N-30RIRs 1 to 15 - Nancy Brockway (on behalf of Consumer Advocate) to NS Attorney General (includes attachment to RIR 11) (Large File - 44 MB)
27 passages
4. Sample Selection As is usual for practical studies of this type, in order to insure representative results, systematic random samples were drawn. Each sample consists of every "n th " case in its respective population. The groups includ...
AI summary The document describes the sample selection process for a study involving EAP participants and non-participants. Systematic random sampling was used, with every nth account selected from each group to ensure representative results.
5. Data CleaningJ As always occurs once the planned samples are generated, a closer look at the data required some reassignment of accounts between groups to ensure that each case met the correct definition for its group. This included mov...
AI summary The data cleaning process involved reassigning accounts between groups to ensure correct group definitions, removing duplicates, and handling missing data. Group 1 accounts with EAP in the pre-period were moved to Group 3, and Group 2 accounts missing pre-period data were dropped. Final group numbers are reported in Table 11-1, column 4.
E. Data Equitable conducted the random selection, and provided data for all accounts. Data was provided for 12 baseline months and 12 participation period months. Data included the account number, income information, poverty level data, co...
AI summary Equitable provided comprehensive data for the proceeding, including account details, income information, consumption data, billing information, and transaction costs for both pre and post periods. Summary data included service transactions, complaints, and arrearage aging.
1. Budget Plus Plan - Company Negotiated Payment Plan Budget Plus plan negotiated with the customer by an Equitable representative over the phone, or in person. This is an average monthly bill based on the past annual consumption, plus an...
AI summary The Budget Plus Plan is a payment arrangement offered by Equitable and Payco American Corporation, allowing customers to pay their energy bills in installments based on past consumption and income information. The plan includes an average monthly payment plus a portion of the arrearage.
G. Movement Among Options As shown in Figure 11-2, customers may succeed in restoring full payments through either the traditional approaches (discussed above), or through EAP (which offers a lower price - based on a percentage of income,...
AI summary The text discusses the movement of customers between traditional payment approaches and the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). EAP is designed for those who fail with traditional methods and offers a lower, income-based payment plan. The goal is to stabilize payment behavior and reduce the number of customers who pay only about 50% of their billed amount.
3. The Need for EAP, or Something Like It For both customers and the utilities which serve them, the structural sources of this problem are largely outside the control of those affected and concerned. 11 a) Major Shift in the Job Structure...
AI summary The text discusses the structural economic and demographic challenges that make an Energy Affordability Program (EAP) necessary. It highlights shifts in job structures, declining high-paying jobs, and the impact on employment, as well as the aging population in Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania, which increases the need for programs like EAP to support vulnerable groups.
a) Improving the Bottom-Line Prior to EAP, Equitable found 8,700 payment troubled low-income customers for whom the traditional credit and collection approaches were not working. Although they were placed on budget plus plans, on average t...
AI summary Prior to the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), Equitable struggled with collecting payments from 8,700 low-income customers, recovering only 50% of billed amounts. EAP is proposed as a solution to help these customers make regular, smaller payments, improving both their economic situation and the recovery rate for Equitable.
23The utility, societal, non-participant, and participant interests have to be carefully balanced for a successful program. Note that this section of the study is limited to consideration of payment behavior. For cost/benefit, see Section...
AI summary The text discusses the balance of interests in a program, focusing on payment behavior within the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). It provides data on participation rates for new and ongoing EAP groups over two years, highlighting statistical calculations and considerations for re-enrollment.
b) Retention by Poverty Level The question of retention by poverty level brings the analysis of customer payment behavior to a more detailed level. At root, the concern in this sub-analysis is whether or not the program is functioning less...
AI summary This section examines customer payment behavior by poverty level, focusing on whether the Energy Affordability Program functions less effectively for those at lower poverty levels. The analysis uses poverty levels defined by the program (0-50%, 51-100%, and 101-150% of the federal Low Income Cut-Off). Table IV-2 provides a cross-tabulation of program retention by poverty level.
Table IV-4: Covering the Variable Cost of Gas CUSTOMER PAYMENT & THE VARIABLE COST OF GAS Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Column 6 Paid by Customer Year Prior to EAP (Group 1) NoEAP pre-period At least some Participation in EA...
AI summary Table IV-4 examines the impact of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) on customer payments and variable gas costs across different groups. It shows that customers who participated in EAP paid significantly less compared to those who did not, with percentages indicating the ratio of paid amounts to variable costs.
Table IV-5: Is Payment Frequency Reliable? FREQUENCY OF PAYMENT (OUT OF 12 POSSIBLE) BY CUSTOMER Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Column 6 Paid by Customer Baseline Not in EAP (Group 1) At least some Participation in EAP (Group...
AI summary Table IV-5 examines the reliability of payment frequency among customers, comparing groups based on their participation in the Energy Affordability Program (EAP). It presents statistics on full, partial, and missed payments across different customer groups, highlighting variations in payment behavior.
31 See Hill, Lawrence J. & Marilyn A Brown, "Estimating the Cost-Effectiveness of Coordinated DSM Programs," Evaluation Review, Vol. 19, No. 2, April 1995, Pp. 181-196. BY CUSTOMER Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Column 6 Year...
AI summary The table presents data on energy affordability program participation and associated costs, comparing different customer groups across various time periods, including baseline years and participation years. It includes metrics for seniors, others, and different poverty levels, with a focus on energy affordability and the impact of programs like LIHEAP and CRISIS.
A. Customer Groups in the Study Two 12-month time periods and three groups (two participant groups and one non-participant group) are compared in this study. 32 The baseline year is defined as the 12 months from October 1 992 through Septe...
AI summary The study compares two 12-month time periods and three customer groups, including two participant groups and one non-participant group. The baseline year is from October 1, 1992, to September 1, 1993, while the EAP participation year is from April 1, 1994, to March 31, 1995.
(Company Monthly Control Report) Month N Average Nonnalized Annual Usage July 6110 182.1 August 6170 182.0 September 6256 181 .7 October 6355 181 .9 November 6414 181.4 December 6440 182.0 1994 January 6415 181.0 February 6621 179.8 March...
AI summary The document presents a table showing monthly energy usage data and a summary of the accounting analysis of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), highlighting changes in energy consumption for participants and non-participants.
- 1. Direction: The direction of the change for each group is toward decreasing energy use. - 2. Size of gross change: For each group the size of the change in energy use relative to the group's respective baseline is very small (reduction...
AI summary The energy use changes for EAP Participant groups are directed toward decreasing energy use, with reductions of 1.2% to 2.5% relative to their baselines. The net change in energy consumption is negligible, showing an increase of 0.4% to 0.6% relative to each group's baseline when compared to the Comparison Group.
Table Vl-5: Gross Change in Energy Use GROSS CHANGE (MCF) Individual Case Analysis Col. 1 Col. 2 Col. 3 (MCF) Col.4 (MCF) Col. 5 (MCF) Col. 6 (%) Group n Mean (Baseline Year) Mean (Participation Year) Average Gross Change Percentage Gross...
AI summary Table Vl-5 presents the gross change in energy use for different groups, including ONGOING EAP, NEW EAP, Non-Participant, and Management Control Statistics. The data shows a slight decrease in energy use for all groups, with the largest percentage change observed in the Non-Participant group.
NET CHANGE (MCF) Individual Case Analysis Col. 1 Col. 2 Col. 3 Col.4 (MCF) (MCF) (%) Group Gross Net Net Change Change Change ONGOING EAP (n=212) (2.93) (1 .15) 0.66% Management Control (4.0) 0.0 0.0% Statistics\ (n=6144) NEW EAP (n=111) (...
AI summary The document presents a net change analysis (MCF) for the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), comparing ongoing and new EAP participants with management control and non-participant groups. The data shows a net change in MCF for each group, with percentages indicating relative changes.
ISTATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Gross Change from Baseline Year to Participation Year Group Average Gross Change (MCF) Standard Deviation (MCF) Standard Error (MCF) t-value Degrees of freedom Alpha (1-tailed) ONGOING EAP (2.93) 21.80 1.50 (1 .9...
AI summary This table presents statistical analysis of the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), comparing average gross changes in different groups. It includes metrics such as standard deviation, t-values, and alpha levels, with the EAP and non-participant groups showing statistically significant differences in some cases.
b) Breakout of Results by Sub-group The remainder of the statistical analysis develops particular breakouts of the EAP participants and of the comparison group: by poverty level, by high consumption, and by proportion of seniors.
AI summary The statistical analysis breaks down results by sub-groups, including poverty level, high consumption, and proportion of seniors, focusing on EAP participants and a comparison group.
In Table Vl-10, the two participant groups and the comparison group are compared across poverty levels, with percentage changes rounded to the PERCENTAGE OF CUSTOMERS BY POVERTY LEVEL6o (within Group) Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 (1...
AI summary The table compares energy consumption across different poverty levels for participants in the Energy Affordability Program (EAP) and a comparison group. It shows the number of customers, baseline and post-period consumption in MCF, and percentage changes, highlighting variations in energy use by poverty level.
(2) High Consumption Customers If "high usage" is defined as use of 200 MCF or more annually, the percentage of high consumption customers ranges from 11% in the Table Vl-11: High Consumption Customers comparison group to 16% in the NEW EA...
AI summary The text discusses the definition of 'high usage' as 200 MCF or more annually and notes the percentage of high consumption customers in different groups, ranging from 11% to 24%. It highlights that the allocation of weatherization resources aligns with the consumption patterns of these groups.
(in both Pre & Post Periods) HIGH CONSUMPTION CUSTOMERS NEWEAP COMPARISON ONGOING EAP mers 18 21 50 umption (16%) (11%) (24%) ding 4 3 20 (22%) (14%) (40%) 61The calculation includes customers who were high users in both the baseline year...
AI summary The table compares the number and percentage of high consumption customers under the New EAP, Comparison, and Ongoing EAP programs. The data indicates a significant increase in the number of high consumption customers in the Ongoing EAP compared to the other programs.
Table Vl-12: Seniors goods and services. As shown in Table Vl-12, the percentage of seniors in the two participant groups is more than double the percentage in the comparison group. SENIORS62 (Persons aged 60 and above) NEWEAP COMPARISON G...
AI summary Table Vl-12 shows that the percentage of seniors in the NEWEAP and ONGOING EAP participant groups is more than double that in the comparison group, indicating a significant representation of seniors in these energy affordability programs.
A. Method & Results Summary figures for arrearage were calculated using the beginning balance at the onset of the Baseline and Participation Years, and the balances at the end of the Baseline and Participation Years. The amount of arrearag...
AI summary Summary figures for arrearage were calculated using balances at the start and end of the Baseline and Participation Years. Table Vlll-1 shows arrearage amounts in March of the Baseline Year and at the end of the Participation Year (March '95), providing insight into the range of arrearage by group at the end of the heating season.
ARREARAGE AMOUNT PER CUSTOMER Column 1 Col. 2 Col. 3 Col.4 n March '93 March '95 All New EAP Customers (Group 1) 221 819.47 1042.94 At least some Participation in EAP (Group 1: Less than 12 months in EAP) 68 1157.52 2008.93 Stable Full Yea...
AI summary The table shows the average arrears per customer in different EAP groups over time, with a strong seasonal pattern where arrears increase in winter, peak in spring, and decline through fall until the service termination moratorium begins.
2. Benefits In introducing a discussion of program benefits, it should be noted that it has been shown that the program meets the economic criterion for benefit to the non-participant customers. 79 Also, as discussed earlier, EAP meets the...
AI summary The Energy Affordability Program (EAP) benefits non-participant customers by meeting economic criteria and societal expectations, including providing energy services to low-income customers and ensuring payment. It also benefits stable participant customers by offering affordable energy services and requiring regular payments. From the utility's perspective, the program provides benefits through realized program payments, including customer payments and receipt of grants.
Table XI-1: Profiles of the Study Groups NEW EAP (GROUP 1) 12 months EAP post period Less than 12 months EAP post ORIGINAL STUDY SET All cases Seniors (60+) Non-seniors postpolicu period Total number of cases 221 73 148 153 68 Number of se...
AI summary Table XI-1 presents profiles of study groups related to the Energy Affordability Program (EAP), including demographic and income data for different groups such as seniors, non-seniors, and those in various poverty levels. It compares pre- and post-EAP periods and includes statistics on LIHEAP and CRISIS program participation.