Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Stakeholder Engagement" in M04819

Matter: E-ENSC-R-12 - Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation - Application for Approval of its Demand Side Management (DSM) Plan for 2013 - 2015
114 passages 23 documents

Stakeholder Engagement across all matters →

E-2Evidence of ENSC as DSM Administrator 32 passages
DATE FILED: February 27, 2012 Page 1 of 45 p. pp. 3-5
DATE FILED: February 27, 2012 Page 1 of 45 1 The June 30, 2011 UARB Order also directed ENSC to: 2 3  engage stakeholders regarding changes to the Program Development 4 Working Group (PDWG) or the creation of a new stakeholder process – 5...

AI summary The UARB directed ENSC to engage stakeholders regarding changes to the Program Development Working Group, meet quarterly with UARB staff, and provide enhanced information on rate and bill impacts for the 2013 DSM Plan. ENSC was also ordered to review cost allocation methodology and address three issues related to CFL disposal, financing, and savings evaluations.

Section 6 p. p. 5
To aid in the preparation of the 2013-2015 DSM Plan, ENSC retained the advice and assistance of Navigant, Dunsky Energy Consulting (Dunsky) and Elenchus Research Associates Inc. (Elenchus). ENSC also received input and counsel from DSM sta...

AI summary ENSC worked with consultants and stakeholders to develop the 2013-2015 DSM Plan, drawing on prior experience and engaging in multiple consultation sessions. Topics discussed include cost allocation methodologies and multi-year DSM planning frameworks.

Section 8 p. p. 6
The PDWG has proven to be a valuable resource and stakeholder forum. It has provided advice and guidance on the design and implementation of DSM programs, beginning with the development of the 2008-09 DSM Plan by NSPI and continuing throug...

AI summary The PDWG has been a key stakeholder forum for DSM program design and implementation, from the 2008-09 DSM Plan to the transition of responsibilities to ENSC in 2010. Stakeholders supported its continuation during UARB hearings for the 2011 and 2012 DSM Plans, and ENSC was directed to report on its review as part of the 2013 DSM Plan. The group evolved into the DSM Advisory Group with a re-focused role and expanded membership.

Preamble p. pp. 7-82
ENSC recognizes that many Nova Scotians have little knowledge of the value of and opportunities provided by DSM. With that in mind, ENSC's Board of Directors has emphasized the need to engage Nova Scotians more broadly in building awarenes...

AI summary ENSC recognizes the need to increase public awareness and engagement in energy efficiency through various outreach efforts, including partnerships with community groups, traditional and non-traditional media, and public speaking initiatives like the 'Take Charge!' tour.

2.3 2011 DSM Programs p. pp. 11-12
2.3 2011 DSM Programs In its first full year of operation, ENSC built awareness as the new place for Nova Scotians to go for energy efficiency solutions, largely through the promotion of its programs, advertising, media opportunities and o...

AI summary ENSC expanded outreach through online presence and targeted low-income programs in 2011, exceeding energy savings targets and increasing participation. They provided free upgrades to renters and homeowners, achieving significant energy savings.

3.4 Quarterly Meetings and Reports p. pp. 17-18
3.4 Quarterly Meetings and Reports ENSC recommends that it continue to meet quarterly with the UARB. Regular meetings with the DSM Advisory Group will provide ongoing opportunities to update stakeholders and discuss issues and concerns. Th...

AI summary ENSC proposes quarterly meetings with UARB and the DSM Advisory Group to update stakeholders, discuss issues, and provide status updates on the DSM Plan. Reports will highlight progress and communicate changes to the approved DSM Plan.

Section 48 p. p. 27
va Scotians' participation and to ultimately help change behaviour around energy efficiency, the Corporation is committed to education and outreach, with a DATE FILED: February 27, 2012 Page 27 of 45 growing emphasis on a more community-ba...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) is committed to promoting energy efficiency through education, outreach, and a community-based approach. ENSC aims to provide individualized energy solutions and improve customer service. It also emphasizes collaboration with trade allies to strengthen the energy efficiency industry and promote energy-efficient codes and standards.

ENSC's Response: p. p. 39
ENSC's Response: ENSC recognizes that lack of financial capital may be a barrier to customers adopting energy efficiency measures. Removal of this barrier could increase participation in energy efficiency programs and therefore increase en...

AI summary ENSC acknowledges financial barriers to energy efficiency and proposes on-bill financing with NSPI and other partners. Discussions include expanding financing options, leveraging bank partnerships, and using rebates for mortgage down payments. Cost-benefit analyses will guide program implementation in 2012.

2.3 New Residential p. pp. 57-60
2.3 New Residential awareness of this opportunity. The New Residential services are available to builders and owner/builders of new houses in Nova Scotia, to encourage the construction of high performance housing by promoting the use of en...

AI summary The New Residential program by ENSC aims to promote energy-efficient construction in Nova Scotia through incentives, design consultation, and marketing. It targets builders to exceed building code energy efficiency requirements, using EnerGuide ratings and tiered incentives. Collaboration with municipalities and CMHC is emphasized to enhance participation and mortgage eligibility.

1 4.0 ENABLING STRATEGIES p. pp. 70-72
1 4.0 ENABLING STRATEGIES 2 3 Enabling Strategies include the following elements: 4 5  Education and Outreach 6  Development and Research 7  Innovative Financing 8  Capacity Building 9  Working with Governments 10 11 Enabling Strategi...

AI summary Enabling Strategies include Education and Outreach, Development and Research, Innovative Financing, Capacity Building, and Working with Governments. These strategies aim to support energy savings through ENSC's DSM services and drive market transformation by changing industry practices through training, labeling, and regulation.

1 ENSC is evaluating several financing options, including potential opportunities to p. p. 74
develop capacity to meet future needs 1 ENSC is evaluating several financing options, including potential opportunities to 23  enhancing existing training and quality assurance for its delivery agents 24  identifying and assessing needs...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENSC) is developing a long-term training strategy and exploring financing options to meet future needs. It plans to enhance training for delivery agents, collaborate with educational institutions, and build partnerships with retailers and distributors to promote energy-efficient products.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS p. p. 82
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS In preparing this report, we benefitted from the collaboration, insights and experience of ENSC's Senior Management, including notably Allan Crandlemire, John Aguinaga and Chuck Faulkner. We also appreciate the thoughtful...

AI summary The report acknowledges collaboration with ENSC's Senior Management, including Allan Crandlemire, John Aguinaga, and Chuck Faulkner, as well as input from stakeholders during consultations on November 3rd and December 8th, 2011. The authors retain sole responsibility for the report's content.

Section 117 p. p. 82
Dunsky Energy Consulting was tasked by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) with reviewing the oversight framework that currently applies to its Demand-Side Management plans. Specifically, we were tasked with identifying opportunities...

AI summary Dunsky Energy Consulting reviewed the oversight framework for Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation's (ENSC) Demand-Side Management (DSM) plans, identifying strengths such as stakeholder trust and operational flexibility, but highlighting the limited one-year approval period as a major hindrance that creates market uncertainty and operational challenges.

The chart below illustrates the recommended approach, including both the regulatory and extraregulatory oversight mechanisms. p. p. 82
The chart below illustrates the recommended approach, including both the regulatory and extraregulatory oversight mechanisms. THREE-YEAR PLAN 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Multi-Year Plan F H A...

AI summary The text presents a chart outlining the recommended approach for regulatory and extraregulatory oversight mechanisms within a three-year plan, detailing various activities such as filings, hearings, meetings, reports, and approvals by the Board of Directors and the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board.

MANDATE p. p. 82
MANDATE Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) has tasked us with reviewing the current regulatory oversight model and proposing changes that may be useful toward improving the Corporation's ability to assist Nova Scotians in saving ene...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) is reviewing the current regulatory oversight model to enhance its ability to improve energy efficiency in Nova Scotia. The review aims to ensure recommendations do not hinder the UARB and stakeholders from tracking ENSC's performance. Consultations with ENSC's Board of Directors, management, and stakeholders in November and December 2011 informed the recommendations.

OBJECTIVES: A BALANCED, EFFECTIVE APPROACH p. pp. 82-89
OBJECTIVES: A BALANCED, EFFECTIVE APPROACH The purpose of this mandate is to recommend changes needed to arrive at an effective, balanced regulatory oversight approach for ENSC. While these are subjective terms, we have focused on ensuring...

AI summary The mandate aims to recommend regulatory changes for ENSC to ensure effective oversight through three keys: performance drivers for DSM success, market latitude for energy efficiency, and stakeholder oversight. ENSC must avoid disincentives, have flexibility to influence markets, and allow public scrutiny of ratepayer contributions.

2. MARKET CREDIBILITY p. p. 89
2. MARKET CREDIBILITY For ENSC to succeed in transforming markets toward greater energy efficiency, it will need to convince a wide array of market actors to invest in new business lines, procurement processes, and other ventures. For exam...

AI summary ENSC requires market actors to invest in training and certification programs for energy efficiency, including retrofit contractors, HVAC vendors, and building professionals. Success depends on sustained demand for these services, necessitating collaboration with educational institutions and private training organizations.

#4. QUARTERLY MEETINGS & REPORTS p. p. 89
#4. QUARTERLY MEETINGS & REPORTS In order to maximize transparency, to ensure that stakeholders and the UARB are kept apprised of results as they evolve, and to provide opportunity to discuss concerns and/or make suggestions to ENSC, we re...

AI summary The document recommends maintaining quarterly meetings with the UARB and stakeholders, transitioning the Program Development Working Group to a DSM Advisory Group for strategic discussions, and distributing savings reports prior to meetings. No changes to UARB meetings are proposed, while stakeholder engagement is to be restructured.

The following table provides an overview of the oversight process we have recommended, while also indicating the extra-regulatory oversight involved. p. p. 89
The following table provides an overview of the oversight process we have recommended, while also indicating the extra-regulatory oversight involved. THREE-YEAR PLAN 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4...

AI summary The text outlines a three-year oversight process with regulatory filings, hearings, meetings, and reports, emphasizing ongoing activities and approvals by the Board of Directors and the Utility and Review Board.

1 INTRODUCTION p. pp. 107-110
1 INTRODUCTION Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") filed its first Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Plan, known officially as the Demand Side Management Plan for 2012 ("2012 DSM Plan") on February 28, 2011. The 2012 DSM Plan...

AI summary ENSC filed its 2012 DSM Plan, including cost allocation methods approved by the UARB. The Board directed ENSC to develop a cost allocation model and policy for tracking time and costs, leading to the 2013-2015 DSM Plan. Elenchus was retained to assist with cost allocation, stakeholder consultation, and rate impact analysis.

2 REVIEW OF ENSC'S COST ALLOCATION PROCESSES p. pp. 111-113
sts in a manner that reflects cost causality. The principles on which ENSC's CAM is based are discussed in the next section. Elenchus has developed a cost allocation model that consists of two parts: - Part One allocates all cost to progra...

AI summary ENSC's Cost Allocation Model (CAM) developed by Elenchus has two parts: Part One allocates costs for audited financial statements using a methodology filed with UARB in 2011, while Part Two addresses ratepayer-funded DSM costs starting in 2013, aligning with the 2009 Settlement Agreement. Stakeholder feedback was sought in 2011.

E-ENSC-R-12 p. p. 123
E-ENSC-R-12 Line# 1 ABLE 1 (2015) Alloca ation of 25% of p rogram cos ts associated with system ben efits Existing New Homes Constructi Efficient products Home Energy Report Prescriptive Custom Small Business Education & Outreach Developme...

AI summary The document presents a table detailing the allocation of program costs associated with system benefits in 2015, including various categories such as efficient products, home energy reports, and education & outreach. The table includes figures for different program categories and their respective costs.

CHANNELS p. p. 202
CHANNELS The Green Heating Systems initiative will focus primarily on existing HVAC channels, as well as on direct marketing to homes heated with electric baseboard, to promote Green Heating Systems. In order to add additional value, the i...

AI summary The Green Heating Systems initiative targets existing HVAC channels and homes with electric baseboard heating, promoting ENSC's EnerGuide for Houses and Performance Plus programs with enhanced incentives.

MARKETING p. p. 202
MARKETING ENSC will conduct marketing and outreach activities to increase awareness and confidence in Green Heating Systems. Marketing strategies would outline the key green heat systems being offered, their characteristics, as well as the...

AI summary ENSC will implement marketing strategies to promote Green Heating Systems, emphasizing system characteristics, selection factors, and case studies. Materials will encourage a holistic view of home energy performance to build customer confidence.

Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program p. pp. 235-236
Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program Josh McLean ENSC Program Manager DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session November 3, 2011

AI summary The document outlines a Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program under Nova Scotia's Demand Side Management (DSM) initiative, with ENSC's Josh McLean leading a stakeholder consultation on November 3, 2011. Key entities include ENSC, DSM, and the consultation session, focusing on regulatory proceedings and energy efficiency programs.

How to take part p. pp. 238-239
How to take part - 1. Send pre-approval application form to ENSC - 2. Receive approval - 3. Purchase and install qualifying equipment - 4. Send in rebate application form and supporting docs - 5. Receive rebate cheque

AI summary The process outlines steps for participating in a rebate program managed by ENSC: submitting pre-approval, purchasing qualifying equipment, and applying for rebates. The procedure emphasizes administrative steps rather than technical or regulatory debates.

Marketing Initiatives p. pp. 240-241
Marketing Initiatives - Direct mail-out to all homes with access to natural gas - Collaboration with Wood Energy Technology Transfer (WETT) Nova Scotia - Newspaper and radio advertising - Cape Breton - Remainder of the Province - Online -...

AI summary Marketing initiatives include direct mail to natural gas homes, collaboration with WETT Nova Scotia, regional newspaper/radio ads, and online campaigns via Facebook, ViewPoint, and the Efficiency Nova Scotia website. These efforts aim to promote energy efficiency programs.

Green Schools Nova Scotia p. pp. 245-246
Green Schools Nova Scotia Laura Sinclair ENSC Program Manager DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session November 3, 2011

AI summary A DSM stakeholder consultation session on November 3, 2011, led by Laura Sinclair of ENSC, focused on Green Schools Nova Scotia initiatives. The session aimed to discuss energy efficiency programs and demand-side management strategies in Nova Scotia.

Overview: p. pp. 246-248
Overview: - Goal: enhance sustainability initiatives in NS schools and engage students through education and participation. - Step-by-step, long-term, whole school process - Working with Clean NS to deliver the pilot program in 2011 - 2011...

AI summary The document outlines a pilot program in Nova Scotia aimed at enhancing sustainability in schools through education and student engagement. Clean NS is collaborating with the NS Minister of Education to implement the initiative, targeting 10-15 schools by 2011. Key components include an energy tracking system, an interactive website, and involvement of 17 schools and 8 school boards.

Efficiency Nova Scotia Demonstration Homes p. pp. 250-251
Efficiency Nova Scotia Demonstration Homes Laura Sinclair ENSC Program Manager DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session November 3, 2011

AI summary A DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session held on November 3, 2011, involving Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) and its Program Manager Laura Sinclair, discussing demonstration homes and energy efficiency initiatives under Nova Scotia's regulatory framework.

• Overview: p. pp. 251-253
• Overview: - Formerly known as Advanced Houses and EcoHome - Goal: Educate the general public, residential construction industry, government and special interest groups on the importance of (and new technologies in) energy efficiency in n...

AI summary The EnerGuide for Houses (EGH) program, previously known as Advanced Houses and EcoHome, aims to promote energy efficiency in new home construction through collaboration with the NS Home Builders' Association. Two model homes built by Denim Homes and Whitestone Developments achieved EnerGuide ratings of 96 and 94, respectively, and were marketed via public events, media, and digital campaigns to raise awareness.

• Key Learnings: p. pp. 253-256
• Key Learnings: - Latest technologies in energy efficient home construction - Realistic, affordable components to implement into any new home - Reduces owners' carbon footprint while saving them money - Represents the future of the reside...

AI summary Highlights advancements in energy-efficient home construction, emphasizing cost-effective solutions that reduce carbon footprints and save money, positioning them as the future of residential building. The program will continue promoting these technologies through Open Houses and online education.

E-2(r)Revised ENSC Evidence 28 passages
DATE FILED: February 27, 2012 Page 1 of 45 p. pp. 3-5
DATE FILED: February 27, 2012 Page 1 of 45 1 The June 30, 2011 UARB Order also directed ENSC to: 2 3  engage stakeholders regarding changes to the Program Development 4 Working Group (PDWG) or the creation of a new stakeholder process – 5...

AI summary The UARB directed ENSC to engage stakeholders regarding changes to the Program Development Working Group, meet quarterly with UARB staff, and provide enhanced information on rate and bill impacts for the 2013 DSM Plan. ENSC was also ordered to review the cost allocation methodology and address issues related to CFL disposal, financing, and savings evaluations.

Section 6 p. p. 5
To aid in the preparation of the 2013-2015 DSM Plan, ENSC retained the advice and assistance of Navigant, Dunsky Energy Consulting (Dunsky) and Elenchus Research Associates Inc. (Elenchus). ENSC also received input and counsel from DSM sta...

AI summary ENSC worked with consultants and stakeholders to develop the 2013-2015 DSM Plan, building on prior experience and engaging in multiple consultation sessions to refine the framework and cost allocation methodologies.

Section 8 p. p. 6
The PDWG has proven to be a valuable resource and stakeholder forum. It has provided advice and guidance on the design and implementation of DSM programs, beginning with the development of the 2008-09 DSM Plan by NSPI and continuing throug...

AI summary The PDWG has been a valuable stakeholder forum for advising on the design and implementation of DSM programs. After the transition of DSM responsibilities to ENSC in 2010, stakeholders supported its continuation. ENSC was directed by the UARB to file results of its review as part of the 2013 DSM Plan. The PDWG evolved into the DSM Advisory Group with a re-focused role and expanded membership.

Preamble p. pp. 7-90
ENSC recognizes that many Nova Scotians have little knowledge of the value of and opportunities provided by DSM. With that in mind, ENSC's Board of Directors has emphasized the need to engage Nova Scotians more broadly in building awarenes...

AI summary ENSC has undertaken extensive outreach to increase public awareness and engagement with energy efficiency through various channels, including partnerships with community groups, media appearances, public speaking tours, and social media. These efforts aim to educate Nova Scotians about the benefits of DSM and encourage behavioral change.

1 2. 2011 DSM RESULTS p. pp. 7-9
1 2. 2011 DSM RESULTS 2

AI summary This section outlines the 2011 Demand Side Management (DSM) results, including program outcomes and regulatory considerations involving Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC), Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), and the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (UARB).

2.3 2011 DSM Programs p. p. 12
encouraging homeowners to take advantage of other programs. While onsite, ENSC's direct install agents may identify additional opportunities for the homeowner to save energy through building envelope & lt;sup>2 Includes Low Income Homeowne...

AI summary In 2011, ENSC implemented DSM programs including direct installs, community engagement with First Nations, and two pilots: Green Schools (16 schools) and Demonstration Homes (5,500 visitors). Programs aimed to promote energy efficiency, train youth, and highlight affordable solutions. Low-income and EnerGuide programs were also promoted.

4. 2013-2015 DSM PLAN p. pp. 18-19
4. 2013-2015 DSM PLAN

AI summary The 2013-2015 DSM Plan section outlines Nova Scotia's demand-side management initiatives. Key entities include Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC), Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), and the Utility and Review Board (UARB). The plan involves program development and regulatory oversight.

4.1 Summary p. p. 19
4.1 Summary ENSC's 2013-2015 DSM Plan, presented in Appendix A, is a multi-year plan, which identifies proposed DSM programs, services, and strategies, and annual investment and energy savings targets, for 2013, 2014 and 2015. The plan bui...

AI summary ENSC's 2013-2015 DSM Plan introduces a customer-focused approach to energy efficiency, replacing program-specific outreach with personalized solutions. It emphasizes cultural change through public education, community engagement, and long-term behavior modification, building on prior DSM strategies. The plan aims to simplify customer interactions and sustain energy savings through social marketing.

ENSC's Response: p. p. 39
ENSC's Response: ENSC recognizes that lack of financial capital may be a barrier to customers adopting energy efficiency measures. Removal of this barrier could increase participation in energy efficiency programs and therefore increase en...

AI summary ENSC acknowledges financial barriers hinder energy efficiency adoption and proposes on-bill financing with NSPI and other partners to expand DSM participation. Discussions include bank partnerships and leveraging rebates for broader program access, with cost-benefit analyses planned for 2012 implementation.

6.3 A Dual Baseline Approach for Savings Evaluations p. pp. 39-40
6.3 A Dual Baseline Approach for Savings Evaluations

AI summary The document proposes a dual baseline approach for evaluating energy savings in Nova Scotia's regulatory proceedings. Key entities include Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) and Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI), with acronyms related to demand-side management, cost recovery, and regulatory testing. The approach aims to improve savings evaluation methodologies under the Utility and Review Board's oversight.

1 4.0 ENABLING STRATEGIES p. pp. 71-73
1 4.0 ENABLING STRATEGIES 2 3 Enabling Strategies include the following elements: 4 5  Education and Outreach 6  Development and Research 7  Innovative Financing 8  Capacity Building 9  Working with Governments 10 11 Enabling Strategi...

AI summary Enabling Strategies include education and outreach, development and research, innovative financing, capacity building, and working with governments. These strategies aim to support energy savings through participation in DSM services and drive market transformation by changing industry practices through training and regulation.

1 ENSC is evaluating several financing options, including potential opportunities to p. p. 75
develop capacity to meet future needs 1 ENSC is evaluating several financing options, including potential opportunities to 23  enhancing existing training and quality assurance for its delivery agents 24  identifying and assessing needs...

AI summary ENSC is evaluating financing options and developing a long-term training strategy to enhance its delivery agents' capabilities and address training gaps. It is also focusing on market channels to promote energy-efficient products and coordinate with stakeholders.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS p. p. 83
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS In preparing this report, we benefitted from the collaboration, insights and experience of ENSC's Senior Management, including notably Allan Crandlemire, John Aguinaga and Chuck Faulkner. We also appreciate the thoughtful...

AI summary The report acknowledges collaboration with ENSC's senior management and stakeholder input from November 2011 and December 2011 consultations. The authors take full responsibility for the report's content and any errors.

Section 121 p. p. 83
Dunsky Energy Consulting was tasked by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) with reviewing the oversight framework that currently applies to its Demand-Side Management plans. Specifically, we were tasked with identifying opportunities...

AI summary Dunsky Energy Consulting reviewed the oversight framework for ENSC's Demand-Side Management (DSM) plans, identifying strengths such as stakeholder trust and operational flexibility, while highlighting the hindrance of a limited 12-month approval period that creates uncertainty and may lead to missed savings and diverted focus.

MANDATE p. p. 83
MANDATE Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) has tasked us with reviewing the current regulatory oversight model and proposing changes that may be useful toward improving the Corporation's ability to assist Nova Scotians in saving ene...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) is reviewing the regulatory oversight model to enhance its energy efficiency programs while ensuring the UARB and stakeholders can track and oversee ENSC's performance. Consultations with ENSC's Board of Directors, senior management, and stakeholders informed the recommendations.

#4. QUARTERLY MEETINGS & REPORTS p. p. 90
#4. QUARTERLY MEETINGS & REPORTS In order to maximize transparency, to ensure that stakeholders and the UARB are kept apprised of results as they evolve, and to provide opportunity to discuss concerns and/or make suggestions to ENSC, we re...

AI summary The text recommends quarterly meetings with the UARB and stakeholders, suggests transitioning the Program Development Working Group (PDWG) to a DSM Advisory Group for strategic discussions, and emphasizes distributing savings reports before meetings to ensure transparency and stakeholder engagement.

1 INTRODUCTION p. pp. 108-111
1 INTRODUCTION Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") filed its first Electricity Efficiency and Conservation Plan, known officially as the Demand Side Management Plan for 2012 ("2012 DSM Plan") on February 28, 2011. The 2012 DSM Plan...

AI summary ENSC filed its 2012 DSM Plan, with the UARB confirming the DSM cost allocation approach. The Board ordered ENSC to develop a cost tracking policy and review DSM allocation methods. ENSC retained Elenchus to create a cost allocation model, analyze rate impacts, and prepare preliminary tables for the 2013-2015 DSM Plan.

2 REVIEW OF ENSC'S COST ALLOCATION PROCESSES p. pp. 113-114
and in recommending changes to the DSM Cost Allocation Approach was presented to stakeholders for comment and feedback at the two Stakeholder Sessions conducted by ENSC in November and December 2011. - Mr. Todd's presentation at the Novemb...

AI summary The document outlines stakeholder sessions in 2011 where ENSC presented its DSM cost allocation approach. Key issues included maintaining a 25%/75% benefit split from the 2009 Settlement Agreement and replacing the customer-count allocator with a system/participant benefit approach for Enabling Strategies. Elenchus recommended continuing EDSM cost allocation to NSPI rate classes.

4 Relative shares of program costs incurred on particpating rate classes before Municipal Class p. p. 124
4 Relative shares of program costs incurred on particpating rate classes before Municipal Class Existing New Efficient Home Energy Small Education & Development Other Enabling 5 Program Homes Construction Products Report Prescriptive Custo...

AI summary This table presents the relative shares of program costs incurred across various rate classes before the Municipal Class. The data highlights the distribution of costs among different categories such as residential, small general, and industrial rate classes for various programs including Home Energy Report and Education & Outreach.

MARKETING p. p. 203
MARKETING ENSC will conduct marketing and outreach activities to increase awareness and confidence in Green Heating Systems. Marketing strategies would outline the key green heat systems being offered, their characteristics, as well as the...

AI summary ENSC will implement marketing strategies to promote Green Heating Systems, including outlining system characteristics, providing case studies, and emphasizing comprehensive home energy performance considerations.

Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program p. pp. 236-237
Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program Josh McLean ENSC Program Manager DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session November 3, 2011

AI summary The Fuel Switching / Substitution Pilot Program is discussed in the context of a DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session held on November 3, 2011, with Josh McLean, ENSC Program Manager, involved. The session focuses on demand-side management initiatives in Nova Scotia.

How to take part p. pp. 239-240
How to take part - 1. Send pre-approval application form to ENSC - 2. Receive approval - 3. Purchase and install qualifying equipment - 4. Send in rebate application form and supporting docs - 5. Receive rebate cheque

AI summary The document outlines a five-step process for participating in a rebate program: submitting a pre-approval application to ENSC, receiving approval, purchasing qualifying equipment, submitting a rebate application with documentation, and receiving a rebate cheque. The process emphasizes program administration through ENSC.

Marketing Initiatives p. pp. 241-242
Marketing Initiatives - Direct mail-out to all homes with access to natural gas - Collaboration with Wood Energy Technology Transfer (WETT) Nova Scotia - Newspaper and radio advertising - Cape Breton - Remainder of the Province - Online -...

AI summary Marketing initiatives include direct mail to natural gas homes, collaboration with WETT Nova Scotia, newspaper and radio advertising in Cape Breton and the province, and online outreach via Facebook, ViewPoint, and the Efficiency Nova Scotia website.

Green Schools Nova Scotia p. pp. 246-247
Green Schools Nova Scotia Laura Sinclair ENSC Program Manager DSM Stakeholder Consultation Session November 3, 2011

AI summary A DSM stakeholder consultation session, led by Laura Sinclair of Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation, took place on November 3, 2011, as part of the Green Schools Nova Scotia initiative to discuss demand-side management programs.

Overview: p. pp. 247-249
Overview: - Goal: enhance sustainability initiatives in NS schools and engage students through education and participation. - Step-by-step, long-term, whole school process - Working with Clean NS to deliver the pilot program in 2011 - 2011...

AI summary The initiative aims to enhance sustainability in Nova Scotia schools through a long-term pilot program with Clean NS, targeting 10-15 schools by 2011. Supported by the NS Minister of Education, the program involves 17 schools, 8 school boards, an energy tracking system, and an interactive website for student engagement.

• Key Learnings: p. pp. 254-258
• Key Learnings: - Latest technologies in energy efficient home construction - Realistic, affordable components to implement into any new home - Reduces owners' carbon footprint while saving them money - Represents the future of the reside...

AI summary The document highlights advancements in energy-efficient home construction, emphasizing cost-effective solutions that reduce carbon footprints and save money. It outlines the continuation of the Efficiency NS Demonstration Homes program through open houses, promotions, and educational resources, positioning energy-efficient technologies as the future of residential construction in Nova Scotia.

The Future of Housing in Nova Scotia p. pp. 260-261
o being recognized for their achievements, both of these companies were given a unique opportunity to showcase their skills and work with the latest technology in energy effi cient home constructi on. Despite a damp start to the summer, co...

AI summary The document details the construction of energy-efficient demonstration homes in Nova Scotia, highlighting collaboration with Efficiency Nova Scotia (ENSC) and the Nova Scotia Home Builders' Association (NSHBA). The project included public outreach via media and social platforms, with homes to be completed by October 1st for public viewing. Denim Homes was involved, and the initiative received media coverage and high-profile visits.

Efficiency Nova Scotia is committed to providing energy saving to Nova Scotians. p. p. 272
Efficiency Nova Scotia is committed to providing energy saving to Nova Scotians. Contact us to find out how we can help you save money on your power bill. It's easy. So why not do it now? Like us on Facebook w: efficiencyns.ca e: info@effi...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia promotes energy-saving initiatives for Nova Scotians, offering assistance in reducing power bills. The text includes contact information, social media links, and a focus on customer engagement through outreach.

E-3ENSC 2011 DSM Evaluation Report prepared by Econoler 5 passages
Section 179
ng an effective marketing strategy is also identified as a barrier to the program. The participant survey results show that 13 percent of respondents recommended that the program be better advertised. In order to improve the program, the t...

AI summary The document discusses participant perspectives on program awareness and enrolment, noting that 46% learned about the program through traditional media, 21% through direct mail, and 20% through word of mouth. It identifies marketing as a key factor in customer awareness and suggests improving the program through better advertising and a more complex tracking system for recycling units.

Section 1624
tion of the partner.) No Don’t know Q15a- What was the complaint about? Q16 – In your opinion, what are the main barriers to the implementation of that program by order of importance? Ref.: 5725 75 Low Income Program Efficiency Nova Scotia...

AI summary The document is an evaluation report and interview guide related to the Low Income Program by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation from 2011. It includes questions about program implementation barriers and participant expectations, emphasizing confidentiality and outreach processes.

Section 1683
indings. Indeed, in 2010, the main sources of awareness were builders, publications (newspapers or renovation guides) and home shows. Table 4: Program Awareness

AI summary The text discusses program awareness in 2010, noting that builders, publications, and home shows were the main sources of awareness.

Section 1764
e Guide Q: On the Web site we see only incentives to electricity measures. In the program manual we have both incentives coming from rate-payer funds and coming from provincial funds, Why is that? Ref.: 5725 Performance Plus Program Effici...

AI summary The document contains questions and clarifications regarding the Performance Plus Program, including the source of funding, program name changes, and the involvement of multiple stakeholders. Questions focus on incentives, program implementation, and data collection practices.

Section 2465
lved in the delivery of that program? Yes: If yes, from which party? (Please do not mention names, just the position of the party.) No Don’t know Q14a- What was the complaint about? Ref.: 5725 54 Small Business Energy Solutions Program Eff...

AI summary The text is part of an evaluation report for the Small Business Energy Solutions Program by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation. It includes a questionnaire for electricians and program partners to identify barriers to program implementation and gather feedback for improving performance.

E-4Letters of Comment 3 passages
1. Legalese text discourages the general public's participation and understanding p. p. 1
1. Legalese text discourages the general public's participation and understanding The letter of request is supposedly available to all Nova Scotians for review prior to final decision or approval by the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board...

AI summary The letter of request, intended for public review by the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board, is criticized for being overly complex and written in legalese, making it inaccessible to the general public. The argument is that it should be simplified for broader understanding.

14. The end must justify the means and the process must be fully understood by Nova Scotians who are 'footing the bill' for these endeavors. p. p. 1
14. The end must justify the means and the process must be fully understood by Nova Scotians who are 'footing the bill' for these endeavors. At this point, the entire process above seems mired in terminology and actions which are not at al...

AI summary The text emphasizes the need for transparency in processes funded by Nova Scotians, criticizing vague justifications for expenses and lack of stakeholder input. It argues that ratepayers must clearly see benefits from programs like Efficiency Nova Scotia Corp., comparing dubious initiatives to past misrepresentations of environmental issues.

Conclusions: p. p. 1
Conclusions: - It is necessary that the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board act in the best interest of all Nova Scotians . - Cost of Efficiency Nova Scotia Corp does not justify the return. The funding for various energy programs is much...

AI summary The text criticizes Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) for not justifying its costs, advocating for stakeholder input, and questioning its non-profit status. It disputes ENSC's survey validity, highlights concerns about increased electricity bills, and references Ontario's Auditor General findings. Solar energy's feasibility in Nova Scotia is also challenged.

E-5Savings Verification Report of the DSM Administrator's 2011 Demand Side Management Programs 1 passage
Scan America® Goals Statement p. p. 5
Scan America® Goals Statement - Excellence in the integration of knowledge, method, and practice - Improvement and learning at all levels - Contextually sound measurement, analysis, and reporting - Anticipate and meet the needs of our clie...

AI summary Scan America® outlines six core goals emphasizing integration of knowledge and practice, continuous improvement, contextually sound analysis, client-centricity, ethical research awareness, and innovation. The statement reflects organizational priorities in research and service delivery.

E-7ENSC (Avon) Responses to IR-1 to IR-27 (REDACTED) 2 passages
21
21 With DSM Case No DSM Case Corporate Communicat ons and Outreach Website Update (architecture) $100,000 0.5 0.5 Development of web-based customer resources, i.e. How to Videos $120,000 0.9 0.1 Website/extranet development $60,000 0.5 0.5...

AI summary The text presents a comparison of costs between scenarios with and without a Demand Side Management (DSM) case, focusing on corporate communications, outreach, education, and research activities. The table includes various expenditures such as website development, advertising, community outreach, and research initiatives.

23 c) The potential loss of significant load would be reflected in NSPI's avoided costs. Please 24 refer to Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14.
23 c) The potential loss of significant load would be reflected in NSPI's avoided costs. Please 24 refer to Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14. 1 Request IR-17: 2 3 Reference: 4.4 Capacity Building Programs (Appendix A, pp. 27-28) 4 5 a) Plea...

AI summary The text discusses the potential loss of significant load and its reflection in NSPI's avoided costs, referencing Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14. It also requests detailed information on training and associated expenses for capacity building programs for trade allies, specifically from ENSC in 2011 and 2012.

E-7(r)ENSC (Avon) Responses to IR-1 to IR-27 (REVISED) (REDACTED) 2 passages
21
21 With DSM Case No DSM Case Website Update (architecture) $100,000 0.5 0.5 Development of web-based customer resources, i.e. How to Videos $120,000 0.9 0.1 Website/extranet development $60,000 0.5 0.5 General corporate information materia...

AI summary The text outlines various costs and allocations related to corporate communication, outreach, education, and research activities, including website development, advertising, community outreach, and research on energy efficiency programs and market penetration.

23 c) The potential loss of significant load would be reflected in NSPI's avoided costs. Please 24 refer to Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14.
23 c) The potential loss of significant load would be reflected in NSPI's avoided costs. Please 24 refer to Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14. 1 Request IR-17: 2 3 Reference: 4.4 Capacity Building Programs (Appendix A, pp. 27-28) 4 5 a) Plea...

AI summary The text refers to the potential loss of significant load and its reflection in NSPI's avoided costs, citing Multeese IR-6 and Synapse IR-14. It also includes a request for details on training and associated expenses for capacity building programs for trade allies, with a response providing a table of training programs, participants, and costs for 2013, 2014, and 2015.

E-8ENSC (Bowater) Responses to IR-1 to IR-4 1 passage
1 Request IR-1:
1 Request IR-1: 2 3 Reference: ENSC Evidence, page 15, lines 5-9. "Dunsky recommends, and ENSC 4 concurs, that the UARB consider adopting a trigger mechanism whereby, if reported 5 results fall below 75 percent of the original plan's forec...

AI summary The text outlines a request and response regarding the adoption of a trigger mechanism for corrective action plans if energy savings fall below 75% of the original forecast. ENSC agrees to allow intervenors to comment on such plans and states that the plans would be included in annual progress reports, subject to stakeholder input and UARB direction.

E-9ENSC (Consumer Advocate) Responses to IR-1 to IR-27 1 passage
1 Request IR-1: p. p. 10
1 Request IR-1: 2 3 Please provide details of how ENSC plans to obtain the stakeholder views on program 4 design and implementation that was formerly provided by the Program Development 5 Working Group. 6 7 Response IR-1: 8 9 As part of it...

AI summary ENSC outlines its approach to obtaining stakeholder input on DSM program design and implementation through the DSM Advisory Group, which will meet quarterly and include various stakeholders such as the Consumer Advocate and Nova Scotia Department of Energy. The group will provide directional advice and consider items from the Utility and Review Board Decision.

E-21Direct Testimony of Paul Chernick (Consumer Advocate) 1 passage
PRESENTATIONS
tiveness Analysis." Presentation as part of "Effective DSM Collaborative Processes," a week-long training session for Ohio DSM advocates sponsored by the Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency, August 1993.

AI summary A presentation titled 'Effectiveness Analysis' was part of a week-long training session for Ohio DSM advocates, sponsored by the Ohio Office of Energy Efficiency in August 1993. The session focused on collaborative processes for demand-side management.

E-22Direct Testimony of George Foote (Consumer Advocate) 2 passages
Q. How should future DSM spending levels be established?
- stakeholders in advance of quarterly meetings, - ongoing tracking and a rolling schedule of full scale evaluations, and - a protective trigger mechanism in case of significant performance setbacks. - This represents a reasonable effort t...

AI summary The text proposes measures to ensure effective oversight of DSM spending, including quarterly meetings, ongoing tracking, and a rolling evaluation schedule. It suggests a phased transition to a three-year plan via a two-year DSM plan to test oversight mechanisms, recommending approval of the first two years of the 2013-2015 plan.

George R. Foote
nce on F/P/T and P/T policy and advisory committees. November 1984 - March 1995 Supervisor, Residential Energy Programs, Energy Management Division, Department of Natural Resources, Halifax, NS, - Managed staff of four engaged in delivery...

AI summary George R. Foote supervised residential energy programs in Nova Scotia from 1984-1995, managing staff, developing partnerships, and leading public education initiatives on energy efficiency, conservation, and renewables. He oversaw projects under the Canada-Nova Scotia Memorandum of Understanding on Energy Conservation.

E-23Direct Testimony of Tim Woolf (Synapse) 1 passage
Q. What conclusions do you draw from the information presented in Figure 4? p. p. 17
Q. What conclusions do you draw from the information presented in Figure 4? A. I do not intend to draw specific conclusions from the participation rates in Figure 4 as part of my testimony, because I see these participation rates as prelim...

AI summary The witness notes Figure 4's participation rates are preliminary and may include double-counting. However, they conclude that DSM programs will reach a large portion of Nova Scotia customers, leading to lower bills. Programs like the Home Energy Report and Efficient Product Rebate are expected to achieve high participation rates. The witness recommends maximizing participation to ensure equity and mitigate rate impacts.

E-25Evidence of Canadian Oil Heat Association - Nova Scotia 3 passages
4 Q. What is COHA-NS? p. p. 2
4 Q. What is COHA-NS? - A. The Canadian Oil Heat Association was established in 1983 by a group of fuel oil5 - dealers to work collectively on matters that affect the oilheat industry. Since then, COHA has6 - grown into a national body wit...

AI summary COHA-NS, established in 1983, represents Nova Scotia's home heating oil industry, advocating for policy, safety, and certification. It operates provincially with over 85 retailers, contributing to local employment and GDP. The sector supports communities through local ownership and charitable activities.

1 Q. What do you recommend? p. p. 2
1 Q. What do you recommend? - A. We recommend that the Board direct ENSC to adjust its DSM Plan to include incentives2 - to fuel switch to Energy Star (84%-97%) oilheat equipment technologies in both existing houses3 - and new construction...

AI summary Recommends adjusting ENSC's DSM Plan to include incentives for fuel switching to Energy Star oilheat equipment. COHA-NS seeks stakeholder recognition and inclusion of oilheat options in future programs. Background includes a 2009-2010 study by Navigant on fuel substitution potential.

Condensing Hydronic Boiler Field Experience p. p. 45
id="page-45-0"> Figure 22 Condensing boiler and complex distribution system, Walden, N.Y. BNL Participation In Field Trials of a New Condensing Boiler Design In its efforts to support the development of new high efficiency options for the...

AI summary BNL participated in field trials of a new condensing boiler developed with NORA and a private company. The boiler uses European heat exchanger and US components, achieving 93% AFUE. Tested in 2005/2006.

E-26Minutes of Settlement 4 passages
Minutes of Settlement
Minutes of Settlement WHEREAS on February 27, 2012, Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") filed the 2013-2015 Demand Side Management (DSM) Plan Evidence and 2011 DSM Plan Evaluation Report ("the Application") with the Nova Scotia Uti...

AI summary This document outlines the settlement agreement reached by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation regarding the 2013-2015 Demand Side Management (DSM) Plan Evidence and 2011 DSM Plan Evaluation Report. It notes the filing of evidence, revised hearing dates, and stakeholder engagement efforts.

Avoided Costs
Avoided Costs 7. The Parties acknowledge that review of the cost-effectiveness of ENSC programs will be facilitated by even greater transparency in the inputs and computations that support NSPI's avoided cost estimates. The Parties request...

AI summary The Parties request the UARB to direct NSPI to collaborate with ENSC and ratepayer representatives to enhance transparency in avoided cost estimates, with revised estimates due by June 1, 2013. ENSC will review these estimates and adjust programming as needed. If Integrated Resource Planning begins by January 1, 2013, separate ratepayer engagement on avoided costs isn't required.

Dual Baseline for Savings Evaluation
Dual Baseline for Savings Evaluation 8. The Parties agree that ENSC will conduct further consultation and analysis regarding dual baseline analysis and include this issue in its first Annual Progress Report to be filed with the UARB and St...

AI summary The Parties agree that ENSC will conduct further consultation and analysis on dual baseline analysis for savings evaluation. This issue will be included in ENSC's first Annual Progress Report submitted to the UARB and Stakeholders.

DSM Advisory Group
DSM Advisory Group - 11. The Parties support the transition from the Program Development Working Group (PDWG) to the DSM Advisory Group generally to provide strategic or directional advice and Stakeholder perspectives on current or emergin...

AI summary Parties support transitioning from the Program Development Working Group (PDWG) to the DSM Advisory Group for strategic advice and stakeholder input. ENSC agrees to collaborate with stakeholders on evaluating Enabling Strategies, refining rate impact methodologies, and improving customer participation tracking to prevent double-counting and enhance program targeting.

E-27ENSC Opening Statement 1 passage
Section 1 p. p. 0
Tuesday, May 29, 2012 Electricity Conservation & Efficiency (DSM) Plan 2013‐15 Hearing Before N.S. Utility and Review Board Opening Remarks by Allan Crandlemire CEO, Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY Good afternoon,...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia's CEO, Allan Crandlemire, emphasizes broad stakeholder consensus on the 2013-15 DSM Plan, highlighting collaboration with ratepayer groups, businesses, and industry players. The agreement ensures multi-year program certainty, supporting energy efficiency investments and stakeholder trust in Nova Scotia.

E-28Proof of Advertising 2 passages
NOVA SCOTIA UTILITY AND REVIEW BOARD NOTICE OF HEARING p. p. 4
NOVA SCOTIA UTILITY AND REVIEW BOARD NOTICE OF HEARING Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") has made an application to the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (the "Board") for approval of its Electricity Demand Side Management Pla...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) seeks approval from the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board for its 2013 Electricity Demand Side Management Plan (DSM). The hearing details include dates, procedures for public participation, and deadlines for filings. Matter No. M04819 is referenced.

NOVA SCOTIA UTILITY AND REVIEW BOARD NOTICE OF HEARING p. p. 5
NOVA SCOTIA UTILITY AND REVIEW BOARD NOTICE OF HEARING Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC") has made an application to the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board (the "Board") for approval of its Electricity Demand Side Management Pla...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) seeks approval for its 2013 Electricity Demand Side Management Plan (DSM) through a regulatory hearing. The hearing details, including deadlines for submissions and participation, are outlined. The Board invites public input via formal standing, written comments, or speaking at the evening session.

E-29Opening Statement - Consumer Advocate 1 passage
Section 1
Opening Statement of Consumer Advocate DSM Plan 2013-2015 (M04819) Residential ratepayers are experiencing continued upward pressure on electricity rates. Reducing energy use is the only controllable means a residential ratepayer has to lo...

AI summary The Consumer Advocate highlights rising residential electricity rates and advocates for improvements to Efficiency Nova Scotia's DSM Plan 2013-2015, including enhanced oversight, program effectiveness, transparency, and fair cost allocation. The proposed settlement aims to approve a two-year plan with ratepayer protections and stakeholder input.

09517Board Order 1 passage
DSM Advisory Group
DSM Advisory Group - matters Group ~-rr,.'tr1r1a Cl1"-r"l1"t::llrc11' or directional advice Minutes of Settlement. (PDWG) to the DSM and Stakeholder -na~'C'-nC~I't"1-'(raC' on current or ...... ...... ¥£"rll_£"r issues or concerns includin...

AI summary The DSM Advisory Group recommends developing Terms of Reference, electing a Chair, and collaborating with ENSC to refine evaluation methods for Enabling Strategies, improve rate impact analysis using Synapse's recommendations, and enhance customer participation tracking to avoid double-counting and maximize program engagement.

08964Consumer Advocate (ENSC) IR-1 to IR-27 1 passage
Consumer Advocate Information Requests to ENSC
Consumer Advocate Information Requests to ENSC

AI summary The document outlines information requests made by a consumer advocate to ENSC, focusing on regulatory proceedings in Nova Scotia. Key details involve the advocate's efforts to obtain data or clarifications from ENSC, though specific claims or legislative references are not detailed in the provided text.

11418DSM Advisory Group - Terms of Reference 3 passages
Introduction
Introduction The DSM Advisory Group has evolved from the former Program Development Working Group (PDWG) which has been a valuable resource in the design and implementation of DSM programs, beginning with the development of the 2008-2009 D...

AI summary The DSM Advisory Group, evolved from the Program Development Working Group (PDWG), supports DSM program design and oversight. Stakeholders endorsed its continuation during UARB hearings, leading to a re-focused mandate, expanded membership, and new name. The UARB mandated ENSC to file Terms of Reference for the DSM Advisory Group following its 2012 order.

Mandate
Mandate The DSM Advisory Group is a forum to provide strategic or directional advice and stakeholder perspectives on current or emerging DSM issues including, but not limited to, the following items as identified in the UARB Order noted ab...

AI summary The DSM Advisory Group provides strategic advice on DSM issues, including evaluating Enabling Strategies, refining rate impact methodologies, improving customer participation tracking, and developing communication strategies. ENSC manages the group and maintains a list of DSM issues on its SharePoint site, with stakeholder input encouraged.

Composition
Composition The membership of the DSM Advisory Group consists of a representative from each of the following and may be revised from time to time as required: - Consumer Advocate - Canadian Oil Heat Association - Ecology Action Centre - Ef...

AI summary The DSM Advisory Group's membership includes representatives from various organizations, including consumer advocates, industry groups, municipalities, and energy entities. Membership may be revised periodically. The group is part of a regulatory proceeding involving energy efficiency and demand-side management in Nova Scotia.

120092013 Annual Progress Report 6 passages
1.5 2012 Enabling Strategies p. p. 0
1.5 2012 Enabling Strategies ENSC launched a financing program for Solar and Fuel Substitution participants in September 2012. Participants of this program received zero-percent financing instead of rebates. In December, the lending partne...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) launched a zero-percent financing program for Solar and Fuel Substitution in 2012, later re-launched after a partner withdrawal. ENSC also conducted LED Holiday Light Exchanges, hosted the Bright Business Conference, developed the Trade Ally program and Efficiency 101 presentations, and initiated the Technical Reference Manual (TRM) with Navigant Consulting. These initiatives aimed to promote energy efficiency, engage businesses, and standardize energy savings calculations.

4.1.3 New Residential p. p. 0
4.1.3 New Residential The 2013 focus for ENSC's New Residential program will be to build on its 2012 success, in which program participation increased beyond anticipated levels. Ongoing efforts will include continued collaboration with mun...

AI summary ENSC's New Residential program aims to expand on 2012 success by increasing collaboration with municipal permit offices through staff training and promotional materials in 2013.

4.2 Business, Non-Profit and Institutional Programs and Services p. p. 0
4.2 Business, Non-Profit and Institutional Programs and Services In 2013 and 2014, ENSC will continue its work in building energy efficiency considerations into Business, Non-profit and Institutional (BNI) customers' decision-making proces...

AI summary ENSC aims to enhance energy efficiency among BNI customers in 2013-2014 by promoting customer ownership, energy monitoring systems, and long-term energy management planning. The organization will adapt to federal lighting standards and invest in emerging technologies to drive cultural change in energy efficiency.

4.3 Enabling Strategies p. p. 0
4.3 Enabling Strategies Enabling Strategies include the following categories: - Education and Outreach - Development and Research - Other Enabling Strategies: Innovative Financing, Capacity Building, and Working with Governments ENSC's eff...

AI summary ENSC's Enabling Strategies focus on education, research, and innovative financing to drive energy savings and market transformation. Initiatives in 2013 aim to enhance participation in ENSC programs and change industry practices through outreach and collaboration with governments.

4.3.1 Education and Outreach p. p. 0
4.3.1 Education and Outreach The focus of ENSC's education and outreach efforts in 2013 will be on connecting with Nova Scotians on their own terms, in communities that may not easily be reached otherwise. Doing so puts a human face on Eff...

AI summary ENSC's 2013 education and outreach initiatives focus on community engagement, expanding energy efficiency programs, collaborating with Habitat for Humanity, developing trade ally programs, and hosting an international conference. Efforts aim to make energy efficiency accessible and socially normative through digital media and local events.

COLUMN A B C D K L M R S T p. p. 0
COLUMN A B C D K L M R S T Program co sts incurred or n participatir g rate classe s New Efficient Home Energy Small Education & Development Other Enabling Program Existing Homes Construction Products Report Prescriptive Custom Business Ou...

AI summary The text presents a detailed breakdown of program participation rates across various rate classes and sectors, highlighting the distribution of program costs and participation percentages. It also includes data on the relative shares of municipal sales in total NSPI sales by sector, providing insights into the breakdown of DSM-eligible sales.

120102012 DSM Evaluation Reports 12 passages
Section 63 p. pp. 31-32
In 2011, the Evaluator noticed that programs marketing and communication represented an area for improvement. Throughout the 2012 evaluation, Econoler has noted major improvements in program marketing and outreach activities. ENSC has been...

AI summary The Evaluator noted improvements in program marketing and outreach since 2011, including a shift to integrated marketing and customer-centric approaches. Performance indicators are now integrated into marketing plans, contributing to the effectiveness of campaigns. The Evaluator recommends further improvements to marketing activities.

p. pp. 142-143
Q7a. Did you receive any complaints from other program partners? No Yes : If yes, from which partners? (Please do not mention names, just the party's role) Q7b. What was the complaint/were the complaints about? Q8. What suggestions do you...

AI summary The text presents a form used to collect feedback from program partners regarding complaints and suggestions for improving program performance. It includes questions about complaints received, their nature, and suggestions for enhancing outreach and marketing efforts.

3.5.1 Interview with Delivery Agent p. pp. 7-8
3.5.1 Interview with Delivery Agent The program's DA was interviewed as part of the process evaluation of Instant Savings. The DA expressed a high level of satisfaction with the overall program and their relationship with ENSC's team. Neve...

AI summary The Delivery Agent (DA) expressed overall satisfaction with the Instant Savings program but highlighted challenges with retailer involvement, particularly at the corporate level, and the need for better communication and education regarding POP and in-store engagement. They also noted improvements in campaign timelines and recommended continuing marketing efforts and one-on-one consumer education.

This Appendix presents all recommendations made by the Evaluator throughout the report as well as the sections where the recommendations originated. p. pp. 52-53
This Appendix presents all recommendations made by the Evaluator throughout the report as well as the sections where the recommendations originated. Sections Recommendations Executive Summary 1. Document the AIR MILES® approach : The progr...

AI summary This section of the report highlights the need to better document the AIR MILES® approach within the Instant Savings program manual and emphasizes the importance of involving retailers at both corporate and store levels to improve program effectiveness. Recommendations include enhancing communication and engagement strategies with retailers.

Section 599 p. p. 58
Q7b. What was the complaint/were the complaints about? Q8a. Now, approximately how many complaints have you received from retailers thus far in 2012? Number of complaints: Q8b. What was the complaint/were the complaints about? Q9. What sug...

AI summary The text contains a series of questions posed to retailers regarding complaints received in 2012, the nature of those complaints, and suggestions for improving program performance, particularly in marketing and outreach. The questions are part of a confidential evaluation process aimed at improving program effectiveness.

Home Depot p. p. 70
Home Depot Lighting Controls Thermostats Appliances Promotional Material Yes No No. Yes No No. Yes No No. Yes No No. Shelf Talkers Posters Stickers Vertical signs Comments: Home Hardware Lighting Controls Thermostats Appliances Promotional...

AI summary The text provides a table showing promotional materials and signage related to lighting, controls, thermostats, and appliances in Home Depot and Home Hardware stores. It indicates the presence or absence of items such as promotional material, shelf talkers, posters, stickers, and vertical signs.

3.6.1 Perceptions Related to Program Changes p. pp. 116-117
3.6.1 Perceptions Related to Program Changes A total of five DAs and two EAs were interviewed for the evaluation of HEA. The program partners were questioned about the recent changes made to the program and their impact on their work. Opin...

AI summary The evaluation of the Heat Energy Assistance (HEA) program reveals mixed satisfaction among partners, with dissatisfaction linked to frequent changes, lack of financial commitment, and unclear messaging. Key concerns include rebate amounts, the 12-month timeline, and the removal of incentives for heating equipment, which has decreased program activities. Improved communication between ENSC and DAs is recommended.

Section 827 p. p. 158
Number of complaints: Q7b. What was the complaint/were the complaints about? Q8. What suggestions do you have to improve program performance? Q9. More precisely, what suggestions do you have concerning program marketing and outreach activi...

AI summary The text includes questions about the nature of complaints, suggestions for improving program performance, and specific recommendations for marketing and outreach activities. It also mentions confidentiality and the potential for follow-up contact.

3.2.5 Marketing and Outreach Activities p. pp. 14-15
erformance indicators make performance visible, reinforce focus on the objectives to be achieved, clarify reasonable expectations and, finally, improve the overall execution of the marketing strategy. The Evaluator has the following recomm...

AI summary The Evaluator recommends making performance indicators in the marketing plan more quantitative and specific to improve the precision and effectiveness of the marketing strategy. The indicators should focus on the performance of individual marketing tools and provide feedback to guide decision-making, with a note to include a revision date due to their dynamic nature.

Q9. More precisely, what suggestions do you have concerning program marketing and outreach activities? p. p. 198
Q9. More precisely, what suggestions do you have concerning program marketing and outreach activities? Thank you very much for your time and co-operation. Your answers will be treated in strict confidence—no names will ever be mentioned in...

AI summary The text is an introduction to a survey or evaluation process regarding program marketing and outreach activities. It emphasizes confidentiality and the purpose of gathering feedback to improve program performance.

Section 1634 p. p. 112
- Q8. What suggestions do you have to improve program performance? - Q9. More precisely, what suggestions do you have concerning program marketing and outreach activities? Thank you very much for your time and co-operation. Your answers wi...

AI summary The text presents two questions regarding suggestions for improving program performance and specifically marketing and outreach activities. It emphasizes confidentiality and the intent to use responses to enhance program effectiveness.

Barriers to Actions and Recommendations [B Series] p. pp. 77-78
Barriers to Actions and Recommendations [B Series] B1. Did you face any challenge or barrier when implementing energy efficiency measures through the Custom Program? 1. Yes 2. No (SKIP TO B4) 98. (Don't know) (SKIP TO B4) 99. (Refused) (SK...

AI summary The document outlines a survey related to barriers faced in implementing energy efficiency measures through the Custom Program. It asks respondents about challenges, the most important barriers, and suggestions for improving the program. Key themes include energy efficiency, program evaluation, and stakeholder engagement.

58156Letter of Sept 24, 2013 from Wickwire Holm 1 passage
Re; HVI048191 E-ENSC-R-12 - 2014 DSM Cost Recovery Rider ("DCRR") p. p. 0
Re; HVI048191 E-ENSC-R-12 - 2014 DSM Cost Recovery Rider ("DCRR") We are writing regarding the upcoming filing of the 2014 DSM Cost Recovery Rider ("DCRR") by Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation ("ENSC"). In an effort to provide stakeholder...

AI summary Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation (ENSC) is preparing to file the 2014 DSM Cost Recovery Rider (DCRR). The DSM Advisory Group met to review a draft, identifying that the current methodology for assigning DSM costs to rate classes may cause significant increases in electricity bills for at least one rate class in 2014.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →