Home›Cost Effectiveness›M06319›Evidence
Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Cost Effectiveness" in M06319

Matter: P-886 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) Rate Application 2007
17 passages 8 documents

Cost Effectiveness across all matters →

N-2-aRIRs 40 to 69 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 34 MB) 1 passage
Plan Benefit cost
Plan Benefit cost The net benefit cost of a post-employment plan for a fiscal year is the sum of the following components:

AI summary The document introduces the methodology for calculating the net benefit cost of a post-employment plan for a specific fiscal year. It establishes that this calculation is derived from the summation of various specific components, though the specific components are not listed in this introductory section.

N-2-cRIRs 1 to 39 - CA to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 14 MB) 3 passages
2 Objective and Background
2 Objective and Background It is the objective ofNSPI to enter into a consulting arrangement with a Service Provider to perform a detailed examination ofNSPI's organizational structure, its level ofOM&G expenditures, and any other pertinen...

AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) intends to engage an independent Service Provider to conduct a detailed operations review of its organizational structure and O&M expenditures. This initiative follows a 2006 Rate Application where the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB) requested an assessment of operational efficiencies. NSPI aims to identify cost savings and implement continuous improvements through independent evaluation and benchmarking against industry standards, as directed by the UARB's March 10, 2006 Decision.

3 Scope
3 Scope - a) The Board has directed that... "an operations review be carried out on NSPI' s operations. The review shall encompass a detailed examination of NSPI' s organizational structure, its level of OM&G expenditures, and any other pe...

AI summary The Board has directed a comprehensive operations review of Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) to identify cost savings and operational efficiencies. The review must examine NSPI's organizational structure and Operations, Maintenance, and General (OM&G) expenditures, including third-party contracted services. A qualified consultant with North American utility experience will be engaged to benchmark practices and provide specific recommendations for structural improvements and efficiency gains, ultimately working with NSPI management to implement these changes.

6.7.3 Findings
oncerning certain expenses. NSPI has not provided an adequate response. As a result, the Board is not satisfied that NSPI management has made every reasonable effort to eliminate unnecessary expenses. [137] Further, the Board understands t...

AI summary The Board expressed dissatisfaction with Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) for failing to provide an adequate response regarding the elimination of unnecessary expenses. While acknowledging NSPI's benchmarking process, the Board emphasized that benchmarking alone is insufficient and must be complemented by exhaustive reviews of operating expenses. The Board noted significant increases in corporate expenses despite stable overall OM&G costs over six years and ordered NSPI to conduct a detailed review of its OM&G expenses to demonstrate cost-efficiency.

N-2-eRIRs 1 to 49 - Liberty to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 15 MB) 1 passage
Question IR-14:
Question IR-14: Please provide a complete description of all fuel, and fuel transportation procurement in 2005 and 2006 to date. Please include the following information: - a. A copy of the model run used to determine the fuel requirements...

AI summary The Information Request (IR-14) seeks a comprehensive description of fuel and fuel transportation procurement activities from 2005 to the present date. The request specifically asks for model runs for fuel requirements through 2010, solicitation documents (RFPs), vendor lists, and all received responses. Furthermore, it requires the analysis and evaluation of these responses based on delivered cost and lowest cost of electrical energy at the bus-bar, including management recommendations and justifications for any procurement not based on the lowest bus-bar cost.

N-18Direct Testimony - Nancy Brockway on behalf of the Consumer Advocate REDACTED (Large File - 37 MB) 4 passages
24 PART 4: THE CONSERVATION AND DEMAND MANAGEMENT COMPONENT.
grated its low-47 income conservation and demand management program into all aspects of the company's 48 operation. As illustrated by Maine's special payment arrangements, it is possible for a company to use low-income conservation and dem...

AI summary The text discusses integrating low-income conservation and demand management programs into a company's operations, suggesting piggy-backing with non-utility-funded efficiency programs to improve cost-effectiveness. It proposes combining utility funds with housing programs to eliminate parallel initiatives and create a single, comprehensive program for low-income households.

33 A. Low-Income Conservation and Load Management Programs.
33 A. Low-Income Conservation and Load Management Programs. 34 35 The existence of indirect financial benefits to utilities arising from conservation and load 36 management programs targeted specifically to low-income households was first...

AI summary The text discusses the concept of indirect financial benefits to utilities from low-income conservation and load management programs, particularly the reduction of bad debt. It references a Pennsylvania PUC proceeding and research showing that such programs can reduce delinquent payments and related costs.

Detroit Edison
Detroit Edison 11 12 13 14 15 16 In early 1991, the Detroit Edison Company, an investor-owned electric utility, began a concerted marketing and energy management effort to improve the payment practices of the company's lowincome customers....

AI summary Detroit Edison implemented an energy management program called Energy Options to address high electric use and arrears among low-income customers. The program offered financial incentives for usage reduction and timely bill payment. Despite data collection challenges, the program reportedly reduced account balances by $150 on average. The initiative aimed to improve payment behavior and reduce financial stress.

National Fuel Gas Distribution Company
National Fuel Gas Distribution Company National Fuel Gas Distribution Company (New York) operates what it calls its Low-Income Rate Assistance (LIRA) program. The impact evaluation of the NFG program developed a mathematical model for calc...

AI summary The National Fuel Gas Distribution Company's Low-Income Rate Assistance (LIRA) program is evaluated for cost-effectiveness, showing that low-income customers pay a higher proportion of their bills under LIRA. The program has positively impacted several metrics, including the percentage of bill paid and the number of disconnections.

N-44RIRs 144 to 191 - SEB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 10 MB) 2 passages
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST TO: NSPI FROM: SEB Question IR-159: Reference, Final Report, pages 12-16. The Terms of Reference for the Operations Report, provided in response to CA IR-38, note in part (d) on page 5 of attachment 1 that "...

AI summary The Nova Scotia Energy Board (SEB) issued an information request to Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) regarding an operations review conducted by Accenture. The Board sought clarification on Accenture's primary purpose for the review—specifically regarding recommendations for improvements, cost savings, and operational efficiencies—and requested specific dollar estimates for the cost savings and efficiencies associated with each identified 'tactical and strategic improvement' mentioned in the Final Report.

RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST TO: NSPI FROM: SEB Question IR-176: On page 6 of the report, it states that for the longer-term strategic opportunities, proactive investments with paybacks anticipated to be three to four years exist. Pleas...

AI summary The Nova Scotia Energy Board (SEB) issued an Information Request (IR-176) to Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) regarding long-term strategic opportunities. The Board requested identification of specific proactive investments with anticipated three-to-four-year paybacks and the underlying economic analyses. NSPI responded by directing the Board to page 16 of its report and stated that no economic analysis has been completed for these investments.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - Appendix A to J - REDACTED (Large File 27 MB) 4 passages
Gas Market Studies
at specific quantities. This work was done on behalf of a consortium of the North Slope producers, led by ExxonMobil. It analyzed the impact on prices and flows across the North American gas network. - Mr. Crook has directed ICF due dilige...

AI summary The text describes due diligence work performed by ICF on behalf of a North Slope producer consortium led by ExxonMobil. This work analyzed price and flow impacts across the North American gas network. Additionally, it notes that Mr. Crook directed ICF to conduct due diligence reviews on the Portland Natural Gas Transmission System, the Maritimes and Northeast Pipeline, and the Pacific Gas Transmission Company's first major expansion, focusing on gas market availability, supply, and competition.

Office of Pipeline Regulation (OPR)
Office of Pipeline Regulation (OPR) 1978- 1983 Served as an Industry Economist in Pipeline Certificates Division, managed environmental assessments (EAs) and environmental impact statements (EISs) for pipeline projects, curtailment plans a...

AI summary The document outlines the professional experience of an individual who served as an Industry Economist in the Pipeline Certificates Division of the Office of Pipeline Regulation (OPR) from 1978 to 1983. Key accomplishments include managing environmental assessments for pipeline projects, developing air quality impact assessments for natural gas curtailment plans in Florida, conducting cost-benefit analyses on oil pipeline impacts in Port Everglades, and researching socioeconomic impact costs for the Alaska Natural Gas Transportation System (ANGTS).

Electricity generation costs could hurt competitiveness
Electricity generation costs could hurt competitiveness Emera's transmission and distribution activities are monopolies and do not face direct competition. Nevertheless, expected increases to NSPI's cost to generate electricity could put p...

AI summary The document discusses how rising electricity generation costs for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) may impact its cost competitiveness against independent power producers and neighboring utilities. It notes that a significant portion of residential load remains exposed to competition from oil and wood heating. While new generation capacity is not immediately required, NSPI may participate in competitive bidding for future capacity, which would then fall under cost-of-service regulation. Additionally, the text clarifies that current wholesale market restructuring is limited and does not pose a significant risk to credit ratings.

NSPI Comment
NSPI Comment NSPI accepts Liberty's conclusions. We are encouraged by and in agreement with the Consultant's finding that NSPI's proposed Distribution System Vegetation Management Program is well-planned and should maximize benefits to cus...

AI summary Nova Scotia Power Industrial (NSPI) expresses agreement with Liberty's conclusions regarding the proposed Distribution System Vegetation Management Program. NSPI supports the finding that the program is well-planned and designed to maximize customer benefits relative to the requested spending. However, NSPI notes that the execution of expanded program recommendations remains contingent upon the Board's approval of additional funding.

N-54Direct Testimony - Consumer Advocate Witnesses - Michael J. McGarry and Rudolph C. Krizan 1 passage
Q. WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS WITH THIS AUDIT AND THE BENEFITS DERIVED FROM THE RESULTS?
Q. WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS WITH THIS AUDIT AND THE BENEFITS DERIVED FROM THE RESULTS? The Report fails to help identify those areas where cost-savings can be established and obtained for the benefit of not only ratepayers but the Company as...

AI summary The report is criticized for not providing quantifiable recommendations or specific implementation plans for cost-savings and operational efficiencies. The UARB and NSPI were aware of the limitations of benchmarking and emphasized the need for a comprehensive audit beyond benchmarking to identify areas for improvement and savings.

58140Final Submission - Ecology Action Centre 1 passage
Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Demand Side Management?
in principle, that a utility can avoid costs by making investments in energy efficiency and that energy efficiency is 'cost-effective' if the cost of these investments are less than the avoided costs. - 11. The experience in the jurisdicti...

AI summary The text argues that Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) is not acting reasonably or prudently by continuing to invest in fossil fuels rather than energy efficiency, which is presented as a less costly alternative. It references Vermont's experience, where energy efficiency was a least-cost resource, and criticizes NSPI for discontinuing Demand Side Management (DSM) programs that could have led to long-term savings for ratepayers.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →