Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Forecasting Methodology" in M13173

Matter: Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) - 2027/2028 Proposed Expenses, Revenue Requirement and Fees Application
36 passages 1 document

Forecasting Methodology across all matters →

N-1Application - Redacted 36 passages
1.3 Material Changes in the Application p. p. 125
1.3 Material Changes in the Application - The Board and parties will note that this Application differs in some respects from the prior - applications for the 2025/2026 and 2026/2027 fiscal years. The material changes or additions - fall u...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines material changes in its current application compared to prior filings for the 2025/2026 and 2026/2027 fiscal years. Key updates include a revised transition date for Phase 2A to March 2028 based on completed design work. The application also introduces a more functional alignment of OM&A expenditures within the revenue requirements to improve consistency for Board evaluation. Additionally, it details the phased implementation of the Phase 2 Control Centre project to support independent Balancing Authority and Transmission Operator functions.

1.4 Process p. p. 125
1.4 Process - This Application reflects a more detailed budgeting process than was possible for IESO Nova - Scotia's first two revenue requirement applications. The organization has developed three - annual budgets within approximately 18...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia describes the evolution of its budgeting process, moving from high-level estimates to a detailed bottom-up approach for the 2027/2028 budget. The process integrates OM&A budgets with capital plans to ensure the revenue requirement reflects asset timing, amortization, and financing costs. Key improvements include revised OM&A cost categories to align with functional departments and the provision of multi-year indicative outlooks for 2028-2030 in response to Nova Scotia Energy Board requirements.

Attached in Appendix 3 p. p. 125
Attached in Appendix 3 The DVM guidelines have been developed and shared with stakeholders for their feedback in advance of the filing of this Application. They are provided herein for the NSEB's review and approval as it relates to approv...

AI summary The document introduces the Net Revenue Requirement Deferral and Variance Mechanism (DVM) guidelines, which were developed and shared with stakeholders for feedback prior to the current application filing. These guidelines are submitted for the Nova Scotia Energy Board's review and approval specifically regarding the approval of variances. They provide detailed treatment for variances stemming from discrepancies between forecast and actual expenditures in previous fiscal years, extending the OM&A Deferral and Variance Account previously approved in proceeding M12412.

Historical Costs and Forecasts. p. p. 125
Historical Costs and Forecasts. "The Board directs that minimum filing requirements will apply to IESO Nova Scotia's future applications, including: … - Up to five years of actual audited historical financial results as they become availab...

AI summary The Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) establishes minimum filing requirements for IESO Nova Scotia's future applications. These requirements mandate the submission of up to five years of audited historical financial results and a three-year financial projection. The document notes that while only fiscal year 2025/2026 actuals are currently available, the filing includes these actuals alongside a three-year forecast and a description of the material assumptions used to generate those projections.

3.4 Operating, Maintenance and Administration p. p. 125
3.4 Operating, Maintenance and Administration - In this application, IESO Nova Scotia seeks review and approval of its OM&A revenue requirement for the 2027/28 fiscal year of $14.76M, a slight reduction from IESO Nova Scotia's OM&A revenue...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking approval for its 2027/28 Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) revenue requirement of $14.76M. The budget was developed using historical spending data, external evidence like quotes and contracts, and internal staff expertise. Due to its status as a new organization with limited historical data, IESO Nova Scotia acknowledges potential for variance but emphasizes a forward-looking approach to refining budgeting processes. The OM&A costs cover statutory mandates, administrative functions, and transitioned operational roles from NS Power, including upcoming bulk electricity system dispatch costs.

Preamble p. pp. 39-125
3 As noted in the Introduction, the OM&A cost categories in this Application are different from 4 the 2025/ 2026 and 2026/ 2027 revenue requirement applications; the OM&A cost categories 5 herein are structured in a manner that is more clo...

AI summary The applicant explains that the OM&A cost categories in the current application differ from the 2025/2026 and 2026/2027 revenue requirement applications to better align with the actual functions performed by IESO Nova Scotia. Key changes include redistributing the 'Employees - Administration' category across functional areas, grouping procurement and system planning, splitting facilities and technology into distinct categories, and renaming 'Corporate Administrative' to 'Corporate Services'. New categories for 2027/2028 will include 'System Operations' and 'Human Resources'.

3 Figure 24: OM&A Costs for the Human Resources Cost Category p. p. 125
3 Figure 24: OM&A Costs for the Human Resources Cost Category Ongoing OM&A Budget ($) Cost Category 2026/2027F Restated 2027/2028 Human Resources 0.42 0.59 Compensation Consulting Recruitment 0.10 0.17 Training and Professional Development...

AI summary The document presents a table detailing the forecast Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs specifically for the Human Resources cost category. It provides a breakdown of expenditures for the 2026/2027F Restated and 2027/2028 periods, highlighting costs for recruitment, training and professional development, and other miscellaneous HR-related expenses.

10 3.5 2027 – 2030F Outlook p. p. 125
10 3.5 2027 – 2030F Outlook - 11 Pursuant to the NSEB's direction in M12412, this section provides IESO Nova Scotia's three years - 12 of projected financial results. Figure 27 below provides 2027/2028F, 2028/2029F, and - 13 2029/2030F for...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia provides a three-year financial outlook for the 2027–2030 period, including projected expenditures, amortization, and OM&A total costs. The company notes that as a newly established not-for-profit entity with less than a year of operational experience, the accuracy of outer-year forecasts is subject to change due to the lack of historical operational data.

19 Figure 27: 2027-2030F Outlook p. p. 125
19 Figure 27: 2027-2030F Outlook Category 2027/2028F Total Budget 2028/2029F Total Budget 2029/2030F Total Budget Proposed Expenditures $27.5 $6.7 $4.8 Revenue Requirement $15.23 $34.7 $37.6 Amortization $0.43 $4.7 $5.8 OM&A $14.8 $30.0 $3...

AI summary The document presents a financial outlook for the 2027-2030 forecast period, specifically highlighting the budget categories for Proposed Expenditures, Revenue Requirement, Amortization, and Operating, Maintenance and Administration (OM&A) costs. The data shows a significant increase in the Revenue Requirement and OM&A costs from 2027/2028F to 2029/2030F, while Proposed Expenditures are projected to decrease significantly over the same period.

10 Figure 30 - 2025-2026 Forecast to Actual Cost Variance p. p. 125
10 Figure 30 - 2025-2026 Forecast to Actual Cost Variance 2025-26 Revenue Application Actual 2025-26 Actual Over/(Under) Revenue Application $ Actual Over/(Under) Revenue Application % Administration Salaries and Wages $1,572,751 $1,047,76...

AI summary The document presents a variance analysis between the 2025-26 Revenue Application and the actual costs incurred for the same period. While total expenses were approximately $237,310 lower than forecasted (a 3.0% variance), specific categories showed significant deviations. Notably, Administration Salaries and Wages were 33.4% under budget, and NS Power Employee Transfers and IRP Consulting were 49.9% under budget. Conversely, Transition and Operational Planning costs were 74.4% over the forecast. The net revenue requirement versus actual expense showed a 6.5% under-spend.

4.0 COST TIMING p. pp. 157-159
4.0 COST TIMING - The cost timing for recording and variance tracking purposes will be IESO Nova Scotia's - fiscal year: April 1, 20XX to March 31, 20XX+1. - Tracking actual costs against the NSEB approved amount will begin as at April 1 e...

AI summary The text outlines the cost timing and variance tracking procedures for IESO Nova Scotia. It establishes a fiscal year from April 1 to March 31, with actual costs tracked against Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) approved amounts annually. Variances are recorded in a deferral account and addressed in subsequent revenue requirement applications or compliance filings. The document provides a hypothetical timeline illustrating how variances from one fiscal year are finalized and integrated into the following year's revenue requirements.

4. IBM Mandate and Assessment Approach p. pp. 183-184
4. IBM Mandate and Assessment Approach IBM was engaged to assess long-term operating model options for Phase 2 and recommend the most appropriate model and pathway for implementation. The work was supported by a parallel independent value...

AI summary The document outlines the mandate and assessment methodology used by IBM to evaluate long-term operating model options for Phase 2 of a project. IBM utilized a multi-criteria decision analysis framework, supported by a parallel value case analysis from FTI Consulting, to assess scenarios based on technical, operational, financial, regulatory, and strategic criteria. The evaluation focused on five overarching themes: reliability, cost-effectiveness, value for Nova Scotians, regulatory compliance, and alignment with legislative direction.

4.1. Strategic Evaluation Methodology p. pp. 184-185
4.1. Strategic Evaluation Methodology IBM's strategic scenario assessment utilized a structured multi-criteria decision analysis framework to compare the five operating model options on a consistent basis. Assessment criteria were grouped...

AI summary IBM outlines a multi-criteria decision analysis framework used to evaluate five operating model options for the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). The methodology weights technical and operational factors (reliability, independence, transparency, and implementation) at 65%, while economic value and cost considerations are weighted at 35%. This weighting prioritizes system security and regulatory compliance over purely economic drivers to ensure a prudent, defensible, and evidence-based recommendation for the province's electricity system.

Why it matters: p. p. 192
Why it matters: - Needed to support independent model - Decouples stakeholder commercial discussions from operational cll!- over, removing a high-risk dependency - Builds maturity and technical readiness, while reducing initial 2A scope -...

AI summary The text outlines the strategic rationale for a phased approach to developing an independent model. Key benefits include decoupling commercial stakeholder discussions from operational complexities to reduce risk, building technical maturity, and narrowing the initial scope of the 2A phase. The initiative aims to improve decision-making, confidentiality, and transparency while ensuring the system can adapt to evolving market and regulatory settlement needs.

9.1. Cost Estimation Method and Assumptions p. p. 199
9.1. Cost Estimation Method and Assumptions The cost estimates for the Phase 2 program have been developed as a Class 3 Budgetary Estimate as defined by AACE standards. This indicates an estimate developed at a level appropriate for strate...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology and assumptions for the Phase 2 program's cost estimates, which are classified as Class 3 Budgetary Estimates according to AACE standards. These estimates are intended for strategic decision-making and program approval rather than final execution, with an expected accuracy range of -15% to +20%. Key assumptions include a 2026 commencement date, a 15% capital contingency, approximately $6.3 million in annual operating costs, and a phased benefit realization schedule validated against benchmarks like the Ontario IESO model.

The economic analysis indicates that the recommended pathway delivers a positive long-term financial outcome, as illustrated by the Net Present Value analysis in Fig 11 below. p. p. 199
The economic analysis indicates that the recommended pathway delivers a positive long-term financial outcome, as illustrated by the Net Present Value analysis in Fig 11 below. Net Present Value (NPV) Scenarios NPV IRR Key Assumptions Base...

AI summary The document presents an economic analysis of the recommended pathway, asserting that it yields a positive long-term financial outcome. This is supported by a Net Present Value (NPV) analysis showcasing various scenarios, including a Base Case Scenario with a positive NPV of $219M and an IRR of 37%. The analysis explores sensitivities such as capital expenditure (Capex) fluctuations, benefit variations, and timing delays, consistently showing positive financial returns across most modeled scenarios.

Base Year: 2026 p. p. 199
Base Year: 2026 In the context of the NPV analysis, "Base Year: 2026" means that the calculations for the NPV are anchored to the year 2026. This implies that all future cash flows, costs, and benefits are discounted back to their present...

AI summary The text defines the 'Base Year: 2026' as the anchor point for Net Present Value (NPV) calculations within the proceeding. It explains that all future cash flows, costs, and benefits are discounted back to this specific year, establishing 2026 as the reference point for the financial analysis to reflect the present value of future expenditures and benefits.

17-Year Analysis Timeline p. p. 199
17-Year Analysis Timeline The NPV analysis is conducted over a 17-year period. This timeline comprises two distinct phases: - 1. Phase 2A Implementation (2 years) : The first two years are allocated for the implementation of Phase 2A, duri...

AI summary The document outlines the 17-year timeline used for the Net Present Value (NPV) analysis of a project. This timeline is divided into two stages: a two-year initial phase dedicated to implementing Phase 2A to establish foundational operational control capabilities, followed by a 15-year depreciation period. This second phase is intended to reflect the assets' useful life and the timeframe for amortizing both costs and benefits.

NPV Scenarios p. p. 199
NPV Scenarios - 1. Mid (Mid-case) Scenario : This scenario represents the expected or most likely outcome based on reasonable assumptions and estimates. It uses mid-case numbers for costs and benefits, reflecting a balanced view that is ne...

AI summary The document outlines three Net Present Value (NPV) scenarios used to evaluate project outcomes. The Mid-case scenario represents the most likely outcome based on balanced cost and benefit estimates. The High scenario assumes more favorable conditions, specifically a 15% reduction in capital expenditure and a 30% increase in benefits. Conversely, the Low scenario assumes less favorable conditions, featuring a 20% increase in capital expenditure and a 40% reduction in expected benefits.

Planning Estimate Uncertainty p. p. 199
Planning Estimate Uncertainty As a Class 3 estimate, the program cost appropriately carries a -15% to +20% range. This uncertainty is typical of planning-level estimates and should be considered when evaluating the projected program costs...

AI summary The document addresses the inherent uncertainty in planning-level cost estimates, specifically identifying the current program cost as a Class 3 estimate. It notes that the cost range carries a -15% to +20% variance. The text advises that this level of uncertainty is standard for planning-level projections and must be accounted for when evaluating the economic outcomes and projected costs presented in the report.

Identification of the ISOs for benchmarking purposes p. pp. 33-34
ww.mbie.govt.nz/building-and-energy/energy-and-natural-resources/energy-statistics-and-modelling/energy-publications-and-technical-papers/energy-in-new-zealand/energy-in-new-zealand-2024/electricity). 27 California Energy Commission, Acces...

AI summary The provided text is a list of references and citations primarily focused on electricity data, renewable energy records, and market fact sheets from various jurisdictions, including California, Ireland, and Australia. These sources are used to provide data for benchmarking purposes within the proceeding. The snippet also includes a reference to a table containing key metrics for benchmarking group 31.

Roles and responsibilities of the benchmarked ISOs p. p. 35
ng-and-energy/energy-and-natural-resources/energy-statistics-and-modelling/energy-statistics/electricity-statistics), CAISO 2024 statistics [(link)](https://www.caiso.com/documents/2024-statistics.pdf), MISO S&P Capital IQ data (accessed 1...

AI summary The provided text is a compilation of various data sources and links related to electricity statistics, market reports, load forecasts, and system demand from multiple jurisdictions. It includes references to organizations such as CAISO, MISO, AESO, NESO, and Transpower, covering regions including North America, Europe, Australia, and Singapore. The document serves as a reference list for electricity consumption and peak demand data rather than a narrative discussion of roles or responsibilities.

Methodology p. p. 62
Methodology In this methodology section, we first discuss the data and general approach used to 4.8 above. After, we describe 4-1 [Table](#page-61-2) listed inand disbenefits compute the benefits in more detail the underlying rationale beh...

AI summary This section introduces the methodology used to calculate the benefits and disbenefits associated with the project described in the proceeding. It outlines the approach for data analysis, summarizes the data sources, and identifies key assumptions. The text indicates that the underlying rationale for each benefit is detailed in the report, with specific formulas and comprehensive data provided in the Appendices.

General approach and key data p. p. 62
General approach and key data , we apply a 4-1 [Table](#page-61-2) For each of the identified benefits and disbenefits listed in4.9 percentage reduction to existing cost categories (or increase in the case of disbenefits), based on assumed...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for quantifying the financial impacts of transitioning to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) model. The analysis employs a 4-1 approach, calculating percentage reductions or increases in existing cost categories based on assumed gains or losses. It specifically identifies benefits and disbenefits associated with the IESO transition, mapping them to specific cost categories to determine the overall impact on the system's financial structure.

Category Cost Category p. pp. 62-65
Category Cost Category Generation CapEx J_]~ ' ' Transmission CapEx ¥ - (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns - (2) Reduced generation cost from competitive procurement ) financial disbenefit ( deployment x E Cap Accelerated (3B) - (7) Increa...

AI summary The text analyzes the impact of various factors on Capital Expenditure (CapEx) for generation and transmission infrastructure. It identifies specific benefits and disbenefits related to competitive procurement, accelerated deployment, system planning advancements, and control room improvements. Notably, it discusses the potential for lost synergies between planners, procurers, and operators. Due to high uncertainty and long time horizons, the analysis utilizes a high and low case methodology to create a reasonable range for each impact, focusing on the midpoint for results.

Results of quantification p. pp. 74-76
Results of quantification 4.60 The results section consists of six parts. First, we introduce the overall results of the quantification of the identified benefits and disbenefits, i.e., the RPV of the IESO transition over the 2026-2050 hor...

AI summary The text outlines the structure of the quantification results for the IESO transition over the 2026-2050 horizon. It details six components of the analysis: the overall Real Present Value (RPV) of benefits and disbenefits, yearly benefit breakdowns, results excluding avoided carbon costs, results including full-priced carbon emissions without policy shields, the annualised costs required for a break-even outcome under various scenarios, and a sensitivity analysis based on specific timelines for Phase 2 and control room improvements.

Transmission CapEx p. p. 96
Transmission CapEx - A3.5 Transmission CapEx was informed by NSP's annual Capital Expenditure Plans filed between 2020 and 2026. The most recent plan, filed in 2026, [122](#page-103-0) includes forecast spending through 2030. Our forecast...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for forecasting transmission capital expenditures (CapEx) through 2050. The analysis utilizes Nova Scotia Power's annual Capital Expenditure Plans (2020-2026) to establish a historic base spending Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR). It distinguishes between base spending and non-base spending, noting that non-base investments typically occur 1-2 years before new non-thermal resources come online. Figure A3-2 provides a visual comparison of historic and forecast CapEx against the 2020-2030 ACE and FTI forecasts.

Production costs p. pp. 96-104
Production costs A3.8 Production costs are short-run power production costs informed by primary confidential data sources provided to us by the IESO. Data sources include generation (GWh) for each major technology (coal, solar, wind, etc.)...

AI summary The text describes the methodology for estimating short-run power production costs for the 2026-2050 period. These costs are derived from confidential IESO data, including generation volumes, fuel costs, variable O&M, and startup/shutdown costs across various technologies. The analysis assumes negligible short-run production costs for wind and solar, noting that fixed costs are recovered through Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) and accounted for as capital expenditures. For accelerated deployment scenarios, the average production cost per unit is shifted while keeping total yearly generation constant as a demand proxy.

Carbon emissions p. pp. 104-105
Carbon emissions - A3.11 Expected system carbon emissions and generation are sourced from the same primary confidential data source provided to us by the IESO. For calculations involving accelerated deployment, we calculate and shift only...

AI summary The text outlines the methodology for calculating expected system carbon emissions and avoided carbon values. It notes that carbon intensity per unit of electricity is used to model accelerated deployment while keeping total generation fixed as a demand proxy. It specifies the federal carbon price escalator from 2026 to 2040 and acknowledges that current planning documents may not reflect changes in dispatch due to updated price signals. Additionally, it accounts for emissions shielded from taxation under the provincial Output-Based Pricing System (OBPS) performance standards.

Appendix 4: Assumptions summary p. p. 105
Appendix 4: Assumptions summary Phase 1: Planning and procurement responsibilities Assumptions (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns 0-50% reduction in cost overruns from 16% historic overspend 50-80% reduction in pass-through to customers fr...

AI summary This appendix outlines the quantitative assumptions used to model the financial and operational impacts of shifting planning and procurement responsibilities. It categorizes these assumptions into two phases: Phase 1 focuses on planning and procurement, highlighting potential cost overrun reductions, competitive procurement benefits, and timeline differences for Capex and carbon emission targets. Phase 2 focuses on system operation, estimating production cost reductions from control room improvements, advanced system planning, and the resolution of synergies between planners, procurers, and operators.

(1) Shifting cost overrun risk p. pp. 105-107
(1) Shifting cost overrun risk A5.1 The measurement of cost overruns is calculated in two parts. First, the counterfactual (VIU case) expected cost overrun passed on to consumers is calculated as: VIU Case expected cost overrun passed on t...

AI summary The text outlines the methodology for calculating and comparing cost overrun risks between two scenarios: the VIU case and the IESO case. The VIU case assumes an average historic cost overrun of 16% for major capital projects, with a 90% passthrough to customers, resulting in a 14% expected cost overrun of original capital costs. In contrast, the IESO case formula incorporates potential cost savings from competitive procurement and adjusted passthrough percentages to determine the net cost impact on consumers.

(4) Avoided carbon costs from accelerated deployment p. p. 107
(4) Avoided carbon costs from accelerated deployment - A5.15 A delay in the reduction in carbon emissions in the VIU case (while holding annual MWh production constant), will result in overall higher carbon emissions across the 2026-2050 p...

AI summary The text describes the methodology for calculating avoided carbon costs resulting from delays in the deployment of generation and transmission infrastructure. The analysis assumes that delays in the VIU case will lead to higher overall carbon emissions between 2026 and 2050. The calculation involves estimating the percentage of emissions subject to the Output-Based Pricing System (OBPS), applying Remaining Present Value (RPV) to emissions with and without delays, and multiplying by the federal carbon price trajectory while holding system demand constant.

(5) Loss of synergies from planner and operator p. p. 107
(5) Loss of synergies from planner and operator A5.21 To quantify this disbenefit, we apply a percentage incremental cost associated with production costs: RPV production costs × Expected increased cost from lost synergies

AI summary The text describes the methodology used to quantify a specific disbenefit resulting from the loss of synergies between the planner and the operator. To calculate this impact, the analysis applies a percentage incremental cost to the Remaining Present Value (RPV) of production costs, specifically looking at the expected increased costs arising from the lack of synergy.

Phase 2: Independent system operation p. pp. 107-110
ther reductions in production costs unlocked by more advanced planning enabled by control room improvements are calculated as incremental benefits beyond the savings from control room improvements as: (RPV expected production costs $ ×(1-E...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for calculating the Remaining Present Value (RPV) of various benefits associated with independent system operation, specifically focusing on production costs, capital expenditures (CapEx), and carbon emissions. It details how to quantify incremental benefits from control room improvements and advanced system planning. Additionally, it explains the calculation for avoided carbon costs, including the estimation of emissions subject to the Output-Based Pricing System (OBPS) and the annual value of carbon emissions based on carbon-equivalent intensity.

Appendix A p. p. 110
Appendix A Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of Sum of 0490-247 Nova Scotia Power Incorporated M12349 - NSPI - 2025 Load Forecast Report 0490-240 Nova Scotia Power Incorporated M12319 - NSPI - CI Various (ATOs) - Distribution R...

AI summary This appendix provides a summary of professional services and expenditures for multiple regulatory matters involving Nova Scotia Power Incorporated. The work includes load forecasting, performance standards reviews, and 10-year system outlook reports. Specifically, it details activities such as reviewing evidence, preparing submissions, filing Information Requests (IRs), and participating in paper hearings for various matters including M12349, M12319, M12376, and M12386.

Small Business Advocate p. p. 110
Small Business Advocate Company Total Hours for SBA and Consultants Sum of Fees for SBA Sum of Costs for SBA Sum of HST for SBA Total Sum for SBA Sum of Fees for Consultants (USD) Sum of Costs for Consultants (USD) Total Sum for Consultant...

AI summary The document provides a detailed breakdown of the Small Business Advocate's (SBA) activities and associated costs for various regulatory proceedings. It outlines the hours spent and fees incurred for reviewing Board orders, consulting with experts, filing and reviewing Information Requests (IRs), and submitting comments on matters such as Asset Retirement Obligations (ATOs), performance standards, load forecasts, and system outlook reports. The table quantifies both SBA internal costs and external consultant fees, including HST, across multiple specific matter numbers.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →