Home›Prudency Reviews›M06319›Evidence
Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Prudency Reviews" in M06319

Matter: P-886 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) Rate Application 2007
33 passages 14 documents

Prudency Reviews across all matters →

N-2-aRIRs 1 to 39 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 19 MB) 1 passage
Response IR-2: (cont'd)
s request in its current general rate application for a 2P-RTP true-up procedure. SEB objects to NSPI's inclusion of this request in the rate application, and asks that it "be struck from the filing". NSPI is not aware of any jurisdiction...

AI summary NSPI requests a 2P-RTP true-up procedure in its general rate application, which SEB objects to, asking it to be struck from the filing. NSPI argues that the Board cannot summarily dismiss portions of a properly filed application and that intervenors cannot object to the inclusion of items in the application. NSPI emphasizes compliance with the Board's ELIIR-2 decision and the proposed mechanism's alignment with the Board's intent.

N-2-bRIR 76 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 46 MB) 1 passage
Bangor Hydro
Bangor Hydro Bangor Hydro's business consists of four primary components wh ich are each governed by their own regulatory structure. The components include distribution, transm ission , standard costs, and supply (metering, billi ng, and s...

AI summary The document outlines the four primary components of Bangor Hydro's business: distribution, transmission, standard costs, and supply. BHE's distribution business operates under an Alternate Rate Plan (ARP) requiring annual rate decreases and performance penalties, with the potential for higher returns on equity. Transmission is regulated by FERC and linked to the Regional Transmission Organization for New England. BHE can recover stranded costs for regulatory assets and power purchases, while metering and billing costs are recoverable as prudently incurred.

N-2-cRIRs 1 to 39 - CA to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 14 MB) 2 passages
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST TO: NSPI FROM: CA Question IR-16: Identify what rate making principle supports recovery of costs incurred prior to the effective date of the rate increase applied for. Response IR-16: As a cost of service ut...

AI summary Canada Nova Scotia Electricity Corporation (CA) responds to a request for information regarding the rate-making principles supporting the recovery of costs incurred prior to a rate increase. CA asserts that as a cost-of-service utility with a service obligation, Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) is entitled to recover prudently incurred costs of service. The response cites Section 45 of the Public Utilities Act, which establishes the utility's right to earn a just and reasonable return on its rate base in addition to allowed reasonable and prudent operating expenses.

6.7.3 Findings
oncerning certain expenses. NSPI has not provided an adequate response. As a result, the Board is not satisfied that NSPI management has made every reasonable effort to eliminate unnecessary expenses. [137] Further, the Board understands t...

AI summary The Board expressed dissatisfaction with Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) for failing to provide an adequate response regarding the elimination of unnecessary expenses. While acknowledging NSPI's benchmarking process, the Board emphasized that benchmarking alone is insufficient and must be complemented by exhaustive reviews of operating expenses. The Board noted significant increases in corporate expenses despite stable overall OM&G costs over six years and ordered NSPI to conduct a detailed review of its OM&G expenses to demonstrate cost-efficiency.

N-12Evidence filed by John Stutz on behalf of NSUARB 1 passage
Preamble
23 submission of evidence, cross-examination and briefing-effectively, to address the reasonableness and prudence of the costs the Company has proposed that it be allowed to recover. Costs and revenues both can change between rate filings....

AI summary The text discusses the regulation of utility costs, emphasizing the importance of the reasonableness and prudence of proposed costs. It argues that regulatory lag helps emulate competitive markets and that utilities should not be allowed to recover certain costs. It also addresses NSPI's request to defer increased fuel expenses, which is not supported due to the company's prior actions and flexibility in rate filings.

N-14Evidence filed by John Antonuk, Donald T. Spangenberg, Jr. and John B. Adger, Jr. (on behalf of NSUARB) (Large File - 26 MB) 1 passage
Testimony
Testimony Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board - testimony on the prudence of fuel procurement, affiliate relationships associated with fuel management, and use of an automatic adjustment clause to recover fuel costs. Arizona Corporation C...

AI summary The testimony section outlines various regulatory proceedings across multiple jurisdictions, focusing on fuel procurement, affiliate relationships, rate increases, and management audits. These testimonies were presented to different utility commissions and regulatory bodies, addressing issues such as prudence of fuel procurement, management-audit recommendations, and interconnection agreements.

N-18Direct Testimony - Nancy Brockway on behalf of the Consumer Advocate REDACTED (Large File - 37 MB) 1 passage
Section 18
ations" is a component of generation business risk. - 7 Q. 8 Please discuss these aspects of Dr. Morin's analysis of risk, beginning with the risk of a regulatory finding of imprudence. 10 A. 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 If...

AI summary The witness discusses the risk of regulatory findings of imprudence related to NSPI's fuel procurement, stating that there is no basis for such a finding if NSPI is operating prudently. The witness also references past rate cases (P-881 and P-882) and notes that the Board has ruled to cut off consideration of imprudence impacts as of P-882.

N-20Direct Testimony and Exhibit - Alan Rosenberg on behalf of SEB - REDACTED (Large File - 20 MB) 3 passages
15 2. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS WITH OTHER NORTH AMERICAN UTILITIES
15 2. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS WITH OTHER NORTH AMERICAN UTILITIES - 16 Q WHY IS A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF NSPI'S PROPOSED RATES WITH 17 OTHER UTILITIES IN THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA RELEVANT TO THIS 18 PROCEErnNG? - 19 A In the first place,...

AI summary The relevance of comparing NSPI's proposed rates with other North American utilities is discussed, emphasizing affordability, utility management, and regulatory discretion. The comparison helps assess whether NSPI's rates are reasonable and align with broader regulatory goals of fairness to both shareholders and ratepayers.

Preamble
management in committing to certain expenditures, the used and useful test examines whether the expenditure in question is (1) physically used and {2) useful to the ratepayers from an economic standpoint, after consideration of any non-pri...

AI summary The used and useful test assesses whether expenditures are both physically used and economically beneficial to ratepayers. An example from Vermont highlights the imprudence of locking into a power purchase agreement with Hydro Quebec, leading to disallowance of related costs due to imprudence and lack of use-and-usefulness.

Q CAN YOU GIVE AN ILLUSTRATION OF HOW THE TWO TESTS CAN BE USED IN CONJUNCTION WITH ONE ANOTHER?
Q CAN YOU GIVE AN ILLUSTRATION OF HOW THE TWO TESTS CAN BE USED IN CONJUNCTION WITH ONE ANOTHER? Yes. Suppose that a utility builds a plant for $500 million, but that the regulators conclude, based on the facts known at the time the plant...

AI summary The example illustrates how prudence and used-and-useful standards are applied in regulatory decisions. If a utility spends more than the prudent cost on a plant, the excess is disallowed. If an equivalent capacity could have been obtained cheaper, the difference is shared between customers and shareholders.

N-40RIRs Attachment SEB-NSPI - 2d (Large File - 20 MB) 2 passages
Section 12
- 3. The Company shall compute, record and report to the Commission the monthly and accumulated over or under-recovery of actual energy cost resulting from application of the Energy Cost Recovery factor as soon as available. - 4. It is the...

AI summary The text outlines the regulatory framework for the Energy Cost Recovery (ECR) mechanism. It requires the Company to report monthly over or under-recoveries resulting from the Energy Cost Recovery factor. The primary purpose of the Rate ECR is to ensure the Company recovers specific energy costs, including an adjustment to refund or collect differences between actual costs and estimated revenues. Additionally, it establishes that the Commission may disallow costs resulting from imprudent conduct and specifies that orders changing the recovery factor are final and subject to judicial review.

For the Attorney General:
For the Attorney General: Len G. Green, Assistant Attorney General, North Carolina Department of Justice, Post Office Box 629, Raleigh, North Carolina 27602-0629 Public Staff witness Edwards testified that he generally agreed with PEC, pro...

AI summary The Commission reviewed whether transaction-related hedging costs incurred by PEC to stabilize natural gas costs should be recoverable as fuel costs. While CIGFUR II argued that these costs fall outside the scope of G.S. 62-133.2, the Commission agreed with Public Staff and PEC. The Commission concluded that direct, transaction-related costs arising from prudent efforts to mitigate natural gas price volatility should be recoverable as fuel costs, provided they meet the standards of reasonableness and prudence.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 31 MB) 4 passages
17 General Comments
17 General Comments Colin Gubbins 19 EVA is gratified that Liberty and the intervenors have considerably reduced 20 issues related to NSPI's solid fuel procurement efforts which EVA believes is 21 reflective of NSPI's dedication and succes...

AI summary EVA acknowledges progress in NSPI's solid fuel procurement efforts and reduced issues from intervenors. The primary discussion focuses on fuel cost forecasting and the prudence of new mechanisms, with reference to past improvements in transparency and documentation.

Preamble
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 - Dr. Rashke in his response to IR-6 which addresses optionality acknowledges (1) the text book approach to valuing optionality is the Black-Scholes model and (2...

AI summary Dr. Rashke discusses the valuation of optionality in fuel contracts using the Black-Scholes model, suggesting it increases fixed prices. He argues that NSPI should not pay more for coal than forecast prices. However, the Board must find imprudence to disallow fuel expenses, which Dr. Rashke does not support. His testimony highlights the inaccuracy of price forecasts and his lack of regulatory experience in North America.

3 Several points should be made:
3 Several points should be made: 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 - Fuel prices have been extremely volatile. All parties to this proceeding acknowledge that volatility is likely to continue. In fact, Liberty sta...

AI summary The document discusses the volatility of fuel prices and the need for a fuel adjustment mechanism to recover prudently incurred fuel costs. It highlights that such mechanisms are widely used in North America and could reduce financial risks for NSPI. The current regulatory process is criticized as disruptive and expensive, with calls for higher standards in intervenor testimony. EVA recommends the Board issue a directive to design a fuel adjustment mechanism and establish a deferral account.

5.0 CONCLUSION
5.0 CONCLUSION 2 1 7 8 9 10 11 13 14 15 12 16 18 19 17 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 In this Rebuttal Evidence, NSPI and its experts rebut the various recommendations from Intervenor and Board consultants that seek, by various means, to...

AI summary NSPI rebuts recommendations from intervenors and consultants that seek to reduce the 2007 test year revenue requirement, arguing that these proposals are arbitrary and not supported by evidence. NSPI emphasizes its prudent fuel procurement practices and asserts that accepting these reductions would increase costs for customers.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - Appendix A to J - REDACTED (Large File 27 MB) 4 passages
Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board
Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board Mailing address PO Box1692, Unit •M• Halifax. Nova Smtia B313S3 [email protected] Web www.nsuarb.ca Office 3rd Floor 1601 Lower Water Street Halifax, Nova Scotia B3J 3P6 902 424-4448 t 902 424-3919 f...

AI summary The Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board is reviewing Nova Scotia Power Industrial's (NSPI) request to recover $3.6 million for a Distribution System Vegetation Management program. While the Board acknowledges that vegetation encroachment is a primary cause of power outages and supports the program's necessity for reliability, it notes that NSPI failed to include this foreseeable expenditure in its 2007 test year revenue requirement filing. Consequently, approving the request now would result in a revenue requirement increase.

Liberty Conclusions
Liberty Conclusions - "1. NSPI based its proposed vegetation management program for the distribution system on reasonable assumptions. The well-planned program appears to maximize the benefits to customers for the requested level of spendi...

AI summary Nova Scotia Power Industrial (NSPI) submitted a proposed vegetation management program for its distribution system. The analysis concludes that the program is built on reasonable assumptions and is well-planned to maximize customer benefits relative to the requested spending. While the program is expected to improve system reliability, it is noted that it may not fully address existing customer dissatisfaction issues.

Dear George:
Dear George: In its March 10, 2006, decision, the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB) deferred the approval of a requested increase in expenditures for vegetation management of the distribution system until Nova Scotia Power Inc. (...

AI summary This document is a letter responding to a request from George regarding Liberty's evaluation of a report filed by Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI). The report addresses a 2006 UARB decision that deferred approval for increased vegetation management expenditures on the distribution system. The UARB required NSPI to justify its spending by estimating potential reductions in outage and repair costs. The letter summarizes Liberty's review of NSPI's justifications and cost estimates.

Liberty concluded:
Liberty concluded: - 1. NSPI based its proposed vegetation management program for the distribution system on reasonable assumptions. The well-planned program appears to maximize the benefits to customers for the requested level of spending...

AI summary The Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB) concluded that Nova Scotia Power Industrial's (NSPI) proposed vegetation management program for the distribution system is based on reasonable assumptions. The Board found that the program is well-planned and effectively maximizes customer benefits relative to the requested spending level. However, it noted that while the program is expected to improve system reliability, it may not fully address existing issues regarding customer dissatisfaction.

N-54Direct Testimony - Consumer Advocate Witnesses - Michael J. McGarry and Rudolph C. Krizan 7 passages
11 Q. HAVE YOU TESTIFIED BEFORE?
11 Q. HAVE YOU TESTIFIED BEFORE? 12 A. 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 Yes. I have proffered or supported testimony in New York, Michigan, Illinois, Colorado, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Maine. Recently, I testified in ICC Docket 05-0597, (...

AI summary The witness has testified in multiple jurisdictions including New York, Michigan, Illinois, Colorado, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Maine. They have provided testimony on behalf of various organizations and in cases related to utility regulation, capital investments, and service tariffs.

15 Q. PLEASE EXPLAIN WHY YOU ARE CRITICAL OF A BENCHMARKING STUDY IN THIS CASE.
15 Q. PLEASE EXPLAIN WHY YOU ARE CRITICAL OF A BENCHMARKING STUDY IN THIS CASE. 17 A. In a broad sense, benchmarking can be a worthwhile endeavor. It is normally used to provide utility managers and regulators a general idea as to how a ut...

AI summary The response discusses the limitations and potential pitfalls of a benchmarking study conducted by Accenture for NSPI. It highlights concerns about the proprietary nature of the study, lack of transparency in methodology, and the difficulty of meaningful comparison due to undisclosed benchmarks and analytic methods.

Testimony and Witness Preparation
Testimony and Witness Preparation He has proffered and I or supported expert testimony in a number of proceedings before commissions including New York State Public Service Commission, Illinois Commerce Commission, Michigan Public Service...

AI summary The individual has provided expert testimony in multiple regulatory proceedings, covering topics such as management decision prudence, operations and maintenance expenses, capital investments, and revenue requirements before various commissions.

Before the New York Public Service Commission
Before the New York Public Service Commission • ' .( Case: 96-M-0858 Prudence Investigation into the Scrap Handling Practices in the Western Division of Niagara Mohawk Power Company Commission Staff and Testifying Witness. Litigated procee...

AI summary This document discusses a prudence investigation into the scrap handling practices of Niagara Mohawk Power Company's Western Division, initiated due to allegations of bribery and corruption involving a vendor. The case involved quantifying excessive payments to the vendor and resulted in a settlement with ratepayers receiving bill credits.

Before the New York Public Service Commission
Before the New York Public Service Commission Case: 91-W-0583 Prudence Proceeding Regarding the Operations and Management of Jamaica Water Commission Staff and Testifying Witness. Litigated proceeding as a result of audit to determine exte...

AI summary This prudence proceeding examines excessive costs resulting from management inattention and inappropriate practices in the design, purchase, and installation of a customer information system by Jamaica Water. Commission staff and a testifying witness testified on these issues.

Before the New York Public Service Commission
Before the New York Public Service Commission Case: 92-W-0030 Operational Audit of Jamaica Water Company Operations and Management Commission Staff. Comprehensive management audit of company operations. Responsible for work plan developmen...

AI summary This document outlines an operational audit of Jamaica Water Company conducted by the New York Public Service Commission. The audit covered engineering, contracting, and information technology, and the findings led to a prudence proceeding.

Before the New York Public Service Commission
Before the New York Public Service Commission Case: 98-E-115 Prudence Proceeding to Investigate the Construction Costs Associated with the Homer City Coal Cleaning Plant Commission Staff and Testifying Witness. Litigated proceeding as a re...

AI summary This proceeding involves an investigation into the construction costs of the Homer City Coal Cleaning Plant, which failed to function as designed, leading to excessive charges. The case was settled with customers receiving a $125 million credit.

57960Board Decision 1 passage
3.7 Findings
ettlement Agreement reflect the fact that almost all of the parties, including the CA, have accepted that the rate increases which flow therefrom fairly reflect the cost increases experienced by NSPI. [27) In view of the consent of the CA...

AI summary The Board finds that the Settlement Agreement is reasonable and justifiable, as it reflects accepted cost increases, includes reasonable revenue requirements, and ensures NSPI remains accountable to the Board and the public. The agreement has been accepted by key stakeholders, including the Consumer Advocate and fuel experts.

57960Board Decision 1 passage
3.7 Findings
3.7 Findings [22] The Board has carefully reviewed the terms of the Agreement and the comprehensive evidentiary record consisting of pre-filed testimony and responses to information requests. It has also considered the comments expressed t...

AI summary The Board has reviewed the Settlement Agreement and supporting evidence, considering intervenor comments and the Consumer Advocate's position. While supportive of settlement agreements, the Board emphasizes the need to ensure that approved costs are fair, justifiable, and in the public interest.

86477Submission - Re: Rate Hearing Future Filing Requirements 4 passages
(d) Solid Fuel Procurement Documentation
(d) Solid Fuel Procurement Documentation 6. In considering the breakdown of solid fuel costs for the test period, as well as the prudency of the contracts themselves, Board Staff, Consultants, and Intervenors must be able to examine all in...

AI summary The document discusses the need for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) to provide detailed procurement documentation related to solid fuel contracts, including contracts, forecasts, audits, and internal communications, to ensure the prudency of its fuel procurement decisions during the test period.

(e) Solid Fuel Procurement Personnel
(e) Solid Fuel Procurement Personnel 7. In P-886, SEB IR-9 asked NSPI to provide a chart showing NSPI's solid fuels procurement team, detailing the length of time each member has been involved in fuel procurement either with NSPI or anothe...

AI summary SEB requests NSPI to provide a detailed chart of its solid fuel procurement team, including each member's experience and any changes in management involved in fuel procurement decisions. SEB argues that this information is necessary to assess the prudency of NSPI's decision-making.

(l) Fuel Supply or Tra nsportation Studies Conducted
(l) Fuel Supply or Tra nsportation Studies Conducted 14. In P-886, SEB IR-38 asked NSPI to "provide any fuel supply or transportation studies that have been performed by or on behalf of NSPI since the 2006 Rate Case Application." Liberty I...

AI summary The document discusses a request from SEB and Liberty for NSPI to provide fuel supply or transportation studies since the 2006 Rate Case Application. SEB argues that such studies are essential for evaluating the prudency of NSPI's current fuel transportation arrangements.

SUMMARY OF SEB RECOMMENDATIONS
r (a) the most recent actual year, (b) the current year (actual and projected), (c) the compliance figures, and (d) the forecast year, along the lines of Liberty IR-66 and UARB IR-12 in P- 886. - 5. SEB submits: that NSPI file, at the time...

AI summary SEB requests that NSPI provide detailed information on fuel procurement, including contracts, internal analysis, and management involvement, to assess the prudency of NSPI's decision-making during the test period. This includes filing a 'family tree' of procurement decision-makers and submitting specific documents as outlined in previous regulatory proceedings.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →