Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Rate Smoothing Adjustment" in M06319

Matter: P-886 Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) Rate Application 2007
37 passages 21 documents

Rate Smoothing Adjustment across all matters →

N-1-aNotice of Application and Direct Evidence - NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 59 MB) 3 passages
22 2.2 Responding to the UARB
22 2.2 Responding to the UARB NSPI has worked diligently to be responsive to the Board's fuel directives. The Company has listened to the Board and its customers and is addressing the issues brought forth in recent Rate Decisions. On March...

AI summary NSPI has been working to comply with the UARB's fuel directives, improving its fuel procurement strategy and addressing recommendations from the 2006 Rate Decision. The company has made significant progress, including updating its fuel portfolio strategy and initiating an Integrated Resource Planning process to meet emissions control requirements.

Section 21 Taxes Amortization
Section 21 Taxes Amortization In the 2005 Rate Decision, the UARB approved the deferral of Section 21 taxes and stated: After considerable reflection, the Board finds that amortization of the s.21 taxes should be deferred for two years (20...

AI summary The UARB approved the deferral of Section 21 taxes for two years, followed by an 8-year amortization period starting in 2007. This approach was deemed reasonable for ratepayers and NSPI, ensuring intergenerational equity. NSPI developed an amortization schedule based on the UARB's directive, with $14.5 million amortized in 2007.

Preamble
NSPI continues to control its Operating, Maintenance & General (OM&G) expenses. As a result, all 2007 costs remain unchanged as compared to the 2006 Compliance Filing costs of $197.5 million with the exception of additional pension expense...

AI summary NSPI has maintained its OM&G expenses at similar levels as in 2006, with only slight increases due to higher pension expenses. The Board requested an operations review to identify potential cost savings and efficiencies, and NSPI submitted terms of reference for this review. The review is expected to be completed in 2007.

N-2-aRIRs 1 to 39 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 19 MB) 1 passage
Response IR-2: (cont'd)
Response IR-2: (cont'd) Now that the Board has issued the final tariff structures, and both customers have selected the ELI 2P-RTP, NSPI is able to assess the possible effects. The results of the true-up mechanism will be transacted betwee...

AI summary NSPI discusses the implications of the true-up mechanism following the final tariff structures and customer selection of ELI 2P-RTP. NSPI asserts that rate increases for other customer classes will not be revised due to the true-up, as costs would be deferred and recovered from other customers, depending on discrepancies and customer behavior.

N-2-bRIRs 70 to 75 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 33 MB) 3 passages
RATE MECHANISM:
RATE MECHANISM: The intent of this rate is to create a mechanism enabling customers to gain benefit equal to the benefit created by altering load usage in accordance to hourly pricing signals. The customer will be billed based on a pre-det...

AI summary This rate mechanism allows customers to benefit from adjusting load usage according to hourly pricing signals. Billing is based on a predetermined CBL at the Standard Energy Charge, with credits for energy use below the CBL and additional costs for energy use above the CBL, calculated using the 20-minute ahead marginal cost from NSPI's RTP website.

Marginal Cost (MC)
Marginal Cost (MC) The MC will be the 20-minute ahead forecast of hourly marginal fuel and variable O&M cost in any hour, excluding any impacts of electricity exports, but including imports when they impact marginal costs. The MC forecast...

AI summary The document defines marginal cost (MC) as a 20-minute ahead forecast of hourly fuel and variable O&M costs, excluding electricity exports but including imports when they affect marginal costs. The MC forecast is calculated by NSPI based on in-province load requirements and is used for billing purposes, adjusted by the Decremental Rebate section of the tariff.

Adjustment Clauses
Adjustment Clauses Below is a list of utilities whose rates include adjustment clauses that may cause fluctuations in the price of electricity even though base rates have not been adjusted. Boston Edison, MA Demand-Side Management Charge E...

AI summary The text lists various utilities and their adjustment clauses that can cause electricity price fluctuations. These include charges related to energy efficiency, renewable energy, decommissioning, and tax adjustments across multiple jurisdictions.

N-2-eRIRs 1 to 7 - HRM to NSPI - REDACTED 1 passage
Response IR-7: (cont'd)
Response IR-7: (cont'd) (c) Increases to rate components within each customer class are proposed to be applied uniformly in all classes. - (d) Generation, transmission, distribution, customer and other costs are allocated to customer class...

AI summary The response outlines how rate components are uniformly applied across customer classes, how costs are allocated to classes rather than individual tariff components, and clarifies the assumptions and figures related to lighting costs. It also explains the application of load shapes and the use of the Misc. Small Loads Tariff.

N-2-gRIRs 1 to 25 - Stutz to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 18 MB) 1 passage
Question IR-15: Reference DE, Page 89 and Appendix C
Question IR-15: Reference DE, Page 89 and Appendix C Please explain why the pension expense varies so dramatically over the years 2005 to 2011. Is there any way to levelize or smooth this pension expense stream?

AI summary The Board is requesting an explanation from Nova Scotia Power Inc. regarding the significant fluctuations in pension expenses recorded between 2005 and 2011, as detailed in the Direct Evidence. Additionally, the Board is inquiring whether there are viable methods to levelize or smooth these pension expense streams to provide more stability in the cost structure.

N-7-bRIRs 142 to 143 - SEB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 45 MB) 1 passage
Challenges
Challenges Consistency of returns, largely due to combination of fuel risk and regulatory lag

AI summary The document identifies the consistency of returns as a primary challenge for the utility. This issue is attributed to two main factors: the inherent risks associated with fuel price fluctuations and regulatory lag, which can create a mismatch between the timing of costs incurred and the timing of their recovery through regulated rates.

N-12Evidence filed by John Stutz on behalf of NSUARB 1 passage
Section 32
- 1. The related, "practical" attributes of simplicity, understandability, public acceptability, and feasibility of application. - 2. Freedom from controversies as to proper interpretation. - 3. Effectiveness in yielding total revenue requ...

AI summary The text outlines eight principles for setting public utility rates, emphasizing simplicity, revenue stability, fairness, and efficiency. These principles aim to ensure effective and equitable rate structures that discourage wasteful use while promoting justified service consumption.

N-14Evidence filed by John Antonuk, Donald T. Spangenberg, Jr. and John B. Adger, Jr. (on behalf of NSUARB) (Large File - 26 MB) 3 passages
Q. WHAT WAS YOUR OPINION OF THOSE ARRANGEMENTS?
Q. WHAT WAS YOUR OPINION OF THOSE ARRANGEMENTS? - A. As detailed in our testimony last year, Liberty was troubled by a number of aspects of the early-2004 arrangements. They were not consistent with good utility practice, with the Company'...

AI summary The witness expressed concerns about early-2004 arrangements, stating they were inconsistent with utility practices and the Board's 2002 Rate Case Order. Recommendations included competitive bidding for gas sales, an audit of affiliate transactions, and a study on in-house gas sales functions.

18 Q. HOW WELL DO THESE CHANGES RESPOND TO YOUR PRIOR RECOMMENDATIONS AND TO THE WEAKNESSES UNDERLYING THEM?
18 Q. HOW WELL DO THESE CHANGES RESPOND TO YOUR PRIOR RECOMMENDATIONS AND TO THE WEAKNESSES UNDERLYING THEM? Liberty believes that NSPI's efforts to find an outside candidate have been diligent, and that efforts to develop internal resourc...

AI summary Liberty acknowledges NSPI's efforts in developing internal resources but recommends an aggressive development program for the selected employee, including training and mentorship, while continuing to use an outside consultant. They also suggest considering a senior, retired individual for a mentoring role to address prior recommendations and underlying weaknesses.

Commission-Sponsored Studies
Commission-Sponsored Studies Served as a Lead Consultant in an audit of the fuel and purchased-power procurement practices and costs of Arizona Public Service Company for the Arizona Corporation Commission. Responsible for examining all as...

AI summary The text outlines various consulting roles undertaken by Liberty in audits related to fuel and energy procurement practices for multiple utility companies across different states and regions, including Arizona, Nova Scotia, Ohio, and Kentucky.

N-18Direct Testimony - Nancy Brockway on behalf of the Consumer Advocate REDACTED (Large File - 37 MB) 1 passage
Equitable Gas Company
Equitable Gas Company Equitable Gas (Pennsylvania), an investor-owned gas company, found the same thing with respect to its Energy Affordability Program (EAP). The Equitable Gas evaluation found that there is a net administrative cost to t...

AI summary The Equitable Gas Company's Energy Affordability Program (EAP) initially had administrative costs but yielded savings over time. Participants who stayed in the program for multiple years generated net savings and improved net back ratios, benefiting both participants and non-participants through reduced collection costs and revenue gains.

N-30RIRs 1 to 15 - Nancy Brockway (on behalf of Consumer Advocate) to NS Attorney General (includes attachment to RIR 11) (Large File - 44 MB) 1 passage
b) Reducing Consumption
b) Reducing Consumption EAP attempts to encourage conservation and discourage waste of energy. - c) Increasing Participation in Assistance Programs By increasing customer participation in external assistance programs, the customer and Equi...

AI summary The EAP aims to promote energy conservation and reduce waste. It also seeks to increase participation in assistance programs, which helps customers access financial resources and supports consistent bill payment practices, benefiting both customers and Equitable.

N-40RIRs Attachment SEB-NSPI - 2a, pt. 4 (Large File - 19 MB) 1 passage
Timing
Timing The Company shall file Deferred NPC Adjustment applications on or before February 1st of each year under normal circumstances. The implementation and effective date of the Deferred NPC Adjustment shall be April 1st of each year unde...

AI summary The document outlines the annual filing and implementation timeline for the Deferred Net Power Costs (NPC) Adjustment. Under normal circumstances, the Company is required to file these applications by February 1st each year, with an effective date of April 1st. However, the Company retains the right to file out-of-period Price Comparison and Amortization Mechanism (PCAM) applications to account for extraordinary circumstances.

N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 31 MB) 3 passages
4.2 Ql Fuel Deferral
4.2 Ql Fuel Deferral invalid. Intervenors and Board Consultants have recommended the Board reject the Company's request for deferred recovery of increased fuel costs during the first quarter of 2007. These criticisms fail to recognize the...

AI summary Intervenors and Board Consultants recommend rejecting NSPI's request for deferred recovery of increased fuel costs in Q1 2007, but NSPI argues that legal and regulatory uncertainties, including new legislation, justify the deferral. The company claims that the legislation restricts the Board's ability to approve timely rate increases, preventing recovery of legitimate costs.

Decrementa1 Rebates
4 the 77 percent he could support. 71 Supplemental Testimony of Alan Rosenberg, P-883, August 31 , 2006, page 32, line 15. 72 Hearing Transcript NSUARB-NSPI-P-883 , page 980, Stutz Opening Statement. "Usage eligible for payments for l...

AI summary The document discusses a three-tiered adjustment approach for load decrements, with no adjustment for load increments. Dr. Stutz's support for the 77 percent adjustment was based on a simple average of the tiers, but the actual adjustment factor is approximately 95 percent of marginal cost due to the distribution of eligible energy across tiers.

Incremental Charges
ch year based on forecast costs, and is reconciled after the year is complete through the use of a 13th bill true-up, and this is not considered retroactive rate-making. 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 Dr. Stutz cites the residential class as an e...

AI summary The text discusses the ELI 2P-RTP rate mechanism, highlighting issues with its decremental credit and incremental charge calculations. It notes that the mechanism is designed to under-recover costs and that adjustments are necessary to correct this inequity. Evidence from Dr. Stutz and Alan Rosenberg is cited, along with a consultant's statement regarding the difficulty of accurately determining true costs.

N-54Direct Testimony - Consumer Advocate Witnesses - Michael J. McGarry and Rudolph C. Krizan 2 passages
Q. WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS WITH THIS AUDIT AND THE BENEFITS DERIVED FROM THE RESULTS?
Q. WHAT ARE YOUR CONCERNS WITH THIS AUDIT AND THE BENEFITS DERIVED FROM THE RESULTS? The Report fails to help identify those areas where cost-savings can be established and obtained for the benefit of not only ratepayers but the Company as...

AI summary The report is criticized for not providing quantifiable recommendations or specific implementation plans for cost-savings and operational efficiencies. The UARB and NSPI were aware of the limitations of benchmarking and emphasized the need for a comprehensive audit beyond benchmarking to identify areas for improvement and savings.

Before the New York Public Service Commission
Before the New York Public Service Commission 20 2 Case: 87003 Operational Audit of the Homer City Coal Cleaning Plant Commission Staff. Comprehensive operational audit to determine effectiveness of ratepayer funds spent on the constructio...

AI summary This document outlines a comprehensive operational audit of the Homer City Coal Cleaning Plant, jointly owned by NYSEG and Penelec, conducted by Commission Staff to assess the effectiveness of ratepayer funds spent on its construction and evaluate costs, alternatives, and contracting practices.

57960Board Decision 1 passage
MINUTES OF SETTLEMENT
MINUTES OF SETTLEMENT WHEREAS the Applicant, Nova Scotia Power Inc. ("NSPI"), the undersigned Intervenors (Avon Valley et al, the Consumer Advocate, the Halifax Regional Municipality, and the Municipal Electric Utilities Co-operative of No...

AI summary The document outlines a settlement agreement regarding NSPI's 2007 revenue requirement, fuel expenses, and the adoption of a Fuel Adjustment Mechanism (FAM). It also addresses deferrals, rate adjustments, and the continuation of certain regulatory studies.

57968Amended Board Order (and attached Schedules A to C) 3 passages
RATE MECHANISM:
RATE MECHANISM: The intent of this rate is to create a mechanism enabling customers to gain benefit equal to the benefit created by altering load usage in accordance to hourly pricing signals. The customer will be billed based on a pre-det...

AI summary This rate mechanism aims to align customer load usage with hourly pricing signals. Customers are billed based on a predetermined CBL, with credits for energy use below and charges for energy use above this baseline, calculated using 20-minute ahead marginal costs from NSPI's RTP website.

Bill Calculation:
Bill Calculation: At the end of each month: Total Bill = CBLbc + Incremental Charges- Decremental Rebates - Incremental Export Benefit Credit Applicable Energy Charges, rebates, penalties, and adjustments will be calculated by the Company...

AI summary The document outlines the formula for calculating a customer's total monthly bill, which includes components such as the customer's baseline load cost, incremental charges, decremental rebates, and incremental export benefit credits. These calculations are determined by the Company and reflected on the customer's bill.

Modification of Existing CBL
Modification of Existing CBL If an existing ELI 2P-RTP customer undertakes significant physical plant modification, (as signified by a specific capital expenditure above and beyond normal annual capital spending) or other material change (...

AI summary The document outlines procedures for modifying the Customer Baseline Load (CBL) for ELI 2P-RTP customers under specific conditions, such as significant capital expenditures or load reductions. Disagreements between the customer and NSPI will be referred to the UARB for adjudication.

57960Board Decision 1 passage
3.7 Findings
ss-examination of witnesses in an environment which can often be aggressive and adversarial; and, except when confidential information is being discussed, the proceeding is open to the general public. [32] While approval of this Settlement...

AI summary The approval of the Settlement Agreement sets NSPI's fuel costs for 2007 but does not eliminate the need for NSPI to justify its fuel procurement policies to the Board. The Board will consider a Fuel Adjustment Mechanism (FAM) in a separate proceeding. Intervenors retain the ability to challenge NSPI's FAM proposal and other issues, with these matters being addressed outside the context of a general rate case.

57974NSPI Compliance Filing 2007 Rate Application - REDACTED (Large File - 36 MB) 5 passages
MINUTES OF SETTLEMENT
n on rate base, return on equity, OM&G, regulatory amortizations and income taxes. - 9. NSPI's request for a true-up for the 2P-RTP is deferred to the December 1 annual review of the ELI 2P-RTP rate. - 10. The UARB directive from the 2006...

AI summary The minutes outline deferred requests and adopted methodologies related to rate base, return on equity, OM&G, and regulatory amortizations. NSPI's true-up request is deferred, and the UARB's 2006 directive regarding OM&G is not considered completed. The Revenue to Cost ratio methodology is adopted with modifications for the unmetered rate class.

Section 28
- 6. Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral offrrst quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Application...

AI summary The document outlines agreements and decisions made in a regulatory proceeding involving NSPI, including the application of excess earnings, withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, and the adoption of a revenue-to-cost ratio methodology. It also addresses ongoing obligations related to OM&G studies and future regulatory positions.

FOR THE YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 2007
FOR THE YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 2007 (1) TOTAL (2) (3) SMALL (4) (5) GENERAL (6) SMALL (7) MEDIUM (8) LARGE (9) EXTRA LI (10) (11) (12) ALLOCATION COMPANY DOMESTIC GENERAL GENERAL LARGE INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL INTERR 2 MUNICIPAL...

AI summary The document presents a table with various metrics related to demand, responsibility percentages, and energy generation and purchase figures for different categories, including small, general, and large industrial sectors, as well as municipal and unmetered entities, for the year ending December 31, 2007.

RATE MECHANISM:
RATE MECHANISM: The intent of this rate is to create a mechanism enabling customers to gain benefit equal to the benefit created by altering load usage in accordance to hourly pricing signals. The customer will be billed based on a pre-det...

AI summary This rate mechanism aims to align customer benefits with load adjustments based on hourly pricing signals. Customers are billed based on a predetermined CBL, with credits for energy use below and costs for energy use above this baseline, calculated using 20-minute ahead marginal costs from NSPI's RTP website.

Modification of Existing CBL
Modification of Existing CBL If an existing ELI 2P-RTP customer undertakes significant physical plant modification, (as signified by a specific capital expenditure above and beyond normal annual capital spending) or other material change (...

AI summary The document outlines procedures for modifying the Customer Baseline (CBL) for ELI 2P-RTP customers under specific conditions, such as significant capital expenditures or load reductions. If the customer and Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) cannot reach an agreement, the matter will be referred to the Utility Arbitration Board (UARB) for resolution.

58003Participant responses to Preliminary Issues List for P-886 2 passages
General
General NSPI supports the schedule put forth by the Board, and notes that it can be achieved through a focus on the material issues which have caused this application to be filed and which affect the 2007 test year. A focused Issues List w...

AI summary NSPI supports the Board's proposed schedule and suggests narrowing the issues list to avoid duplication of recent reviews. It highlights that many operational aspects have already been or will be reviewed, such as fuel-related directives, affiliate audits, and demand-side management plans.

General
General NSPI supports the schedule put forth by the Board, and notes that it can be achieved through a focus on the material issues which have caused this application to be filed and which affect the 2007 test year. A focused Issues List w...

AI summary NSPI supports the Board's proposed schedule and suggests narrowing the issues list to avoid duplication of recent reviews. The Company highlights ongoing and completed reviews by the Board and third-party consultants, such as Liberty and Accenture, and notes that many aspects of its operations have already been addressed.

58137Submission - Consumer Advocate (CA) - Re: Compliance filing process 1 passage
Section 1
MERRICK JAMIESON STERNS WASHINGTON & MAHODY BARRISTERS John P. Merrick, Q.C. Direct Line: (902) 429-3178 [email protected] February 14, 2007 VIA COURIER 23439 ' Ms. Nancy McNeil Regulatory Affairs Officer/Clerk Nova Scotia Utility and Rev...

AI summary The Consumer Advocate raises concerns about the transparency and impact of the compliance filing process in the NSPI 2007 Rate Application. They argue that the process can alter expected rate increases and lacks transparency, leading to confusion and skepticism among consumers.

58244Comments on Preliminary Issues List - NSPI 1 passage
General
advance of the rate hearings. Meanwhile, the Company has committed to hold OM&G expenses constant in the 2007 test year. NSPI suggests the Board clarify in the final Issues List, should the Board have further questions, which specific aspe...

AI summary NSPI requests the Board to clarify which aspects of fuel and OM&G expenses are subject to review and focus the review on the 2007 test year. They argue that a focused review will make the application more efficient and effective, avoiding redundant reviews in other proceedings.

86477Submission - Re: Rate Hearing Future Filing Requirements 1 passage
Re: Rate Hearing Future Filing Requirements: Board File P-886.2
Re: Rate Hearing Future Filing Requirements: Board File P-886.2 Please find attached the Submission of Stora Enso Port Hawkesbury Limited and Bowater Mersey Paper Company Limited ("SEB") with respect to the above noted matter. Although the...

AI summary Stora Enso Port Hawkesbury Limited and Bowater Mersey Paper Company Limited (SEB) submit comments on future rate case filing requirements, emphasizing the need for transparency, electronic formatting of documents, and the provision of complete work papers and calculations. They reference the Board's 2007 Rate Case Order and highlight concerns with NSPI's reluctance to provide electronic versions of the Cost of Service model.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →