N-1Application - Redacted
34 passages
centre, as required to fulfil - the organization's mandate under the MAEA, enable independent Balancing Authority - (BA)/Transmission Operator (TOP) operations, and create defined physical and cyber - boundaries - Phase 2B Introduces provi...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Board approval for capital costs associated with Phase 2A ($40.91 million) and Phase 2B ($8.08 million) of the Phase 2 Control Centre project, along with forecast amortization for Phase 2A. These phases aim to fulfill mandates under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), including enabling independent Balancing Authority/Transmission Operator operations and establishing physical and cyber boundaries. Phase 2C, which focuses on grid optimization and an independent Energy Management System, is being deferred to allow for further validation and refinement based on future operating experience.
ies, and carry out the other functions - necessary to operate as an independent energy system operator. - The proposed capital expenditures for Phases 2A and 2B of the Control Centre project are the - principal costs associated with this p...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its capital expenditures and operational priorities for the 2026/2029 fiscal years, specifically focusing on the Control Centre project (Phases 2A and 2B). The project involves approximately $48.99 million in capital work in progress to establish an independent energy system operator model, including cybersecurity and reliability compliance. Additionally, the entity emphasizes its mandate to plan and procure electricity resources to maintain system reliability, aiming to complete its first Integrated Resource Plan by 2027/2028.
or Economic Capacity and Constraint Portfolio Optimization. It is a tool used by Nova Scotia Power (NSP) to optimize the dispatch of generation resources based on economic and operational constraints. SCED (Security Constrained Economic Di...
AI summary The text evaluates four operational scenarios for the establishment of IESO Nova Scotia, focusing on the balance between cost-efficiency and organizational independence. It analyzes 'Shared Operations' (Scenario 2), which leverages existing Nova Scotia Power infrastructure but creates operational inefficiencies and dependency issues. It also considers 'Minimum Independence' (Scenario 3). Ultimately, the document identifies Scenario 4 ('Enhanced Independence') as the selected option, noting the trade-offs between implementation costs, physical separation, and the independence of the IESO Nova Scotia entity.
nd dispatching - the electricity system, administering market settlements, and carrying out related market - administration functions, while continuing to rely on certain shared NS Power systems and - infrastructure. Steady State 1 therefo...
AI summary The text outlines a phased approach for establishing IESO Nova Scotia as an independent system operator under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). Steady State 1 establishes core operational capabilities, while Phases 2A and 2B provide the functional capabilities for independent system operation and participant administration. Steady State 2 represents a long-term target model incorporating cybersecurity segregation and advanced system capabilities. This phased implementation is intended to manage complexity, preserve system reliability, and allow for reassessment before full commitment.
1 Figure 6: Cost Breakdown (All costs in $M) Total Phase 2A Phase 2B Phase 2C IT Costs $ 20.6 $ 0.8 $ 5.9 $ 13.9 Proqram lnteqration $ 11.4 $ 9.0 $ 1.0 $ 1.4 Control Center Build $ 9.0 $ 9.0 $ - $ - NERC Compliance $ 6.4 $ 6.4 $ - $ - Cybe...
AI summary The document provides a detailed cost breakdown for different phases (2A, 2B, and 2C) of a project, likely related to grid infrastructure or IT modernization. It categorizes expenditures into IT costs, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, cybersecurity, and NSP support costs. The table highlights that Phase 2A has the highest direct capital expenditures and program integration costs, while Phase 2C is significantly more weighted toward IT costs and direct capital expenditures.
IT Costs - IT Costs include the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, transferred - platforms, communications, interfaces, and other technology systems required to support - Phase 2 operations. This includes operational tec...
AI summary The text outlines the Information Technology (IT) costs associated with the configuration and implementation of shared platforms, communications, and interfaces required to support Phase 2 operations. These costs specifically cover the capabilities transferred to IESO Nova Scotia under Scenario 4, including settlement, reporting, and market administration functions. IBM developed the cost estimates using a capability-based assessment approach, incorporating EMS, SCADA, cybersecurity, and data analytics requirements based on vendor data, utility information, and analogous projects.
NERC Compliance - NERC Compliance includes compliance program and procedure development, audit readiness, - certification activities, and the documentation required for IESO Nova Scotia to assume BA and - TOP functions. This work supports...
AI summary The text outlines the requirements for NERC Compliance as part of the IESO Nova Scotia transition to assume Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions. This involves developing compliance programs, audit readiness, and certification activities aligned with reliability and cybersecurity standards. These activities are essential for certification by NERC and the NPCC. The cost estimate for these compliance activities was developed by IBM based on industry benchmarks and past experience, primarily supporting Phase 2A of the project.
Cyber Security - Cyber Security includes the security architecture, network controls, monitoring, identity - management, and other cybersecurity controls required to support IESO Nova Scotia's - independent operating environment. This work...
AI summary The document outlines the scope and requirements for cyber security within IESO Nova Scotia's independent operating environment. It specifies that cyber security encompasses security architecture, network controls, monitoring, and identity management necessary to support Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions while adhering to NERC CIP requirements. The associated cost estimates were developed by IBM based on industry benchmarks and professional judgment. These activities are essential throughout Steady State 1 and Steady State 2, specifically during Phases 2A and 2B.
Phase 2A Workstreams (GRA) Governance & Regulatory - Market Rules & Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) Establish the governance, regulatory change management, stakeholder approval, and agreement frameworks needed to support the IESO NS...
AI summary The document outlines the specific workstreams for Phase 2A of a project aimed at establishing the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO NS). The workstreams are categorized into Governance & Regulatory (covering market rules, OATT, and NERC compliance), Technology & Communications, Control Centre infrastructure, and Operational Frameworks (focused on processes and people). These activities are designed to ensure regulatory compliance, cybersecurity, and operational readiness for the transition to a new market model.
5. Cybersecurity Risk: Cybersecurity risk associated with shared systems, transitional access arrangements, and interim technology solutions implemented during the phased transition to IESO Nova Scotia operations. Mitigation: While certain...
AI summary The document outlines cybersecurity risks and mitigation strategies during the phased transition to IESO Nova Scotia operations. Key risks involve shared systems and transitional access arrangements. Mitigation efforts include network segmentation, identity and access management, and adherence to NERC and NPCC Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) standards. The transition plan aims to reduce reliance on NS Power systems over time while building internal expertise at IESO Nova Scotia, supported by external consultants and collaborative risk assessments with NS Power.
1 3.3.2 Information Technology 2 Separate from the assets deployed in the Control Centre, IESO Nova Scotia will also need to 3 implement software and hardware assets to enable additional existing business functions. As 4 more employees are...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia identifies necessary investments in information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT) to support its foundational business functions and strategic priorities. This includes the procurement of hardware, such as computers and mobile devices, to accommodate new employees, as well as a specific software solution to manage transmission interconnection activities. The text emphasizes that these IT expenditures are essential for the organization's core operations and includes an amortization budget for these assets.
3.4.3 Information Technology - IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $2.1M in expenses as part of the Information Technology cost - category. This cost category consists of costs incurred for internal staff, Managed IT Services, - IT Application S...
AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is budgeting $2.1 million for Information Technology costs to support its functional areas and business mandates. These expenses cover internal staff, Managed IT Services, IT Application Software, and other technology services. The organization's technology strategy is heavily influenced by the utilization of cloud and managed services, which are deemed necessary to execute its strategic priorities and meet future requirements.
IT General Controls (ITGCs) These are system-based controls in place at IESO Nova Scotia which help ensure data is accessed only by authorized staff and kept secure. Preventative controls - User access provisioning and termination - Role-b...
AI summary The document outlines the Information Technology General Controls (ITGCs) implemented at IESO Nova Scotia. These system-based controls are designed to ensure data security and restricted access to authorized personnel only. The controls are categorized as preventative and include specific procedures for user access provisioning and termination, role-based and privileged access management, change management involving testing and approvals, as well as data backup and recovery protocols.
Priority 1 - Complete the Successful Transition of Independent Grid Operations Key Activity/ Project Description Estimated Completion MAEA Linkage Independent Grid Operations Planning and Implementation Please refer to Proposed Expenditure...
AI summary The document outlines Priority 1 for the transition to independent grid operations in Nova Scotia, primarily involving the establishment of IESO Nova Scotia. Key activities include the creation of an independent control centre, obtaining NERC certification for Balancing Authority and Transmission Operator functions, and updating market rules and tariffs. The plan also encompasses technology enablement (cybersecurity and IT/OT systems), organizational change management for personnel transitioning from Nova Scotia Power, and the development of a new settlement system to support a competitive electricity market.
Appendix 6 – IBM Control Centre Analysis NON-CONFIDENTIAL Phase 2: Control Centre Options Analysis and Recommendation Roadmap IBM Report
AI summary This document serves as an appendix containing an analysis and recommendation roadmap for the IBM Control Centre options. It specifically focuses on Phase 2 of the project, which involves evaluating options for the Control Centre and outlining the subsequent roadmap for implementation.
What it delivers: - Establishes the independent IESO-NS control centre (ADC) - Begins BA/TOP operations using existing NSP systems - Creates secure physical/cyber boundaries - Builds operator capabilit1• and early credibility
AI summary The text outlines the initial deliverables of a project focused on establishing independent control center operations for the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). Key objectives include establishing the ADC control center, initiating Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) operations utilizing existing Nova Scotia Power (NSP) systems, and creating secure physical and cyber boundaries to build operator capability and credibility.
Scenario 2 - Shared Operations Scenario 2 achieves a faster transition by leveraging NSP's existing operational systems and control room infrastructure. IESO-NS personnel would utilize shared systems and facilities, minimizing implementati...
AI summary The document describes 'Scenario 2 - Shared Operations,' a model where the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS) utilizes Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSP) existing operational systems and control room infrastructure. While this approach accelerates the transition and minimizes implementation costs and timelines, it creates significant operational, cyber, and governance dependencies on NSP. The text notes that while technically feasible, this model restricts the future flexibility and independence of the IESO-NS.
Scenario 3 - Minimum Independence Scenario 3 introduces an independent IESO-NS control room while continuing to utilize NSP-hosted EMS and SCADA environments. This model improves physical separation and organizational independence but cont...
AI summary Scenario 3 describes a model for the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS) that establishes an independent control room while maintaining reliance on Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSP) for hosted Energy Management System (EMS) and SCADA environments. While this configuration enhances physical separation and organizational independence compared to previous models, the text notes that it leaves significant operational and cyber dependencies, resulting in only a partial achievement of independence objectives.
Scenario 4 - Enhanced Independence Scenario 4 introduces an independent EMS environment, enhanced operational optimization capabilities, stronger cyber segregation and greater operational autonomy. It delivers a level of independence suffi...
AI summary Scenario 4 describes an 'Enhanced Independence' model for the Energy Management System (EMS). This scenario aims to provide an independent EMS environment that features improved operational optimization, stronger cyber segregation, and increased operational autonomy. The goal is to satisfy the long-term legislative intent of the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) while deliberately avoiding the high implementation complexity associated with a full wholesale market model.
5.2. Basis of Cost, Benefit and Timeline Estimates The strategic scenarios were supported by high-level Class 4 planning estimates developed to provide a consistent basis for comparing costs, benefits and implementation timelines across th...
AI summary The text describes the methodology used to develop Class 4 planning estimates for various strategic scenarios. IBM used a capability-based assessment to decompose requirements into workstreams like EMS, SCADA, and cybersecurity, utilizing a mix of vendor data, NSP information, and analogous projects. FTI Consulting independently developed the benefit estimates, focusing on operational independence and optimization. Timelines were established based on complexity factors such as procurement lead times, facility readiness, and NERC compliance obligations.
7.Recommended Delivery Pathway: Phase 2A / 2B / 2C IBM recommends that Scenario 4 be implemented through a phased 2A / 2B / 2C delivery pathway. This phased approach is central to the recommendation. It allows IESO-NS to progress toward th...
AI summary IBM recommends a phased delivery pathway (2A, 2B, and 2C) for Scenario 4 to transition IESO-NS toward its long-term end-state. This approach manages complexity and preserves reliability by creating decision points. Steady State 1 (Phases 2A and 2B) establishes the first independent operating model by transferring BA/TOP responsibilities while leveraging existing systems. Steady State 2 (Phase 2C) completes the target model, adding technology resilience, cybersecurity segregation, and operational flexibility while minimizing risk.
What it delivers: - Establishes the independent IESO-NS control centre (ADC) - Begins BA/TOP operations using existing NSP systems - Creates secure physical/cyber boundaries - Builds operator capability and early credibility
AI summary The text outlines the functional objectives and deliverables of a new initiative, which includes establishing an independent IESO-NS control centre (ADC). Key milestones include commencing BA/TOP operations utilizing existing Nova Scotia Power (NSP) systems, creating secure physical and cyber boundaries, and developing operator capability to build early credibility in the system's management.
Why it matters: - Achieves the long-term "North Star" operating model and long-term customer benefits - Postpones enhancement capex, allowing design to be based on real operational experiences, including seeing full lunctionality of NSP EC...
AI summary The text outlines a three-phase roadmap to establish IESO-NS as an independent electricity system operator in Nova Scotia. Phase 2A focuses on operational control, including monitoring and dispatching. Phase 2B introduces independent settlement capabilities and commercial transactions. Phase 2C provides enhanced independence through an independent Energy Management System and improved dispatch optimization. This phased approach aims to achieve long-term system value, postpone capital expenditures, and eliminate dependencies to accelerate the transition to an independent operator model.
Fig 8 below illustrates the technology operating model for Steady State 1, with most of the OT components either shared with NSP or transferred from NSP. Base capablUtles Option selected for this capability Component I SCADA & Monitoring S...
AI summary The text describes the technology operating model for 'Steady State 1,' outlining how various Operational Technology (OT) components will be managed between Nova Scotia Power (NSP) and IESO-NS. Key capabilities such as SCADA & Monitoring, Energy Management Systems (EMS), and Training Systems will be shared or transferred. Specific tools for ECC Optimization, Operational Forecasting, Intertie Management, and Settlement are identified for transfer to IESO-NS, while new reporting capabilities will be built from the ground up.
7.3. Phase 2C Phase 2C corresponds to Steady State 2, which represents the completion of the long-term Scenario 4 target model. Steady State 2 builds on the independent operating model already delivered in Steady State 1, extending it with...
AI summary The text describes Phase 2C of the project, which corresponds to Steady State 2 of the long-term Scenario 4 target model. While Steady State 1 (Phases 2A and 2B) establishes the core operational and commercial capabilities for IESO-NS to assume BA, TOP, and market administration responsibilities, Steady State 2 builds upon this foundation. Phase 2C introduces enhanced technology resilience, cybersecurity segregation, independent EMS capabilities, and reduced dependency on NSP-hosted infrastructure to support Nova Scotia's long-term energy transition and future grid complexity.
Strategic Scenario #4 Option selected for this capability Component I Base capablUtles SCADA & Monitoring Same as Steady State 1 Same as in Scenario #3. The system is built around a core SCADA platform for real-time monitoring, control, an...
AI summary The document outlines Strategic Scenario #4 for system capabilities, focusing on the transition to a new operational framework. Key components include the transfer of an Energy Management System (EMS) from Nova Scotia Power to IESO-NS, featuring tools for automatic generation control and power system analysis. It also details plans for enhanced ECC Optimization Tools, improved market management, operational forecasting for wind and load, and the procurement of a new settlement system to align with market rules.
The estimated program costs are summarized in Fig 11 below, illustrating both the total investment and the allocation across each implementation phase. (All costs in $M) Total IT Costs $ 20.7 Program Integration $ 11.3 Control Center Build...
AI summary The document provides a detailed financial breakdown of estimated program costs for Phase 2 implementation, categorized into capital expenditures (Capex) and operating expenses (Opex). It outlines specific costs for IT, program integration, control center construction, NERC compliance, and cybersecurity. The summary includes a 'Mid Case' total Capex of $75.4M, with low and high case variations, and allocates these costs across three distinct implementation phases (Phase 2A, 2B, and 2C).
4. NERC Compliance (process & documentation): - Description: Includes compliance program and procedures development, audit readiness, and certification activities. This includes the work required for IESO-NS to be certified by NERC/NPCC to...
AI summary The text outlines the scope and basis for NERC compliance activities, focusing on the development of compliance programs, procedures, audit readiness, and certification. Specifically, it covers the work required for IESO-NS to obtain NERC/NPCC certification to perform Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions. This involves aligning documentation with NERC CIP and reliability standards, with estimates derived from professional judgment, industry benchmarks, and historical project data.
5. Cyber Security: - Description: Covers security architecture, network controls, monitoring, identity management, and required cyber controls. This includes the cybersecurity architecture and controls needed to support IESO-NS's independe...
AI summary The document outlines the requirements and scope for cybersecurity in the context of the IESO-NS independent operating environment. It specifies that the security architecture must include network controls, monitoring, identity management, and necessary cyber controls to meet NERC CIP requirements for BA/TOP certification. The cost estimates for these measures are based on a combination of vendor quotes, industry benchmarks, and professional judgment from past project experiences.
11. Opex Items: - Description: Includes incremental annual operating costs such as staffing, system operating costs, NERC compliance, training, and telecommunications. This reflects the ongoing annual operating costs required to sustain IE...
AI summary The document outlines the estimated annual operating expenses (OPEX) for IESO-NS's independent operations, totaling approximately $75 million. These costs cover staffing, system operations, NERC compliance, training, and telecommunications. The estimates are based on professional judgment and industry benchmarks, categorized as Class 3 accuracy (-15% to +20%). The text justifies the $64 million to $90 million range as reasonable for a large-scale operational transformation involving complex systems and governance development.
Program Integration Risk The transition of core operational functions involves complex integration between IESO-NS systems, NSP legacy infrastructure, and third-party vendors. The full extent of integration complexity may not be fully know...
AI summary The text addresses the risks associated with integrating core operational functions during the transition between IESO-NS systems and legacy Nova Scotia Power infrastructure. It highlights that the complexity of integrating these systems with third-party vendors may not be fully quantifiable until the detailed design phase of the project commences.
(a) General Comments The 2025 regulatory calendar involved the hearing of various significant matters before the Board, and particularly with regards to matters involving NSPI and Halifax Water, which both filed General Rate Applications i...
AI summary The Consumer Advocate (CA) provides general comments on the 2025 regulatory calendar, highlighting significant changes driven by Bill 404, including a new Board structure and an independent energy system operator. The CA notes that Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) faced a cyberattack in 2025 with ongoing regulatory impacts. The CA participated in over 100 proceedings in 2025, primarily advocating for residential ratepayers in matters involving NSPI, such as General Rate Applications and new Cost of Service methodologies.
Appendix A Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of 0490-208 Nova Scotia Power Incorporated M12117 - NSPI - CI C0061284 - IT - OT Cyber Security ControlPaper Hearing: Review of all evidence and material filed in matter. Corr...
AI summary The document provides a summary of professional services and activities related to several regulatory matters involving Nova Scotia Power Incorporated. These include a cyber security control paper hearing, an investigation arising from a joint use agreement, and the 2024 annual report for commercial net metering. The table outlines specific tasks such as reviewing evidence, filing information requests (IRs), and holding meetings with consultants and interested parties, alongside associated costs.
Small Business Advocate Company Total Hours for SBA and Consultants Sum of Fees for SBA Sum of Costs for SBA Sum of HST for SBA Total Sum for SBA Sum of Fees for Consultants (USD) Sum of Costs for Consultants (USD) Total Sum for Consultant...
AI summary The document provides a detailed breakdown of the Small Business Advocate's (SBA) activities and associated costs for various regulatory proceedings. It lists the hours spent by the SBA and its consultants, along with the corresponding fees and costs (including HST) for matters such as the NERC Winter Reliability Report, Storm Outage Analysis, Cyber Security Control Implementation, ELIADC Annual Report, and Joint Use Agreements. The data highlights the financial resources allocated to these specific regulatory oversight tasks.