N-1Application - Redacted
105 passages
Assumptions and Expenditures Support " The Board directs that minimum filing requirements will apply to IESO Nova Scotia's future applications, including: • Formal support for all significant assumptions and expenditures in the application...
AI summary The Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) establishes minimum filing requirements for IESO Nova Scotia's future applications. The Board mandates that the applicant must provide formal support for all significant assumptions and expenditures, including quotes, market information, and correspondence from discussions. IESO Nova Scotia has complied with these requirements by providing descriptions for all cost categories and supporting documentation for significant expenditures where available and appropriate.
3.2.2 Options Analysis - To develop the option selection process, select an option, and prepare budget estimates, IESO - Nova Scotia engaged the expert support of FTI and IBM. FTI was engaged to develop a value - framework and to quantify...
AI summary The text describes the process for selecting and budgeting options for the Independent Energy System Operator (IESO) Nova Scotia's Control Centre. Nova Scotia engaged FTI Consulting to develop a value framework to quantify the benefits and disbenefits of transitioning from a vertically integrated utility model to an independent system operator model. IBM was engaged to assess five strategic scenarios, ranging from simple models to the construction of a new control facility with new systems, and to provide AACE Class 3 cost estimates for the recommended option.
11 Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence Limited tactical investments Enhanced Independence Enhanced Capability Fit for future market evolution Contr...
AI summary The document presents a comparative analysis of five strategic scenarios for the evolution of the Independent Energy System Operator (IESO) and Nova Scotia Power (NSP) operational relationship. The scenarios range from 'IESO-Lite' (minimum independence) to 'Fit for future market evolution' (full independence). Each scenario is evaluated based on control center facilities, EMS/SCADA systems, dispatch capabilities, market mechanisms, and projected CAPEX and benefits. The 'Fit for future' scenario requires the highest investment ($167M mid-range) but offers the most robust market operation capabilities and highest projected benefits.
- Scenario 4 Enhanced Independence scored the highest, balancing operational factors with costs and benefits, as shown in Figure 4 below. As a result, it is the Project scenario sought - 7 for approval in this Application.
AI summary The document identifies 'Scenario 4 Enhanced Independence' as the preferred project scenario for the Application. This selection is based on a comparative analysis that scored the scenario highest by balancing operational factors against associated costs and benefits.
in-service. IESO Nova Scotia retained IBM to provide expert support in the development of the - budget for the Project. For additional details see: Appendix 6 IBM Control Centre Options - Analysis. - Capital costs applied for approval in t...
AI summary The text outlines the capital costs for the IESO Nova Scotia project, specifically focusing on the requirements for 'Steady State 1'. It states that the capital costs of $49.0 million are necessary to establish the operational, settlement, and market administration capabilities required for IESO Nova Scotia to function as an independent system operator under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). The text emphasizes that many investments support the overall project goals rather than being isolated to a single phase.
1 Figure 6: Cost Breakdown (All costs in $M) Total Phase 2A Phase 2B Phase 2C IT Costs $ 20.6 $ 0.8 $ 5.9 $ 13.9 Proqram lnteqration $ 11.4 $ 9.0 $ 1.0 $ 1.4 Control Center Build $ 9.0 $ 9.0 $ - $ - NERC Compliance $ 6.4 $ 6.4 $ - $ - Cybe...
AI summary The document provides a detailed cost breakdown for different phases (2A, 2B, and 2C) of a project, likely related to grid infrastructure or IT modernization. It categorizes expenditures into IT costs, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, cybersecurity, and NSP support costs. The table highlights that Phase 2A has the highest direct capital expenditures and program integration costs, while Phase 2C is significantly more weighted toward IT costs and direct capital expenditures.
3 The cost estimates are organized into two categories: (i) capital costs associated with - 4 establishing the facilities, technology systems, compliance framework, and supporting - 5 infrastructure required for Phase 2 implementation and...
AI summary The document outlines the organization of cost estimates for Phase 2 implementation, dividing them into two primary categories: capital costs and capitalized interest. Capital costs encompass the establishment of facilities, technology systems, compliance frameworks, and supporting infrastructure. Capitalized interest covers the financing of project expenditures during the implementation period, including contingencies. A proposed expenditure profile by fiscal year is provided in the associated figure.
IT Costs - IT Costs include the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, transferred - platforms, communications, interfaces, and other technology systems required to support - Phase 2 operations. This includes operational tec...
AI summary The text outlines the Information Technology (IT) costs associated with the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, communications, and interfaces required to support Phase 2 operations. These costs specifically cover the capabilities transferred to IESO Nova Scotia under Scenario 4, including settlement, reporting, and market administration functions. IBM developed the cost estimates using a capability-based assessment approach, incorporating EMS, SCADA, cybersecurity, and data analytics requirements based on vendor data, utility information, and analogous projects.
NS Power Support Costs - NS Power Support Costs represent incremental costs associated with support provided by NS - Power to facilitate the implementation of Phase 2, including system transition activities, - knowledge transfer, handover...
AI summary The text outlines the 'NS Power Support Costs' associated with the phased transition of responsibilities to IESO Nova Scotia under Scenario 4. These incremental costs include system transition activities, knowledge transfer, handover, reconfiguration of shared systems, and operational readiness. The estimates, developed by IBM using NS Power data, specifically cover activities during Steady State 1 where NS Power maintains support while transferring operational, settlement, reporting, and market administration capabilities to IESO Nova Scotia.
Other - Other costs cover internal IESO Nova Scotia effort, third-party vendor costs for systems to be - transferred or shared, training coordination, market changes and miscellaneous - implementation items. This category captures costs th...
AI summary The text describes 'Other' costs associated with Phase 2 implementation, which include internal IESO Nova Scotia efforts, third-party vendor costs for system transfers or sharing, training coordination, and miscellaneous items related to market changes. It specifies that these costs are necessary to complete the project scope but do not fit into predefined categories. The cost estimate was developed by IBM based on vendor information, industry benchmarks, past project experience, and professional judgment.
Interest - Interest reflects financing costs associated with capital deployed during the delivery period. It - represents the estimated carrying cost on capital expenditures incurred between the point of - investment and the point at which...
AI summary The text defines 'Interest' as the financing costs associated with capital expenditures during the delivery period. It represents the estimated carrying cost on capital incurred from the point of investment until the assets become operational. These costs were developed by IBM using an estimated project spend timing and a 5.0% interest rate. For Phase 2, these financing costs are capitalized as capital investment increases throughout the phased implementation until assets are placed into service.
Contingency - A contingency of 15% is applied to direct capital costs to account for estimate uncertainty and - variation within the expected range of a Class 3 AACE estimate. Contingency is applied to direct - capital costs only and does...
AI summary The text outlines the application of a 15% contingency to the direct capital costs of a project to account for estimate uncertainty and variations typical of a Class 3 AACE estimate. Developed by IBM, this contingency reflects the project's current planning-level status, with an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20% post-contingency. The contingency is specifically excluded from operating costs and capitalized interest, covering uncertainties in procurement, design, and implementation across all project phases.
3.2.4.1 Class of Estimate - The Control Centre cost estimates were developed by IBM as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate in - accordance with AACE estimating standards. The estimate after contingency carries an - expected accuracy range of -15%...
AI summary IBM developed the Control Centre cost estimates as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate, adhering to AACE standards. The estimate, which carries an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20% after contingency, was derived from a mix of vendor data, Nova Scotia Power information, analogous projects, and industry benchmarks. IBM asserts the estimate is sufficient for current decision-making, with plans to refine precision to Class 2 and Class 1 levels as the project moves into detailed design and procurement.
3.2.5 Project Economics - While the Project is required to implement IESO Nova Scotia's MAEA mandate, IBM was engaged - to conduct an options analysis incorporating expected costs and benefits as part of identifying - the recommended solut...
AI summary The text outlines the economic analysis conducted for a project required by the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) mandate. IBM performed an options analysis and Net Present Value (NPV) analysis, utilizing benefit data developed by FTI Consulting. The analysis identifies eight areas of benefits and dis-benefits across four categories of customer-passed costs: generation capital, transmission capital, production, and carbon costs. Various scenarios were evaluated, with Scenario 5 showing a 25-year anticipated benefit of $1,010 million.
12 Figure 8: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Full Project Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios - Full Project NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$219M 37% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$328M 54% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% benefits) +$?3M 16% Cap...
AI summary The document presents a sensitivity analysis of the Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for a full project under various scenarios. It evaluates the project's financial viability against fluctuations in capital expenditures (Capex), realized benefits, and timing. The Base Case Scenario shows a positive NPV of $219M with a 37% IRR. Notably, a 'Low Case' involving a 20% Capex increase and 40% benefit reduction results in a negative NPV of -$3M, while a scenario with both 50% higher capital costs and 50% lower benefits yields a marginal NPV of $21M.
1 Figure 9: NPV Sensitivity Analysis - Steady State 1 Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios - essents: 1000000 Phases 2A and 2B NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$110M 30% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$173M 46% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% b...
AI summary The document presents a Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) sensitivity analysis for Phases 2A and 2B of a project. It evaluates various scenarios, including adjustments for capital expenditure (Capex) fluctuations, variations in projected benefits, delays in benefit realization, and the impact of carbon removal. The analysis shows that the project remains viable in most scenarios, though a simultaneous 50% increase in capital costs and a 50% decrease in benefits results in a negative NPV.
1. Costs and Timeline - Risk: As with any major project, there is a risk of cost increases. The Project is complex, so - there is the potential for cost and/or timeline increases from actual circumstances differing - from assumptions, inte...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia acknowledges the inherent risks of cost and timeline overruns associated with the Project's complexity. To mitigate these risks, the project utilizes an AACE Class 3 estimate with a 15% contingency, aiming for an 80% confidence interval. Mitigation strategies include quarterly reporting of cost changes, price locking through procurement, and a governance structure for oversight. Furthermore, the phased implementation and annual budgeting under the More Access to Energy Act allow for adjustments based on real-world experience.
4 Figure 15 - Cost Category Map 5 - 6 Figure 16 below demonstrations the redistribution of compensation from the 2026/2027 - 7 application into the functional categories of this 2027/2028 Application.
AI summary The text introduces a cost category map (Figure 15) and refers to subsequent figures (Figure 16) that demonstrate how compensation from the 2026/2027 application is redistributed into functional categories for the 2027/2028 Application.
13Merged with "Legal and Regulato1y" in 27/28. 14Merged with "System Planning and Procurement" in 27/28. 15Split into two new categories: "Information Technology" and "Facilities" in 27/28. 16Also referenced as "Phase II Transitional Costs...
AI summary The text describes the reorganization of various cost categories within a regulatory filing. Specific items are being merged into 'Legal and Regulatory' and 'System Planning and Procurement' sections, while others are being split into new 'Information Technology' and 'Facilities' categories. Additionally, it notes the redistribution of 'Phase II Transitional Costs' from the 26/27 application into various operational areas including System Operations, Communications and Stakeholder, Human Resources, and Corporate Services.
Staffing and Compensation - Consistent with IESO Nova Scotia's prior revenue requirement applications (M12412 and - M12663), compensation continues to be the single largest category of cost across all functional - areas of the organization...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its staffing and compensation requirements for fiscal year 2027/2028, noting that compensation remains its largest OM&A cost at approximately $6.9M. The staffing plan reflects the organization's growth as it assumes new responsibilities under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), specifically the transfer of bulk system control operations from Nova Scotia Power. The plan projects a phased increase from 55 to 91 full-time equivalents (FTEs) by March 2028, prioritizing internal hiring to build expertise and reduce project costs.
Figure 17 - FTE Projected Increases from 2026/2027 to 2027/2028 Consistent with IESO Nova Scotia's prior revenue requirement applications (M12412 and M12663), compensation continues to be single largest category of cost across all function...
AI summary The document discusses IESO Nova Scotia's staffing and compensation strategy for the 2027/2028 fiscal year. It highlights that compensation remains the organization's largest cost category, totaling approximately $6.9M. Based on a benchmarking study by Marsh, IESO Nova Scotia intends to adopt a scalable compensation framework with benchmarked pay bands to align with market median pay. The report concluded that current compensation is reasonable and below market medians, and the new framework will support future hiring and employee progression without altering the current OM&A budget.
2 4 Compensation: IESO Nova Scotia has included 26 roles in the System Planning and Procurement 5 function for 2027 / 2028, including continuity of the 23 roles budgeted in 2026/ 2027. For 6 2027 / 2028 this category includes the VP Planni...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its compensation requirements for 26 roles within the System Planning and Procurement function for the 2027/2028 period. This includes 23 continuing roles and 3 new positions, such as a Director of System Planning and an Energy Resource Procurement Analyst, to manage increasing workloads and procurement activities. The estimates are based on current staff rates, a four percent cost-of-living adjustment, and employer payroll costs, benchmarked against the Marsh Report.
Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget The costs in this category have reduced from 2025/2026 as the New Brunswick capacity contract moves to the project execution stage and the fast acting generation RFP gets closer to being awarded, but offset w...
AI summary The text compares the 2027/2028 budget to the 2026/2027 budget, noting a decrease in costs due to the New Brunswick capacity contract moving to the project execution stage and the progress of the fast-acting generation RFP. These savings are partially offset by new procurement costs for capacity and storage. The 2027/2028 budget specifically accounts for technical experts, legal, and communication support, while adjusting compensation from projections to actuals with a 4% allowance. One FTE has been reallocated to the Phase 2 transition project.
1 Figure 19: OM&A Costs for the System Operations Cost Category Ongoing OM&A Budget (S) Cost Category 2026/2027F Restated 2027/2028F Total System Operations 1.06 0.74 Compensation 0.56 0.45 System Operation Solutions 0.50 0.29 2
AI summary The document provides a financial breakdown of the Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs for the System Operations cost category. It presents a restated budget for 2026/2027F and a forecast for 2027/2028F, showing a projected decrease in total costs from $1.06 million to $0.74 million. The costs are divided into two primary sub-categories: Compensation and System Operation Solutions.
1 Figure 20: OM&A Costs for the Information Technology Cost Category Ongoing OM&A Budget ($) Cost Category 2026/2027F Restated 2027/2028F Total Technology 2.14 2.10 Compensation 0.96 0.66 IT Application Software 0.89 0.81 Managed IT Servic...
AI summary The document presents a breakdown of the Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs for the Information Technology cost category. It provides a comparative budget for two fiscal periods: 2026/2027F Restated and 2027/2028F. The figures illustrate a projected decrease in total technology costs, primarily driven by a reduction in compensation and IT application software expenses, while managed IT services and other IT costs are projected to increase.
1 3.4.6 Finance 2 IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $1.03M in ongoing costs as part of the Finance cost category. This 3 cost category primarily consists of costs incurred in respect of financial services other than 4 insurance, which are cove...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $1.03M for ongoing finance costs in the 2026/2027 forecast. These costs primarily relate to financial services, excluding insurance, which is categorized under Corporation Administration. The Corporation asserts that these finance costs are a foundational necessity for executing its strategic priorities. A provided figure summarizes the sub-categories of finance costs and compares them against the restated forecast.
3.4.7 Human Resources IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $0.59M in ongoing costs as part of the Human Resources OM&A cost category. This cost category primarily consists of compensation for professional staff, recruitment fees, consulting and a...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $0.59M for Human Resources as part of its Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs. These funds are designated for professional staff compensation, recruitment fees, consulting, and training and professional development. The expenditure is framed as essential for meeting the organization's strategic priorities, specifically the objective to build a strong organizational culture that supports employee growth and retention.
1 3.4.9 Corporate Services 2 IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $1.53M in costs as part of the Corporate Services OM&A cost 3 category. This cost category primarily consists of various types of corporate expenses, including executive compensati...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $1.53 million for Corporate Services as part of its Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs. This budget covers essential corporate expenses such as executive compensation, consulting, travel, insurance, memberships, and employee education. These expenditures are identified as necessary to support the organization's strategic priorities. The document also references a summary of Communications & Stakeholder Engagement costs in comparison to the restated 2026/2027 forecast.
4 Comparison to 2026/2027 Budget - 5 This cost category decreased from IESO Nova Scotia's 2026/2027 Revenue Requirement - 6 Application due to a decrease in consulting costs as a result of the prior year budget including - 7 work for the p...
AI summary The text compares the current budget to the 2026/2027 Revenue Requirement, noting a decrease in consulting costs. This reduction is attributed to the completion of Phase 2 transition planning in the prior year. For the 2027/2028 fiscal year, Phase 2 transition work is being reclassified from Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) expenses to proposed capital work in progress. These savings are partially offset by incremental increases in other cost sub-categories.
10 Figure 30 - 2025-2026 Forecast to Actual Cost Variance 2025-26 Revenue Application Actual 2025-26 Actual Over/(Under) Revenue Application $ Actual Over/(Under) Revenue Application % Administration Salaries and Wages $1,572,751 $1,047,76...
AI summary The document presents a variance analysis between the 2025-26 Revenue Application and the actual costs incurred for the same period. While total expenses were approximately $237,310 lower than forecasted (a 3.0% variance), specific categories showed significant deviations. Notably, Administration Salaries and Wages were 33.4% under budget, and NS Power Employee Transfers and IRP Consulting were 49.9% under budget. Conversely, Transition and Operational Planning costs were 74.4% over the forecast. The net revenue requirement versus actual expense showed a 6.5% under-spend.
Impairment of Accounts Receivable IESO Nova Scotia recognises a loss allowance for expected credit losses ("ECLs") on accounts receivable in accordance with IFRS 9 – Financial Instruments. The simplified approach is applied to trade receiv...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its accounting treatment for the impairment of accounts receivable, specifically focusing on the recognition of expected credit losses (ECLs). The entity follows IFRS 9 guidelines using a simplified approach for trade receivables, which requires recognizing lifetime ECLs at the point of initial recognition. The assessment methodology incorporates historical credit loss data integrated with forward-looking economic forecasts. Receivables are formally written off only when recovery is deemed impossible.
Classification and Measurement IESO Nova Scotia's financial assets consist of cash and trade accounts receivable. These assets meet the criteria for measurement at amortized cost, as they are held within a business model whose objective is...
AI summary The text outlines the classification and measurement of financial assets for IESO Nova Scotia. It specifies that cash and trade accounts receivable are measured at amortized cost. This approach is justified because these assets are held within a business model aimed at collecting contractual cash flows consisting of principal and interest. Furthermore, trade accounts receivable without significant financing components are initially recognized at the transaction price per IFRS 15 and subsequently measured at amortized cost.
Letter of Credit IESO Nova Scotia has issued a letter of credit in the ordinary course of business. - The letter of credit represents a financial guarantee contract under IFRS 9 only if it requires IESO Nova Scotia to make specified paymen...
AI summary The text outlines the accounting treatment for a letter of credit issued by IESO Nova Scotia in the ordinary course of business. It specifies that the letter of credit is treated as a financial guarantee contract under IFRS 9 only if it requires reimbursement for losses due to a failure to meet contractual obligations. If the likelihood of payment is remote, it is disclosed as a commitment rather than recognized on the statement of financial position; however, a liability is recognized once payment becomes probable.
Government Grants Government grant revenue is assistance provided by the government in return for compliance with specified conditions relating to operating activities, public interest mandates, or the delivery of system operator functions...
AI summary The text defines government grant revenue as assistance provided by the government for compliance with specific operating conditions, public interest mandates, or system operator functions. It specifies that such funding is treated as revenue under IAS 20 and is not considered customer consideration under IFRS 15. IESO Nova Scotia recognizes this revenue on a gross basis to ensure transparency regarding government support and operational costs, deferring recognition as a liability until grant conditions are met.
Initial Measurement of Right-of-Use Assets The ROU asset is initially measured at cost, which comprises: - The initial amount of the lease liability; - Any lease payments made at or before the commencement date, less any lease - incentives...
AI summary The text defines the initial measurement criteria for Right-of-Use (ROU) assets for IESO Nova Scotia. It specifies that the ROU asset is measured at cost, which includes the initial lease liability amount, lease payments made before the commencement date (minus incentives), any initial direct costs incurred by the utility, and estimated costs for dismantling, removing, or restoring the asset or site as required by the lease terms.
Preventive controls - Board approved budget requirement. All procurement must be included in the Boardapproved annual budget or supported by an approved budget amendment. This control prevents unauthorized and unfunded spending ensuring al...
AI summary The text outlines the preventive controls established within the organization's procurement and financial policies to ensure fiscal accountability and prevent unauthorized spending. Key controls include requiring all procurement to align with Board-approved budgets, establishing clear dollar thresholds for approval authorities, and mandating purchase orders for significant commitments. Additionally, the document highlights segregation of duties, competitive procurement processes, corporate credit card restrictions, and formal employee expense reporting as essential mechanisms to mitigate fraud and ensure value for money.
3.Legislative and Strategic Context Phase 2 represents the final step in the transition of operating responsibilities from NSP to IESO-NS, as required under the 2024 More Access to Energy Act . Following Phase 1 operations, the focus of Ph...
AI summary The text describes Phase 2 of the transition of operating responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSP) to the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS), as mandated by the 2024 More Access to Energy Act. The objective is to establish independent operational control while prioritizing system reliability, cost optimization, and value for customers. IBM was engaged to ensure the transition balances legislative compliance with prudence, affordability, and long-term operational feasibility, viewing the change as a foundational structural shift rather than a mere compliance exercise.
Scenario 2 - Shared Operations Scenario 2 achieves a faster transition by leveraging NSP's existing operational systems and control room infrastructure. IESO-NS personnel would utilize shared systems and facilities, minimizing implementati...
AI summary The document describes 'Scenario 2 - Shared Operations,' a model where the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS) utilizes Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSP) existing operational systems and control room infrastructure. While this approach accelerates the transition and minimizes implementation costs and timelines, it creates significant operational, cyber, and governance dependencies on NSP. The text notes that while technically feasible, this model restricts the future flexibility and independence of the IESO-NS.
9.Cost Summary The Phase 2 program is estimated at $75 million over a five-year implementation period. The cost summary is as follows: - Total Capital Cost: $75 million - Incremental Operating Cost: approximately $6.3 million per year Phas...
AI summary The document provides a cost summary for the Phase 2 program, which is estimated to cost $75 million over a five-year implementation period. The program is divided into three phases: Phase 2A ($40.9 million capital cost), Phase 2B ($8 million capital cost), and Phase 2C ($26 million capital cost). Phase 2C is noted to provide expected additional benefits of approximately $20 million per year upon completion. Incremental operating costs for the total program are estimated at $6.3 million annually.
The estimated program costs are summarized in Fig 11 below, illustrating both the total investment and the allocation across each implementation phase. (All costs in $M) Total IT Costs $ 20.7 Program Integration $ 11.3 Control Center Build...
AI summary The document provides a detailed financial breakdown of estimated program costs for Phase 2 implementation, categorized into capital expenditures (Capex) and operating expenses (Opex). It outlines specific costs for IT, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, and cybersecurity. The summary includes a 'Mid Case' total Capex of $75.4M, with low and high case variations, and allocates these costs across three distinct implementation phases (Phase 2A, 2B, and 2C).
1. IT Costs: - Description: Assumes the configuration of shared platforms (EMS, etc.), transferred platforms, communications, interfaces, and other IT tools. This includes shared or partitioned EMS and SCADA environments, telemetry, and hi...
AI summary The document outlines the basis for estimating Information Technology (IT) costs associated with the IESO-NS project. It covers the configuration of shared and exclusive platforms, including EMS, SCADA environments, telemetry, and historian systems. The text emphasizes that shared systems with Nova Scotia Power (NSP) are preferred for ratepayer benefit. Cost estimates are derived from a combination of vendor quotes, NSP internal estimates, industry benchmarks, and historical project data.
2. Program Integration: - Description: Includes program management, design authority, process, change and quality assurance, and program administration. This covers the resources and activities required to coordinate design, delivery, and...
AI summary This section describes the 'Program Integration' component of the project, which encompasses program management, design authority, process oversight, quality assurance, and administration. It covers the resources and activities necessary to coordinate the design, delivery, and quality assurance across all Phase 2 workstreams, including the oversight of vendors and system integrators. The cost estimate for these activities was developed using a bottom-up approach based on detailed work packages, professional judgment, internal planning, and past project experience.
6. NSP Support Costs: - Description: Includes internal Nova Scotia Power effort supporting transition, handover, and system readiness. This reflects the effort required from Nova Scotia Power to support the transfer or shared operation of...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power (NSP) identifies 'NSP Support Costs' as a category covering the internal efforts required to facilitate the transition, handover, and system readiness for shared operations with IESO-NS. These costs specifically account for the transfer of systems and knowledge during implementation. The estimates for these costs are provided directly by Nova Scotia Power.
7. Other: - Description: Covers internal IESO-NS effort, software licenses, third-party vendor costs for systems to be transferred/shared, training, and miscellaneous implementation items. This category captures costs that do not fall with...
AI summary This section describes 'Other' costs associated with the Phase 2 implementation of the IESO-NS system. These costs include internal efforts, software licenses, third-party vendor expenses for system transfers or sharing, training, and miscellaneous implementation items not captured in other categories. The estimates for these costs are based on a combination of vendor quotes, industry benchmarks, and professional judgment.
8. Contingency (15%): - Description: A 15% contingency is applied to direct capital to absorb estimate variation within the expected Class 3 range. Contingency is applied to direct capital costs only and does not apply to Opex or Capitaliz...
AI summary The document outlines a 15% contingency applied to direct capital costs to account for estimate variations within the expected Class 3 range. This contingency is specifically excluded from operating expenses (OPEX) and capitalized interest. The basis for this 15% contingency is grounded in standard industry practice for Class 3 estimates, utilizing professional judgment and established industry standards.
10. Capitalized Interest: - Description: Reflects financing costs associated with capital deployed during the delivery period. This reflects the estimated interest carrying cost on capital expenditures between the point of investment and t...
AI summary The document defines capitalized interest as the financing costs associated with capital expenditures deployed during the delivery period. Specifically, it represents the estimated interest carrying costs incurred from the time of investment until the associated assets become operational. The methodology for estimating these costs relies on financial models and professional judgment.
11. Opex Items: - Description: Includes incremental annual operating costs such as staffing, system operating costs, NERC compliance, training, and telecommunications. This reflects the ongoing annual operating costs required to sustain IE...
AI summary The document outlines the estimated annual operating expenses (OPEX) for IESO-NS's independent operations, totaling approximately $75 million. These costs cover staffing, system operations, NERC compliance, training, and telecommunications. The estimates are based on professional judgment and industry benchmarks, categorized as Class 3 accuracy (-15% to +20%). The text justifies the $64 million to $90 million range as reasonable for a large-scale operational transformation involving complex systems and governance development.
9.2. Incremental Costs and Transfers from NSP A clear distinction should be drawn between costs that are incremental — representing new investment required to establish independent operational capability — and costs that represent the tran...
AI summary The text distinguishes between two types of costs associated with the Phase 2 program regarding the transition of responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power (NSP) to the IESO-NS. Incremental costs refer to new investments required to build independent operational capabilities, such as a control centre, operational technology, staffing, and governance. In contrast, transferred costs involve existing functions and cost structures currently funded by NSP that will be moved to IESO-NS as part of the legislatively mandated transition.
The economic analysis indicates that the recommended pathway delivers a positive long-term financial outcome, as illustrated by the Net Present Value analysis in Fig 11 below. Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios NPV IRR Key Assumptions Base...
AI summary The document presents an economic analysis of the recommended pathway, asserting that it yields a positive long-term financial outcome. This is supported by a Net Present Value (NPV) analysis showcasing various scenarios, including a Base Case Scenario with a positive NPV of $219M and an IRR of 37%. The analysis explores sensitivities such as capital expenditure (Capex) fluctuations, benefit variations, and timing delays, consistently showing positive financial returns across most modeled scenarios.
NPV Scenarios - 1. Mid (Mid-case) Scenario : This scenario represents the expected or most likely outcome based on reasonable assumptions and estimates. It uses mid-case numbers for costs and benefits, reflecting a balanced view that is ne...
AI summary The document outlines three Net Present Value (NPV) scenarios used to evaluate project outcomes. The Mid-case scenario represents the most likely outcome based on balanced cost and benefit estimates. The High scenario assumes more favorable conditions, specifically a 15% reduction in capital expenditure and a 30% increase in benefits. Conversely, the Low scenario assumes less favorable conditions, featuring a 20% increase in capital expenditure and a 40% reduction in expected benefits.
10.2. Potential Cost Risk Areas The Phase 2 program was designed to optimize cost and implementation risk while protecting reliability. Notwithstanding the positive overall case, the following cost risk areas are identified as warranting p...
AI summary The document introduces a section identifying potential cost risk areas associated with the Phase 2 program. It notes that while the program's overall case is positive, specific risks regarding cost and implementation must be monitored to ensure project reliability and fiscal responsibility during the execution phase.
Implementation Timing Risk Delays to Phase 2A would postpone realization of the anticipated benefits and could require adjustments to program schedules, procurement activities, and implementation plans. Any associated cost implications wou...
AI summary The document addresses the risks associated with potential delays in the implementation of Phase 2A. It notes that any postponement would delay the realization of anticipated benefits and necessitate adjustments to program schedules, procurement activities, and overall implementation plans. Furthermore, the text indicates that the specific financial consequences of such delays would be contingent upon both the duration and the specific nature of the delay.
Planning Estimate Uncertainty As a Class 3 estimate, the program cost appropriately carries a -15% to +20% range. This uncertainty is typical of planning-level estimates and should be considered when evaluating the projected program costs...
AI summary The document addresses the inherent uncertainty in planning-level cost estimates, specifically identifying the current program cost as a Class 3 estimate. It notes that the cost range carries a -15% to +20% variance. The text advises that this level of uncertainty is standard for planning-level projections and must be accounted for when evaluating the economic outcomes and projected costs presented in the report.
Labour Market Risk Skilled power system operators and engineers are in high demand across the electricity sector. Recruitment timelines and compensation requirements may vary from current assumptions.
AI summary The document highlights risks associated with the labor market within the electricity sector. It notes that skilled power system operators and engineers are in high demand, which may lead to recruitment timelines and compensation requirements that differ from the current project assumptions.
Technology Procurement Risk Vendor pricing and availability for operational technology systems, including EMS components, may vary from planning estimates once competitive procurement is underway. The key point is that the recommended phas...
AI summary The text discusses the risks associated with technology procurement for operational technology systems, specifically noting that vendor pricing and availability for EMS components may fluctuate during competitive procurement. To mitigate these risks, a phased implementation pathway with defined decision gates is recommended. IBM supports this approach, asserting that the staged strategy effectively manages procurement uncertainties while maintaining the program's overall benefits.
11. Managing Risks, Costs, and Reliability Through the 2A / 2B / 2C Approach A central strength of IBM's recommendation is that it does not propose a single-step transition. Instead, it recommends a phased pathway that manages risk, reliab...
AI summary The text highlights the strategic advantages of IBM's recommendation to adopt a phased approach (2A / 2B / 2C) for infrastructure or system transitions. Rather than proposing a single-step change, this methodology is designed to mitigate risks, maintain system reliability, and manage costs progressively over time.
Cost Management A phased pathway allows capital commitments to be sequenced and enables updated information from earlier phases to inform later decisions. This is especially valuable where costs are planning-level and subject to the normal...
AI summary The document outlines a phased approach to capital commitment management, allowing for sequenced investment and the integration of updated information from early project phases into later decisions. This strategy is particularly useful for planning-level costs within the Class 3 estimate range. Key cost management mechanisms identified include a 15% contingency on direct capital to address estimate variations, decision gate reviews to compare actual costs against estimates before authorizing further spending, and annual reporting of actual versus forecast expenditures to ensure ongoing governance.
Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios – Phases 2A and 2B NPV IRR Base Case Scenario +$110M 30% High Case (-15% Capex, +30% benefits) +$173M 46% Low Case (+20% Capex, -40% benefits) +$26M 11% Capex +50% +$88 20% Benefits -50% +$16M 10% Capital...
AI summary The document presents a sensitivity analysis of Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for various project phases (2A and 2B). It evaluates the financial viability of the project under multiple scenarios, including a Base Case, High Case (reduced Capex, increased benefits), Low Case (increased Capex, reduced benefits), and scenarios involving delayed benefits, carbon removal, and significant fluctuations in capital costs and benefits. The findings indicate that the project's profitability is highly sensitive to capital expenditure and benefit realization rates.
Executive summary - ES.1 FTI Consulting ("FTI" or we) has been retained by the Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator ("IESO-NS" or the "IESO") to examine the Business Case and Value Framework of transitioning from an investor-owne...
AI summary FTI Consulting was retained by the Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO-NS) to evaluate the business case and value framework of transitioning from a vertically integrated utility (VIU) model to an independent system operator (ISO) model. The transition aims to enhance transparency and investment opportunities amidst Nova Scotia's electricity sector transformation. The report estimates that the transition will deliver strategic benefits—impacting cost, reliability, and environmental performance—quantified at approximately $500 million to $2.4 billion over the 2026-2050 period.
Benchmarking the roles, responsibilities and operating costs of an ISO ES.8 In Chapter 2 of our report, we compare IESO-NS with a benchmarking group of ISOs in other regions. No existing ISO is entirely comparable with IESO-NS in its curre...
AI summary The report benchmarks the IESO-NS against other Independent System Operators (ISOs) to determine reasonable operating costs and roles. It establishes a general minimum fixed operating cost of $70-140 million per year for ISOs. The analysis highlights that many ISO costs are non-incremental, as they replace functions previously performed by Vertically Integrated Utilities (VIUs) or Transmission System Operators (TSOs). Furthermore, the report notes that cost scaling is not strictly linear with grid size but depends on specific roles, such as wholesale energy and capacity markets.
ial improvements in the control room may result in improved operational decisions – these improved operations may further advance Phase 1 benefits due to enhanced information quality and availability. - ES.12 In Figure ES-2 below we map ho...
AI summary The text discusses the anticipated benefits and costs of transitioning from a Vertically Integrated Utility (VIU) model to an Independent System Operator (ISO) model in Nova Scotia. Key benefits include improved operational decisions, reliability, and environmental gains through enhanced information quality. However, the transition involves one-off implementation costs, incremental operating expenses due to corporate duplication, and a potential loss of synergies between the system planner and operator during the initial phase.
2. Benchmarking the roles, responsibilities and operating costs of an ISO - 2.1 The objective of this chapter is three-fold: (1) benchmarking IESO-NS among its peers globally; (2) understanding from that benchmark what the typical roles an...
AI summary This chapter outlines the methodology for benchmarking the IESO-NS against global peers to determine typical Independent System Operator (ISO) roles, responsibilities, and operating costs. It acknowledges that while no direct comparable benchmark exists for IESO-NS, a range of international ISOs with shared characteristics will be analyzed. The study aims to identify key cost drivers and map operating costs against metrics like population served and installed capacity, noting that findings are illustrative due to diverse global differences.
Roles and responsibilities of the benchmarked ISOs - 2.6 Each of the ISOs introduced in the previous section has its own differing set of roles and responsibilities – each having its own associated costs and benefits. To draw additional va...
AI summary The document introduces a comparison of the roles and responsibilities of various Independent System Operators (ISOs) against the IESO-NS. It notes that each ISO has distinct functions that result in different associated costs and benefits. The text establishes the framework for analyzing these differences to provide context for the operating cost comparisons presented in the benchmarking study.
Operating costs - 2.22 In this section, we compare and discuss major operating costs of the benchmarking group. These fall generally into the major categories of salaries and benefits; outside services; facility, equipment, various IT and...
AI summary The text analyzes the operating costs of various Independent System Operators (ISOs) and Transmission System Operators (TSOs) as part of a benchmarking exercise. It identifies key cost drivers including salaries, benefits, outside services, and IT/office expenses. Notably, Transpower's high operating costs are attributed to its dual role as both an ISO and a significant transmission asset owner. The analysis distinguishes between incremental ISO costs, transferred utility costs, and excluded costs such as system service procurement, regulatory fees, and non-recurring transition costs.
ISO-NE MISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO Transpower Year 2024 2024 2024 2023 FY2025 FY2025 $m USD Salaries and related benefits 154 243 70 129 153 68 Outside services 25 81 7 15 79 7 Facility and equipment costs 4 19 4 19 Hardware, software main...
AI summary The document provides a comparative analysis of operating costs for several regional transmission system operators and independent system operators, including ISO-NE, MISO, AESO, IESO Ontario, NESO, and Transpower. It details line items such as salaries, outside services, depreciation, and maintenance. Crucially, it provides a scaled estimate of these operating costs adjusted to the size of Nova Scotia's grid, alongside cost metrics like OpEx per TWh and notes regarding regulatory fees and transition costs.
3. Anticipated benefits of an ISO - 3.1 In this chapter, we describe the benefits and costs from the establishment of an ISO. The establishment of an ISO is a step in the liberalisation or restructuring of the electricity sector. - 3.2 Unb...
AI summary The text outlines the anticipated benefits and costs associated with establishing an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia as part of the electricity sector's liberalization. Key benefits include reduced bias, increased competition, innovation, and lower consumer costs through fair grid access and technology diversity. Conversely, the text acknowledges that unbundling a vertically integrated business introduces incremental costs, including staff and equipment expenses, and a potential loss of synergies between roles.
IESO role transition 3.4 The rationale for establishing the IESO was to create an independent body with enhanced focus on the system's energy requirements.[52](#page-48-1) The IESO transition is planned in two phases (as explained in more...
AI summary The document outlines the planned two-phase transition of roles to the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). Phase 1 focuses on long-term planning and procurement functions, while Phase 2 involves real-time operations. The transition aims to create an independent body to manage system energy requirements, reducing potential bias. While operational roles will transition from Nova Scotia Power (NSP), NSP will retain ownership of the transmission system. The report intends to evaluate the benefits and cost implications of these role transfers.
Phase 1: Independent planning and competitive resource procurement - 3.11 For the purposes of this section, we divide Phase 1 roles transferred to IESO-NS into core roles and supporting roles. We separately categorise more discrete, indivi...
AI summary The document outlines Phase 1 of a transition involving the transfer of roles to the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). It distinguishes between 'core roles' and 'supporting roles,' focusing on the benefits of independent planning and competitive resource procurement. Key benefits identified include long-term security of supply through cost discipline in competitive procurements and the facilitation of more efficient transmission investment decisions and non-wires alternatives due to reduced perceived bias and increased trust in the planning entity.
Table 3-1: Phase 1 benefits and underlying levers Long-term security of supply Transmission planner (1) Shifting cost overruns risk ❷ Increased competition (2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement (3A) Red...
AI summary The document outlines the benefits and underlying levers associated with Phase 1 of a transmission planning initiative. Key benefits include long-term security of supply, increased competition, and improved timeliness. Specific levers identified include shifting cost overrun risks, reducing resource investment costs through competitive procurement, and accelerating capital expenditure deployment for both resources and transmission. It also highlights the avoidance of carbon costs through accelerated deployment and notes that the IESO-NS's independence supports its role in these initiatives.
Table 3-2: Phase 2 benefits and underlying levers Direct benefits from Phase 2 Scheduler, residual energy system balancer and settlement Indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles from Phase 2 Long-term security of supply Transmission planner Scal...
AI summary Table 3-2 outlines the benefits and levers associated with 'Phase 2' of a project, categorized into direct benefits, indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles, and the scaling of Phase 1 benefits. Key benefits include improved operational efficiency leading to decreased production and avoided carbon costs, as well as increased innovation and diversity through reduced capital expenditures (CapEx). Additionally, the phase is expected to foster increased competition by facilitating greater entry into competitive procurement processes.
Phase 1 incremental costs - 3.21 It must be acknowledged that certain costs are inherent to a transition of certain tasks from a VIU to an ISO. While many costs are likely to be comparable, e.g., many computing and software costs, some are...
AI summary The text discusses the incremental costs and potential disbenefits associated with transitioning certain tasks from a Variable Independent Utility (VIU) to an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia. Key issues include one-off upfront costs like real estate, duplicate software licenses, and redundant corporate functions. Furthermore, the analysis highlights a potential loss of synergies if Phase 1 is implemented without Phase 2, as separating the planner and operator roles may hinder efficient investment decisions and increase transaction costs due to reduced operational expertise in planning.
Phase 2 incremental costs - 3.25 Much of the cost for Phase 2 falls into the same broad categories as Phase 1, but to a larger magnitude for one-off costs associated with the control room and other capital-intensive activities. The impleme...
AI summary The text analyzes the incremental costs associated with Phase 2 of a system operator transition, noting that costs are largely similar to Phase 1 but higher due to one-off capital-intensive activities like control room modernization. It highlights a tension between restored planning and operator synergies and the potential loss of operational synergies caused by unbundling asset ownership from operation. Specifically, unbundling may lead to increased transaction costs for activities like temporary line overloading due to information gaps and negotiation requirements.
ceived bias in the operator's role. The disbenefit from transitioning the system operator role for NSP to the IESO is the loss of synergies between the system operator and asset owner.[61](#page-60-0) - 4.2 [Table 4-1](#page-61-0) below sh...
AI summary The text discusses the business case for transitioning the system operator role from Nova Scotia Power (NSP) to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). It highlights a potential disbenefit in the loss of synergies between the asset owner and the system operator. The analysis evaluates the Real Present Value (RPV) of benefits versus the one-off and ongoing incremental operational costs of the transition for the 2026-2050 horizon, specifically considering assets like transmission and generation.
Benefit (CADm) Low Mid. High (1) Shifting cost overrun risk 47 67 87 (2) Reduced resource cost from competitive procurement - 67 135 (3A) Reduced production costs from accelerated deployment 186 274 363 (3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (f...
AI summary The document presents a quantitative benefit-cost analysis of Nova Scotia Power's 2025 Annual Capital Expenditure Plan, categorized into Low, Mid, and High scenarios. It evaluates various factors including cost overrun risk mitigation, competitive procurement savings, accelerated deployment benefits, and avoided carbon costs. The analysis also accounts for financial disbenefits such as lost synergies from planner-operator separation and accelerated CapEx deployment. Total estimated benefits range from $500 million in the Low scenario to $2,361 million in the High scenario.
General approach and key data , we apply a 4-1 [Table](#page-61-2) For each of the identified benefits and disbenefits listed in4.9 percentage reduction to existing cost categories (or increase in the case of disbenefits), based on assumed...
AI summary The document outlines the methodology for quantifying the financial impacts of transitioning to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) model. The analysis employs a 4-1 approach, calculating percentage reductions or increases in existing cost categories based on assumed gains or losses. It specifically identifies benefits and disbenefits associated with the IESO transition, mapping them to specific cost categories to determine the overall impact on the system's financial structure.
Category Cost Category Generation CapEx J_]~ ' ' Transmission CapEx ¥ - (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns - (2) Reduced generation cost from competitive procurement ) financial disbenefit ( deployment x E Cap Accelerated (3B) - (7) Increa...
AI summary The text analyzes the impact of various factors on Capital Expenditure (CapEx) for generation and transmission infrastructure. It identifies specific benefits and disbenefits related to competitive procurement, accelerated deployment, system planning advancements, and control room improvements. Notably, it discusses the potential for lost synergies between planners, procurers, and operators. Due to high uncertainty and long time horizons, the analysis utilizes a high and low case methodology to create a reasonable range for each impact, focusing on the midpoint for results.
(2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement - 4.23 NSP, as a VIU, has historically built the majority of non-renewable generation assets. The IESO transition will allow for increased competitive procurement o...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power (NSP) argues that the transition to the IESO will facilitate competitive resource procurement, leading to lower capital costs for new generation assets. This shift is expected to attract firms with better access to lower-cost capital and create a more level playing field. The document quantifies potential savings on capital cost overruns (ranging from 8% to 18% depending on the scenario) and outlines a methodology for annualizing these savings over a project's lifetime, starting with the first realized savings in 2028.
(3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (financial disbenefit) 4.32 As discussed above, for both generation and transmission, we can expect faster construction timelines and a faster reduction of production costs relative to the counterfactual V...
AI summary The text discusses the financial implications of accelerated capital expenditure (CapEx) deployment resulting from the creation of the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). While faster construction timelines reduce production costs compared to the counterfactual Variable Independent Utility (VIU) scenario, they create a financial disbenefit due to the time value of money. Because costs are incurred earlier, their discounted present value is higher. This effect is expected to begin in 2026, with the first realized costs occurring in 2028.
(5) Loss of synergies from planner and operator 4.36 Prior to the IESO, the planner and operator functions were combined under NSP. Separating these functions – if Phase 1 only was implemented - can conceivably create additional transactio...
AI summary The document discusses the potential negative impacts of separating the planner and operator functions, which were previously combined under Nova Scotia Power (NSP). The separation may create additional transaction costs and obstruct information flows due to the loss of inherent system knowledge. These factors are expected to increase production costs by 1-2% starting in 2029, as real-time operational constraints may no longer align with long-term planning.
(6) Direct control room improvements - 4.40 The transfer of system operations from NSP to the IESO is expected to coincide with a significant modernization of the current dispatch process. [78](#page-72-1) Updates to operational assets and...
AI summary The text discusses the expected operational improvements resulting from the transfer of system operations from Nova Scotia Power (NSP) to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). It argues that the IESO's core focus on system operation will drive modernization of control room hardware and software, leading to more efficient resource utilization and reduced production costs. These improvements are projected to yield 2-10% in savings starting in 2029, surpassing the expected benefits of current improvements being implemented by NSP.
(7) Scaling effect from independent system operation: increased entry in competitive procurement - 4.44 In a Phase 1-only IESO, a dispatch run by the incumbent NSP may deter some participation of third-party competitors in IESO-led procure...
AI summary The document discusses the benefits of establishing an independent system operator (IESO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that separating the system operator role from the incumbent utility (NSP) reduces information asymmetries and conflicts of interest, which is expected to increase third-party participation in competitive procurements and lower capital costs for new generation and storage assets starting in 2027. Additionally, it highlights that control room modernization will enable more advanced system planning for transmission and generation by providing more detailed system information.
(12) Loss of synergies between asset owner and operator (disbenefit) 4.58 The separation of asset ownership and operation creates some lost synergies, as explained in Chapter 3. This is due to the change to a contractual interface (in whic...
AI summary The document discusses the potential disbenefit of lost synergies resulting from the separation of asset ownership and operation. Transitioning from an operational interface to a contractual one is expected to create friction, leading to increased transaction and information-sharing costs. These factors are projected to cause a slight increase in production costs, estimated between 0.5% and 1%, starting in 2027 when Phase 2 begins.
Core results - 4.61 The results of the quantification described above sum to over $1.4 billion in the midpoint case, within a range of $500 million to $2.4 billion over the 2026-2050 period. The IESO transition has a diverse set of benefit...
AI summary The text quantifies the economic impacts of the IESO transition, estimating a midpoint benefit of over $1.4 billion between 2026 and 2050. Benefits are driven primarily by reduced capital expenditures and production costs, with Phase 2 accounting for two-thirds of the total. Significant benefits arise from accelerated decarbonization in Phase 1 and control room improvements in Phase 2. The analysis also accounts for specific disbenefits and the cascading positive impacts of improved control room operations on competitive energy procurement.
Benefits by year - 4.67 The benefits of the IESO transition are frontloaded given (1) the greatest reduction in carbon emissions occurring in the 2027-2030 period, and (2) the steepest decline in production costs occurring in 2027-2032.82...
AI summary The text outlines the projected economic and environmental benefits of transitioning to the IESO model, categorized into two phases. Phase 1 benefits are frontloaded (2027-2032) due to accelerated decarbonization and immediate cost savings. Phase 2 benefits are more enduring and distributed over the long term, with significant growth expected from 2035 onwards. The report highlights that over half of the cumulative Real Present Value (RPV) benefits are realized within the first eight years of the 2026-2050 period, reaching a $1 billion milestone by 2039.
Benefits excluding avoided carbon costs - 4.72 Benefits driven by reductions in carbon emissions range from 32% to 20% of total benefits in the low and high cases, respectively. This benefit category is not as monetarily direct as the othe...
AI summary The text quantifies the benefits derived from carbon emission reductions, estimating them to be between 20% and 32% of total benefits depending on low and high-case scenarios. It notes that these benefits are less monetarily direct than other categories because they are contingent upon federal and provincial carbon policies and the federal price of carbon.
- 4.73 As shown in Table 4-2 below, when excluding this benefit category from the analysis, the cumulative benefits across the 2026-2050 period are $1,119 million in the midpoint case. Unlike Figure 4-19 which shows Phases 1 and 2 as stack...
AI summary The document quantifies the transition benefits associated with the IESO (Independent Electricity System Operator) over the 2026-2050 period, excluding avoided emissions-related benefits. The analysis presents low, midpoint, and high cases, identifying key drivers such as reduced resource costs from competitive procurement, accelerated deployment of production assets, and control room improvements. It also accounts for disbenefits, such as lost synergies from planner-operator and owner-operator models, and notes negative impacts from accelerated CapEx deployment.
4.74 If carbon emissions are not shielded by any policy exemptions and priced at the federal carbon price, updated in May 2026, the value of avoided carbon is over twice as high, with a total midpoint of $684 million compared to $312 milli...
AI summary The text quantifies the financial impact of carbon pricing on the project's value. It highlights that if carbon emissions are subject to the federal carbon price (updated in May 2026) without policy exemptions, the value of avoided carbon reaches a midpoint of $684 million. This is more than double the $312 million value calculated under a scenario where policy shields are applied.
Table 4-3: Quantification of different methods for IESO transition benefits related to avoided carbon costs, midpoint and range, $m 2025 [88](#page-82-2) Benefit (CADm) Full-priced carbon Carbon emissions policy shield (4) Avoided carbon c...
AI summary The provided text presents Table 4-3, which quantifies different methods for calculating IESO transition benefits related to avoided carbon costs for the year 2025. It compares two methodologies: 'Full-priced carbon' and 'Carbon emissions policy shield.' The benefits are categorized into three areas: accelerated deployment of resources, control room improvements, and more advanced system pathways, with figures provided as midpoints and ranges in millions of Canadian dollars.
Table 4-4 Equivalent annual benefit, $m 202589 Equivalent annual benefit, annuity corresponding to PV of benefits Low Mid. High Phase 1 15 29 43 Phase 2 20 71 122 Total $35 $100 $165 <sup>89 For sources, see Appendix 3. - ES.28 This ana...
AI summary The text presents an analysis of the Equivalent Annual Benefit (EAB) for Nova Scotia's transition to an Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO-NS). It provides a breakdown of annual benefits across different scenarios (Low, Mid, High) for Phase 1 and Phase 2, totaling up to $165 million. The analysis further calculates potential net benefits to consumers by subtracting illustrative incremental operating costs from these EAB figures, resulting in estimated benefit-to-cost ratios ranging from 1.8 to 8.7.
4.83 The EAB, a constant annual amount that has the same present value of the benefit stream, is shown in Table 4-6 and Table 4-7 below, with and without the value of avoided carbon. Table 4-6: Sensitivity analysis equivalent annual benefi...
AI summary The text presents a sensitivity analysis of the Equivalent Annual Benefit (EAB) for a project, divided into Phase 1 and Phase 2. It provides two sets of data: one including the value of avoided carbon and another excluding it. The EAB values range from a low of $32 million to a high of $148 million (including avoided carbon). The analysis also notes that specific disbenefits are numerically included in the totals, with some netted against specific benefits.
Benefits and costs of Phase 1 of the creation of IESO-NS 5.6 In this section, we describe Phase 1 core roles and benefits, supporting roles and benefits, as well as incremental costs of implementation. Phase 1 core roles: timelier and effi...
AI summary The document introduces an analysis of Phase 1 of the creation of the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). It outlines the framework for evaluating the core roles and benefits of the initiative, which include facilitating timelier and more efficient investments in transmission and energy resources, alongside the identification of supporting roles and the incremental costs associated with implementation.
Transmission planner and long-term security of supply - A1.1 The creation of an ISO in Nova Scotia has been under consideration for well over a decade.[96](#page-87-0) In recent years, public opinion of NSP as a VIU with conflicting incent...
AI summary The text discusses the ongoing debate regarding the creation of an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that Nova Scotia Power (NSP), acting as a Variable Independent Utility (VIU), faces an inherent conflict of interest between its duty to provide reliable, affordable electricity and its obligation to generate profit for shareholders. This conflict may lead to biased system planning, where the utility might delay transmission upgrades to protect its core generation business or avoid costs due to rate pressures.
Industry governance: Improved reliability standards and grid codes A1.21 The ISO may, as an independent and knowledgeable neutral entity, help to implement reliability standards and set grid codes better reflecting the economic trade-off b...
AI summary The text discusses the role of an Independent System Operator (ISO) in establishing reliability standards and grid codes. It highlights the ISO's ability to act as a neutral entity to balance the economic trade-off between investment costs and load served. The document notes that Variable Independent Utilities (VIUs) may face conflicting pressures between maintaining strict reliability standards and ensuring ratepayer affordability, and emphasizes that an independent ISO helps avoid conflicts of interest inherent in entities that own generation or transmission assets.
Avoided professional services costs A1.24 Some professional services costs may be avoided with an ISO. For instance, the government can avoid direct hire of consultants if it can rely on ISO expertise, or reduce the amount of auditing and...
AI summary The text discusses the potential for cost savings and improved administrative efficiency through the use of an Independent System Operator (ISO). Key benefits include the avoidance of direct consultant hiring by the government, reduced auditing and investigation costs for policing a Variable Independent Utility (VIU), and a decreased regulatory burden on the board. Additionally, an ISO can provide more consistent advisory support, potentially enhancing the quality of advice while reducing overall labor costs.
ed to operate its units at a level of operational prudence above the level applied in dispatching merchant facilities. This may result in a disadvantage to IPPs and resulting advantage to NSP's units. - A1.31 This perceived conflict of int...
AI summary The text discusses the potential benefits and costs of Phase 2 of the IESO-NS creation, specifically focusing on the perceived conflict of interest regarding the dispatch of Independent Power Producers (IPPs) versus Nova Scotia Power (NSP) owned units. While currently of minor importance due to the nature of existing IPPs, this conflict is expected to increase as dispatchable resources like batteries connect to the grid. Ultimately, Phase 2 is argued to provide production cost savings through more efficient and fair use of existing system assets.
Competitive generation procurement A1.36 Transparency of dispatch is key for competitive procurement, which reduces costs by incentivizing innovation to increase efficiency among a larger pool of bidders (quantified benefit 7) . The IESO,...
AI summary The text discusses the importance of transparency in competitive generation procurement to drive innovation and reduce costs. It argues that moving operational control to an independent entity (IESO) is necessary to prevent Nova Scotia Power (NSP) from having an unfair advantage or access to sensitive competitor data. By insulating Independent Power Producers (IPPs) from operational risks and ensuring transparent settlement, the transition is expected to increase investor trust, lower the cost of capital, and reduce overall resource investment costs.
and-side management, [120](#page-96-2) all of which may also have environmental benefits ( avoided carbon costs ) in addition to cost-saving benefits ( reduced system production costs ). - A1.41 As explained above, IESO's incentive for inn...
AI summary The text discusses the benefits of the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) taking on the system operator role in Phase 2 of a project. It highlights that the IESO's expertise in operational knowledge, system operations, and power flow calculations can lead to more optimal planning, procurement, and contracting decisions. This integration is expected to provide quantified benefits, including cost savings from reduced system production costs and environmental benefits from avoided carbon costs, while potentially annulling incremental costs identified in Phase 1.
Production costs A3.8 Production costs are short-run power production costs informed by primary confidential data sources provided to us by the IESO. Data sources include generation (GWh) for each major technology (coal, solar, wind, etc.)...
AI summary The text describes the methodology for estimating short-run power production costs for the 2026-2050 period. These costs are derived from confidential IESO data, including generation volumes, fuel costs, variable O&M, and startup/shutdown costs across various technologies. The analysis assumes negligible short-run production costs for wind and solar, noting that fixed costs are recovered through Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) and accounted for as capital expenditures. For accelerated deployment scenarios, the average production cost per unit is shifted while keeping total yearly generation constant as a demand proxy.
Appendix 4: Assumptions summary Phase 1: Planning and procurement responsibilities Assumptions (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns 0-50% reduction in cost overruns from 16% historic overspend 50-80% reduction in pass-through to customers fr...
AI summary This appendix outlines the quantitative assumptions used to model the financial and operational impacts of shifting planning and procurement responsibilities. It categorizes these assumptions into two phases: Phase 1 focuses on planning and procurement, highlighting potential cost overrun reductions, competitive procurement benefits, and timeline differences for Capex and carbon emission targets. Phase 2 focuses on system operation, estimating production cost reductions from control room improvements, advanced system planning, and the resolution of synergies between planners, procurers, and operators.
uction cost per MWh, delay it, and multiply this by the same system demand trajectory: Production cost with delays = Average production costs with delay $/MWh × Total system demand without delay MWh - A5.11 For example, in our low case wit...
AI summary The text discusses the financial modeling of cost overrun risks and the impact of project delays on production costs. It outlines a methodology for calculating 'production cost with delays' by multiplying delayed per-MWh costs by system demand trajectories. The analysis compares the financial disbenefits of delayed capital expenditures (CapEx) and transmission projects against the benefits of accelerated deployment of production cost improvements, noting that the latter is of lesser magnitude than the former in specific scenarios.
Phase 2: Independent system operation - (5) Regained synergies from planner and operator - A5.22 This cancels out the disbenefit above. - (6) Direct control room improvements - A5.23 Innovation in control room design and management benefit...
AI summary The text outlines the financial benefits and cost reductions associated with Phase 2 of independent system operation. It details specific methodologies for calculating savings derived from regained synergies between planners and operators, control room design innovations, and scaling effects. Key benefits include increased entry in competitive procurement, decreased capital expenditure (CapEx) from advanced system planning, and reduced production costs. The document provides mathematical frameworks for calculating the Remaining Present Value (RPV) of these savings across newly and always procured resources.
(a) General Comments The 2025 regulatory calendar involved the hearing of various significant matters before the Board, and particularly with regards to matters involving NSPI and Halifax Water, which both filed General Rate Applications i...
AI summary The Consumer Advocate (CA) provides general comments on the 2025 regulatory calendar, highlighting significant changes driven by Bill 404, including a new Board structure and an independent energy system operator. The CA notes that Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) faced a cyberattack in 2025 with ongoing regulatory impacts. The CA participated in over 100 proceedings in 2025, primarily advocating for residential ratepayers in matters involving NSPI, such as General Rate Applications and new Cost of Service methodologies.
Appendix A Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of 0490-228 Eastward Energy M12261 - Eastward Energy - RDA Recovery Rate Amendments Application Review Proceeding: Review of all evidence and material filed in matter. Corresp...
AI summary Appendix A provides a table detailing specific regulatory matters and associated costs for various entities. It includes entries for Eastward Energy regarding a RDA Recovery Rate Amendments Application Review Proceeding (M12261) and EfficiencyOne regarding a DSM Advisory Group Behavioural Program Update (M12030). The table lists activities such as attendance at workshops, review of reports, and correspondence with stakeholders, alongside corresponding financial figures and sums.
ental Law and El should not be approved, the SBA believes that the information that it requested through the IR process and Ms. Whitten's evidence was of assistance to the Board and other intervenors. - M12217 WTI NS-NB Reliability Interti...
AI summary The Small Business Advocate (SBA) provides general comments on its participation in various proceedings, specifically highlighting its involvement in the WTI NS-NB Reliability Intertie Project. The SBA notes that its evidence regarding project costs, inter-provincial risks, and blended Return on Equity (ROE) assisted the Board's analysis. The SBA emphasizes its commitment to holding utilities accountable for providing reliable, cost-effective services while prioritizing rate stability and affordability for small business customers.
18.11 Leasing Commission. The Landlord agrees to pay the Tenant's Agent a Leasing Commission comprised of $7.50 per square foot, plus HST, payable upon the execution of the Lease Document, so long as the Tenant occupies the Premises for bu...
AI summary The document specifies the terms for a Leasing Commission payment. The Landlord is required to pay the Tenant's Agent a commission of $7.50 per square foot, plus Harmonized Sales Tax (HST), upon the execution of the Lease Document. This payment is contingent on the Tenant occupying the premises for business purposes.