and amortization costs. It also addresses the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism, fee recovery mechanisms, and the transfer of operations from NS Power.

104379Notice of Public Hearing 1 passage
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING _____________________________________________________________________________ The Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) has applied under s. 29 of the More Access to Energy Act , for app...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia has filed an application under the More Access to Energy Act seeking approval for its 2027-2028 fiscal year revenue requirement of $15.19 million, which includes OM&A and amortization costs. The application also requests approval for capital costs related to the Phase 2 Control Centre for four fiscal years, a positive variance in the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism, updated accounting policies, and fees under the fee recovery mechanism currently under consideration in Matter M13007.

104380Hearing Order 1 passage
HEARING ORDER
HEARING ORDER The Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) applied to the Nova Scotia Energy Board on November 5, 2026, under s. 29 of the More Access to Energy Act , for approval of its proposed expenditure and re...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia has applied to the Nova Scotia Energy Board for approval of its 2027-2028 fiscal year revenue requirement of $15.19 million, which includes OM&A and amortization costs. The application also seeks approval for capital costs related to the Phase 2 Control Centre for four fiscal years (2026/2027 to 2029/2030). Additionally, the applicant requests approval for a positive variance in the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism, specific accounting policies, and fees under a fee recovery mechanism currently under consideration in Matter M13007.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →