064632010 DSM Evaluation Reports 2/28/2011
32 passages
1.3.1 Data Quality Issues The NMR team encountered several issues involving inconsistent, inaccurate, or missing data in 2010. These issues were experienced particularly in the SBLS, DI, and C&I Custom programs. Inconsistent and Inaccurate...
AI summary The NMR team identified data quality issues in 2010, particularly in the SBLS, DI, and C&I Custom programs. These included data entry errors, discrepancies between recorded and observed installations, and potential vulnerabilities in programs using subcontractors. Corrective actions were taken, but additional audits are recommended for similar programs.
p levels continue to rise, consider adjusting the if it continues to increase it may become an area of concern. screening procedures used to identify free-riders. C&I-F2. C&I-R2. Due to the compressed time frame between the end of the prog...
AI summary The document highlights challenges with the C&I Custom program's evaluation process, including compressed timelines, data entry errors, and the need for improved tracking systems and evaluation schedules to ensure accurate and rigorous impact assessments.
re sufficient unsuccessful in the bidding process was taken over by two of the three to carry out the program as designed. Delivery Agents. LIH-F14. LIH-R14. The Delivery Agents reported that the protocol for replacing The DSM Administrato...
AI summary The text discusses challenges in a program's delivery, including difficulties in replacing refrigerators and freezers due to burdensome protocols and the need for updated guidelines. It also mentions the separation of audit scopes to improve cost-effectiveness and the importance of involving Delivery Agents in program design changes.
please tell me if you are very satisfied, satisfied, neither satisfied nor dissatisfied, dissatisfied, or very dissatisfied with your experience with that specific aspect of the program. VS S Neither Dissat V.Dissat DK/Ref a. Program marke...
AI summary The text presents a survey asking participants to rate their satisfaction with various aspects of a program, including marketing, support, interactions with staff, and rebate processes. It also asks for reasons for dissatisfaction and recommendations for improvement, focusing on barriers to participation and ways to enhance the Power Down program.
program effectiveness and success in short-, intermediate-, and long-term? Marketing, Participating Retailers, and Verification: 17. Please explain the various marketing activities utilized by each program. What do you think is particularl...
AI summary The text outlines a set of questions aimed at evaluating the effectiveness and success of energy efficiency programs, focusing on marketing strategies, program delivery, free-ridership safeguards, coverage gaps, and areas for improvement. It also includes a request for additional individuals or groups to interview regarding the program.
it provided? How frequently is it provided? Approximately how much of your organization‘s effort for the Appliance Retirement Program is spent on fulfilling data tracking requirements? 14. In general, how well do you think the program trac...
AI summary The document outlines a series of questions related to the Appliance Retirement Program, focusing on data tracking requirements, program delivery processes, and customer participation. It seeks feedback on the efficiency of data capture, program delivery timelines, process improvements, and factors influencing customer participation.
s it provided? How frequently is it provided? Approximately how much of your organization‘s effort for the Appliance Retirement Program is spent on fulfilling data tracking requirements? 17. In general, how well do you think the program tr...
AI summary The text focuses on data tracking and reporting requirements for the Appliance Retirement Program, asking about the frequency and effort involved in data collection, the effectiveness of the current process, and potential improvements. It also inquires about the program delivery process, including timelines for customer interactions and follow-up actions.
Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................ I IMPACT EVALUATION FINDINGS .........................................................
AI summary The document outlines a program description and data tracking process, including program theory, logic models, and impact evaluation methodologies. It discusses evaluated program impacts, prescriptive savings, and 2010 program impacts. The content appears to be part of a larger evaluation or regulatory proceeding.
3.4.1 Delivery Agent Perspectives ............................................................................................... 21 3.4.2 On-Site Visits ........................................................................................
AI summary The text outlines sections related to program tracking, awareness, participant actions, and program impact. It includes subsections on program awareness, participation motivations, participant plans, and satisfaction with the program. These sections aim to evaluate the effectiveness and reach of energy efficiency programs.
Findings and Recommendations The EnerGuide for Existing Homes program has been somewhat confusing for potential participants since the withdrawal of the rebates from NRCan in March 2010. In March, 2010 NRCan announced that new participants...
AI summary The EnerGuide for Existing Homes (EEH) program exceeded its energy and demand savings goals despite confusion caused by the withdrawal of federal rebates in 2010. However, uncertainty about the program's continuation past March 31, 2011, led to staff layoffs and affected program delivery infrastructure. NMR emphasized the importance of maintaining strong relationships with Delivery Agents to rebuild trust and infrastructure.
of specific areas later in the interview, but from an overall perspective, what would you say are the successes you were able to achieve in planning and implementing the program(s) this year? a. Again at the broadest level, what were the a...
AI summary The text discusses the evaluation of the 2010 EnerGuide for Existing Houses Program, focusing on its successes, challenges, and theoretical framework. It asks about program theory, logic models, and whether the program aims to reduce demand or transform market practices.
Marketing and Verification: 16. Please explain the various marketing activities utilized by each program. What do you think is particularly good about program marketing? How could program marketing be improved? 17. Overall, how successful...
AI summary The text outlines a set of questions to be addressed in a regulatory proceeding, focusing on program marketing, delivery, success, free-ridership safeguards, coverage gaps, and evaluation of past recommendations. It also asks for an assessment of program strengths and weaknesses and potential improvements.
that can be done to encourage these customers to implement recommended measures? 22. For customers who go on to do the final audit, typically, how soon after the first audit do they implement the measures and how much time after the first...
AI summary The text consists of a series of questions aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of the 2010 EnerGuide for Existing Houses Program, focusing on customer behavior, program implementation, vendor practices, and overall program performance.
Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ......................................................................................................................................... I IMPACT EVALUATION FINDINGS ................................................
AI summary The document outlines the structure of a program description and impact evaluation, including sections on program theory, logic, research design, methodology, and billing information analysis. It emphasizes the development of participant and control group data, as well as temperature normalization of bills for accurate evaluation.
AP%20Evaluation%20Report.pdf NMR Evaluation of 2010 Low Income Households Program Page 19 Table 2-10 presents the final estimates of savings for the LIH program based upon the billing analysis results described above. This table utilizes t...
AI summary The document evaluates the 2010 Low Income Households (LIH) Program, estimating energy and demand savings based on billing analysis. It reports total energy savings of 800.3 MWh at the meter and 895.4 MWh at the generator, with a 30% realization rate compared to the program tracking estimate. Demand savings are estimated at 178 kW at the meter and 199.2 kW at the generator.
Staff Interview Guide for NSPI, 2010 Date: Name: Programs responsible for: Introduction: [This interview should take about an hour] Your comments are confidential. By the way, if I ask you about areas you don‘t know about, please feel free...
AI summary This document is a staff interview guide for NSPI, focusing on program responsibilities, interactions with various stakeholders, and communication challenges. It includes questions about program timelines, energy savings goals, and collaboration with entities like Conserve Nova Scotia and delivery agents.
a. Again at the broadest level, what were the areas that were not so successful? b. To what do you trace the difficulties you encountered? How might they be addressed in future programs? Marketing and Verification: 8. Please explain the va...
AI summary The document outlines a series of questions related to the evaluation of energy efficiency programs, including their marketing, delivery, success, and gaps in coverage. It also touches on the impact of changes in incentive structures and the review of past recommendations.
Program Coordination and Communications 11. What organizations and individuals do you primarily interact with for this program? What is the nature of these interactions? How frequently are you in contact with them? [PROBE IF NOT MENTIONED:...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions related to program coordination, communication, and reporting for an energy efficiency initiative. It asks about interactions with organizations and individuals, vendor relationships, and the challenges faced in communication and collaboration. It also inquires about the nature and frequency of data tracking and reporting for the LI REAP Program.
16. In general, how well do you think the program tracking and reporting process is working? Do you believe all the necessary data is being captured and passed on to Conserve Nova Scotia? To Nova Scotia Power? If not, what data should be c...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions concerning the program tracking and reporting process, data collection efficiency, program delivery timelines, vendor selection, and challenges in program implementation. It focuses on data accuracy, communication, and process improvements.
4.1.1 Sampling Error ........................................................................................................ 33 4.2 PROGRAM GOALS AND DESIGN ....................................................................................
AI summary The text outlines various sections of a program evaluation, covering sampling error, program goals, communication strategies, information sources, homeowner involvement, motivations and barriers, participant and staff perspectives, benefits of energy-efficient homes, program incentives, and overall program satisfaction.
Program Performance and Savings Finding Recommendation NH-F11. NH-R11. Only one of the four builders reported being satisfied with the The program should work to improve the scheduling and scheduling and timing of the audit. timing of the...
AI summary The findings highlight issues with the scheduling of energy audits, double counting of prescriptive measures in HOT2000, inconsistent modeling of CFLs, and the inability to model water heater pipe wrap insulation. Recommendations include improving audit scheduling, ensuring proper modeling practices, and addressing gaps in HOT2000.
upgrade options. Upon completion of construction, the Energy Advisor verified the upgrades that had been completed and notified the homeowners about which rebates that they were eligible to receive. 4.3 Program Communication and Delivery I...
AI summary The document discusses the communication and delivery challenges of the Nova Scotia New Homes (NH) program. It highlights confusion among builders and inspectors due to changes in program support and the discontinuation of the EnerGuide for Existing Houses program. Program staff have taken steps to address this by increasing promotion efforts.
12α Don‘t know 5 5 α Significantly different from the 2009 sample at the 90% confidence level. Two of the four builders provided suggestions for additional upgrades they would like to see covered by the program. One indicated that he would...
AI summary Respondents to the survey provided feedback on the EnerGuide for New Houses program, suggesting upgrades like electric hot water and in-floor heating, requesting higher rebates for solar power and heat pumps, and calling for increased marketing, more information during the EnerGuide process, and faster rebate processing.
Marketing and Verification: 17. Please explain the various marketing activities utilized by each program. What do you think is particularly good about program marketing? How could program marketing be improved? 18. Overall, how successful...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions aimed at evaluating the marketing, delivery, and effectiveness of energy efficiency programs, as well as identifying gaps and areas for improvement. It also requests feedback on the adoption of 2008 recommendations and an assessment of program strengths and weaknesses.
h of your organization‘s effort for the EnerGuide for NMR Evaluation—2010 EnerGuide for New Houses Program Page A34 New Homes Program is spent on fulfilling data tracking requirements specifically for electric measures rebated by Nova Scot...
AI summary The text discusses data tracking and reporting processes for the EnerGuide for New Houses Program, including questions about program management, data capture efficiency, and improvements to the data tracking process. It also inquires about the program delivery process and timing for each step.
keeps customers from participating in the program? NMR Evaluation—2010 EnerGuide for New Houses Program Page A36 34. What impact, if any, has the entry of Nova Scotia Power into the program had on customer awareness and/or response to the...
AI summary The text consists of a series of evaluation questions about the 2010 EnerGuide for New Houses Program, focusing on customer awareness, program effectiveness, customer satisfaction, and areas for improvement. It also requests contact information for an energy advisor from an unspecified organization.
ny independent, or part of a larger company? Independent Part of a larger company Don‘t know Refused Other ( _) 9. (Don‘t know/Don‘t recall) NMR Process and Impact Evaluation: Prescriptive Rebate Programs 2010 February 25, 2011 Final Repor...
AI summary This document outlines the final report of a process and impact evaluation of prescriptive rebate programs conducted in 2010, submitted to Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation by NMR Group, Inc. The evaluation was carried out by a team of principal investigators and includes contributions from KEMA, Inc.
Introduction: [This interview should take about an hour] Your comments are confidential. By the way, if I ask you about areas you don‘t know about, please feel free to tell me and we will move on. For transcription purposes we will be reco...
AI summary The text outlines an interview protocol for gathering information about a program's status, launch timeline, energy savings goals, and program evaluation needs. It also asks about the role of the interviewee, collaboration with other stakeholders, and any challenges encountered.
b. To what do you trace the difficulties you encountered? How might they be addressed in future programs? 10. Do you have a plan in place for transitioning the program over to the new administrator? If yes: what does that plan involve? Do...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions aimed at evaluating program challenges, transition plans, and the theoretical framework of a program. It asks about difficulties encountered, future improvements, transition strategies, and the program's goals, structure, and outcomes.
primary motivations for participating in the program? What are the major barriers to their participation in the program? 20. What has changed about the program since the beginning, and why? Marketing and Verification: 21. Please explain th...
AI summary The text presents a series of questions related to program evaluation, including participation motivations, program changes, marketing and delivery effectiveness, free-ridership safeguards, and coverage gaps. It also includes a reference to an impact and process evaluation of a commercial and industrial custom program from 2010.
Theory and Logic Model Review: 9. Is the program theory and logic model included in the C&I program manual still valid? 10. Has the program been expanded to include participants other than larger commercial, industrial and municipal custom...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions regarding the validity and scope of a Commercial and Industrial (C&I) program, its outreach efforts, and its goals, including whether it functions as a Resource Acquisition or Market Transformation program. It also explores short-term and intermediate goals, as well as the program's impact on the market.
cipate in the NSPI rebate programs? [Probe: Save energy, rebates offered, reduce maintenance costs, protect environment, recommended by utility, concerns with carbon, etc.] 12. Were there any challenges or barriers that you faced in making...
AI summary The text outlines a series of questions aimed at evaluating the experience of participants in NSPI rebate programs, focusing on barriers to participation, challenges in implementation, satisfaction levels, and gaps in program coverage. It also asks about the effectiveness of communication, rebate amounts, and measurement and verification processes.