Topic:"Energy Efficiency Resource Assessment Model" in M07544

Table 3: Research Engagement Phase Research and Engagement Phase Research For example: Efficiency Maine's Residential and Commercial TRM provides documentation for energy and demand savings calculation of measures and operates as a common...

AI summary The text discusses the Research and Engagement Phase, highlighting examples such as Efficiency Maine's Residential and Commercial TRM, which provides documentation for energy and demand savings calculations. It also references the Commission of Con Ed in New York approving technical manuals for uniform energy estimation methods.

NOVA SCOTIA MARKET CHARACTERISTICS Nova Scotia has a population of approximately 950,000 people. There are just under 500,000 residential, commercial and industrial electricity accounts for NS Power. 29 12 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scot...

AI summary Nova Scotia has a population of about 950,000 and approximately 500,000 electricity accounts managed by NS Power. A reference is made to 'Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020' as a source of information.

er jurisdictions have applied different approaches for measure level testing, choosing to exclude administration costs as these can vary greatly depending on the maturity of the measure in the market. In conducting cost effectiveness scree...

AI summary The document discusses Nova Scotia's approach to cost effectiveness and avoided costs in energy efficiency programs. It notes that ENS uses the EERAM model for long-term planning, while avoided costs are updated every three to four years. Nova Scotia's methodology differs from other jurisdictions by not using average or marginal costs, and capacity costs are set at $0/kW until 2019.

Current Programs Program Name Program Offer and Incentive Structure Energy Management Information Systems (EMIS) For larger commercial and industrial customers, the EMIS program offers access to a performance management system to monitor a...

AI summary The document outlines two programs aimed at helping larger commercial and industrial customers manage energy usage: Energy Management Information Systems (EMIS) and Strategic Energy Management (SEM). Both programs provide support for implementing energy management solutions, including funding, training, and evaluation.

25 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Available: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary The document outlines Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, focusing on general principles, current activities, and recommended activities related to the province's electricity future.

Understand Technology Savings, Price and Market Penetration For Instant Savings, EfficiencyOne gains an understanding of technology savings, price and penetration through the following activities: 1. Energy Efficiency Standards (Regulation...

AI summary The text discusses EfficiencyOne's approach to understanding technology savings, price, and market penetration for the Instant Savings Program. It highlights the use of energy efficiency standards, program evaluation, industry data, and specific studies. In 2014, EfficiencyOne removed CFLs from the program in response to new codes and standards. Program evaluation is used annually to review and update energy savings assumptions.

echnology savings and pricing. Investigate the potential to develop a method, beyond randomized audits, to document and understand the different operating hours for the program participants in the Instant Rebates stream because those hours...

AI summary CLEAResult recommends investigating methods to document operating hours for program participants in the Instant Rebates stream, beyond randomized audits, and implementing recommendations from the General Principles section. It also suggests using semi-annual surveys to understand technology penetration in commercial efficiency programs.

JURISDICTIONAL SCANS - GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Jurisdiction Peak Load (MW) or Annual Consumption (Therms) Population Served Types of Electricity Generation Nova Scotia (ENS) 2,124 MW ≈ 950,000 Coal, Renewables, Natural Gas Ontario Electricity...

AI summary The jurisdictional scans compare electricity generation, consumption, and energy efficiency frameworks across various regions. Nova Scotia's energy framework period is 2016-2018, with an annual savings target of 135.3 GWh and a budget of $34.05 million. The table highlights differences in peak load, population served, generation sources, and efficiency programs.

3 2011-2014 Conservation Results: http://www.ieso.ca/Documents/2011-2014_Conservation_Results_Report.pdf Highlights from the results include: Retrofit program delivered 46 percent of portfolio savings Over 9.9 million energy efficient prod...

AI summary The 2011-2014 Conservation Results report highlights that the retrofit program delivered 46% of the portfolio savings, over 9.9 million energy-efficient products were incentivized, and the portfolio's LUEC, TRC, and PAC figures are provided.

Coal: 2 (0%) ELECTRIC - (millions of kilowatt-h iours) FIRM SALES AND INTERRUPTIBLE FOR NYPA OFF-SYSTEM CUSTOMER-OWNED AND YEAR RESIDENTIAL GENERAL TRANSPORTATION TRANSPORTATION N SALES AND OTHERS SALES GAS TRANSPORTATION 2014 46,661 28,96...

AI summary The document presents a table with electric and gas data, including sales and customer statistics for various years from 2009 to 2014. It includes information on residential, general, and transportation usage, as well as customer-owned and off-system sales.

Figure 42: Overall Targets 2007 - 20158 Energy Efficiency Savings (GWh) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991 7,263 10,631 14,082 17,608 21,222 24,927 NYSERDA SBC III Cu...

AI summary Figure 42 outlines energy efficiency savings targets from 2007 to 2015, including statewide goals, jurisdictional gaps, and specific territory targets. It also presents energy efficiency potential studies, such as the Con Edison Energy Efficiency Study 2010 and the Optimal Energy Efficiency Study 2008. Figures 43 and 44 provide program budgets for electric and gas programs over the same period.

Figure 45: Electric Savings Result 9 & lt;sup>8 Global Energy Partners, LLC, "Energy Efficiency Potential Study for Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. Volume 1: Executive Summary," http://www.coned.com/documents/Volume_1_Executi...

AI summary Figure 45 presents electric savings results from an energy efficiency study conducted by Global Energy Partners, LLC for Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc., with a reference to the New York Public Service Commission's Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard.

Program Analysis Initiatives Target Market Incentive Setting Methodology Multi-family Energy Efficiency (Electric and Gas) Customers that own/manage a multifamily building looking to make their property more energy-efficient. Free in-unit...

AI summary The document outlines energy efficiency initiatives targeting multifamily and commercial/industrial customers, detailing incentive structures and rebate programs. These include free installations, per-unit savings incentives, and prescriptive rebates for equipment upgrades, with specific caps and requirements such as the TRC test.

Previous Results (Savings, Expenditure, Cost Effectiveness) Year Electricity Savings Expenditure Cost Effectiveness 2013 Not Available Not Available Not Available 2014 Not Available Not Available Not Available 2015 Not Available Not Availa...

AI summary The document outlines previous results and future targets related to electricity savings, expenditure, and cost effectiveness, but data is not available for the years 2013 to 2018. It also mentions an incentive level setting methodology, though details are not provided.

EFFICIENCY VERMONT CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures (Prescriptive Incentives) Links Electronics Residential  Advanced Power Strips Incentive provided through a coupon at particip...

AI summary This section outlines the core program offerings of Efficiency Vermont, including residential and business programs such as advanced power strips, heat pump water heaters, and residential heating systems. Incentives are provided through coupons or rebates, with some qualifying products listed in upstream lists for instant incentives.

MARKET STRUCTURE OVERVIEW The Efficiency Maine Trust Act came in effect in 2009 and is responsible for Efficiency Maine's inception as an independent Trust. Their purpose is to develop, plan, coordinate, and implement energy efficiency/alt...

AI summary The Efficiency Maine Trust Act, effective in 2009, established Efficiency Maine as an independent trust responsible for implementing energy efficiency programs in Maine. These programs aim for significant energy savings, job creation, and greenhouse gas reductions. Triennial plans are developed and approved by the MPUC, and funding is sourced from ratepayers, the Forward Capacity Market, and utility contracts.

NATIONAL GRID CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures Links Small Business Program Commercial  For customers with a demand under 300 kW, offer a free audit for identifying energy saving...

AI summary The document outlines National Grid's core program offerings for residential and business customers, including incentives for energy efficiency measures such as audits, retrofits, and new construction or renovation projects. These programs aim to reduce energy consumption and promote sustainable practices.

Research and Engagement Phase Technology Research This research is conducted with the goal of understanding the savings opportunity for the technology, and to establish a range for the incentive level. All of the jurisdictions investigated...

AI summary This section discusses the importance of technology research in determining energy efficiency incentives. It highlights practices such as benchmarking, market research, and the use of technical resource manuals (TRMs) to establish savings opportunities and set incentive levels. Examples from various jurisdictions, including Efficiency Maine and Con Ed New York, are provided to illustrate these practices.

Year Residential Energy Savings (GWh) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Savings (GWh) Residential Demand Reduction (MW) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Demand Reduction (MW) Fully Allocated Residential Expenditure ($ mi...

AI summary The document presents tables showing historical energy savings and expenditure for residential and business sectors in Nova Scotia, and compares Nova Scotia's energy efficiency performance with other jurisdictions. It notes that Nova Scotia's efficiency programs are comparable to those in other regions in terms of spending and energy savings.

16 Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Restructuring (2014) Act - http://nslegislature.ca/legc/bills/62nd_1st/1st_read/b041.htm From a total consumption perspective, ENS's annual target for 2015 is 1.3 percent of electricity sales for...

AI summary The Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Restructuring (2014) Act is referenced, noting that ENS's 2015 annual target is 1.3 percent of electricity sales, comparable to other jurisdictions as seen in Table 12.

Understand Technology Savings, Price and Market Penetration For Instant Savings, EfficiencyOne gains an understanding of technology savings, price and penetration through the following activities: 1. Energy Efficiency Standards (Regulation...

AI summary EfficiencyOne uses energy efficiency standards, program evaluation, industry data, and specific studies to understand technology savings, price, and market penetration for the Instant Savings Program. In 2014, CFLs were removed from the program in response to upcoming codes and standards. Recommendations include continuing current activities and implementing changes to support the program.

Program Financial Simulation Analysis

AI summary The document outlines a Program Financial Simulation Analysis, likely evaluating financial models for energy efficiency programs regulated by Nova Scotia's Utility and Review Board. It may involve assessing demand-side management initiatives, efficiency programs, and regulatory criteria for utility operations.

Appendix A – Jurisdictional Scans

AI summary Appendix A outlines jurisdictional scans relevant to Nova Scotia's regulatory proceedings, likely involving energy efficiency, utility oversight, and demand-side management frameworks. The context includes references to regulatory bodies, programs, and technical criteria.

ONTARIO (IESO) –OVERVIEW

AI summary Overview of Ontario's IESO regulatory proceeding, involving entities like ENS, OEB, and LDCs, focusing on energy efficiency programs and regulatory frameworks. Key acronyms and organizations related to demand-side management and electricity system operations are listed.

Figure 22: Union Gas Scorecar[d](#page-125-0) 4 Union Resource Acquisition Low- Income Large Volume Market Transformation Performance- based Cumulative natural gas savings metric weight 75% 100% 100% 0% 0% Other metric weight 25% 0% 0% 100...

AI summary Figure 22 outlines Union Gas's proposed scorecard with different metric weights for various categories, including resource acquisition, low-income, large volume, market transformation, and performance-based. The scorecard assigns different weights to metrics such as cumulative natural gas savings and other metrics.

- 4. Net Levelized cost ($/kWh)1 = PV (costs all benefits except for electric energy benefits) / PV (energy savings) Benefits Costs Commercial BC Hydro Leaders in Energy Management This program provides a range of technologies, but focuses...

AI summary The document discusses a Net Levelized Cost calculation formula and outlines a program by BC Hydro that focuses on energy efficiency initiatives, including business management tools, asset management funding, change management education, and peer recognition.

APPENDIX A-4: CALIFORNIA (PG&E) Program Type Programs Details Energy Studies & Audits Energy assessments are given to determine how to use energy and trim costs. Eligibility is based on energy consumption and system size. The types of stud...

AI summary This section outlines energy studies and audits offered by PG&E in California, including customer site investigations, plant-wide audits, end use assessments, and energy efficiency feasibility studies, with eligibility based on energy consumption and system size.

Peak Demand Electricity: 12,316 MW (2015) Gas: 1,068 MDt (2016) Electric Retail Price per kWh in 2014 for Con Ed (In Cents) Residential: 28.85 Commercial: 22.16 Industrial: 20.18 Transportation: 17.44 Retail Price per Thousand Cubic Feet i...

AI summary The text provides statistics on electricity and gas demand, retail prices, and energy generation sources in Nova Scotia and New York. It includes data on peak demand, energy sources like nuclear, natural gas, and hydroelectric, and electricity prices for residential, commercial, and industrial sectors.

KEY PLAYERS

AI summary The 'KEY PLAYERS' section outlines key organizations, programs, and regulatory bodies involved in Nova Scotia's energy and utility proceedings. It includes acronyms for entities such as Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB), Demand Side Management (DSM), and Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS), along with other provincial, national, and international stakeholders.

Figure 43: Overall Targets 2007 - 2015 8 Energy Efficiency Savings (GWh) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991 7,263 10,631 14,082 17,608 21,222 24,927 NYSERDA SBC III C...

AI summary The text presents energy efficiency savings targets and program budgets for New York State and Con Edison from 2007 to 2015, highlighting the gap between statewide goals and jurisdictional targets, as well as the financial commitments allocated to various energy efficiency programs.

VERMONT ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM INCENTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVENESS POLICY Vermont is viewed as one of the leading jurisdictions for promoting conservation in North America. Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) has won multiple awar...

AI summary Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) manages energy efficiency programs in Vermont, which does not have state legislation setting annual energy efficiency targets. Instead, targets are negotiated in three-year cycles and are based on achieving all reasonably available, cost-effective energy efficiency. The current cycle (2015-2017) has a savings target of 321,800 MWh and a total resource benefits target of $336.3 million.

2012 2013 2014 2012–2014 Total Energy savings in megawatt- hours (MWh) 110,179 85,582 91,146 286,907 Total Resource Benefits 2 $118,358,445 $83,830,177 $82,101,439 $284,290,061 U.S. tons of carbon dioxide emissions avoided through efficien...

AI summary The document presents key quantifiable performance indicators (QPIs) for energy efficiency programs, including energy savings in megawatt-hours, total resource benefits, and carbon dioxide emissions avoided from 2012 to 2014. The results show that most goals were achieved or exceeded, with a notable 163% achievement in the ratio of gross electric benefits to spending.

LOAD AND CONSUMPTION INFORMATION (ELECTRIC) Electricity in Maine is distributed by ISO New England. Northern Maine Independent System Operator services northern Maine. Maine itself has 13 electric utility suppliers. Three of these utilitie...

AI summary The document provides information about electricity distribution in Maine, mentioning ISO New England and Northern Maine Independent System Operator as key entities. It also notes that Maine has 13 electric utility suppliers, with three major ones serving over 90% of the state's 1.33 million residents. The peak demand in 2014 was 2,200 MW.

Figure 51: Retail Sales of Electricity (Million kilowatt-hours) 4 2012 2013 2014 2015 Retail sales of electricity (million kilowatthours) New England All sectors 120,456 121,357 119,983 119,311 ··· Residential 47,208 48,369 47,212 47,397 ·...

AI summary The text presents retail electricity sales data for New England and Maine across various sectors from 2012 to 2015, including residential, commercial, industrial, and transportation. The data highlights fluctuations in electricity consumption over time.

Figure 61: Benefit- Cost Ratios: Electric Programs 2015 [12](#page-198-0) Adjusted Gross Benefit-to-Cost-Ratio Net Benefit-to-Cost-Ratio Programs TRC PACT Last Evaluation Net to Gross Ratio TRC PACT Business Incentive Program Electric Meas...

AI summary The text presents benefit-cost ratios for various electric and natural gas programs in 2015, including adjusted gross and net benefit-to-cost ratios for different initiatives such as the Business Incentive Program, Home Energy Savings Program, and Low-Income Direct Install Initiative. These ratios are calculated using TRC and PACT metrics.

NATIONAL GRID – UTILITY OVERVIEW

AI summary The document provides an overview of National Grid's utility operations, referencing regulatory bodies, energy efficiency programs, and technical standards relevant to Nova Scotia. Key entities include Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB), Demand Side Management (DSM), and Efficiency Nova Scotia (EN). Topics focus on utility regulation and energy efficiency initiatives.

NATIONAL GRID CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures Links Sustainable Office Design Commercial  The sustainable office design provides an incentive of $1.00/sqft (leased space net of...

AI summary The document outlines National Grid's core program offerings for residential and business customers, including incentives for energy-efficient lighting, building assessments, and benchmarking tools. These programs aim to promote energy efficiency and reduce environmental impact.

Year Residential Energy Savings (GWh) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Savings (GWh) Residential Demand Reduction (MW) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Demand Reduction (MW) Fully Allocated Residential Expenditure ($ mi...

AI summary The tables provide historical data on energy savings and expenditures for residential and business sectors in Nova Scotia from 2010 to 2014. The data show energy savings, demand reduction, and expenditures for Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS). The text notes that ENS performance is comparable to other jurisdictions in terms of energy efficiency targets and spending.

er jurisdictions have applied different approaches for measure level testing, choosing to exclude administration costs as these can vary greatly depending on the maturity of the measure in the market. In conducting cost effectiveness scree...

AI summary Nova Scotia uses the Energy Efficiency Resource Assessment Model (EERAM) for long-term energy savings planning and excludes administration costs in measure-level testing. Avoided costs are updated every three to four years and are currently set at $0/kW for capacity savings until 2019. This methodology differs from other jurisdictions as conservation activity competes with the lowest cost of supply, and measures can only claim avoided energy costs until 2020.

Table 151115 : ENS Program Overview Program Name Program Offer and Incentive Structure Type of Program (for CE modelling purposes) Energy Management Information Systems (EMIS) For larger commercial and industrial customers, the EMIS progra...

AI summary The document outlines two ENS programs: Energy Management Information Systems (EMIS) and Strategic Energy Management (SEM), both targeting larger commercial and industrial customers. These programs provide support for energy management systems, including installation, training, and evaluation, with the goal of achieving long-term energy and cost savings.

The following table contains an analysis of the barriers and the associated incentive strategy for the four investigated programs. Program Identified Barriers Incentive Strategy Home Energy Assessment 1) Residential customers lack knowledg...

AI summary The text discusses barriers to the Home Energy Assessment program, including lack of customer knowledge and concerns about upfront costs, and outlines an incentive strategy involving subsidized assessments and personal energy planning services.

25 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Available: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary The document presents Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, outlining general principles, current activities, and recommended activities related to the province's electricity future.

Understand Technology Savings, Price and Market Penetration For Instant Savings, EfficiencyOne gains an understanding of technology savings, price and penetration through the following activities: 1. Energy Efficiency Standards (Regulation...

AI summary EfficiencyOne uses energy efficiency standards, program evaluation, industry data, and specific studies to understand technology savings, price, and market penetration for the Instant Savings program. In 2014, they eliminated CFLs based on upcoming codes and standards. Annual reviews and conversations with retailers help update assumptions and gather market data.

LOAD AND CONSUMPTION INFORMATION Peak Demand (2017 Forecast): 11,681 MW Consumption (2017 Forecast): 63,238 GWh o Residential: 19,761 GWh (31%) o Commercial: 17,815 GWh (28%) o Industrial: 19,016 GWh (30%)

AI summary The document provides load and consumption information for 2017, forecasting peak demand at 11,681 MW and total consumption at 63,238 GWh. Residential, commercial, and industrial consumption percentages are also outlined as 31%, 28%, and 30%, respectively.

Figure 262526: Electricity Savings from Energy Efficiency Programs F2003 - F2007 [44](#page-139-0) Cumulative Electricity Savings (GWh/year) Plan Actual Variance F2003 353 358 1% F2004 610 739 21% F2005 890 1,147 29% F2006 1,177 1,391 18%...

AI summary The figure shows electricity savings from energy efficiency programs from F2003 to F2007, with actual savings exceeding planned targets. A forecast of 10,610 GWh of savings per year and 1,756 MW of savings in 2020 is mentioned, aligned with the 2007 Energy Plan's conservation target, based on a Conservation Potential Review (CPR) conducted in 2006 and 2007.

APPENDIX A-4: CALIFORNIA (PG&E) Program Type Programs Details Energy Studies & Audits Energy assessments are given to determine how to use energy and trim costs. Eligibility is based on energy consumption and system size. The types of stud...

AI summary Appendix A-4 discusses energy studies and audits offered by California's PG&E. These include customer site investigations, plant-wide audits, end use assessments, and energy efficiency feasibility studies, with eligibility based on energy consumption and system size.

Figure 403940: Electricity Use and Number of Customers 1 ELECTRIC - (millions of kilowatt-h ours) TOTAL SALES TOTAL SALES COMMERCIAL AND DELIVERIES DELIVERY SERVICE DELIVERY SERVICE SERVICE FOR AND DELIVERIES OFF-SYSTEM & INDUSTRIAL RAILRO...

AI summary The document presents tables showing electricity and gas use along with the number of customers over several years, providing data on sales, deliveries, and customer counts for different sectors such as residential, commercial, industrial, and others. This data is used for analysis and planning purposes.

Figure 434243 : Overall Targets 2007 - 2015 8 E- normy Effi cionar Car vings (GW (b.) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 2007 2000 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2013 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991...

AI summary The text presents data on energy efficiency targets and program budgets from 2007 to 2015, including statewide goals, jurisdictional gaps, and program expenditures for electric and gas initiatives in New York State. It outlines energy efficiency potential studies and budget allocations for various programs targeting residential, commercial, and industrial sectors.

2010 $2.046.E99 2011 $3,046,588 2012 2013 $8,066,906 $4,748,800 $25,945,436 $12,790,000 $6,963,628 2014 $6,000,900 φ4,740,000 $25,945,430 $12,790,000 φ0,903,026 2015 Figure 464546 : Electric Savings Result 99 Program Names (Savings in MWh)...

AI summary The text presents tables showing electric and gas savings results from various programs between 2009 and 2015. It includes data on accumulated savings, program names, and specific savings by program type and year. The section also mentions 'Cost Effectiveness Testing,' indicating a focus on evaluating the financial performance of these programs.

Previous Results (Savings, Expenditure, Cost Effectiveness) Year Electricity Savings Expenditure Cost Effectiveness 2013 Not Available Not Available Not Available 2014 Not Available Not Available Not Available 2015 Not Available Not Availa...

AI summary The document provides a summary of previous results related to electricity savings, expenditure, and cost effectiveness from 2013 to 2015, with data not available for these years. It also outlines future targets for 2016 to 2018, with similarly missing data. The section on incentive level setting methodology is mentioned but not detailed.

VERMONT ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM INCENTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVENESS POLICY Vermont is viewed as one of the leading jurisdictions for promoting conservation in North America. Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) has won multiple awar...

AI summary Vermont's energy efficiency program, managed by Efficiency Vermont, sets three-year energy savings targets and budgets negotiated between the PSB and VEIC. The 2015-2017 cycle targets 321,800 MWh of savings and a total resource benefits target of $336.3 million. Performance is measured through an EM&V process, with payments contingent on meeting targets.

NATIONAL GRID CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures Links Large Retrofit Program Commercial  Provides incentives for lighting and lighting controls, variable speed drives, food servic...

AI summary The National Grid Core Program Offerings include incentives for energy efficiency retrofits in commercial settings, covering lighting, variable speed drives, and food service equipment. Custom incentives are available for non-prescriptive measures, with engineering studies to assess savings.

EFFICIENCYONE INCENTIVE SETTING METHODOLOGY FILING (E-ENS-R-16) 1 EfficiencyOne developed a market research plan for 2017-2018 within the first 2 quarter of 2017 to address CLEAResult's recommendations. 3 4 EfficiencyOne is currently deter...

AI summary EfficiencyOne developed a market research plan in 2017 to address CLEAResult's recommendations and is determining the best approach for conducting technology and market penetration research. EfficiencyOne is also developing an electronic TRM for use in its new data tracking system and has completed a consolidated calculator for incentive design.

Research and Engagement Phase Research Efficiency Maine's Residential and Commercial TRM provides documentation for energy and demand savings calculation of measures and operates as a common point of reference for the methods, formulas, as...

AI summary The text discusses the use of Technology Readiness Matrices (TRMs) by Efficiency Maine and the Commission of Con Ed New York for calculating energy and demand savings. These matrices serve as standardized references for methods, formulas, and assumptions used in energy efficiency programs.

Year Residential Energy Savings (GWh) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Savings (GWh) Residential Demand Reduction (MW) Business, Not for Profit and Institutional Demand Reduction (MW) Fully Allocated Residential Expenditure ($ mi...

AI summary The tables provide data on energy savings and expenditures related to residential and business energy efficiency programs in Nova Scotia from 2010 to 2014. The data includes energy savings in gigawatt-hours, demand reduction in megawatts, and expenditures in millions of dollars. Additional tables compare the unit cost of conservation and energy savings percentages across various jurisdictions, including Nova Scotia, Ontario, British Columbia, California, and others.

Table 15 : ENS Program Overview Program Name Program Offer and Incentive Structure Type of Program (for CE modelling purposes) Name costs $99, and based on changes to the design, the customer can receive up to $2,000 in rebates. The rebate...

AI summary The table outlines the ENS Program Overview, highlighting the rebates and incentive structures for residential and business energy efficiency programs. Residential customers receive rebates based on energy performance improvements, while commercial and industrial customers have options for prescriptive incentives or interest-free financing.

SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS - 1. It is recommended that EfficiencyOne consider all of the general principles for incorporation into an incentive setting process. - CLEAResult has provided a documented, incentive setting process (that incorp...

AI summary The summary outlines recommendations for EfficiencyOne to adopt a structured incentive setting process, including leveraging CLEAResult's methodology, updating technology assumptions through research, implementing a TRM approach, developing a consolidated calculator, and conducting program financial simulations to evaluate current incentive levels.

22 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Available: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary The document outlines Nova Scotia's energy plan from 2015 to 2020, focusing on general principles, current activities, and recommended activities related to electricity future planning.

Understand Technology Savings, Price and Market Penetration For Instant Savings, EfficiencyOne gains an understanding of technology savings, price and penetration through the following activities: 1. Energy Efficiency Standards (Regulation...

AI summary The Instant Savings Program relies on EfficiencyOne's understanding of technology savings, price, and market penetration through activities such as energy efficiency standards, program evaluation, industry data, and specific studies. EfficiencyOne has taken proactive steps, such as eliminating CFLs in 2014, and continues to review energy savings assumptions annually. The recommendations include continuing current activities and implementing changes to support the program.

JURISDICTIONAL SCANS - GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Jurisdiction Peak Load (MW) or Annual Consumption (Therms) Population Served Types of Electricity Generation Nova Scotia (ENS) 2,124 MW ≈950,000 Coal, Renewables, Natural Gas Ontario Electricity...

AI summary The jurisdictional scans compare energy data across various regions, including Nova Scotia, Ontario, British Columbia, and others. Nova Scotia's energy framework period is 2016-2018 with a target of 135.3 GWh annual savings, while Ontario's framework period is 2015-2020 with a much higher savings target of 1,450 GWh. The data highlights differences in peak load, population served, electricity generation types, and energy efficiency programs.

Figure 22: Union Gas Scorecar[d](#page-125-0) 4 Union Resource Acquisition Low- Income Large Volume Market Transformation Performance- based Cumulative natural gas savings metric weight 75% 100% 100% 0% 0% Other metric weight 25% 0% 0% 100...

AI summary Figure 22 presents a scorecard for Union Gas, outlining the metric weights for various categories, including resource acquisition, low-income, large volume, market transformation, and performance-based metrics. The scorecard emphasizes different weights for each category, with a focus on cumulative natural gas savings and other metrics.

Figure 23: Union Gas Targets & Performance Metric[s](#page-125-0) 4 Resource Acquisition Scorecard Large Volume Large Volume Large Volume - Revised Large Volume - Revised Evaluation - Revised Administrative costs - Revised Large Volume Tot...

AI summary The document presents a table titled 'Union Gas Targets & Performance Metrics' which outlines various resource acquisition scorecards, including categories such as Large Volume, Market Transformation, Commercial Savings By Design, and Program Budgets. The table includes revised administrative costs, overheads, and evaluation components, but the content is largely incomplete or repetitive.

Figure 29: Cumulative GWh/Year following the 2008 BC Energy Plan [4](#page-134-0) GWH/YEAR F2008 F2009 F2010 F2011 F2012 Target 295 761 1,700 2,300 3,500 Actual 326 983 1,778 2,348 BC Hydro has developed annual cumulative targets using the...

AI summary Figure 29 shows the cumulative GWh/year targets and actuals from the 2008 BC Energy Plan, highlighting the performance of BC Hydro's demand-side management (DSM) initiatives. Targets and actuals are provided for the years 2008 to 2012, with the Conservation Potential Review (CPR) and other DSM tools used to set these targets.

- 4. Net Levelized cost ($/kWh)1 = PV (costs all benefits except for electric energy benefits) / PV (energy savings) Benefits Costs Avoided electric energy costs Avoided electric capacity costs Avoided non-electric fuel costs Customer non-...

AI summary The text outlines the calculation of net levelized cost per kWh, focusing on the ratio of present value of costs (excluding electric energy benefits) to present value of energy savings. It lists various benefits and costs associated with energy efficiency programs, including avoided costs, customer impacts, and program expenses.

Peak Demand Electricity: 12,316 MW (2015) Gas: 1,068 MDt (2016) Electric Retail Price per kWh in 2014 for Con Ed (In Cents) Residential: 28.85 Commercial: 22.16 Industrial: 20.18 Transportation: 17.44 Retail Price per Thousand Cubic Feet i...

AI summary The text provides statistical data on peak demand, electricity and gas usage, retail prices, and energy generation sources in Nova Scotia and New York State, including breakdowns by sector and fuel type.

Figure 43: Overall Targets 2007 - 20158 Eı nergy Effi ciency Sa vings (GW /h) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991 7,263 10,631 14,082 17,608 21,222 24,927 NYSERDA SBC...

AI summary The text presents tables showing energy efficiency targets and program budgets from 2007 to 2015 for New York State and Con Edison territories, including goals set by NYSERDA and the New York State Public Utilities Commission (PUC). These tables include energy efficiency savings targets, jurisdictional gaps, and program budgets for electric and gas programs.

VERMONT ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM INCENTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVENESS POLICY Vermont is viewed as one of the leading jurisdictions for promoting conservation in North America. Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) has won multiple awar...

AI summary Vermont's energy efficiency programs are managed by Efficiency Vermont, which operates under budgets and targets negotiated with the PSB. These targets aim for 'all reasonably available, cost effective energy efficiency' and are set in three-year cycles. The 2015-2017 cycle had a savings target of 321,800 MWh and a total resource benefits target of $336.3 million, with funding contingent on performance verified through an EM&V process.

EFFICIENCY VERMONT CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures (Prescriptive Incentives) Links Industrial & Special Equipment  Compressed Air  Pool Pumps Rebates are paid after purchase an...

AI summary The document outlines the Efficiency Vermont Core Program Offerings, focusing on residential and business programs, including incentives for industrial and special equipment like compressed air and pool pumps, with rebates available after purchase and submission of a rebate form.

High Level Specifications

AI summary The document provides a list of acronyms and their expansions related to energy efficiency, regulatory proceedings, and utility management in Nova Scotia and other jurisdictions. It serves as a reference for terminology used in regulatory analyses and proceedings.

1 EfficiencyOne commits to developingdeveloped a market research plan for 2 2017-2018 within the first quarter of 2017 to address CLEAResult's 3 recommendations. 4 5 EfficiencyOne is currently determining the best approach for conducting 6...

AI summary EfficiencyOne is working on developing a market research plan and an electronic TRM as recommended by CLEAResult. They are also creating a consolidated calculator for incentive design purposes. These initiatives are part of their commitment to improve energy efficiency programs and data management systems.

ac • u E f f ic ien On ho l d int du fo l ion l i da ion t t • cy e s u ro ce a rm a me as ure s as su mp v a d l. Ma he j is d ic ion fer he l a t t to t p roc es s a n su mm ary m an ua ny o r ur s re m an ua s he T R M d ha for l fo int...

AI summary The document outlines the implementation of efficiency measures and the development of a comprehensive energy plan for Nova Scotia from 2015 to 2020, focusing on energy efficiency, renewable energy, and stakeholder engagement. It includes discussions on policy frameworks, program development, and the role of Efficiency Nova Scotia.

Un de d ta rs n Te hn log c o y Sa ing Pr ice d s, a n v Ma ke Pe ion t tra t r ne Fo he Ho En As E f f ic ien On ins de d ing f t hn log ing ice d r t nt ta me er g y se ss me p rog ra m, cy e g a a n un rs n o ec o y sa v s, p r a n ion...

AI summary CLEAResult provides recommendations for the Home Energy Assessment program, focusing on the evaluation of the program's effectiveness, the use of technology for energy savings, and the need for improved information and communication strategies to enhance program participation and outcomes.

Before the current Conservation First Framework (CFF, 2015-2020), Ontario's previous cycle for efficiency programs was from 2011-2014. The following results are summarized for that period 3 : Program Net Savings (GWh) Expenditure Appliance...

AI summary This text discusses the results of Ontario's efficiency programs from 2011-2014, presenting data on net savings and expenditures for various programs, as well as TRC and PAC metrics for different sectors.

APPENDIX A-4: CALIFORNIA (PG&E) Program Type Programs Details Energy Studies & Audits Energy assessments are given to determine how to use energy and trim costs. Eligibility is based on energy consumption and system size. The types of stud...

AI summary This section outlines energy studies and audits offered by PG&E in California, including various types of assessments aimed at helping customers reduce energy consumption and costs. Eligibility is based on energy consumption and system size.

Avoided Costs Within California, the avoided costs of electricity are generated by E3 for a 20-year period based on the following components: generation energy, generation capacity, ancillary services, transmission and distribution capacit...

AI summary The document discusses avoided costs in California, including components like generation energy, capacity, and environmental benefits, as well as natural gas avoided costs. The avoided cost model is updated periodically, with the most recent update in 2011.

Peak Demand Electricity: 12,316 MW (2015)Gas: 1,068 MDt (2016) Electric Retail Price per kWh in 2014 for Con Ed (In Cents) Residential: 28.85Commercial: 22.16Industrial: 20.18Transportation: 17.44 Retail Price per Thousand Cubic Feet in 20...

AI summary The text provides statistics on peak demand and energy generation, including electricity and gas figures, retail prices for different sectors, and state net generation by energy source. It includes data from 2014 to 2016, highlighting the share of energy generated from various sources such as nuclear, natural gas, hydroelectric, coal, wind, and others.

KEY PLAYERS

AI summary The 'KEY PLAYERS' section lists organizations, programs, and legislation involved in Nova Scotia's regulatory proceeding, including energy efficiency initiatives, utility boards, and technical advisory groups. Key entities include Nova Scotia Power (NSP), Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS), and the Canadian Energy Efficiency Alliance (CEEA), alongside methodologies like RULDICM and TRM.

Figure 43: Overall Targets 2007 - 2015 8 Energy Efficiency Savings (GWh) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991 7,263 10,631 14,082 17,608 21,222 24,927 NYSERDA SBC III C...

AI summary Figure 43 presents energy efficiency savings targets from 2007 to 2015 for New York State and Con Edison, highlighting statewide goals, jurisdictional gaps, and studies on achievable potential. Figure 44 and 45 provide electric and gas program budgets across various years, illustrating funding allocated to energy efficiency initiatives.

Figure 46: Electric Savings Result 9 Program Names (Savings in MWh) Accumulated Savings to Year C&I Custom Efficiency C&I Equipment Rebate Small Business Direct Install Residential Direct Install Appliance Bounty Residential Room Air Condi...

AI summary The text presents tables showing electric and gas savings results from various programs over the years, with data on accumulated savings and targets. It includes program names, years, and savings metrics, highlighting the performance of different initiatives in energy efficiency and conservation.

VERMONT ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM INCENTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVENESS POLICY Vermont is viewed as one of the leading jurisdictions for promoting conservation in North America. Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) has won multiple awar...

AI summary Vermont promotes energy efficiency through negotiated targets with the PSB and VEIC, operating under three-year cycles with performance-based payments. The 2015-2017 cycle has a savings target of 321,800 MWh and a total resource benefits target of $336.3 million. The DRP process sets these targets over a 20-year horizon.

EFFICIENCY VERMONT –OVERVIEW

AI summary Overview of Efficiency Vermont, focusing on energy efficiency initiatives and regulatory considerations. The text outlines key programs, stakeholders, and methodologies related to demand-side management and energy conservation in Nova Scotia.

second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the...

AI summary The text includes repeated text, chart parameters, and citations to reports and data sources related to electricity customer accounts and pricing in Maine. It references the Maine Public Utilities Commission and the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

Figure 56: 2011-2015 Electric Savings Result 11 Year Total (GWh) 2011 173.5 2012 226 2013 134 2014 162 2015 224 Total 919.5 10 Efficiency Maine, "2010 Annual Report," http://www.efficiencymaine.com/docs/EMO16444_AnnualReport_2010.pdf

AI summary Figure 56 presents electric savings results from 2011 to 2015, showing total savings in gigawatt-hours (GWh) for each year, with a cumulative total of 919.5 GWh. The data highlights fluctuations in energy savings over this period.

NATIONAL GRID CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures Links Large Retrofit Program Commercial • Provides incentives for lighting and lighting controls, variable speed drives, food servic...

AI summary The Large Retrofit Program provides incentives for energy efficiency measures in commercial settings, including lighting, variable speed drives, and energy management systems. Incentives vary based on prescriptive, quasi-prescriptive, or custom measures and are available for qualifying equipment and studies.

High Level Specifications

AI summary The document outlines high-level specifications for a Nova Scotia regulatory proceeding, listing numerous acronyms related to energy efficiency, utility regulation, and demand-side management. Key entities include regulatory bodies, programs, and technical methodologies relevant to energy policy and resource planning.