Home›Program Evaluation›M06319›Evidence
Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Program Evaluation" in M06319

Matter: P-886 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) Rate Application 2007
17 passages 7 documents

Program Evaluation across all matters →

N-2-aRIRs 40 to 69 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 34 MB) 1 passage
Section 25
The following table shows the estimated benefit cost for 2006 as compared to the actual benefit cost for 2005. All figures in thousands.

AI summary The provided text introduces a table comparing the estimated benefit-cost figures for the year 2006 against the actual benefit-cost results achieved in 2005. The figures are presented in thousands.

N-2-bRIRs 1 to 26 - AEC to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - MB) 3 passages
The UK Experience
The UK Experience · Liz Kelly Strategic Business Development I - The UK context - DSM Policy drivers - Fuel poverty - Delivering solutions - Impacts - Lessons learnt

AI summary This section introduces a presentation by Liz Kelly regarding the United Kingdom's experience with Demand Side Management (DSM) policies. The discussion focuses on the strategic drivers behind UK DSM policy, specifically addressing fuel poverty, the delivery of energy solutions, and the resulting impacts and lessons learned. It serves as a comparative context for understanding how different regulatory and policy frameworks can influence energy efficiency and demand management.

Background
Background - May 31 st Minister's letter - began to explore opportunities for providing CDM to low-income customers - developed relationship with LIEN and provided input into LIEN's program template - Brantford low-income pilot included in...

AI summary The text outlines the historical background of efforts to provide Community Domestic Maintenance (CDM) to low-income customers. It notes that the initiative began following a Minister's letter on May 31st. Key actions included developing a relationship with the Low-Income Energy Efficiency Program (LIEN) to provide input on program templates and the inclusion of a low-income pilot project in Brantford within the 2005 CDM Plan approved by the Ontario Energy Board (OEB).

Pilot objectives
Pilot objectives - Provide energy conservation measures & education to approx. 100 low-income households who pay their own electricity bills - Approx 50 tenants & 50 homeowners - Evaluate pilot success - e.g. number of participants, energy...

AI summary The document outlines the objectives for a pilot program aimed at providing energy conservation measures and education to approximately 100 low-income households in Nova Scotia. The target demographic includes 50 tenants and 50 homeowners who pay their own electricity bills. The pilot is designed to evaluate success metrics such as participant numbers, energy savings, behavioral changes, and capacity building to determine future roll-out options.

N-18Direct Testimony - Nancy Brockway on behalf of the Consumer Advocate REDACTED (Large File - 37 MB) 2 passages
24 PART 4: THE CONSERVATION AND DEMAND MANAGEMENT COMPONENT.
grated its low-47 income conservation and demand management program into all aspects of the company's 48 operation. As illustrated by Maine's special payment arrangements, it is possible for a company to use low-income conservation and dem...

AI summary The text discusses integrating low-income conservation and demand management programs into a company's operations, suggesting piggy-backing with non-utility-funded efficiency programs to improve cost-effectiveness. It proposes combining utility funds with housing programs to eliminate parallel initiatives and create a single, comprehensive program for low-income households.

25 Columbia Gas Company of Pennsylvania
rom the 1990 Columbia Gas Low-Income Usage-Reduction Program," Proceedings of the 1993 Energy Program Evaluation Conference, at 771 , Energy Program Evaluation Conference: Chicago. 4 1 /d., at 775 . We found that both utility shortfall and...

AI summary The 1990 LIURP improved utility shortfall and customer billing deficit, with program participants showing a 15% surplus compared to a 3% shortfall before the program. The expected improvement could be higher if public assistance levels remained constant, suggesting a potential $17 monthly surplus per participant.

N-30RIRs 1 to 15 - Nancy Brockway (on behalf of Consumer Advocate) to NS Attorney General (includes attachment to RIR 11) (Large File - 44 MB) 8 passages
I. Executive Summary
I. Executive Summary The Energy Assistance Program (EAP) Impact Evaluation Report provides answers to several practical questions regarding the program based on measurement and analysis. This Executive Summary provides the questions, the r...

AI summary The Energy Assistance Program (EAP) Impact Evaluation Report addresses practical questions about the program through measurement and analysis. The Executive Summary outlines the questions, results, and recommendations derived from the study.

3. Defining Abuse & the Mathematical Test of Abuse
3. Defining Abuse & the Mathematical Test of Abuse If EAP participants show a high percentage of change towards increased energy use in the program participation year as compared to the baseline year, while the comparison group shows eithe...

AI summary The text discusses the mathematical test for detecting abuse in energy efficiency programs. It outlines that if EAP participants show a significant increase in energy use compared to a non-participating comparison group, it may indicate abuse. Conversely, similar changes between the two groups suggest no abuse. A 'difference of differences' approach is used to evaluate this.

1. Why Pooled Data Analysis is useful for CAP-type Programs
1. Why Pooled Data Analysis is useful for CAP-type Programs Since their inception, programs for payment troubled customers have presented a special problem for program managers and evaluators concerning the measurement of change in energy...

AI summary Pooled data analysis is useful for CAP-type programs because payment-troubled customers often have erratic and incomplete data, making traditional statistical methods less effective. This leads to a high rate of data loss during cleaning, which can affect the representativeness of results for energy conservation programs.

1. Why Individual Case Analysis is useful for CAP-type Programs
1. Why Individual Case Analysis is useful for CAP-type Programs Individual case statistical analysis is the traditional approach to the analysis of differences in energy use. Its advantage is that it yields representative results based upo...

AI summary The text discusses the use of individual case statistical analysis for CAP-type programs, emphasizing its advantages such as yielding representative results by filtering out poor-quality data and outliers. It also notes that this approach is traditional and commonly used in similar studies, integrating probability information like statistical significance and power.

1. Five Minor Recommendations
1. Five Minor Recommendations - 1. The possibility of abuse of consumption, of course, must be checked from time to time. Addition of a year against prior year% change of average normalized annual usage to the monthly EAP Statistics contro...

AI summary The document proposes five minor recommendations aimed at improving the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). These include monitoring consumption trends, organizing participants by half-year groups, comparing consumption between program and non-program participants, collecting housing data, and classifying data by senior status and number of residents to improve analysis accuracy.

B. Assessing Overall Program Perfonnance
B. Assessing Overall Program Perfonnance By definition, overall program performance involves the relationship of the relative benefits and costs of the program. Once the individual benefits and costs are determined and summed, they are cas...

AI summary The assessment of overall program performance involves evaluating the relationship between the benefits and costs of a program, with the primary measure being the 'Net Back Ratio' and a secondary measure being dollars returned to Equitable.

5. Measurement Issue: Baseline Year
5. Measurement Issue: Baseline Year In many evaluations, there is a direct comparison of "before" and "after'', the "pre" and the "post" which in this evaluation finds expression as the Baseline Year and the Participation Year. For the NBR...

AI summary The evaluation compares the Net Back Ratio (NBR) of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) participants with a baseline group. While the NBR for EAP participants is similar to the baseline group, the baseline group's composition has changed due to EAP's introduction, affecting the validity of the comparison. The NBR of 1.4 is projected to remain stable if the program structure remains unchanged.

X. A Final Note
X. A Final Note As this study has demonstrated, Equitable's Energy Assistance Program (EAP) is successful. It works as planned. More importantly, it benefits participant customers, non-participant customers, Equitable, and society. The pra...

AI summary The study concludes that Equitable's Energy Assistance Program (EAP) is effective and benefits various stakeholders. The evaluation used multiple methods, including a 'Net-Back' approach, and findings were validated through repeated analysis with different data sets. The results are considered very solid, with no evidence of program abuse.

N-44RIRs 76 to 136 - CA to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 19 MB) 1 passage
- ☐ Holidays scheduled for Dec 25, 26, and Jan 1
- ☐ Holidays scheduled for Dec 25, 26, and Jan 1 Key Milestones Target Date Status Conduct current state assessment 12/15 Complete Document leading practices in terms of 12/19 Complete capability and performance Evaluate NSPI performance a...

AI summary The document outlines key milestones for a project involving the assessment of NSPI's performance and the development of future operating capabilities, with a report submission to the UARB and scheduled workshops.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - Appendix A to J - REDACTED (Large File 27 MB) 1 passage
Average Credit Provided by ELI 2P-RTP Three-Tiered Credit Mechanism
Average Credit Provided by ELI 2P-RTP Three-Tiered Credit Mechanism The average percentage (of marginal cost) that SEB is credited, based on the three tiered credit mechanism of the ELI 2P-RTP rate, exceeds 95%. This is in contrast with th...

AI summary The document discusses the average percentage of marginal costs credited to SEB under the ELI 2P-RTP three-tiered credit mechanism. It notes that the actual credit exceeds 95% because the majority of load reductions occur in the first tier, which provides a 100% marginal cost credit. This figure is contrasted against Dr. Stutz's testimony in the ELIIR-2 Hearing, where he suggested a 77% credit rate was more appropriate.

58140Final Submission - Ecology Action Centre 1 passage
Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Demand Side Management?
. - 14. Further, the DSM Plan submitted by Nova Scotia Power Inc. on September 81 2006 does not provide a full accounting of avoided costs or the maximum achievable economic potential in Nova Scotia. - 15. A letter written by EAC consultan...

AI summary The DSM Plan submitted by Nova Scotia Power Inc. is criticized for not fully accounting for avoided costs or the maximum achievable economic potential in Nova Scotia. The EAC highlights that the report's methodology may have been unduly influenced by other jurisdictions and lacks necessary documentation to assess energy efficiency potential.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →