N-30RIRs 1 to 15 - Nancy Brockway (on behalf of Consumer Advocate) to NS Attorney General (includes attachment to RIR 11) (Large File - 44 MB)
33 passages
A. Results - ( 1) Are customers enrolled in EAP willing and able to pay the offered EAP price? Yes, a significant sector of low-income payment-troubled customers successfully meet the requested payments of the EAP offer. Of those who enter...
AI summary The Energy Affordability Program (EAP) is evaluated as effective in helping low-income customers make regular payments, covering variable gas costs, reducing arrears, and being revenue-positive for Equitable. Over 70% of participants meet payment requirements, and the program does not lead to increased energy consumption. It is deemed a cost-effective business investment.
1. Four Major Recommendations 1. Perform a study of those who fall out. Equitable has taken an intelligent approach to the critical problem of affordability in the design of its program . Yet some customers do not meet the payment requirem...
AI summary The document outlines four major recommendations: conducting a study on customers who fall out of the Energy Assistance Program, increasing payments for the top two poverty groups, studying the cost impact of arrearage forgiveness, and expanding usage reduction activities. These recommendations aim to improve affordability and program effectiveness.
2. Five Minor Recommendations 1 . Add to monthly report. Add a year against year "% change" column to the monthly EAP Statistics report. See pages 84. - 2. Add comparison format. Add to the format of the EAP Statistics Report to allow comp...
AI summary The document outlines five minor recommendations for improving the EAP Statistics Report, including adding a year-over-year percentage change column, enabling half-year performance comparisons, tracking potential eligibles, collecting housing data, and classifying participants by senior status for better analysis and marketing.
2. Group 2: Non-participant Comparison Customers Non-participants, each of whom has been identified as both payment troubled and income eligible for EAP make up Group 2. The income requirement, as for EAP, was set at or below 150% of the F...
AI summary Group 2 consists of non-participant, payment-troubled customers who are income-eligible for the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) but chose not to participate. They are self-selected based on optimism about returning to full-payment status and are not used as a comparison group for payment behavior, though they are used for energy consumption comparisons.
a) Improving the Bottom-Line Prior to EAP, Equitable found 8,700 payment troubled low-income customers for whom the traditional credit and collection approaches were not working. Although they were placed on budget plus plans, on average t...
AI summary Prior to the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), Equitable struggled with collecting payments from 8,700 low-income customers, recovering only 50% of billed amounts. EAP is proposed as a solution to help these customers make regular, smaller payments, improving both their economic situation and the recovery rate for Equitable.
b) Reducing Consumption EAP attempts to encourage conservation and discourage waste of energy. - c) Increasing Participation in Assistance Programs By increasing customer participation in external assistance programs, the customer and Equi...
AI summary The EAP aims to promote energy conservation and reduce waste. It also seeks to increase participation in assistance programs, which helps customers access financial resources and supports consistent bill payment practices, benefiting both customers and Equitable.
23The utility, societal, non-participant, and participant interests have to be carefully balanced for a successful program. Note that this section of the study is limited to consideration of payment behavior. For cost/benefit, see Section...
AI summary The text discusses the balance of interests in a program, focusing on payment behavior within the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). It provides data on participation rates for new and ongoing EAP groups over two years, highlighting statistical calculations and considerations for re-enrollment.
b) Retention by Poverty Level The question of retention by poverty level brings the analysis of customer payment behavior to a more detailed level. At root, the concern in this sub-analysis is whether or not the program is functioning less...
AI summary This section examines customer payment behavior by poverty level, focusing on whether the Energy Affordability Program functions less effectively for those at lower poverty levels. The analysis uses poverty levels defined by the program (0-50%, 51-100%, and 101-150% of the federal Low Income Cut-Off). Table IV-2 provides a cross-tabulation of program retention by poverty level.
Table IV-2: Poverty PROGRAM RETENTION AND POVERTY Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Less than 12 Months in Poverty Level One Full Year EAP New EAP (n=335) 0-50 n=73 36% 64% 51-100 n=146 32% 68% 101-150 n=116 25% 75% (n=102) (n=233) Ongoing EAP (n...
AI summary The table presents data on program retention and poverty levels among participants in the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). It shows a weak tendency for retention in EAP to increase with higher levels of resources, though statistical significance is not confirmed.
B. Will the Payment Cover the Variable Cost of Gas? As shown in Table IV-4, total customer payment is higher for customers outside EAP (columns 2 and 6) than for customers in EAP, which is a natural artifact of any program concept which pr...
AI summary The document discusses how EAP participants pay the full variable cost of gas plus a contribution to fixed costs, with differences in payment observed between EAP and non-EAP customers. It also notes that some eligible individuals opt out of EAP for traditional credit and collection methods.
Table IV-4: Covering the Variable Cost of Gas CUSTOMER PAYMENT & THE VARIABLE COST OF GAS Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Column 6 Paid by Customer Year Prior to EAP (Group 1) NoEAP pre-period At least some Participation in EA...
AI summary Table IV-4 examines the impact of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) on customer payments and variable gas costs across different groups. It shows that customers who participated in EAP paid significantly less compared to those who did not, with percentages indicating the ratio of paid amounts to variable costs.
Table IV-5 shows the effect of EAP participation on the regularity of payment. It is clear in looking across the columns of Table IV-5 that EAP is quite successful in restoring the pattern of regular payment. The two groups outside EAP, Gr...
AI summary Table IV-5 demonstrates that EAP participation significantly improves the regularity of payments. Stable EAP participants show the best payment records, while those who drop out early have the worst. Groups outside EAP have similar payment profiles.
V. Do EAP Participants bring in more Grant Funding? CAP-type programs can be developed, implemented, maintained and improved for many reasons. Some major utilities see these programs as sound business policies, both because they place the...
AI summary The document discusses the funding sources for CAP-type programs, including payments from participants, LIHEAP grants, and operational expense reductions. It references the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission's guidance on program funding sources.
(iii) Operations and maintenance expense reductions. This section of the study reports on funding from Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) grants. LIHEAP is a Federally funded program which provides grants to eligible consum...
AI summary This section discusses the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), a federally funded initiative providing grants to eligible consumers in Pennsylvania for heating costs. It outlines the program's components, eligibility changes, and the impact of Congressional cuts. The Energy Assistance Program (EAP) is also mentioned as a related initiative aimed at encouraging assistance applications.
As shown in Table V-1, for "All Cases", there was a pattern of increase in average grant amount applied with degree of commitment to the program. Thus, in their Baseline Year, customers received an average of $153.33, increasing to $194.97...
AI summary The Energy Affordability Program (EAP) results in higher average grant amounts for participants compared to traditional approaches, with increases observed across different participation periods and poverty levels. EAP participants bring in more grant funds in the Participation Year than in the Baseline Year, with an overall increase of $70.00 per full first-year participant.
VI. Is there any Problem of Abuse of Energy Consumption? One of the primary objectives of this study is to determine the relationship between energy consumption and EAP participation, since an increase in consumption associated with EAP pa...
AI summary This section of the study examines whether the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) leads to increased energy consumption among participants, which could undermine program success. Two analytical approaches are used: a pooled data method to assess overall consumption trends and a statistical method to analyze consumption changes associated with program participation.
A. Customer Groups in the Study Two 12-month time periods and three groups (two participant groups and one non-participant group) are compared in this study. 32 The baseline year is defined as the 12 months from October 1 992 through Septe...
AI summary The study compares two 12-month time periods and three customer groups, including two participant groups and one non-participant group. The baseline year is from October 1, 1992, to September 1, 1993, while the EAP participation year is from April 1, 1994, to March 31, 1995.
1. Elements Common to Both Methods The basis for both methods is the analysis of billing history. Billing analysis involves comparison of EAP participants to a comparison group of similar customers outside EAP. Energy use from customer bil...
AI summary The analysis of energy consumption changes for EAP participants involves comparing their billing data to a control group using weather normalization and statistical methods. This process includes using PRISM® and SPSS to assess baseline and post-participation energy use, adjusting for weather variations.
3. Size of net change: The change of each participant group relative to its baseline, corrected for the absolute value of the change in the comparison group is about one percent, with a value of approximately for paired samples. \ Manageme...
AI summary The analysis of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) indicates that the net change in participant groups is negligible, with a one percent correction relative to the comparison group. Statistical significance tests fail to confirm the hypothesis of abuse, and the statistical power of the tests is high at 99%, supporting the conclusion that there is no abuse of the program.
EAP and 14 MCF for Ongoing EAP, see point 3 on page 61) the result is also a power level of 99% for each group. Thus the finding that there is no abuse of Program is true with a probability of 99%. 58 58This positive finding is based on th...
AI summary The analysis concludes that there is no abuse of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) with a 99% probability, based on multiple statistical analyses and power calculations. This conclusion is supported by agreement across various analytical factors including direction, size, and statistical significance.
E. Recommended Action Since the finding in the consumption analysis is that there is no abuse of the EAP, the recommendations regarding consumption are not suggested as essential actions, but rather as steps which might be helpful in conti...
AI summary The document recommends that since no abuse of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) was found, the consumption-related recommendations are not essential but may be useful for ongoing program management. The first three of five minor recommendations are likely easy to implement, while the last two may be impractical but could be considered if changes occur in the customer accounting system.
1. Five Minor Recommendations - 1. The possibility of abuse of consumption, of course, must be checked from time to time. Addition of a year against prior year% change of average normalized annual usage to the monthly EAP Statistics contro...
AI summary The document proposes five minor recommendations aimed at improving the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). These include monitoring consumption trends, organizing participants by half-year groups, comparing consumption between program and non-program participants, collecting housing data, and classifying data by senior status and number of residents to improve analysis accuracy.
VII. Comparative Administrative Cost Programs, of course, cannot be run without administrative cost. And, even the absence of a program will lead to the incurring of administrative costs. One of the concerns regarding any program is cost o...
AI summary The section discusses the importance of comparing administrative costs between the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) and traditional credit and collection methods, highlighting that all programs, including the absence of one, incur administrative costs.
ARREARAGE AMOUNT PER CUSTOMER Column 1 Col. 2 Col. 3 Col.4 n March '93 March '95 All New EAP Customers (Group 1) 221 819.47 1042.94 At least some Participation in EAP (Group 1: Less than 12 months in EAP) 68 1157.52 2008.93 Stable Full Yea...
AI summary The table shows the average arrears per customer in different EAP groups over time, with a strong seasonal pattern where arrears increase in winter, peak in spring, and decline through fall until the service termination moratorium begins.
2. Benefits In introducing a discussion of program benefits, it should be noted that it has been shown that the program meets the economic criterion for benefit to the non-participant customers. 79 Also, as discussed earlier, EAP meets the...
AI summary The Energy Affordability Program (EAP) benefits non-participant customers by meeting economic criteria and societal expectations, including providing energy services to low-income customers and ensuring payment. It also benefits stable participant customers by offering affordable energy services and requiring regular payments. From the utility's perspective, the program provides benefits through realized program payments, including customer payments and receipt of grants.
a) "Net Back Ratio" For the analysis, we use a benefit-cost measure of a type suggested by Roger Colton, the "Net Back Ratio" (NBR). The philosophy of this measure was introduced in Colton (1991):81 In addition to the decreased expenses as...
AI summary The document introduces the Net Back Ratio (NBR) as a benefit-cost measure to evaluate the performance of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). The NBR compares net program receipts to the variable cost of gas, providing a dimensionless indicator of program effectiveness. It helps assess whether the program generates net receipts exceeding variable gas costs and accounts for changes in gas prices over time.
~ COMPARATIVE PERFORMANCE Col. 1 I Col. 2 I Col. 3 I Col. 4 I Col. 5 I Col. 6 I Col.? I I I Variable I Table IX-1: Comparative Net Back Ratio Results Group Customer Payments Grants Applied Overhead Other Costs Cost of Gas NBR 1989 Referenc...
AI summary Table IX-1 presents comparative Net Back Ratio (NBR) results for different groups, including the 1989 Reference, Baseline Pre-Period, EAP (Energy Affordability Program) for varying timeframes, Tuned EAP, and Standard Rate. The data includes customer payments, grants applied, overhead, other costs, cost of gas, and NBR values.
a) Net Back Ratio Results Results on this measure are displayed in Table IX-1 . This table includes four virtual groups: a modeled "1989 Reference Group", a rate corrected (2) The "Baseline Pre-Period" group is the actual data for Group 1...
AI summary The Net Back Ratio (NBR) results show that most groups, except the 1989 Reference Group, have a positive return relative to the variable cost of gas. The EAP groups show favorable performance, with the Tuned EAP showing an improved NBR of 1.69 compared to the actual EAP's 1.41, indicating potential for better performance with adjusted payment ceilings.
b) Dollars Returned Results The "Dollars Returned" measure is referenced to the payment behavior evidenced by the 1989 Reference Group. In this model, based on the 50% payment rate in the group studied in 1989-1990, a customer who would ha...
AI summary The 'Dollars Returned' measure evaluates payment behavior based on a 1989 reference group, showing shortfalls when customers fail to pay full bills under the standard residential rate. EAP (Energy Affordability Program) is designed to assist low-income customers who struggle with traditional collection methods, ensuring they pay 100% of their billed amount under a more affordable rate structure.
COMPA ARATIVE SHORTE FALL PERI FORMANO Œ Col. 1 Col. 2 Col. 3 Col. 4 Col. 6 Group Standard Rate Customer Payments +Grants Shortfall EAP Credits Dollars Recovered 1989 Reference 1368 684 684 0 0 EAP: One full year 1385 955 0 430 262 EAP: Tw...
AI summary The table and text discuss the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), showing how EAP credits help recover dollars that would otherwise not be received by the utility. For customers in EAP for one full year, $262 is recovered, and an additional $206 is recovered for those remaining in the program for a second year, totaling $468 for two full years.
C. Revenue Impact of Those who Fail What happens to the 30% of customers who enter EAP, but fail to fully comply with program requirements during the first year? Those who drop out of EAP return to the traditional collection approaches, or...
AI summary The text discusses the revenue impact of customers who fail to comply with the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) requirements. These customers either return to traditional collection methods, reapply under certain conditions, or fall into a pattern of irregular payments under standard residential pricing, leading to ongoing revenue challenges.
The revenue effect by poverty level is shown in Table IX-3. Here, the percentage EAP credit is approximately equally across the three · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · DISTRIBUTIONAL EFFECTS DISTRIBUTION AL EL LECTS Col. 1 Col. 2 Col....
AI summary The text discusses the distributional effects of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) by poverty level, showing that the percentage EAP credit is approximately equal across income groups. This is attributed to grants being applied to the lowest income customers within poverty groups as funds become scarce and rationing is applied.
Table XI-1: Profiles of the Study Groups NEW EAP (GROUP 1) 12 months EAP post period Less than 12 months EAP post (GROUP 1) receiving amount receiving amount receiving amount receiving amount receiving amount LIHEAP pre 46 $142 12 $148 34...
AI summary Table XI-1 presents profiles of study groups, comparing data related to the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) and other assistance programs like LIHEAP and CRISIS before and after a 12-month period. It includes statistics on the number of recipients and grant amounts.