Home›Prudency Review›M06319›Evidence
Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Prudency Review" in M06319

Matter: P-886 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) Rate Application 2007
8 passages 5 documents

Prudency Review across all matters →

N-2-cRIRs 1 to 39 - CA to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 14 MB) 3 passages
Response IR-18 (cont'd):
Response IR-18 (cont'd): - a. The use of a forward test year is not considered a form of protection, although the use of a historic test year would tend to increase regulatory risks. A future test year has been assumed by Dr. Morin. - b. T...

AI summary The text addresses the methodology used in a cost-of-service assessment, specifically focusing on the selection of test years and the inclusion of costs in forecasts. It argues that using a forward test year does not constitute a form of protection, unlike a historic test year which would heighten regulatory risk. Furthermore, it clarifies that including costs in a test year forecast is a standard regulatory procedure, and the assessment assumes that all prudent costs are included without assuming a denial of cost recovery.

6.7.3 Findings
6.7.3 Findings [ 1] In past decisions, the Board has expressed concern about the control of OM&G expenses by NSPI. In its 2002 rate decision, the Board stated: [133] The Board has significant concerns with respect to whether NSPI has reduc...

AI summary The Board expresses significant concern regarding Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) control over OM&G expenses. Citing past decisions, the Board notes that NSPI has failed to provide sufficient information to prove that corporate expenses are as low as prudently possible or that internal budgeting procedures are sufficiently thorough. Because NSPI is seeking to pass these costs to ratepayers through a significant rate increase, the Board emphasizes the utility's obligation to demonstrate cost efficiency and eliminate unnecessary expenses, which NSPI has failed to do adequately.

14.13 Operations Review
14.13 Operations Review [703] In past decisions, the Board has expressed concern about the control of OM&G expenses by NSPI. Following its review of the evidence in this hearing, the Board continues to be concerned about the magnitude of t...

AI summary The Board expresses ongoing concern regarding Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) control over Other Management and General (OM&G) expenses, especially given NSPI's request for a significant rate increase. Consequently, the Board mandates a comprehensive operations review of NSPI to identify potential cost savings and operational efficiencies. NSPI is required to submit terms of reference for this review by May 31, 2006, and must provide detailed five-year forecasts of OM&G costs in all future rate applications.

N-20Direct Testimony and Exhibit - Alan Rosenberg on behalf of SEB - REDACTED (Large File - 20 MB) 1 passage
IN YOUR OPINION, HOW SHOULD THIS BOARD ARRIVE AT AN APPROPRIATE DISALLOWANCE FOR THE PRUDENTLY ALLOWED PORTION OF NSPI'S COAL COSTS?
IN YOUR OPINION, HOW SHOULD THIS BOARD ARRIVE AT AN APPROPRIATE DISALLOWANCE FOR THE PRUDENTLY ALLOWED PORTION OF NSPI'S COAL COSTS? Ms. Hennings has calculated what NSPI's coal costs would have been if they had been purchased at market pr...

AI summary The text discusses how the Board should determine an appropriate disallowance for NSPI's coal costs, suggesting that if the Board finds NSPI's costs imprudent, a reasonable disallowance would be half the difference between calculated market prices and actual test year costs, based on the 'used and useful' test.

N-21Direct Evidence - Colin V. Gubbins (Revised) on behalf of SEB - REDACTED 1 passage
Timing of Purchasing Decisions
Timing of Purchasing Decisions While we have concerns that NSPI appear to be disregarding their own procedures, in our past expert testimony we have argued for a flexible purchasing strategy that recognises the extraordinary movement in co...

AI summary The text discusses concerns about Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) purchasing decisions, particularly entering into long-term coal contracts at high prices when market conditions were unfavorable. It argues that these decisions led to unnecessary costs and suggests that NSPI should have adopted a more flexible strategy, waiting for market normalization before committing to long-term contracts.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - Appendix A to J - REDACTED (Large File 27 MB) 1 passage
Summary
Summary - Lower fuel costs during Ql 2006 helped in the recovery of credit metrics for the 12 months ended June 30, 2006. - This is the result of the favourable settlement of a natural gas supply contract, which was offset against a fuel e...

AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) experienced improved credit metrics in Q1 2006 due to lower fuel costs resulting from a favorable natural gas supply contract settlement. Conversely, 2005 saw the lowest EBIT and net income in five years because higher actual fuel costs exceeded the 90% recovery approved by the UARB, which deemed certain costs 'imprudently incurred.' Additionally, a lower approved return on equity (ROE) of 9.55% in 2005 compared to 2004 further impacted earnings during that period.

58140Final Submission - Ecology Action Centre 2 passages
PART ll- ISSUES
PART ll- ISSUES - 1. Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Demand Side Management? - 2. Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Renewable Energy Generation? - 3. Is...

AI summary The document outlines seven key issues under Part ll of the proceeding, focusing on NSPI's expenses, demand-side management, renewable energy, prudence, social and environmental considerations, fuel adjustment mechanisms, public participation, and cost awards for the EAC.

Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Demand Side Management?
Is NSPI Undertaking Reasonable and Prudent Expenses Given Opportunities for Demand Side Management? - 6. Sec 45(2) of the Public Utilities Act R.S.N.S c. 380 [hereinafter PUA] specifies that the Board determines a request by NSPI for an in...

AI summary The document discusses whether NSPI's continued fossil fuel generation is reasonable and prudent, given the availability of cost-effective demand side management (DSM) options. The Ecology Action Centre argues that evidence from DSM and IRP processes should be considered holistically, not restricted to one process.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →