Topic:"Evidence Requirements" in M04819

4.3Data analyzed As discussed, EPS obtained daily averages for key operating and energy consumption variables for at least one full year prior to the start of each energy efficiency project studied and one year following the implementation...

AI summary The analysis used data from NPPH's PI historian and NSPI's billing data, validated by Alexander Allen and Mark Frith. Discrepancies were noted but data was accepted. Projects include Line 1 Refiner Replacement, Line 3 Optimization, and others, with data limitations for Noss Cleaners and PM2 projects.

ASSESSMENT OF ENSC'S FRAMEWORK

AI summary The document outlines the assessment of Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation's (ENSC) framework by the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB), involving stakeholders such as Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and the Program Development Working Group (PDWG). Key considerations include DSM programs, cost recovery mechanisms, and compliance with regulatory tests like the Total Resource Cost Test (TRC) and Program Administrator Cost Test (PAC).

4. EVALUATION PROTOCOL & METHODOLOGY We have principally relied on the Superior Energy Performance (SEP) measurement & verification protocol found in Appendix-1 in conducting the M&V evaluation. We have relied on this document as it is ver...

AI summary The evaluation relies on the Superior Energy Performance (SEP) and International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) to assess energy performance improvements at NPPH. The goal is to validate preliminary self-reported energy data from NPPH's INITIAL REPORT, which lacked independent auditing.

4.3Data analyzed As discussed, EPS obtained daily averages for key operating and energy consumption variables for at least one full year prior to the start of each energy efficiency project studied and one year following the implementation...

AI summary EPS analyzed energy efficiency projects at NPPH using data from the PI historian and NSPI invoices, finding general alignment despite minor discrepancies. Key projects included Line 1 Refiner Replacement and PM2 Vacuum Blower initiatives, with data collection challenges noted for some projects.

sing the format indicated in the data extraction section below. The following procedures, extracted from the SmartWare Operator’s guide, must be used for data extraction and saving. Data Extraction: > Connect Lighting Logger to computer, u...

AI summary The text outlines procedures for data extraction using the SmartWare software and describes an algorithm for calculating free-ridership in the Small Business Energy Solutions Program. The algorithm is based on survey responses from participants.

Scan America® Vision Statement To be a world leader in developing truthful measurement and useful results; to support development of efficient, ethical, and effective practices, sustained economically, to advance human development.

AI summary Scan America® aims to lead globally in truthful measurement and impactful results, promoting efficient, ethical, and economically sustainable practices to advance human development. The vision emphasizes transparency, effectiveness, and long-term societal benefits through responsible innovation.

(7) Efficient Products – Direct Install Program (EP-DI) The Efficient Products – Direct Install Program provides business and multi-unit residential buildings with free installation of energy-efficient products. Measures include CFLs, LED...

AI summary The EP-DI program offers free energy-efficient product installations for businesses and multi-unit residential buildings, including LED lights, thermostats, and insulation. A pilot program (Retail LED Direct Install) was launched in 2011. Evaluation metrics like Net-to-Gross effect (0.95) and free ridership (15.4%) are discussed. Econoler recommends improving data collection through enhanced tracking sheets, site visits, and detailed technical information gathering for better savings accuracy.

(8) EnerGuide for Existing Houses Program The EnerGuide for Existing Houses program provides support to homeowners to reduce use of electrical energy and fuel consumption. Financial assistance for fuels other than electricity is provided b...

AI summary The EnerGuide for Existing Houses Program, managed by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation, supports homeowners in reducing energy use through measures like programmable thermostats and insulation. Due to data limitations, a 'true-up' analysis adjusted savings estimates by 25%. Econoler recommended improving data collection, refining HOT2000 models, and enhancing billing analysis to improve accuracy. The Province supports these recommendations.

(11) Performance Plus Program (PP) The Performance Plus Program is the residential new houses program. It provides financial incentives to homeowners and builders to exceed the energy efficiency requirements of the building code. Modeling...

AI summary The Performance Plus Program (PP) incentivizes residential new homes to exceed building code energy efficiency. Econoler adjusted EnerGuide baselines and savings estimates, citing studies. Free-ridership was 42%, with 5% market effect. Four recommendations include expanding builder interviews, integrating HOT2000 data, random model revisions, and tracking electric heating percentages for accurate EnerGuide calculations.

IV. References Campbell, Donald T & Julian C. Stanley, Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand-McNally College Publishing Company, 1963. Cook, Thomas D. & Donald T. Campbell, Quasi-Experimentation Designs &...

AI summary The references section lists academic and industry publications on research methodologies, demand-side management, and energy efficiency. Key works include studies on quasi-experimental designs, energy conservation, and measurement protocols, authored by experts like Donald T. Campbell, Clark W. Gellings, and Thomas D. Cook. The International Performance Measurement & Verification Protocol (IPMVP) is cited as a key resource.

Selected Approach The methodology selected for assessing net-to-gross ratios (NTGRs) for Efficiency Nova Scotia's programs relies on the self-report approach (SRA). The SRA involves the analysis of responses to survey questions that are de...

AI summary The self-report approach (SRA) is selected to assess net-to-gross ratios (NTGRs) for Efficiency Nova Scotia's energy efficiency programs. SRA uses survey data to estimate program impacts and energy savings. It was chosen for its feasibility and cost-effectiveness over other methods like econometric and cross-sectional approaches discussed in a 2010 workshop. Organizations such as ScanAmerica and Navigant Consulting were involved in the workshop.

Forecast Models Nova Scotia electric energy sales are modeled and forecast as three provincial customer sectors: residential, commercial and industrial. Energy forecasts for sector electricity sales are calculated using econometric models...

AI summary Nova Scotia electric energy sales are forecast using econometric models for residential, commercial, and industrial sectors, incorporating variables like GDP, prices, and heating degree-days, with data sourced from the Conference Board of Canada's Economic Outlook.

Report on the Financial Statements We have audited the accompanying financial statements of Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation which comprise the statement of financial position as at December 31, 2011 and the statements of operations, cha...

AI summary The audit of Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation's financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2011, includes the statement of financial position, statements of operations, changes in fund balances, cash flows, and a summary of accounting policies. The audit covers compliance with financial reporting standards and provides assurance on the accuracy of the presented information.

Auditor's Responsibility Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audit. We conducted our audit in accordance with Canadian generally accepted auditing standards. Those standards require that w...

AI summary The auditor's responsibility involves expressing an opinion on financial statements in accordance with Canadian auditing standards. The audit includes procedures to assess material misstatements, evaluate internal controls, accounting policies, and the reasonableness of management's estimates. The auditor concludes that obtained evidence is sufficient for their opinion.

Q. Please summarize your analysis of program participation levels. A. Figure 4 presents a summary of program participation rates for some of ENSC's key DSM programs, based on information provided by ENSC in response to information requests...

AI summary The analysis calculates participation rates for ENSC's DSM programs by comparing participants to eligible customers, noting challenges in participant identification and double-counting. Rates are illustrative, with a need for better data collection to address these issues.

ORDER WHEREAS Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") filed an Application on February 27, 2012 with the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (the "Board") for approval of its Electricity Demand Side Management ("DSM") Plan for 2013 to...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) applied for approval of its 2013-2015 Electricity Demand Side Management (DSM) Plan. After intervenor participation, evidence submission, and a settlement agreement reached by ENSC, Avon, Bowater, the Consumer Advocate, COHA, and SBA, the Board approved the settlement (excluding Section 16(b)) as being in ratepayers' best interests.

16 Request IR-6 - The benefits of the programs are shown in terms of energy savings (GWh) and demand savings17 - (MW), but the dollar Lifetime Benefits are shown as a single number ($million, second column).18 - Please provide ENSC Evidenc...

AI summary The request asks ENSC to provide evidence tables (4.1-4.4) that separate Lifetime Benefits into demand and energy savings, as currently aggregated as a single figure.

INFORMATION REQUEST To: Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) From: Nova Scotia Chapter – Canadian Oil Heat Association (COHA-NS)

AI summary The Nova Scotia Chapter of the Canadian Oil Heat Association (COHA-NS) has submitted an Information Request to Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) as part of a regulatory proceeding. The request seeks clarification or information, though specific details are not provided in the text.

f residence, the main and secondary heating sources and the type of hot water heating. The item "county" indicates the participant's geographic location and is very useful for on-site visits planning. Moreover, for those RDI participants w...

AI summary The tracking sheet collects data on participants' heating sources and geographic locations, but lacks a unique identifier for participants. It also has missing data in key fields, such as rate codes, and does not clearly indicate contact persons in multi-residential buildings. ENSC is working to improve data collection.