Topic:"Program Evaluation" in M11647

Evaluation and Attribution of Energy Savings Subject to the Board's approval, EOne and NS Power jointly propose that EOne assume ownership and responsibility for conducting all required CEM evaluation, measurement, and verification (" EM&V...

AI summary EOne and NS Power propose that EOne take responsibility for evaluating and verifying energy savings from EOne's behavioural programs using the CEM platform, excluding billing impact evaluations. This arrangement aims to streamline the EM&V process, reduce duplication, and ensure clarity for ratepayers.

- d) All calls or other communications regarding the Home Energy Report shall be directed to EfficiencyOne's call centre. - 2) Bidgely : EfficiencyOne will conclude a contract with Bidgely for the Home Energy Reports module with an anticip...

AI summary EfficiencyOne is responsible for managing Home Energy Reports in collaboration with NS Power, using the CEM platform. NS Power will provide AMI data for free, and EfficiencyOne will handle incremental costs related to Bidgely's services. EfficiencyOne must file an updated method for accounting energy savings with the NSUARB.

m. E1's operational control of content and branding for "My Recommendations" through the Bidgely platform does not require any additional investment by E1 beyond NS Power's original acquisition costs. Request IR-02: Regarding Evaluation an...

AI summary EfficiencyOne (E1) confirms its intention to submit the Load Impact Report (renamed 'Energy Usage') as part of its annual filings to the NSUARB, and states that savings from the Customer Energy Management (CEM) program will be attributed to E1. E1 also mentions using the difference-in-difference measurement approach for Load Impact.

- customers. 1 Request IR-04: 2 3 Page 4 of the application proposes that this framework will streamline the EM&V process. 4 Please elaborate on how incorporating EOne's responsibilities in the EM&V of the CEM will 5 streamline the EM&V? 6...

AI summary The document discusses a proposal to streamline the EM&V process by integrating EOne's responsibilities in the evaluation of the CEM program. However, the response indicates that no direct cost savings are expected from this reallocation of responsibilities.

2 - 3 Schedule A item 7 indicates that EOne was to provide an update to the Board in February 2024. - 4 As well as 7(b) indicates a request would be submitted to the Board from NS Power seeking - 5 approval to be relieved of its obligation...

AI summary Schedule A item 7 indicates that EOne was to provide an update to the Board in February 2024, and NS Power requested approval to be relieved of its obligation to conduct an EM&V for the CEM, with EOne assuming responsibility. This conflicts with Schedule B, which outlines NSP's current responsibilities under M10460.

(c) Please refer to EfficiencyOne's IR response to (b). (d) Please refer to EfficiencyOne's IR response to (b). Request IR-03: Refer to the Letter, bottom of page 3 through top of page 4, quoted below and answer the questions that follow....

AI summary The response outlines the roles of Econoler and the Board's verifier in evaluating EfficiencyOne's demand-side management programs. It notes that Econoler conducts impact evaluations, while the Board's verifier confirms results. The response also addresses distinguishing load shift results from those tracked by NS Power's TVP/TOU program.

E1 Responses to Nova Scotia Small Business Advocate Information Requests NON-CONFIDENTIAL available capacity achieved. Process and market evaluations also take place when deemed necessary. The evaluator's findings are submitted in Evaluati...

AI summary E1 provides responses to information requests regarding its programs, including the process for evaluating electricity energy savings and demand reduction. Evaluations are submitted to the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (NSUARB), with a Verification Consultant verifying the findings annually. E1 would rely on third-party evaluators if the transfer of Load Impact metrics is approved.

1 Request IR-04: 2 3 Refer to the Letter page 3 which states "EOne submits that the ongoing collaborative efforts 4 and agreement reached between the two utilities respecting the CEM and EOne's behavioural 5 program will result in a reduct...

AI summary EOne and NS Power have agreed to share a CEM platform to reduce duplicative costs, with an estimated annual savings of approximately $100,000. EOne will report actual cost reductions in its quarterly and annual reports, and the Board is being asked about future cost increases related to additional responsibilities.

ting EOne's Home Energy Reports (HER) and each party will hold an independent contract with Bidgely Inc. Through this agreement, EOne anticipates there will be a reduction in costs for both utilities. EOne said that, subject to the Board's...

AI summary EOne proposes assuming responsibility for conducting EM&V of Load Impact related to its behavioural program, with savings attributed exclusively to EOne. NS Power would retain responsibility for other evaluations. The Board invited submissions, and responses were filed by EOne, the SBA, and NS Power.

nded to IRs from the Board and the Small Business Advocate (SBA) on June 19, 2024. Comments from the SBA and NS Power were filed on July 4, 2024, and EOne's reply comments were filed on July 18, 2024. It was apparent from the comments file...

AI summary The Board notes disagreements between EOne and NS Power regarding the EM&V responsibilities under their agreement, particularly concerning the scope of EOne's responsibilities and savings allocation. The Board emphasizes the need for alignment before seeking approval and reiterates existing reporting requirements. It also expects EOne and NS Power to address concerns about cost savings and duplication of services.

M11647 – EfficiencyOne – Behavioural Program Update On April 8, 2024, EfficiencyOne (EOne) filed an update with the Board about EOne's collaborative efforts with Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NS Power) and stakeholders on energy efficiency progr...

AI summary EfficiencyOne (EOne) filed an update with the Board regarding its collaboration with Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NS Power) on energy efficiency programs under the 2023–2025 DSM Plan. EOne seeks approval to assume ownership of CEM EM&V reporting and attribute all savings from the CEM to itself. The Board has directed EOne to provide quarterly updates and will accept information requests and comments from interested parties.

- a) Please refer to page 1 of the Letter and describe the difference in roles, responsibilities, and funding sources for EOne versus EfficiencyNS (ENS), where the latter is first referenced in Schedule A, paragraph 1.b. - b) What is the m...

AI summary The text contains a series of requests related to the roles of EOne and EfficiencyNS, the definition of 'DID', data sources for load shift analysis, the status of a revised Home Energy Report, and the evaluation process involving Econoler. These requests are part of a regulatory proceeding.

Board's verifier through a single process following the evaluation methodologies and reporting presently used by EOne." - a) What are the roles and responsibilities performed by Econoler versus the Board's verifier? - b) How will EOne dist...

AI summary The document outlines several requests for clarification regarding the roles of Econoler and the Board's verifier, the distinction between load shift results from EOne and NS Power, cost reductions from collaborative efforts, and the allocation of savings from the Bidgely CEM platform. These requests aim to ensure transparency and accountability in program management and cost reporting.

July 4, 2024 EfficiencyOne 230 Brownlow Avenue, Suite 300 Dartmouth, NS B3B 0G5 Attention: Gina Thompson Re: M11647 – EfficiencyOne – Behavioural Program Update Dear Ms. Thompson: On April 8, 2024, EfficiencyOne (EOne) filed its Behavioura...

AI summary EfficiencyOne submitted a Behavioural Program Update to the NSUARB regarding its collaboration with NS Power on energy efficiency programs under the 2023–2025 DSM Plan. The Board requested information from interested parties and set timelines for responses and comments. An information request from the NSUARB highlighted a potential conflict between Schedule A and Schedule B of the submission.

to provide an update to the Board in February 2024. As well as 7(b) indicates a request would be 1 NSUARB Letter, M11647 – EfficiencyOne – Behavioural Program Update, May 14, 2024, page 2. submitted to the Board from NS Power seeking appro...

AI summary This document discusses a request by NS Power to be relieved of its obligation to conduct EM&V for the CEM, with EOne assuming responsibility. There is a conflict between the request and Schedule B of M10460.1F. EOne clarified that it would be responsible for the Load Impact metric, while NS Power retains responsibility for others. The Operational Agreement was finalized in April 2024.

Power from its obligation to conduct its own evaluation under its CEM, place responsibility for all CEM evaluations and verifications with EfficiencyOne under its existing EM&V process;3F 4 This is inconsistent with EOne's Update letter an...

AI summary NS Power and EfficiencyOne have agreed to transfer CEM EM&V responsibilities to EfficiencyOne under an arrangement that includes sharing of the CEM platform and attribution of savings. The agreement is aligned with legal and regulatory requirements and aims to serve ratepayers' best interests. Further discussions are planned to align positions on ownership of CEM EM&V items.

ting EOne's Home Energy Reports (HER) and each party will hold an independent contract with Bidgely Inc. Through this agreement, EOne anticipates there will be a reduction in costs for both utilities. EOne said that, subject to the Board's...

AI summary EOne proposes assuming responsibility for conducting EM&V of load impact related to its behavioural program, while NS Power retains responsibility for other evaluations. EOne anticipates cost reductions through its agreement with Bidgely Inc. for Home Energy Reports (HER). The Board invited Information Requests, and responses were filed by EOne, the SBA, and NS Power.

nded to IRs from the Board and the Small Business Advocate (SBA) on June 19, 2024. Comments from the SBA and NS Power were filed on July 4, 2024, and EOne's reply comments were filed on July 18, 2024. It was apparent from the comments file...

AI summary The Board has received comments from NS Power and the SBA regarding an agreement between EOne and NS Power on CEM EM&V responsibilities. Disagreements exist over EOne's responsibility for EM&V and savings allocation. The Board emphasizes the need for alignment before seeking approval and reiterates reporting requirements from Matter M11694.