N-1-aNotice of Application and Direct Evidence - NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 59 MB)
17 passages
Updated Return on Asset Assumption 1 2 3 4 5 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 In its pre-filed evidence in the 2006 Rate Decision, PricewaterhouseCoopers noted that the return on asset assumption and the di...
AI summary The document discusses NSPI's revised return on asset assumption from 7.5% to 7.25%, based on industry trends and actuarial analysis. It notes the impact of this change on pension expenses and the OM&G revenue requirement for 2007, citing PricewaterhouseCoopers' 2006 Rate Decision and Morneau Sobeco's actuarial findings.
5.0 CAPITAL STRUCTURE AND FINANCING 2 3 5.1 Overview 4 5 6 7 8 1 On June 21, 2006 Standard & Poor's (S&P) downgraded NSPI's credit rating from BBB+ to BBB. As a result of this action, NSPI has the lowest credit rating of any regulated elec...
AI summary This section discusses the downgrade of Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) credit rating by Standard & Poor's in 2006 and its implications for the company's financial position and customers. The downgrade highlights concerns over NSPI's cash flow and fuel risk, and the potential long-term cost implications for customers. The Board acknowledges the importance of maintaining a financially strong utility to ensure access to capital and provide reliable service.
5.3 Return on Equity: Compensation for the Equity Investor 19 20 21 22 18 The return on equity earned by the Company is the compensation provided to the equity investor over the long-term. The return that can be earned by investors is asse...
AI summary The document discusses the return on equity (ROE) for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), noting that due to its higher business risks, investors expect a higher return compared to other utilities. However, NSPI's current ROE does not reflect this higher risk, and the document highlights the impact of increased foreign competition on Canadian utilities' access to capital.
n behalf of numerous corporations and legal 15 firms in matters of financial management and corporate litigation. 17 I have been a cost of capital witness before numerous federal, provincial, and 16 18 state regulatory boards in both Canad...
AI summary The witness has extensive experience as a cost of capital expert before regulatory boards in Canada and the U.S., including the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board. They have also worked as a consultant for regulators, such as the CRTC and OTSC, on regulatory finance and cost of capital methodologies.
9 Purpose Of Memorandum 10 11 As part of its Application for 2007 rates, Nova Scotia Power Inc. ("NSPI", the 12 "Company") is requesting to retain the 9.55 percent return on equity ("ROE") 13 and the 37.5 percent common equity ratio author...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. is requesting to retain its 9.55% return on equity and 37.5% common equity ratio, previously authorized by the UARB in 2005. An expert opinion is sought on the fairness and reasonableness of this proposal under current and future capital market conditions.
19 Summary 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1) My assessment of NSPI's investment risk relative to other Canadian utilities is that business risk is above average, regulatory risk has increased slightly and lies slightly above that of other util...
AI summary The assessment concludes that NSPI's investment risk is above average due to higher business and regulatory risks. A higher allowed ROE and stronger balance sheet are required to offset these risks. The current deemed capital structure of 37.5% common equity is considered too low, and a 40-45% ratio is recommended. A fair ROE for NSPI is suggested to be in the range of 9.6% to reflect its higher risk profile.
1 Approach 2 13 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3 On March 2005, the Board authorized a ROE of 9.55 percent, with a range of 4 9.3 percent - 9.8 percent, and a deemed common equity ratio of 37.5 percent. 5 This decision was...
AI summary The document discusses the determination of a fair rate of return on common equity (ROE) for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) based on changes in capital market conditions, investment risk, and availability of comparable investment alternatives since the 2005 Board decision.
I. NSPI's Investment Risk It is convenient to disaggregate NSPI's risk into three broad components: business risk, regulatory risk, and financial risk. Business risk refers to the relative variability of operating profits induced by the ex...
AI summary NSPI's investment risk is analyzed by breaking it into business, regulatory, and financial components. NSPI has above-average business and regulatory risks and average financial risks compared to other Canadian energy utilities. Its unique status as a vertically integrated utility and lack of a fuel adjustment clause contribute to its higher perceived risk, suggesting its allowed ROE and common equity ratio should be higher than peers.
1.2 Regulatory Risk 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 An important component of risk for utilities is "regulatory risk". On these grounds, regulatory treatment by the Board has been perceived...
AI summary The text discusses regulatory risk for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), emphasizing the absence of a fuel adjustment clause (FAC) and its impact on credit ratings, cost of capital, and customer rates. It highlights how regulatory lag and the lack of a FAC make NSPI's financial situation more vulnerable compared to other utilities.
1.3 Financial Risk Financial risk stems from the method used by the firm to finance its investments and is reflected in its capital structure. The greater the percentage of fixed charges to the total income of the company, the greater the...
AI summary The document discusses NSPI's financial risk, emphasizing its weak balance sheet, high business risk, and lower bond ratings compared to Canadian utilities. It highlights the importance of maintaining current financial measures and capital structure to avoid further downgrades and urges the Board to act prudently to ensure financial stability.
II. Capital Structure 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 In order to establish the reasonableness of the Company's requested deemed capital structure consisting of 37.5 percent common equ...
AI summary The document discusses the evaluation of Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s requested deemed capital structure of 37.5 percent common equity. It examines imputed ratios by regulators, actual capital structures of Canadian and U.S. energy utilities, and bond rating agency benchmarks to determine the reasonableness of the proposed structure.
19 20 If we focus on those electric utilities that are most comparable to NSPI, namely, Fortis BC, Newfoundland Power, Maritime Electric, the average equity ratio is 41.5 percent, again higher than NSPI's. 1 2 9 17 18 15 16 20 21 19 22 23...
AI summary The document compares NSPI's equity ratio to that of other Canadian and U.S. utilities, highlighting that NSPI's deemed common equity ratio of 37.5% is lower than industry benchmarks and does not reflect its higher business risk. It also references industry standards and ratings from S&P and DBRS.
Ill. FAIR RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY According to the seminal risk premium principle, a fair and reasonable ROE is seen as the sum of the risk-free rate and a risk premium: Return = Risk-free Rate + Risk Premium
AI summary The text discusses the calculation of a fair return on common equity (ROE) using the risk premium principle, where ROE is determined by adding a risk-free rate to a risk premium.
1 Risk-Free Rate To assess whether NSPI's currently allowed ROE of 9.55 percent is reasonable, I examined the behaviour of both of these components since the Board issued its Decision in March 200578 • I also examined the currently allowed...
AI summary The analysis evaluates whether NSPI's allowed ROE of 9.55% is reasonable by comparing interest rates from 2005 and current projections. The risk-free rate has slightly increased, suggesting the allowed ROE should not be lowered and may even be raised slightly.
2 Risk Premium 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 With regard to the risk premium component of ROE, I compared my risk premium estimates presented to the Board in 2004 with current estimates. I found very little change. The table be...
AI summary The text discusses the risk premium component of Return on Equity (ROE), comparing risk premium estimates from 2004 with current estimates, noting very little change. A table is referenced comparing results from various cost of capital studies applied to Canadian and U.S. energy utilities.
Relevance of International Comparisons 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 2 1 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Consideration of the U.S. and world market results is certainly justified, and even more so since the Board's last ROE...
AI summary The document discusses the increasing integration of Canadian and U.S. capital markets, emphasizing that U.S. data are relevant for Canadian regulators. It highlights that allowed returns on equity (ROE) for U.S. utilities are higher than those in Canada, suggesting that Canadian utilities may need to reconsider their allowed ROE and equity ratios in light of these international benchmarks.
8.0 COST OF SERVICE 2 3 1 8.1 Overview 4 5 6 7 8 9 In the development of new rates, revenue-to-cost ratios are an important consideration. These are determined using NSPI's Cost of Service Study (COSS) which the Company has prepared for th...
AI summary The document discusses updates to NSPI's Cost of Service Study (COSS) in response to UARB directives, including methodology changes, the development of a replacement rate for ELIIR, adjustments to cost bases for Additional Energy and Unrnetered classes, and updates to street light rates and their components.
N-1-aAppendix D - Credit Rating Reports (Large File - 12 MB)
4 passages
a moderate financial profile, absence of a timely fuel cost recovery mechanism for NSPI, some exposure to higher risk activities such as energy trading, and a strategy for growth through acquisition. Emera is a utility holding company base...
AI summary The text outlines the financial profile of Emera, a utility holding company, noting its reliance on regulated cash flows from Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and Bangor Hydro-Electric Co. (BHEC). NSPI provides monopoly electricity services in Nova Scotia, while BHEC provides transmission and distribution in Maine. The document highlights the regulatory framework supporting these entities, including specific return on equity (ROE) targets and equity layer limits, while also noting risks such as energy trading and the lack of a timely fuel cost recovery mechanism for NSPI.
ial for significant improvement in NSPI's credit metrics over the course of the next two to three years and/or a reduction in NSPI's risk exposure to volatile fossil fuel costs, a downgrade is likely. A notable rating event since the last...
AI summary The text discusses credit rating trends and risks within the Canadian utility sector, specifically focusing on Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and other regional utilities. It highlights the assignment of recovery ratings for first mortgage bonds by Standard & Poor's and identifies key factors influencing credit quality, such as volatile fossil fuel costs and the financial impact of allowed return on equity (ROE) declines. Additionally, it notes upcoming risks related to smart meter implementation and major infrastructure project financing.
Declining regulatory ROEs The annual automatic adjustments to allowed ROE embedded in the frameworks of a number of Canadian regulatory regimes have led to lower ROEs for many utilities. Although the adjustment mechanisms provide transpare...
AI summary The text discusses the impact of declining regulatory returns on equity (ROE) on the credit quality of Canadian utilities. While automatic ROE adjustments provide predictability, a significant reduction in allowed ROEs—particularly below 9%—can diminish cash flow available for debt service, especially for utilities with high debt costs or those using deferral accounts. However, the text notes that the return of capital through depreciation often has a more significant impact on credit metrics like FFO than ROE. It also highlights that bond rate volatility and the timing of ROE settings remain key risks.
Issuer Review issuel IV South Neview BBB+/Stable/ Martin Laurie Conheady Laurie increase of approximately 3% effective May 1, 2006. The LDC will have to respond to written interrogatories but there will not be an oral hearing; a decision b...
AI summary The document provides an issuer review of several utilities, focusing on credit ratings, financial health, and project progress. It notes that Maritime Electric's rating reflects its parent company, Fortis Inc., and mentions the construction of a 50-MW combustion turbine facility in Charlottetown. For LHI, the review discusses its equity layer, a 2005 regulatory decision regarding the recoverability of deferred regulatory assets, and its funds from operations (FFO) interest coverage. It also notes the credit ratings for Newfoundland Power.
N-1-aAppendix E - Dr. Roger A. Morin Exhibits
3 passages
o/o Deemed Common Equity Ratios Canadian Gas & Electric Utilities Common Equity Ratio Electric Utilities Alta Link 35.0% ATCO Electric Transmission 33.0% ATCO Electric Distribution 37.0% ENMAX Distribution 39.0% EPCOR Transmission 35.0% EP...
AI summary The document provides a comparative table of Deemed Common Equity Ratios for various Canadian gas and electric utilities. It categorizes the data into three sectors: Electric Utilities, Gas Distributors, and Gas Pipelines. The data shows that electric utilities have an average common equity ratio of 38.0%, gas distributors average 36.6%, and gas pipelines average 33.3%, with a grand average across all categories of 36.3%.
Canadian Electric Utilities Equity Ratios 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 Average 1999-2004 Integrated Publicly-Owned B.C. Hydro 17.8% 21.4% 19.0% 19.2% 20.0% 19.5% Hydro-Quebec 25.3% 25.2% 26.5% 30.3% 33.0% 28.1% Manitoba Hydro 14.7% 17.1% 15.4%...
AI summary The document provides a comparative data table of equity ratios for various Canadian electric utilities between the years 2000 and 2004. It categorizes utilities into Integrated Publicly-Owned, Integrated Investor-Owned, Transmission & Distribution, and Holding Companies (Consolidated). The data includes specific figures for entities such as Nova Scotia Power, Hydro-Quebec, and Fortis Inc., alongside calculated averages for each category and an overall industry average.
VERTICALLY INTEGRATED ELECTRIC UTILITIES COMMON EQUITY RATIOS Company Industry %Common Equity 1 ALLETE UTILCENT 60.9 2 Alliant Energy UTILCENT 50.2 3 Ameren Corp. UTILCENT 52.6 4 Amer. Elec. Power UTILCENT 44.9 5 Cen. Vermont Pub. Serv. UT...
AI summary The document provides a comparative table of common equity ratios for various vertically integrated electric utilities across different regions (Central, Least, and West). The data, sourced from the Value Line Investment Analyzer (April 2006), illustrates the capital structure of 27 different utility companies, with ratios ranging from approximately 24.9% to 62.6%.
N-2-bRIRs 77 to 84 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 35 MB)
3 passages
1. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES Nova Scotia Power ("NSPI") is the primary electricity supplier in Nova Scotia providing over 95% of electricity generation, transmission and distribution in the province. NSPI is a public utili...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power (NSPI) is the primary electricity supplier in Nova Scotia, providing over 95% of the province's electricity generation, transmission, and distribution. As a public utility regulated by the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (NSUARB) under the Public Utilities Act, NSPI operates under a cost-of-service model. This model ensures rates cover prudently incurred costs while providing an appropriate return on equity (ROE) to investors, with the current allowed ROE range set between 9.3% and 9.8%.
2005 Nova Scotia Power Inc. Management's Discussion & Analysis Management's Discussion and Analysis ("MD&A") provides a review of the results of operations of Nova Scotia Power Inc. ("Nova Scotia Power" or "NSPI") during the fourth quarter...
AI summary This section introduces the 2005 Management's Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), outlining the financial results for 2005 compared to previous years. It highlights that NSPI is a vertically integrated, regulated electric utility serving 470,000 customers. The text emphasizes that NSPI's accounting policies are subject to UARB approval and may differ from GAAP. It also establishes NSPI's status as a cost-of-service utility, where rates are designed to recover prudently incurred costs and provide a prescribed return on equity.
Overview NSPI is the primary electricity supplier in Nova Scotia, providing over 95% of the electricity generation, transmission and distribution in the province. The company owns 2,293 megawatts ("MW") of generating capacity. Approximatel...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Incorporated (NSPI) is the province's primary electricity supplier, providing over 95% of its generation, transmission, and distribution. The company's capacity is comprised of coal, oil, natural gas, hydro, and wind. As a regulated public utility under the Public Utilities Act (Nova Scotia), NSPI's operations and rates are overseen by the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB). NSPI operates under a cost-of-service model where rates are set to cover prudently incurred costs and provide a regulated return on equity (ROE).
N-2-bRIR 76 - NSUARB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 46 MB)
7 passages
am of testing new coal blends, and have invested in a new marine term inal. These efforts will both reduce costs and provide the utility with access to competitive coal supply basins around the globe. In response to our regulator's 2005 de...
AI summary The text discusses Nova Scotia Power's (NSPI) efforts to improve fuel procurement practices, including testing new coal blends and securing a new marine terminal to access competitive global supply basins. It highlights a successful renegotiation of a natural gas supply contract that added $15 million to 2005 net earnings. The author notes that the Utility and Rate Advisory Board (UARB) has recognized these improvements in its 2006 rate decision, which is expected to help the utility achieve its target return on common equity.
- Nova Scotia Power Inc. ("NSPI") is an electricity generation, transmission and distribution company, provid ing service to the vast majority of the province of Nova Scotia. NSPI has $3 bill ion in assets, and 470,000 customers. NSPI is a...
AI summary The text provides a preamble describing the corporate structure and regulatory environment of Emera's electric utilities. Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) serves Nova Scotia as a cost-of-service utility regulated by the UARB, while Bangor Hydro-Electric Company (BHE) serves eastern Maine under FERC and MPUC oversight. The document highlights that while these utilities provide stable earnings due to their monopoly positions and regulated markets, Emera seeks growth through infrastructure expansion, including a joint venture for a pumped storage hydro-electric facility in Massachusetts.
OVERVIEW NSPI is the primary electricity supplier in Nova Scotia, providing over 95% of electricity generation, transmission and distribution in the province. The company owns 2,293 megawatts ("MW") of generating capacity. Approximately 55...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) is the primary electricity provider in Nova Scotia, owning over 95% of the province's generation, transmission, and distribution infrastructure. The company's generation portfolio consists of coal, oil, natural gas, hydro, and wind. As a public utility regulated under the Public Utilities Act, NSPI is overseen by the Utility and Rate Advisory Board (UARB). The company operates under a cost of service model where rates are set to cover prudently incurred costs and provide an appropriate return on equity (ROE) to investors.
OVERVIEW Bangor Hydro is the second largest electric utility in Maine. BHE's core business is the transmission and distribution ("T&D") of electricity. Electricity generation is deregulated in Maine, and several suppliers compete to provid...
AI summary Bangor Hydro Electric (BHE) is a Maine-based electric utility primarily engaged in transmission and distribution. The company manages significant 'regulatory' assets (stranded costs) from the late 1990s industry restructuring, which account for 30% of its electric rate. BHE's operations are split between regulatory jurisdictions: distribution and stranded costs are regulated by the Maine Public Utilities Commission (MPUC) under an Alternate Rate Plan (ARP), while transmission is regulated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).
EQUITY EARNINGS Equity earnings from the Maritimes & Northeast Pipeline were $1.7 million in Q4, 2005 compared to $1.2 million for the same period in 2004. The increase is primarily due to increases in tol ls collected for the US operation...
AI summary The document details the equity earnings of Maritimes & Northeast Pipeline (M&NP) for 2004 and 2005, noting an increase in 2005 primarily driven by higher tolls from US operations. It discusses the pending FERC rate decision for 2004, the interim collection of proposed rates, and the potential return of excess funds to customers. The text also highlights how earnings were impacted by pipeline expansion write-offs, currency fluctuations, and lower volumes in the US component.
Bangor Hydro Bangor Hydro's business consists of four primary components wh ich are each governed by their own regulatory structure. The components include distribution, transm ission , standard costs, and supply (metering, billi ng, and s...
AI summary The document outlines the four primary components of Bangor Hydro's business: distribution, transmission, standard costs, and supply. BHE's distribution business operates under an Alternate Rate Plan (ARP) requiring annual rate decreases and performance penalties, with the potential for higher returns on equity. Transmission is regulated by FERC and linked to the Regional Transmission Organization for New England. BHE can recover stranded costs for regulatory assets and power purchases, while metering and billing costs are recoverable as prudently incurred.
1. SUJ\1MARY <H SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES Emera Inc. ("Emera" or the Company), incorporated in the Province of Nova Scotia, through its principal subsidiaries, Nova Scotia Power Inc. ("Nova Scotia Power" or "NSPI") and Bangor Hydro-E...
AI summary The document provides an overview of the significant accounting policies and regulatory framework for Emera Inc., specifically its subsidiaries Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and Bangor Hydro-Electric Company (BHE). It highlights NSPI's role as the primary electricity supplier in Nova Scotia, regulated by the Utility and Rate Board (UARB) under the Public Utilities Act. NSPI operates under a cost of service model, where rates are set to recover prudently incurred costs while providing a regulated return on equity (ROE) to investors.
N-2-dRIRs 1 to 46 - CME to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 18 MB)
5 passages
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST TO: NSPI FROM: CME Question IR-23: Reference Page 89, Lines 10-20 Provide a copy of all relevant actuarial information and assumptions utilized to support the adjustment of the Return on Asset assumption to...
AI summary Campbell Scott Management (CME) provided a response to an Information Request (IR-23) from Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI). The request sought actuarial information and assumptions justifying the adjustment of the Return on Asset assumption to 7.25%. CME directed the requester to four specific previous information requests (CA IR-57, CA IR-58, CA IR-60, and CA IR-61) for the relevant documentation.
RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST TO: NSPI FROM: CME Question IR-24b: Reference Page 110, Lines 15-20 Provide the list of Canadian utilities used in determining the average ROE. Response IR-24b: This confidential information is available for...
AI summary Campbell Scott Management (CME) responded to an Information Request (IR-24b) from Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) regarding the list of Canadian utilities used to determine the average Return on Equity (ROE). CME stated that the requested confidential information is available for viewing at NSPI's offices.
Weaknesses: • Earnings pressures are expected to slowly increase from electricity industry restructuring and the introduction of natural gas as an energy alternative, creating the possibility for stranded assets. - Comparatively weak marke...
AI summary The text identifies several financial and market weaknesses facing the utility. Key concerns include potential stranded assets resulting from electricity industry restructuring and the rise of natural gas as a competitive alternative. The document notes that low-growth market conditions may intensify competitive pressures. Furthermore, while most power costs are recovered through rates, the utility must hedge against commodity risks. Finally, financial measures are constrained by regulatory guidelines regarding deemed equity.
nerate approximately 90%-95% of Emera's consolidated assets and cash flow. Although Emera's nonregulated businesses do not materially influence the ratings at present, they have a higher risk profile. Nova Scotia Power's above-average busi...
AI summary The text analyzes the credit profile of Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), noting that it represents 90%-95% of Emera's consolidated assets. NSPI's business profile is considered above-average due to a favorable regulatory environment, its dominant monopoly position, and a rate-of-return regulation that recovers costs and capital expenditures. However, the text notes that the financial profile is below average. It highlights that while leverage is currently supported by monopoly status, potential industry restructuring and deregulation in Nova Scotia could increase future business risk.
-Average of past three fiscal Fiscal year ended Dec. 31- years Rating history BBB+/Stable BBB+/Stable N.R. N.R. N.R. Sector median Issuer 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 (Mii.C$) Sales 811 .6 844.8 876.5 838.6 819.2 798.9 759.1 Net income from co...
AI summary The document presents a financial performance table for an issuer (implied to be a utility) covering the fiscal years from 1998 to 2002. It details key financial metrics including sales, net income, funds from operations (FFO), capital expenditures, total debt, and total capital. Additionally, it provides credit rating history, interest coverage ratios (EBIT and FFO), return on common equity, and various leverage and liquidity ratios to assess the entity's financial health over a five-year period.
N-2-gRIRs 1 to 25 - Stutz to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 18 MB)
5 passages
Rationale The ratings on Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) reflect the consolidated business and financial risk profile of its parent, Emera Inc., based on Standard & Poor's Ratings Services consolidated rating methodology. Any change to the r...
AI summary The text explains the rationale for Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) credit ratings, noting they reflect the consolidated financial risk profile of its parent company, Emera Inc. NSPI is a vertically integrated utility with a stable customer base and monopoly network. Key credit strengths include stable cash flows, supportive cost-of-service regulation allowing for a specific return on equity (ROE), and a mature market with limited exposure to volatile sectors like pulp and paper.
5 4.4 Schedule 4 - Determination of Depreciation and Capital-related costs by Fixture Type 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 In this schedule, the capital component of the street light rate is determined by individual fixture type. The depre...
AI summary The document outlines the methodology for determining the capital component of the street light rate based on individual fixture types. It specifies the use of a 4.55% depreciation rate, corresponding to Year 2 of the DARB-approved phase-in schedule for 2006. Additionally, a tax-adjusted weighted average cost of capital (WACC) of 11.96% is applied to calculate remaining capital-related costs, including interest, taxes, and dividends. This methodology aligns with the approved approach for Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT).
19 4.5 Schedule 5 - Tax-Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Capital 20 21 22 23 24 25 As stated previously, using a tax-adjusted WACC is consistent with the methodology used in the development ofNSPI's currently approved OATT. The calculatio...
AI summary The document outlines the calculation of Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s (NSPI) tax-adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) for 2006. The methodology is consistent with the approved Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT). The final tax-adjusted WACC of 11.96% is derived from four components: a pretax WACC of 8.21%, additional income tax on Common Equity (2.10%), Large Corporation Tax (0.46%), and Grants-in-Lieu of Property Taxes (1.19%).
Capital Cost Rate Component Calculation Depreciation Rate for 2006 4.44% Tax Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of
AI summary The document provides a specific calculation for the Capital Cost Rate Component, identifying the Depreciation Rate for the 2006 calendar year as 4.44%. It initiates the calculation for the Tax Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Capital, which is a standard metric used to determine the return on equity for utility assets.
STREET I CROSSWALK LIGHTING STUDY Tax-Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Capital a) Weighted Average Cost of Capital - Pretax Proportion Cost Extended ST Debt 7.77% 5.08% 0.39% L T Debt 45.57% 8.19% 3. 73% Preferred 9.15% 5.42% 0.50% Common...
AI summary The document presents a detailed calculation of the Tax-Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) specifically for Street and Crosswalk Lighting. It breaks down the components of the WACC, including short-term and long-term debt, preferred equity, and common equity. The analysis further adjusts the WACC by accounting for common equity income tax, large corporations tax (provincial and federal capital taxes), and grants in lieu of property tax to determine the final interest carrying cost.
N-7-bRIRs 142 to 143 - SEB to NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 45 MB)
17 passages
Investment Proposition A focus on building greater predictability and stability in earnings from low risk businesses with a proven dividend commitment Forecast
AI summary The document introduces the 'Investment Proposition' section, emphasizing a strategic focus on creating greater predictability and stability in earnings. This is achieved by targeting low-risk businesses that have a proven commitment to dividend payments, as part of a broader forecasting and investment strategy.
In summary, Emera is focused on: - Building greater stability and predictability in earning and cash flow from our utility businesses to support our dividend - Disciplined investment of free cash flow in complementary energy businesses tha...
AI summary Emera outlines its strategic focus on two primary objectives: enhancing the stability and predictability of earnings and cash flows from its utility operations to support its dividend payments, and maintaining disciplined investment of free cash flow. The company intends to invest in complementary energy businesses that leverage electricity infrastructure opportunities to achieve profitable growth.
Emera's Investment Proposition - Regulated assets, low risk profile - $0.89 dividend yields 4.5% - Focused on building stable earnings stream to support dividend growth
AI summary The text outlines Emera's investment proposition, highlighting the company's focus on regulated assets with a low risk profile. It notes a dividend yield of 4.5% and emphasizes the company's strategic objective of establishing stable earnings streams to facilitate consistent dividend growth for its investors.
Nova Scotia Power - Vertically integrated electric utility - Traditional regulated monopoly - Wholesale market competitive, <2% of sales - Cost of service regulation - $3B assets; 470,000 customers - ROE between 9.3% and 9.8% - Low cost th...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power is described as a vertically integrated, traditional regulated monopoly electric utility with $3B in assets serving 470,000 customers. The utility operates under a cost-of-service regulatory model, maintaining a return on equity (ROE) between 9.3% and 9.8%. It benefits from a low-cost thermal-based fleet that facilitates competitive pricing. The utility is noted for improving its regulatory relationship and is currently working toward implementing a fuel adjustment mechanism.
Brunswick Pipe Delivers LNG and Growth - Recently announced $350 M gas pipeline links Canaport TM LNG terminal to U.S. - Builds on EMA's stake in M&NP - Duke Energy operating partner - Comprehensive risk mitigation for EMA - 11% 14% ROE, o...
AI summary The text highlights the development of a $350 million gas pipeline project designed to link the Canaport LNG terminal to the United States. This project builds upon Emera's (EMA) stake in M&NP and involves Duke Energy as an operating partner. The initiative is described as providing comprehensive risk mitigation for EMA, with a projected return on equity (ROE) of 11% to 14% based on a minimum of 40% equity capitalization.
Why Invest in Emera? Reliable income - Core regulated electric monopolies - Disciplined growth Income Growth - ■NRI - Brunswick Pipeline - Energy Marketing Capital Growth - Strategic partnerships - Earnings momentum - Risk management
AI summary The document outlines the investment thesis for Emera, highlighting its appeal to investors through reliable income from regulated electric monopolies and disciplined growth. It identifies key drivers of income and capital growth, including NRI, Brunswick Pipeline, and Energy Marketing, alongside strategic partnerships, earnings momentum, and robust risk management practices.
Emera's Investment Proposition - Regulated assets, low risk profile - $0.89 dividend yields 4.2% - Building earnings stream to support sustainable dividend growth by - Enhancing returns in existing investments - Prudent, profitable investm...
AI summary Emera outlines its investment proposition for its regulated assets, highlighting a low-risk profile and a current dividend yield of 0.89% (4.2%). The company aims to support sustainable dividend growth through two primary strategies: maximizing returns on existing infrastructure and ensuring prudent, profitable investments in new assets. The proposition emphasizes the stability of the regulated earnings stream as a foundation for shareholder value.
Nova Scotia Power Overview - Vertically integrated electric utility - Traditional regulated monopoly - Wholesale market competitive, <2% of sales - $3B assets; 470,000 customers - Cost of service regulation - Allowed ROE between 9.3% and 9...
AI summary The text provides an overview of Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), describing it as a vertically integrated, traditionally regulated monopoly electric utility. With $3 billion in assets and a customer base of 470,000, the company operates under a cost-of-service regulation with an allowed Return on Equity (ROE) between 9.3% and 9.8%. Its generation portfolio consists of 2,300 MW, featuring a low-cost thermal fleet and a growing investment in renewable energy sources.
Strengths - Strong earnings base supports dividend - Opportunities to invest in rate base - Attractive allowed ROE - Outstanding operator
AI summary The document highlights the financial and operational strengths of the utility, noting a robust earnings base that supports dividend payments. It identifies significant opportunities for investment within the rate base and emphasizes an attractive allowed return on equity (ROE). Additionally, it acknowledges the company's status as an outstanding operator.
Challenges Consistency of returns, largely due to combination of fuel risk and regulatory lag
AI summary The document identifies the consistency of returns as a primary challenge for the utility. This issue is attributed to two main factors: the inherent risks associated with fuel price fluctuations and regulatory lag, which can create a mismatch between the timing of costs incurred and the timing of their recovery through regulated rates.
Improving Returns at NSPI - Reducing fuel price risk key to improving consistency of returns - Two stage process - Ensure rates reflect full fuel costs - 2007 rate application in process - Advance automatic fuel cost pass-through - Impleme...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) outlines a two-stage strategy to improve the consistency of its returns by mitigating fuel price risk. The first stage involves ensuring that current rates accurately reflect full fuel costs, specifically through a 2007 rate application. The second stage focuses on advancing an automatic fuel cost pass-through mechanism by implementing fuel procurement changes in cooperation with the regulator. Additionally, NSPI identifies the recovery of tax regulatory assets as a critical component for improving returns.
Increasing Returns at BHE - Stranded cost recovery provides pool of capital to reconfigure BHE's asset base for higher returns - Focus on transmission investments - "Northeast Reliability Interconnect" will provide second U.S. / Canada lin...
AI summary The text discusses Boston Edison's (BHE) strategy to increase returns by leveraging stranded cost recovery to reconfigure its asset base. A primary focus is on transmission investments, specifically the $110M 'Northeast Reliability Interconnect' project, which aims to improve reliability and facilitate cross-border electricity sales between the U.S. and Canada. BHE also intends to capitalize on its success in permitting to pursue additional transmission opportunities in Maine valued between $70M and $200M.
Increasing returns at Bear Swamp - Contracting significant portion of output to enhance consistency of returns - LICAP settlement adds substantial value
AI summary The text discusses the strategy for enhancing the consistency of returns at the Bear Swamp facility by contracting a significant portion of its output. Additionally, it notes that the settlement of the Load Investment Cost Adjustment Program (LICAP) provides substantial value to the project's financial profile.
Brunswick Pipe Delivers Growth - Recently announced $350 M gas pipeline links Canaport ™ LNG terminal to U.S. - Builds on EMA's stake in M&NP - Duke Energy operating partner - Comprehensive risk mitigation for EMA - 11% 14% ROE, on minimum...
AI summary Emera (EMA) is involved in a $350 million gas pipeline project linking the Canaport LNG terminal to the United States. The project leverages EMA's stake in M&NP and involves Duke Energy as an operating partner. The investment aims to provide comprehensive risk mitigation for EMA, with a target return on equity (ROE) of 11% to 14% based on a minimum 40% equity capitalization. The project is currently undergoing hearings with the National Energy Board (NEB).
Reliable income - Core regulated electric monopolies - Disciplined growth
AI summary The document excerpt introduces the concept of 'Reliable income' as a fundamental principle for core regulated electric monopolies. It emphasizes that these entities require a stable and predictable revenue stream to support long-term infrastructure investment and operational stability. The text highlights that achieving this reliability is predicated on disciplined growth strategies, ensuring that the utility's expansion and financial planning remain sustainable and aligned with regulatory expectations.
Performance Graph The performance graph below compares the Company's cumulative total shareholder return (assuming an investment of $100 and reinvestment of dividends) for its shares with that of the S&P TSX Utilities and the S&P TSX Compo...
AI summary The document introduces a performance graph designed to compare the Company's cumulative total shareholder return against two benchmarks: the S&P TSX Utilities index and the S&P TSX Composite index. The analysis assumes an initial investment of $100 with the reinvestment of all dividends to provide a standardized comparison of investment performance over time.
Cumulative Total Return on $100 Investment December 31, 2000 to December 31, 2005 Dec. 31/00 Dec. 31/01 Dec. 31/02 Dec. 31/03 Dec. 31/04 Dec 31/05 Emera Inc. $100.00 $99.48 $100.43 $117.60 $132.61 $152.56 S&PTSX Utilities 100.00 110.83 117...
AI summary The document provides a financial comparison of the cumulative total return on a $100 investment from December 31, 2000, to December 31, 2005. It tracks the performance of Emera Inc. against the S&PTSX Utilities index and the S&PTSX Composite index. While the S&PTSX Utilities index saw significant growth reaching $222.79, Emera Inc. showed a more moderate return of $152.56 over the same five-year period.
N-22Direct Testimony and Exhibit - Michael Gorman (on behalf of Stora Enso/ Bowater)
13 passages
4 Q WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF YOUR TESTIMONY? - 5 A I recommend a return on equity for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), and a reduction in 6 pension expense.
AI summary The testimony recommends a specific return on equity for Nova Scotia Power Inc. and suggests reducing pension expenses.
7 Q PLEASE SUMMARIZE YOUR RECOMMENDATIONS IN THIS PROCEEDING. 8 A I recommend NSPI's authorized return on equity be reduced from the currently 9 authorized return of 9.55% down to at least 9.0% to reflect a decline to capital market 10 cos...
AI summary The recommendation is to reduce NSPI's authorized return on equity from 9.55% to at least 9.0% due to declining capital market costs. Additionally, pension expense normalization is suggested to lower the test year expense by $4.58 million, using an average projected pension expense of $28.46 million from 2007 to 2011.
CURRENT AUTHORIZED RETURN ON 23 A NSPI's current authorized return on equity was originally set by the Board in its 24 Decision NSUARB-NSPI-P-881, 2005 NSUARB 27, March 31, 2005. In that 22 EQUITY. 1 Decision, the Board found a 9.55% retur...
AI summary The authorized return on equity for NSPI may be reduced if a fuel deferral mechanism is approved, as it lowers NSPI's operating risk and shifts fuel price volatility to customers. The current 9.55% return on equity was set in 2005 based on a 5.0% Canadian bond yield, but long-term bond yields have since declined significantly.
12 Q IS THERE EVIDENCE THAT AN EQUITY RISK PREMIUM TO LONG-TERM 13 CANADIAN BOND YIELDS TO DEVELOP NSPI'S RETURN ON EQUITY HAS 14 INCREASED SINCE 2004? 15 A No. Indeed, NSPI witness Dr. Morin clearly stated in his evidence in this case tha...
AI summary The answer states that there is no evidence that the equity risk premium to long-term Canadian bond yields has increased since 2004. Dr. Morin's testimony indicates that equity risk premiums have remained flat, and declining interest rates suggest that NSPI's authorized return on equity should be reduced.
1 Q HOW WOULD THE DECLINE IN CANADIAN BOND YIELDS IMPACT A FAIR 2 RETURN FOR NSPIIN THIS PROCEEDING? 3 A NSPI's current authorized return of 9.55% was based on current long-term Canadian 4 bond yields of approximately 5.0%, and projected l...
AI summary The decline in Canadian bond yields since 2005 has led to a potential reduction in NSPI's authorized return on equity. Based on current and projected yields, the return on equity could be 75 to 110 basis points lower than the 9.55% approved in 2005, suggesting a range of 8.45% to 8.80%. A conservative recommendation is to set the return at 9.0%.
1 3. AUTHORIZED UTILITY RETURNS - 2 Q WHY DO YOU BELIEVE CANADIAN AUTHORIZED RETURNS ON EQUITY FOR - 3 UTILITY COMPANIES HAVE DECLINED SIGNIFICANTLY OVER THE LAST TWO - 4 YEARS? - 5 A On my Schedule MPG-1, Page 2, Column 1, I show the appr...
AI summary The authorized return on equity for Canadian utility companies has declined significantly over the past two years, according to the testimony. The decline is attributed to reduced capital market costs. The witness argues that NSPI's return on equity should be adjusted to reflect these changes, rather than being set equal to other Canadian utilities.
7 Q IS THERE AN IMPLICIT EQUITY RISK PREMIUM TO A PROJECTED LONG TERM 8 CANADIAN BOND YIELD THAT RELATES TO NSPI'S CURRENT 9.55% RETURN 9 ON EQUITY? 10 A Yes. In the record that provided the support for the Board's finding of a 9.55% fair...
AI summary The answer confirms that there is an implicit equity risk premium of 3.85 percentage points applied to the long-term Canadian bond yield of 5.7% to arrive at NSPI's current 9.55% return on equity. This is deemed more reasonable than Dr. Morin's estimate of 4.5 to 5.5 percentage points. The Board's decision also suggests that reducing NSPI's return on equity to 9.0% would be reasonable.
1 return on equity reduction of 0.6% if a FAM was approved. As such, if the Board 2 approves a fuel deferral or other regulatory mechanism in this proceeding, then 3 NSPI's authorized return on equity should be reduced by approximately 0.5...
AI summary The text discusses a potential reduction in Nova Scotia Power Inc.'s authorized return on equity if a fuel deferral or other regulatory mechanism is approved by the Board, with a suggested reduction of approximately 0.5 percentage points.
5 Q WHAT RETURN ON EQUITY WOULD BE APPROPRIATE FOR NSPI IN THIS 6 PROCEEDING IF A FUEL DEFERRAL OR SIMILAR REGULATORY MECHANISM 7 IS APPROVED? 8 A Excluding consideration of adoption of a fuel deferral mechanism, NSPI's current 9 9.55% aut...
AI summary The response discusses the appropriate return on equity (ROE) for NSPI in the proceeding, considering a fuel deferral mechanism. It suggests reducing the current authorized ROE of 9.55% by at least 55 basis points to 9.0% without the mechanism. With a proposed fuel deferral mechanism, the ROE should be reduced by less than 0.5%, and potentially 0.25 percentage points, resulting in an ROE of 8.75%.
9 SHOULD NOT BE ADJUSTED IN THIS PROCEEDING? 19 20 21 10 A Yes. Dr. Morin's evaluation is based on stale and false assumptions. Specifically, 11 Dr. Morin is of the opinion in his August 2006 testimony that Canadian authorized 12 returns o...
AI summary The text argues that Dr. Morin's testimony regarding return on equity (ROE) is based on outdated and incorrect assumptions, as Canadian utility ROEs and interest rates have declined since 2006. The author contends that NSPI's ROE should be reduced to reflect current lower interest rates, and that Dr. Morin's comparison of interest rates fails to account for higher rates used in past evidence.
19 5. PENSION EXPENSE - 20 Q WHAT LEVEL OF PENSION EXPENSE DID NSPIINCLUDE IN ITS 2007 REVENUE - 21 REQUIREMENT? - 22 A The Company is requesting a level of pension expense of $33.0 million in 2007. This 23 compares to a level of pension e...
AI summary NSPI requested a pension expense of $33.0 million for 2007, an increase of $3.2 million from 2006, citing updated return on asset assumptions. The respondent noted that this level is higher than NSPI's projections for the next four years.
Approved Return on Equity(ROE) Premium to Actual Long-Term Canadian Bond Yield Year Multi-pipeline Approved Return on Eguitl!1 (1) Annual Avg. LT Canadian Bond Yield1 (2) Approved ROE Premium to l T Canadian Bond Yield (3) 2000 9.90% 5.71%...
AI summary The table presents the approved Return on Equity (ROE) premium to the actual long-term Canadian bond yield from 2000 to 2006, highlighting the difference between the multi-pipeline approved ROE and the annual average long-term Canadian bond yield.
Approved Return on Equity(ROE) Premium to Projected Long-Term Canadian Bond Yield Year Multi·plpellne Approved Return on Egultv (1) Projected Canadian Bond Yield (2) Premium (3) 2000 9.90% 6.12% 3.78% 2001 9.61% 5.73% 3.88% 2002 9.53% 5.63...
AI summary The document presents the approved Return on Equity (ROE) premium to the projected long-term Canadian bond yield from 2000 to 2007, showing a consistent premium ranging from 3.78% to 4.24% with an average of 3.94%.
N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - REDACTED (Large File - 31 MB)
8 passages
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 In this section, NSPI presents the Rebuttal Evidence of Dr. Roger Morin in respect of return on equity (ROE). NSPI also responds to issues raised by consultants in regard to pension, depreciation, rate base and OM&G. The impo...
AI summary NSPI presents Dr. Roger Morin's rebuttal evidence regarding return on equity (ROE) and responds to issues raised by consultants on pension, depreciation, rate base, and OM&G. The section emphasizes the importance of maintaining the financial health of the utility by allowing an appropriate ROE and timely cost recovery.
Analysis 19 20 21 22 23 In determining NSPI's return on common equity capital ("ROE"), Mr. Gorman recommends that NSPI's currently allowed ROE of 9.55 percent be reduced to 9.00 percent because of a decline in interest rates since the last...
AI summary The document discusses a recommendation by Mr. Gorman to reduce NSPI's allowed return on common equity capital from 9.55% to 9.00% due to declining interest rates since 2005. The response raises four concerns, including lack of independent analysis, reliance on a formulaic approach, unapproved automatic adjustment formulas, and failure to account for NSPI's higher investment risk.
Lack of Independent Analysis 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 5 The required return on common equity is usually estimated with several methodologies: (1) the Capital Asset Pricing Model, or CAPM, (2) the Risk Premium, (3) the Discounted Cash Flow...
AI summary The document highlights that Mr. Gorman's recommendation for the required return on common equity (ROE) was based solely on the Board's previous authorization and changes in interest rates, without conducting any formal independent analysis using standard methodologies like CAPM or DCF.
Relationship Between Interest Rates and ROE 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Mr. Gorman argues that since interest rates have declined since the Company's last rate order, the Company's authorized ROE should be reduce proportionally. Mr. G...
AI summary Mr. Gorman argues that the Company's authorized ROE should be reduced proportionally with declining interest rates. However, academic studies indicate that risk premiums vary inversely with interest rates, and Canadian regulators have adjusted ROE formulas accordingly.
Automatic ROE Adjustment Formulas 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Automatic ROE adjustment formulas of the kind implied in Mr. Gorman's approach whereby ROEs are a direct function of i...
AI summary The text critiques the use of automatic ROE adjustment formulas based on interest rates, arguing that they fail to account for risk, reduce efficiency incentives, and are not transferable across utilities. It highlights that NSPI has a higher investment risk compared to other utilities and thus requires a higher allowed ROE or stronger balance sheet.
NSPI's Relative Investment Risk 27 28 29 30 31 32 26 Mr. Gorman also refers to the lower allowed returns for Canadian pipelines and Alberta utilities as an argument to lower NSPI's currently allowed return. This circular approach does not...
AI summary The text argues that NSPI's investment risk is higher than Canadian pipelines and Alberta utilities due to its vertically integrated nature and exposure to power generation risks. It suggests that a higher return on equity (ROE) should be allowed for NSPI compared to lower returns applied to pipelines and T&D utilities.
Updated Recommendation 9 10 11 12 13 I agree with Mr. Gorman that interest rates are lower since I last prepared my own ROE recommendation. I am able to update my ROE recommendation in light of favourable changes that have occurred in capi...
AI summary The document discusses an updated recommendation for the return on equity (ROE) for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), considering current capital market conditions and the risk profile of the company. The recommended ROE range is 9.0% to 10.0%, with the upper end of the range being more appropriate for NSPI due to its higher risk profile.
5 6 7 4 8 9 10 11 12 14 15 13 17 18 19 16 20 21 22 23 24 25 27 28 26 29 30 ability to attract capital, access fuel markets and control costs must not be compromised. 60 Following the Rate Decision in March 2006, Standard & Poor's (S&P) dow...
AI summary NSPI's credit ratings have been negatively impacted due to its inability to recover fuel costs and regulatory risks. The company has not met its allowed ROE in several years, and a fair ROE is essential for its financial health and future capital investments. Experts have criticized recommendations to reduce ROE without proper analysis.
N-46Rebuttal Evidence of NSPI - Appendix A to J - REDACTED (Large File 27 MB)
8 passages
Strengths - Regulated operations contribute to earnings and cash flow stability - Cash flow from operations are expected to remain sufficient to fund capital expenditures and dividends - Geographic isolation and limited interconnections ar...
AI summary The text highlights the financial and operational strengths of the regulated utility. It notes that regulated operations provide stable earnings and cash flow, which are sufficient to support capital expenditures and dividend payments. Furthermore, the company benefits from geographic isolation and limited interconnections, creating barriers to entry for competitors. Additionally, the transition to cleaner burning coal is expected to provide a short-term reduction in emissions.
EGULATION SPI is regulated by the UARB under a cost-of-service methodology. - Large industrial customers (approximately 15% of sales volumes) are subject to annually adjusted rates, which are adjusted based on an approved formula. - Export...
AI summary The text outlines the regulatory framework for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), which is governed by the UARB under a cost-of-service methodology. It highlights a 2006 rate ruling where the UARB approved an 8.6% rate increase and signaled a shift toward full-cost recovery for fuel costs, ending prior 'imprudence' disallowances. The UARB recognized NSPI's improved fuel procurement strategies and noted that while a fuel adjustment mechanism (FAM) is not yet approved, it remains a logical next step once the procurement strategy is finalized.
Summary - Lower fuel costs during Ql 2006 helped in the recovery of credit metrics for the 12 months ended June 30, 2006. - This is the result of the favourable settlement of a natural gas supply contract, which was offset against a fuel e...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) experienced improved credit metrics in Q1 2006 due to lower fuel costs resulting from a favorable natural gas supply contract settlement. Conversely, 2005 saw the lowest EBIT and net income in five years because higher actual fuel costs exceeded the 90% recovery approved by the UARB, which deemed certain costs 'imprudently incurred.' Additionally, a lower approved return on equity (ROE) of 9.55% in 2005 compared to 2004 further impacted earnings during that period.
Outlook - As a stable, regulated business in a relatively mature market, NSPI's earnings are expected to remain relatively stable over the medium term, absent significant volatility in fuel prices. - The Company will benefit from further e...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) expects stable earnings over the medium term, supported by provincial economic growth and a recent 8.6% rate increase designed to recover higher fuel costs. While the Company aims to earn within its allowed ROE, global commodity price volatility remains a key challenge. The text notes that full fuel-cost recovery will eventually boost earnings, as current figures reflect the Company's absorption of these costs. It also mentions specific financial items including a past coal contract write-off and deferred taxes.
fiNANCIAL PROFILE 12 mos. ended For the year ended December 31 (CAD millions) June 30, 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 EBITDA 415.0 360.0 414.0 411.4 355.9 361.4 Net income available to common 98.4 91.2 107.3 112.1 86.1 105.1 Depreciation an...
AI summary The document provides a financial profile for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (SPI) spanning the fiscal years 2001 to 2006. It details key financial metrics including EBITDA, net income, depreciation and amortization, and capital expenditures. The data highlights the company's cash flow from operations, common dividends, and net changes in long-term debt. Additionally, it presents key financial ratios such as EBITDA interest coverage, fixed-charges coverage, and the percentage of adjusted debt in the capital structure.
Nova Scotia Power Inc. Dalance Sheet 1 tova Scott a rower inc • % debt in capital structure 54.5% 55.1% 54.0% 52.0% 53.2% 56.3% 56.3% 57.4% % adjusted debt in capital structure (2) 57.2% 57.8% 56.7% 54.8% 56.0% 59.1% 59.0% 59.9% % debt in...
AI summary The document presents a detailed financial balance sheet and performance summary for Nova Scotia Power Inc. It tracks key financial metrics including debt-to-capital structure ratios, interest coverage ratios (EBIT and EBITDA), and dividend payouts. Additionally, it provides data on operating efficiency, fuel costs relative to revenues, profit margins, and return on equity. The data also includes operational metrics such as customer-to-employee ratios and electricity sales (GWh) per employee over several periods.
Regulation: regime presents some issues Cost-of-service regulation supports Emera's business risk profile. Nevertheless, the specific regulation that applies to NSPI is viewed as somewhat less favorable than other regulatory regimes. - The...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) argues that its current regulatory regime is less favorable than those governing its affiliate, Bayonne Hydroelectric Corporation (BHEC). NSPI highlights risks such as the lack of a fuel cost variance mitigation mechanism and the UARB's prioritization of rate stability over cash flow, citing a C$150 million tax recovery deferral. In contrast, BHEC benefits from supportive US regulations, including a higher ROE range, automatic tariff adjustments, and a 50-50 sharing mechanism for performance-based regulation.
Steady profitability; less stable cash flow Profitability and cash flow protection at Emera are largely a function of the capital structure and returns provided by NSPI's regulatory regime. Accordingly, in the past four years , Emera's net...
AI summary Emera Inc. reports stable net profits of approximately C$120 million annually, primarily driven by NSPI's regulatory regime and capital structure. While operating cash flows experience some volatility due to working capital, they remain sufficient to cover dividends and capital expenditures, which exceed depreciation. The company maintains a debt-to-total capital ratio of 53% and intends to invest C$350 million in a natural gas pipeline, though specific financing details have not yet been disclosed.
57968Amended Board Order (and attached Schedules A to C)
4 passages
AND WHEREAS, pursuant to s. 45(1) of the Public Utilities Act, the Board approves the average Rate Base of $2,776.3 million and the Rate of Return on average Rate Base of 8.25% as set out in Appendix 2, Table 1 of NSPI's Compliance Filing;
AI summary The document states that the Board has approved the average Rate Base of $2,776.3 million and a Rate of Return of 8.25% on that base, as outlined in Appendix 2, Table 1 of NSPI's Compliance Filing, under section 45(1) of the Public Utilities Act.
IT IS ORDERED that: 1. The Minutes of Settlement dated the 21st day of January, 2007, attached hereto as Schedule "C", are approved and the terms are adopted by the Board as part of this Order; Document: 127640 - 2. NSPI's proposed revenue...
AI summary The Board approves the Minutes of Settlement from January 2007, NSPI's revenue requirement of $1,159.5 million, and new rates effective April 1, 2007. The Board also sets the common equity ratio at 37.5% and the rate of return on common equity at 9.55%. A separate hearing is established for constitutional and human rights challenges.
tes for 2008. - 6. Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSP...
AI summary This settlement agreement outlines the resolution of various matters related to NSPI's 2007 and 2008 earnings, deferrals, and regulatory proceedings. Key points include the application of excess earnings to an unamortized balance, the withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, and the adoption of a revenue-to-cost ratio methodology with specific modifications.
- 6. Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Applicatio...
AI summary The text outlines several decisions and agreements related to Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) in a regulatory proceeding. It includes the application of excess earnings to an unamortized balance, withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, and the adoption of a revenue-to-cost ratio methodology. The agreement does not preclude future regulatory positions and allows for a potential rate adjustment proceeding for 2008.
57968Amended Board Order (and attached Schedules A to C)
4 passages
AND WHEREAS, pursuant to s. 45(1) of the Public Utilities Act, the Board approves the average Rate Base of $2,776.3 million and the Rate of Return on average Rate Base of 8.25% as set out in Appendix 2, Table 1 of NSPI's Compliance Filing;
AI summary The document references the approval of the average Rate Base and Rate of Return by the Board under the Public Utilities Act, as detailed in NSPI's Compliance Filing.
IT IS ORDERED that: 1. The Minutes of Settlement dated the 21st day of January, 2007, attached hereto as Schedule "C", are approved and the terms are adopted by the Board as part of this Order; Document: 127640 - 2. NSPI's proposed revenue...
AI summary The Board approves the Minutes of Settlement from January 2007, NSPI's revenue requirement of $1,159.5 million, and sets the common equity ratio at 37.5% and the rate of return on common equity at 9.55%. The Order also outlines procedures for future settlement agreements and compliance filings, and establishes a separate hearing for constitutional and human rights challenges.
tes for 2008. - 6. Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSP...
AI summary This agreement outlines the resolution of various issues related to NSPI's financial and regulatory matters for 2007 and 2008, including the handling of excess earnings, deferral of fuel costs, and adoption of the Revenue to Cost ratio methodology, while noting that certain directives and studies remain pending.
- 7. NSPI's request for a deferra] of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Application including: rate base and return on rate base, return on equity, OM&G, regulatory amortizations and in...
AI summary The document outlines various decisions and agreements related to NSPI's regulatory proceedings, including the withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, no changes to rate base and return on equity, deferral of a true-up for the ELI 2P-RTP rate, and adoption of the Revenue to Cost ratio methodology with modifications.
57974NSPI Compliance Filing 2007 Rate Application - REDACTED (Large File - 36 MB)
5 passages
a future proceeding if actual 2007 gas margin is less than $4 7 million. 32 33 3. The third year of the phase in of depreciation rates is deferred for recovery in the next general rate application. This reduces 2007 depreciation expense by...
AI summary The document outlines several financial and regulatory matters related to Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), including the deferral of depreciation rates, the agreement on establishing a Fuel Adjustment Mechanism (FAM), and the withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request. It also mentions the application of excess earnings to an unamortized balance and the requirement for NSPI to provide updated cost forecasts.
hanges for 2008. - Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - There are no further changes to NSPI's...
AI summary The document outlines various agreements and decisions from a regulatory proceeding involving NSPI. It mentions the application of excess earnings to an unamortized balance, withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, and deferral of a true-up request for the 2P-RTP rate to an annual review. It also notes the adoption of a revenue-to-cost ratio methodology with modifications.
- 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Application including: rate base and return on rate base, return on equity, OM&O, regulatory amortizations and in...
AI summary NSPI has withdrawn its request to defer first quarter 2007 fuel costs and made no further changes to its application. The UARB directive regarding the study of NSPI's OM&G remains incomplete. The Revenue to Cost ratio methodology will be adopted with modifications. The agreement does not prevent future regulatory positions.
- 7. NSPI's request for a deferral of first quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Application including: rate base and return on rate base, return on equity, OM&G, regulatory amortizations and in...
AI summary NSPI has withdrawn its request to defer first quarter 2007 fuel costs and made no further changes to its application. The UARB directive regarding the study of NSPI's OM&G remains incomplete. The Revenue to Cost ratio methodology will be adopted with modifications. This agreement does not prevent future regulatory positions.
- 6. Excess earnings by NSPI, if any, in 2007 and 2008 will be applied to the S21 unamortized balance. - 7. NSPI's request for a deferral offrrst quarter 2007 fuel costs is withdrawn. - 8. There are no further changes to NSPI's Application...
AI summary The document outlines agreements and decisions made in a regulatory proceeding involving NSPI, including the application of excess earnings, withdrawal of a fuel cost deferral request, and the adoption of a revenue-to-cost ratio methodology. It also addresses ongoing obligations related to OM&G studies and future regulatory positions.
58003Participant responses to Preliminary Issues List for P-886
3 passages
rom. tecent rate c~ses; and - ROE, ccwital s.tructtrre and return on rate base were fully reviewed and decided effective Mtzy 19. 2005, and re-confirmed in the most recent de~sion on March 10., 2006. The Preliminary lssues List includes (i...
AI summary The document discusses past reviews of NSPI's fuel and OM&G costs, noting that previous rate cases have already addressed these issues. The Board has acknowledged NSPI's improvements and clarified that past imprudence will not affect future years. NSPI proposes that a separate review back to 2000 is not necessary, and suggests maintaining OM&G expenses constant in the 2007 test year.
Specific Proposed Issues NSPI offers the following comments in respect of the specific issues contained in the proposed list: - 1. FuelRelated Issues Each ofthe pxaposed items in this topic arise in the NSPI Application Evidence. NSPI note...
AI summary NSPI provides comments on specific proposed issues in the proceeding, addressing fuel-related matters, compliance directives, deferred items, OM&G costs, financial issues, and existing regulations. It emphasizes the need for clarity on certain items and suggests removing some topics from the Issues List to streamline the process.
General NSPI supports the schedule put forth by the Board, and notes that it can be achieved through a focus on the material issues which have caused this application to be filed and which affect the 2007 test year. A focused Issues List w...
AI summary NSPI supports the Board's proposed schedule and suggests narrowing the issues list to avoid duplication of recent reviews. The Company highlights ongoing and completed reviews by the Board and third-party consultants, such as Liberty and Accenture, and notes that many aspects of its operations have already been addressed.
86477Submission - Re: Rate Hearing Future Filing Requirements
7 passages
III. Financial Information / Capital Structure / ROE - (a) Presentations made by NSPl / Emera to Analysts and Bondholders - (b) Most Recent Emera Proxy Statement - (c) Financial Statements, Annual Repo1ts, Etc. - (d) Average Capital and Co...
AI summary The document outlines various financial and operational topics related to Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and Emera, including capital structure, return on equity (ROE), financial statements, debt financing, and cost of service. It also covers load forecasting and operational and maintenance (OM&G) cost breakdowns.
III. Financial Information / Capital Structure / ROE - (a) Presentations made by NSPI I Emera to Analysts and Bondholders - 18. Financial presentations made by NSPI and its parent company Emera offer an insight into the financial health of...
AI summary The document discusses financial presentations made by NSPI and its parent company Emera to financial analysts and bondholders, highlighting the relevance of these materials to capital structure and financing issues. SEB requests that all such presentations be filed with NSPI's Application, emphasizing their importance in assessing the approved Rate of Return.
(b) Most Recent Emera Proxy Statement 19. In P-886, SEB IR-143 requested "a copy of the most recent proxy statement for Emera shareholders." SEB submits: that NSPI should file with its Application Emera's most recent proxy statement to sha...
AI summary SEB requested a copy of Emera's most recent proxy statement, arguing that it is relevant to Capital Structure and Financing issues, specifically SPI's approved Rate of Return.
(c) Financial Statements and Annual Reports 20. In P-886, the Board filed a series of Information Requests (UARB IR-76 to 81) that requested the most recent financial statements and annual reports from NSPI and Emera. CME IR-27 also reques...
AI summary The Board filed several information requests (UARB IR-76 to 81) and CME IR-27, asking for financial statements and annual reports from NSPI and Emera. SEB argues that NSPI should provide these documents, along with reports from financial analysts or bondholders, to support the determination of capital structure and financing issues.
(d) Average Capital and Cost of Capital 21. In P-886, NSPI included Table 13 in Appendix 1 of its direct evidence. This table sets out the forecasted Average Capital and Cost of Capital for the test period. SEB submits: that in addition to...
AI summary The document discusses the need for NSPI to provide a rate of return schedule, including capital structure and cost components, to support its financial assumptions for the test year, as requested by SEB in P-886.
OJ Financial Ratios 27. Financial ratios are an analytical element that provides insight into a utility's financial condition. SEB submits: that NSPI be required to file at the time of its Application, all financial ratios and supporting c...
AI summary SEB argues that NSPI should be required to file all financial ratios and supporting calculations at the time of its application to help parties understand NSPI's financial condition and analyze its requested return on equity (ROE).
on any fuel supply or transportation studies that have been conducted. This information may play an essential role in the evaluation of the prudency of NSPI's current fuel transportation arrangements. - 15. SEB submits: that NSPI be requir...
AI summary SEB recommends that NSPI provide detailed information on fuel transportation costs, legislative requirements, emissions targets, force majeure provisions, and financial presentations to ensure transparency and prudence in its operations and financing arrangements.