N-1Application
11 passages
updated July 2025) at 8, https://www.nerc.com/globalassets/our-work/assessments/2024 ltra_corrected_july_2025.pdf [hereinafter 2024 LTRA ]. NERC develops the LTRA annually in accordance with the showed higher demand growth than at any poin...
AI summary The text discusses the findings of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) regarding significant demand growth and emerging risks from large computational loads, such as data centers. NERC identified that these loads exhibit unique electrical behaviors, where large-scale customer-initiated load reductions during grid faults could cause voltage and frequency excursions. To mitigate these risks, NERC launched the Large Loads Action Plan, while FERC initiated an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANOPR) to address the impact of these aggregate risks on the Bulk Power System.
IV. THE NEED TO ADDRESS COMPUTATIONAL LOAD NERC, through its engineering staff and technical industry groups, assessed the impacts to the BPS of unprecedented load growth that has occurred over the past few years. Through that work, NERC d...
AI summary The text discusses the growing risks posed to the Bulk Power System (BPS) due to unprecedented load growth from computational loads. NERC, in coordination with the U.S. Department of Energy and FERC, identified unique electrical characteristics of these loads that necessitate new mandatory Reliability Standards for owners and operators of Computational Load Sites. NERC is proposing the development of new functional entities within its Compliance Registry and has initiated the 'Large Loads Action Plan' to address these interconnection and reliability risks.
A. NERC Large Loads Action Plan Over the past few years, NERC in its Long-Term Reliability Assessments identified unprecedented load growth, noting that demand growth is higher than at any point in the last two decades. 21 This projected i...
AI summary The text discusses the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) Large Loads Action Plan, which addresses unprecedented electricity demand growth in North America. This growth is primarily driven by the digital economy, specifically data centers for artificial intelligence. The rapid expansion of these large loads presents unique challenges for demand forecasting and system behavior planning. NERC is collaborating with stakeholders to ensure transmission system reliability and mitigate potential impacts on the Bulk Power System (BPS).
1. NERC Large Loads Working Group As part of the NERC Large Loads Action Plan, NERC engaged the Reliability and Security Technical Committee Large Loads Working Group ("LLWG") 24 to assess the risks to the reliability of the BPS posed by l...
AI summary The text describes the activities of the NERC Large Loads Working Group (LLWG), which was established to assess risks to the Bulk Power System (BPS) posed by large loads. NERC identified specific risks associated with emerging power electronic loads, such as those for data centers, artificial intelligence, and cryptocurrencies. These loads are characterized by high energy consumption, variable demand, significant cooling requirements, and the use of software controls to manage load behavior, which differ from traditional electrical characteristics.
2. NERC Alerts and Incident Reviews Another component of the NERC Large Loads Action Plan, NERC published a Level 2 Alert on September 9, 2025 that provided additional insight into the impacts of the integration of large loads and industry...
AI summary The text discusses NERC's Level 2 Alert and subsequent public report regarding the integration of large loads into the Bulk Power System (BPS). NERC identified significant risks to reliability and highlighted gaps in current industry preparedness, specifically noting that registered entities often lack the necessary modeling information or direct coordination with large load entities. The findings emphasize the need for new functional entities and updated Reliability Standards to mitigate these risks.
3. Need for New Functional Entities The severity of the aggregate risk posed by the types of occurrences outlined in the incident reviews grows with the amount of computational load expected on the system. In the Level 2 Alert report, NERC...
AI summary The text discusses the increasing reliability risks posed by the proliferation of large computational loads on the Bulk Power System (BPS). NERC identifies that computational loads may account for 90% of large loads by 2027, presenting unique electrical behaviors and geographic concentrations that threaten grid stability. To mitigate these risks, NERC is proposing new registry criteria and Reliability Standards to help grid planners understand load profiles. Interim measures include Level 3 Essential Action Alerts and Reliability Guidelines to manage load reductions and oscillations.
B. ANOPR and FERC Directive While NERC implemented its Large Loads Action Plan, the Secretary of the U.S. DOE and FERC also recognized the need for action to address the reliable integration of large loads with the transmission system. On...
AI summary The text details the regulatory actions taken by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) regarding the integration of large loads into the interstate transmission system. Specifically, it discusses a 2025 Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANOPR) and a subsequent FERC directive requiring NERC to develop new reliability standards and registry criteria for computational loads. NERC has committed to a timeline to submit these revised standards by late 2026 to mitigate grid reliability risks.
"47 Consistent with that intent, when FERC reviewed the initial suite of NERC Reliability Standards, it declined to define user of the BPS, leaving it to a case-by-case, risk-based analysis, stating: While we recognize the desire of some c...
AI summary The text discusses the regulatory framework surrounding the definition of 'users' of the Bulk Power System (BPS). It highlights FERC's decision to avoid a generic, universal definition of 'user' to prevent the scope from being too broad or too narrow. Instead, FERC favors a case-by-case, risk-based analysis where individual Reliability Standards identify specific applicable entities. However, the text notes that FERC precedent suggests large end-use customers can be considered BPS users if they directly impact grid reliability.
1. Computational Load Site NERC proposes the following new definition in Appendix 2 of the NERC Rules of Procedure: "Computational Load Site" means one or more buildings, structures, or installations at a single location that - 1) Primaril...
AI summary The text outlines a proposed new definition by NERC for a 'Computational Load Site.' This definition is intended to provide clarity on site boundaries for identifying ownership and calculating total connected load. A site qualifies if it is at a single location, primarily contains information technology infrastructure (such as for AI training, software services, or cryptocurrency mining), and is connected to the Bulk Power System (BPS). The proposal responds to requests for clearer distinctions between various types of computational activities.
2. Computational Load Operator and Computational Load Owner In feedback on the April posting, commenters recommended the proposed criteria use the same "Owner" and "Operator" model for computational loads to remain consistent with the regi...
AI summary The text discusses NERC's proposal to establish distinct definitions for 'Computational Load Operator' and 'Computational Load Owner' within Appendix 2. This distinction aims to mirror existing models for transmission and generation, allowing for scenarios where ownership and operations are separate. The 'owns and maintains' criteria for owners is intended to identify active participants rather than passive financial interests, ensuring that only entities with significant operational responsibility are registered for compliance.
C. Appendix 5B Appendix 5B ( Attachments 2-C and 3-C ) contains the specific criteria NERC and the Regional Entities use to identify which organizations may be candidates for registration for functional entity types. In accordance with the...
AI summary The text outlines proposed revisions to Appendix 5B regarding the criteria for identifying organizations eligible for registration as Computational Load Owners and Computational Load Operators. In alignment with the United States Federal Power Act, NERC aims to identify Bulk Power System (BPS) users with material impacts. The proposed thresholds for registration are set at a total connected load of at least 50 MW and a voltage level of 100 kV or higher, adjusted from previous recommendations based on NERC Level 2 Alert data and stakeholder feedback.