Topic:"Energy Efficiency Resource Standards" in M07544

BEST-IN-CLASS In Canada, Ontario and British Columbia have the largest energy efficiency budgets and the longest history of designing and delivering energy conservation programs. They are also usually considered the leading provinces for p...

AI summary Ontario and British Columbia lead in Canada's energy efficiency programs. The ACEEE 2015 scorecard ranks U.S. states, with most in the top ten except Maine. American jurisdictions have long-term Energy Efficiency Resource Standards (EERS), showing commitment to energy efficiency.

POLICY CONSIDERATIONS

AI summary The policy considerations section discusses energy efficiency initiatives, regulatory frameworks, and stakeholder input. Key topics include demand-side management (DSM), Energy Efficiency Resource Standards (EERS), and technology evaluation methods. Organizations like the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB) and the Canadian Energy Efficiency Alliance (CEEA) are referenced, along with programs such as EERS and DSM.

COST EFFECTIVENESS AND AVOIDED COSTS At the portfolio level, cost effectiveness is guaranteed since the combination of savings targets and budget is lower than the cost effectiveness threshold (provided that the persistence of the energy s...

AI summary The document discusses cost effectiveness and avoided costs in Nova Scotia's Demand Side Management (DSM) programs. It outlines a Technology Research Cost (TRC) threshold of 1.0 for program measures, inclusion of program administration costs in TRC screening, and references strategies used in other jurisdictions like Energy Trust of Oregon. A study by Navigant Consulting is cited for DSM potential analysis.

25 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Available: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary The document outlines Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, focusing on general principles, current activities, and recommended activities related to the province's electricity future.

JURISDICTIONAL SCANS - GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Jurisdiction Peak Load (MW) or Annual Consumption (Therms) Population Served Types of Electricity Generation New York (ConEd) 2009-2015 (EEPS) 2012-2015 (EEPS II) 163.56 GWh (EEPS) Average $78.25...

AI summary The document presents a jurisdictional scan comparing energy data across various regions, including peak load, population served, electricity generation types, and cost metrics. It highlights differences in energy consumption, costs, and efficiency programs across jurisdictions such as New York, Vermont, Maine, and Massachusetts.

APPENDIX A-1: ONTARIO ELECTRICITY

AI summary Appendix A-1 discusses Ontario electricity, referencing organizations and programs related to energy efficiency and demand-side management. Key entities include Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board, American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, and Energy Efficiency Resource Standards.

ONTARIO (IESO) –OVERVIEW

AI summary Overview of the Ontario Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) regulatory proceeding, involving key entities like the Ontario Energy Board (OEB), Ontario Power Authority (OPA), and Local Distribution Companies (LDCs). Focus areas include Demand Side Management (DSM) and Energy Efficiency Resource Standards (EERS).

ONTARIO - ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMMING

AI summary The document outlines Ontario's energy efficiency programming initiatives, involving key stakeholders and regulatory bodies. It references programs, methodologies, and organizations involved in demand-side management and energy efficiency standards.

APPENDIX A: MEASURE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS

AI summary Appendix A outlines the Measure Development Process within a Nova Scotia regulatory proceeding, involving entities like the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB) and the DSM Advisory Group (DSMAG). It references energy efficiency frameworks, cost methodologies, and stakeholder involvement in demand-side management (DSM) initiatives.

LOAD AND CONSUMPTION INFORMATION

AI summary The text provides context for load and consumption information, listing acronyms related to energy efficiency, regulatory bodies, and programs. Key entities include organizations like the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board and programs such as Demand Side Management.

KEY PLAYERS

AI summary The document outlines key players in a Nova Scotia regulatory proceeding, including organizations, programs, and legislation related to energy efficiency, demand-side management, and utility regulation. Entities listed include regulatory bodies, industry groups, and energy programs.

EXISTING PROGRAMS The following are programs a part of the EEPS. Major changes are expected when the CEF portfolio is introduced.

AI summary The text outlines existing programs under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS) and notes significant changes anticipated with the introduction of the Clean Energy Fund (CEF) portfolio. The focus is on program structure and upcoming reforms.

Sources of Funding The Systems Benefit Charge (SBC) is the primary source of NYSERDA s funding for energy conservation programs. It was established on May 20, 1996. The funds collected from the SBC are allocated towards energy efficiency p...

AI summary The Systems Benefit Charge (SBC) is the primary funding source for NYSERDA's energy conservation programs, supporting energy efficiency, R&D, low-income initiatives, and environmental disclosure. SBC was extended in 2016 and funds the Clean Energy Fund (CEF) after replacing the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS). Additional funding comes from the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS), which finance renewable energy and carbon abatement projects.

Cost Effectiveness Testing Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level. The TRC is used as the cost effectiveness test. Prior to the implementation of the EEPS, the TRC was applied at the...

AI summary Under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS), NYSERDA must conduct cost effectiveness testing using Total Resource Cost (TRC) at the project level. Previously, under the Clean Energy Fund (CEF), TRC was applied at the program level, and this will continue under CEF.

BEST-IN-CLASS In Canada, Ontario and British Columbia have the largest energy efficiency budgets and the longest history of designing and delivering energy conservation programs. They are also usually considered the leading provinces for p...

AI summary Ontario and British Columbia lead in energy efficiency budgets and programs. The ACEEE 2015 scorecard ranks U.S. jurisdictions highly, except Maine. All selected U.S. states have Energy Efficiency Resource Standards (EERS), demonstrating commitment to energy efficiency as a sustainable electricity supply.

JURISDICTIONAL SCANS - GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Jurisdiction Peak Load (MW) or Annual Consumption (Therms) Population Served Types of Electricity Generation New York (ConEd) 2009-2015 (EEPS) 2012-2015 (EEPS II) 163.56 GWh (EEPS) Average $78.25...

AI summary The text presents jurisdictional scans comparing energy data across multiple regions, including peak load, population served, electricity generation types, and cost metrics. It highlights variations in energy efficiency programs and associated costs in jurisdictions like New York, Vermont, Maine, and Massachusetts.

ONTARIO (IESO) –OVERVIEW

AI summary Overview of Ontario's IESO regulatory proceeding, involving entities like ENS, OEB, and LDCs, focusing on energy efficiency programs and regulatory frameworks. Key acronyms and organizations related to demand-side management and electricity system operations are listed.

APPENDIX A: MEASURE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS

AI summary Appendix A outlines the Measure Development Process for energy efficiency programs in Nova Scotia, involving the Demand Side Management Advisory Group (DSMAG) and Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS). It references the Technical Reference Manual (TRM) and Energy Efficiency Resource Assessment Model (EERAM), incorporating inputs from the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE) and Massachusetts Technical Advisory Committee (MTAC). The process evaluates program costs and benefits, aligning with regulatory frameworks.

KEY PLAYERS

AI summary The 'KEY PLAYERS' section outlines key organizations, programs, and regulatory bodies involved in Nova Scotia's energy and utility proceedings. It includes acronyms for entities such as Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB), Demand Side Management (DSM), and Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS), along with other provincial, national, and international stakeholders.

EXISTING PROGRAMS The following are programs a part of the EEPS. Major changes are expected when the CEF portfolio is introduced.

AI summary The text outlines existing programs under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS) and notes significant changes anticipated with the introduction of the Clean Energy Fund (CEF) portfolio. The EEPS is highlighted as a current framework, while the CEF's implementation is expected to alter the program landscape.

Cost Effectiveness Testing Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level. The TRC is used as the cost effectiveness test. Prior to the implementation of the EEPS, the TRC was applied at the...

AI summary Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level using TRC. Prior to EEPS, TRC was applied at the program level under CEF, and will be again under CEF.

Figure 61: Benefit- Cost Ratios: Electric Programs 2015 [12](#page-198-0) Adjusted Gross Benefit-to-Cost-Ratio Net Benefit-to-Cost-Ratio Programs TRC PACT Last Evaluation Net to Gross Ratio TRC PACT Business Incentive Program Electric Meas...

AI summary The text presents benefit-cost ratios for various electric and natural gas programs in 2015, including adjusted gross and net benefit-to-cost ratios for different initiatives such as the Business Incentive Program, Home Energy Savings Program, and Low-Income Direct Install Initiative. These ratios are calculated using TRC and PACT metrics.

NATIONAL GRID CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Program Name Program Area Program Measures Links Sustainable Office Design Commercial  The sustainable office design provides an incentive of $1.00/sqft (leased space net of...

AI summary The document outlines National Grid's core program offerings for residential and business customers, including incentives for energy-efficient lighting, building assessments, and benchmarking tools. These programs aim to promote energy efficiency and reduce environmental impact.

NOVA SCOTIA MARKET CHARACTERISTICS Nova Scotia has a population of approximately 950,000 people. There are just under 500,000 residential, commercial and industrial electricity accounts for NS Power. 42 12 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scot...

AI summary Nova Scotia has a population of around 950,000 people and approximately 500,000 electricity accounts managed by NS Power. A reference is made to 'Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020' as a source of information.

19 Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Restructuring (2014) Act - http://nslegislature.ca/legc/bills/62nd_1st/1st_read/b041.htm From a total consumption perspective, ENS's annual target for 2015 is 1.3 percent of electricity sales for...

AI summary The document references the Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Restructuring (2014) Act and notes that ENS's 2015 annual target is 1.3 percent of electricity sales, comparable to other jurisdictions as shown in Table 812.

FORMAL & DOCUMENTED INCENTIVE SETTING PROCESS It is recommended that ENS use a formal and documented incentive setting process for all incentive setting exercises. This does not necessarily mean that every step of the process needs to be f...

AI summary The document recommends that Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENS) adopt a formal, documented incentive-setting process for all exercises, with three potential processes outlined. It emphasizes documenting justifications for process steps and considering existing market incentives in customer, technology, and financial analyses to address barriers and attribution issues.

For the Instant Savings Program, CLEAResult has the following recommendations: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary CLEAResult provides recommendations for the Instant Savings Program, focusing on general principles, current activities, and recommended activities. The table outlines areas for improvement and potential changes to enhance the program's effectiveness.

AI summary Figure 242324 outlines Union Gas's targets and budgets, likely related to energy efficiency programs and regulatory oversight. The context includes acronyms for regulatory bodies, energy efficiency initiatives, and technical terms used in utility planning and cost analysis.

Figure 434243 : Overall Targets 2007 - 2015 8 E- normy Effi cionar Car vings (GW (b.) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Statewide Goals 1 2007 2000 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2013 New York State 15 x 15 Goals 564 1,471 3,991...

AI summary The text presents data on energy efficiency targets and program budgets from 2007 to 2015, including statewide goals, jurisdictional gaps, and program expenditures for electric and gas initiatives in New York State. It outlines energy efficiency potential studies and budget allocations for various programs targeting residential, commercial, and industrial sectors.

EXISTING PROGRAMS The following are programs a part of the EEPS. Major changes are expected when the CEF portfolio is introduced.

AI summary The text identifies existing programs under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS) and notes significant changes anticipated with the introduction of the Clean Energy Fund (CEF) portfolio.

Cost Effectiveness Testing Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level. The TRC is used as the cost effectiveness test. Prior to the implementation of the EEPS, the TRC was applied at the...

AI summary Under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS), NYSEDRA was required to apply the Total Resource Cost (TRC) method at the project level. Previously, under the Clean Energy Fund (CEF), TRC was applied at the program level, and this will continue post-EEPS implementation.

High Level Specifications

AI summary The document outlines key terms and acronyms relevant to energy efficiency and utility regulatory proceedings in Nova Scotia. It provides definitions for organizations, programs, and methodologies used in demand-side management, cost evaluation, and energy efficiency initiatives.

BEST-IN-CLASS In Canada, Ontario and British Columbia have the largest energy efficiency budgets and the longest history of designing and delivering energy conservation programs. They are also usually considered the leading provinces for p...

AI summary Canada's Ontario and British Columbia lead in energy efficiency programs. US states (except Maine) top ACEEE's 2015 scorecard, showing strong EERS commitments.

NOVA SCOTIA'S ELECTRICITY SYSTEM In 2015, Nova Scotia had an annual electricity consumption of 10,400 GWh. The residential sector accounts for 45 percent of consumption, the commercial sector uses about 32 percent, and the industrial secto...

AI summary Nova Scotia's electricity system shows 10,400 GWh annual consumption, with residential (45%), commercial (32%), and industrial (23%) sectors. Retail rates rose 70% over 10 years due to coal phase-out, renewables integration, and fuel costs. NS Power (95% infrastructure owner) is regulated by UARB. By 2020, coal will drop to 20-35%, renewables to 27%, and imported renewables to 23%. Provincial legislation mandates 40% renewables by 2020 and 25% GHG emission reductions.

POLICY CONSIDERATIONS

AI summary The policy considerations section outlines regulatory proceedings involving energy efficiency programs, cost methodologies, and stakeholder groups in Nova Scotia. Key entities include Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation, the Utility and Review Board, and various advisory groups. Topics focus on demand-side management, cost calculations, and regulatory frameworks.

Table 15 : ENS Program Overview Program Name Program Offer and Incentive Structure Type of Program (for CE modelling purposes) Custom Commercial, institutional and industrial customers are eligible to apply to the Custom Program for measur...

AI summary The Custom Program offers tailored energy efficiency incentives for commercial, institutional, and industrial customers in Nova Scotia. Eligible projects require scoping studies and feasibility assessments before approval. Incentives are negotiated based on factors like total cost and payback period, with financing options and specialized services such as recommissioning and compressed air studies available.

3. What is the acceptable incentive threshold in terms of Customer Cost? With respect to Customer Cost, there may be an acceptable incentive level threshold that is based on the retail price, project cost, Incremental Equipment Cost or pro...

AI summary The document discusses acceptable incentive thresholds for Customer Cost, referencing factors like retail price, Incremental Equipment Cost, and payback periods. It emphasizes a 100% limit on Incremental Equipment Cost, which may be exceeded with justification. Thresholds are presented as guidelines, not hard caps, with examples of 50-70% of retail price or one-year payback periods. CLEAResult's experience informs suggested thresholds in Table 17.

22 Our Electricity Future: Nova Scotia's Energy Plan 2015-2020, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Available: General Principle Current Activities Recommended Activities

AI summary The document outlines Nova Scotia's energy plan from 2015 to 2020, focusing on general principles, current activities, and recommended activities related to electricity future planning.

Program Financial Simulation Analysis

AI summary The document outlines a financial simulation analysis for energy efficiency programs in Nova Scotia, involving regulatory bodies, advisory groups, and cost methodologies. Key entities include Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation, the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board, and various energy efficiency standards and programs.

JURISDICTIONAL SCANS - GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Jurisdiction Peak Load (MW) or Annual Consumption (Therms) Population Served Types of Electricity Generation New York (NYSERDA) ≈1% $0.2005/kW h Vermont 2015-2017 107.27 GWh $43.43 55% $0.40/kWh...

AI summary The document presents a comparison of energy jurisdictions, including New York, Vermont, Maine, and Massachusetts, with data on peak load, population served, electricity generation types, and energy costs. It highlights variations in energy consumption, pricing, and efficiency programs across different regions.

APPENDIX A-1: ONTARIO ELECTRICITY

AI summary Appendix A-1 outlines Ontario's electricity regulatory context, listing acronyms and entities involved in energy efficiency, demand-side management, and utility regulation. Key organizations include Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENS), Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (URB), and the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE). Topics focus on energy efficiency programs, cost methodologies, and regulatory frameworks.

ONTARIO - ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMMING

AI summary The document pertains to Ontario's energy efficiency programming, though no specific content or details are provided in the text. It includes a list of acronyms and entities relevant to energy regulation and efficiency initiatives.

ONTARIO CORE PROGRAM OFFERINGS (RESIDENTIAL AND BUSINESS) Currently, the conservation programs in Ontario cover the residential, low income, small business, commercial and industrial, and large industrial sectors. The programs cover financ...

AI summary Ontario's conservation programs target residential, low-income, and business sectors through financial incentives, coaching, and training. Rigorous five-year evaluations have raised energy efficiency baselines, with T8 lighting now standard. Ontario recently introduced a pay-for-performance framework for LDC funding, a first in North America.

Figure 23: Union Gas Targets & Performance Metric[s](#page-125-0) 4 Resource Acquisition Scorecard Large Volume Large Volume Large Volume - Revised Large Volume - Revised Evaluation - Revised Administrative costs - Revised Large Volume Tot...

AI summary The document presents a table titled 'Union Gas Targets & Performance Metrics' which outlines various resource acquisition scorecards, including categories such as Large Volume, Market Transformation, Commercial Savings By Design, and Program Budgets. The table includes revised administrative costs, overheads, and evaluation components, but the content is largely incomplete or repetitive.

KEY PLAYERS

AI summary The 'KEY PLAYERS' section lists organizations, programs, and regulatory bodies involved in energy efficiency, utility regulation, and demand-side management in Nova Scotia and other regions. It includes acronyms for entities such as the Utility and Review Board, Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation, and various energy efficiency initiatives and methodologies.

NYSERDA ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM INCENTIVE AND COST EFFECTIVENESS POLICY

AI summary The document outlines NYSERDA's Energy Efficiency Program Incentive and Cost Effectiveness Policy, focusing on criteria for evaluating energy efficiency initiatives. Key entities include NYSERDA, EERS, EEPS, and SBC III, with topics centered on energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and incentive structures.

Cost Effectiveness Testing Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level. The TRC is used as the cost effectiveness test. Prior to the implementation of the EEPS, the TRC was applied at the...

AI summary Under the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS), NYSERDA was required to conduct project-level cost effectiveness testing using the Total Resource Cost (TRC) method. Previously, under the Clean Energy Fund (CEF), TRC was applied at the program level, and this approach will continue post-EEPS implementation.

NATIONAL GRID – UTILITY OVERVIEW

AI summary The document provides an overview of National Grid's utility operations in Nova Scotia, referencing regulatory frameworks, energy efficiency programs, and related acronyms. Key entities include Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (URB), Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC), and various energy efficiency initiatives.

High Level Specifications

AI summary The document provides a list of acronyms and their expansions related to energy efficiency, regulatory proceedings, and utility management in Nova Scotia and other jurisdictions. It serves as a reference for terminology used in regulatory analyses and proceedings.

COST EFFECTIVENESS TESTING & AVOIDED COSTS 14

AI summary The document section focuses on cost-effectiveness testing and avoided costs in regulatory proceedings, referencing footnote 14. It involves analysis of energy efficiency programs, cost methodologies, and regulatory frameworks in Nova Scotia.

Detailed Measure Development - •Identify technical guidelines and data, identify any data gaps and create research plan for gaps - •Stakeholder outreach - •Facilitation of crossprogram coordination - •Cost Effectiveness testing - •Draft Me...

AI summary The process outlines steps for developing energy efficiency measures, including identifying technical guidelines, stakeholder outreach, cross-program coordination, cost-effectiveness testing, and drafting a Measure Approval Document (MAD). Measures with sufficient data and stakeholder support are promoted for approval, while those with data gaps may be piloted.

EXISTING PROGRAMS The following are programs a part of the EEPS. Major changes are expected when the CEF portfolio is introduced.

AI summary The existing programs are part of the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS). Major changes are anticipated with the introduction of the Clean Energy Fund (CEF) portfolio, indicating a shift in energy efficiency strategies.

Sources of Funding The Systems Benefit Charge (SBC) is the primary source of NYSERDA s funding for energy conservation programs. It was established on May 20, 1996. The funds collected from the SBC are allocated towards energy efficiency p...

AI summary The Systems Benefit Charge (SBC) is the primary funding source for NYSERDA's energy conservation programs, established in 1996 and extended in 2016. Funds support energy efficiency, research, low-income programs, and environmental disclosure. The SBC funds the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS), now replaced by the Clean Energy Fund (CEF). Other sources include the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS), which focus on carbon abatement and renewable energy, respectively.

Cost Effectiveness Testing Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct cost effectiveness testing at the project level. The TRC is used as the cost effectiveness test. Prior to the implementation of the EEPS, the TRC was applied at the...

AI summary Under the EEPS, NYSEDRA was required to conduct project-level cost effectiveness testing using the TRC. Previously, under the CEF, TRC was applied at the program level, and this approach will continue under CEF.

second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the second and the...

AI summary The text includes repeated text, chart parameters, and citations to reports and data sources related to electricity customer accounts and pricing in Maine. It references the Maine Public Utilities Commission and the U.S. Energy Information Administration.