E-16E1 (Synapse) RIRs 1-90
38 passages
1 o Attachment 2, Appendix F: Round 2 Measure Level Technical Tables 1Solar-PV 2 Base (excel) 3 o Attachment 2, Appendix G: Round 2 Measure Level Technical Tables 1SE-Base 4 (excel) 5 o Attachment 2, Appendix H: DSMAG Consideration of the...
AI summary EfficiencyOne (E1) has modified certain attachments in its IR response, replacing specific references to DSMAG members with general references to the DSMAG and removing DSMAG Round 1 comments. These materials and discussions are critical to the development of E1's DSM plans and are conducted confidentially and without prejudice.
5. OTHER ITEMS - STANDARDIZED FILING FRAMEWORK In 2024, E1 proposed an approach for DSMAG consideration of the Standardized Filing Framework. As part of this process, E1 proposed updates to the Framework for DSMAG consideration and comment...
AI summary In 2024, E1 proposed updates to the Standardized Filing Framework for consideration by the DSMAG, incorporating stakeholder feedback received in 2024 and early 2025. The updates are provided in Attachment 2 (Redline) and Attachment 3 (Clean). This work continues efforts initiated during the development of the 2026-2030 DSM Plan.
Standardized Filing Framework Prepared by EfficiencyOne Dartmouth, NS 20 July 2016 Revised [insert date TBD] 20 July 2026 1 Standardized Filing Framework
AI summary The document outlines a standardized filing framework prepared by EfficiencyOne for the Nova Scotia Energy Board. It includes a revision date placeholder and a reference to a picture, indicating the framework's structure and context.
2. BACKGROUND On June 16, 2015, EfficiencyOne (E1), Nova Scotia Power Incorporated (NS Power), the Consumer Advocate, the Small Business Advocate, the Ecology Action Centre, the Affordable Energy Coalition, and the Industrial Group signed...
AI summary In 2015, EfficiencyOne and other stakeholders signed a Consensus Agreement to establish a Standardized Filing Framework for DSM applications, which was approved by the NSUARB in 2015 and implemented in 2016. The Framework was later reviewed and updated by the DSMAG in 2024 and 2025 following guidance from the NSUARB in the 2023-2025 DSM Plan Decision.
Table 1: STANDARDIZED FILING FRAMEWORK ITEM DESCRIPTION
AI summary The text introduces a table titled 'Standardized Filing Framework' that outlines items and their descriptions, though the content of the table is not provided in the given text. The table is likely related to regulatory filings and procedures.
13 M10830, NSUARB Letter, E1 2022 RBIA, February 24, 2023, page 5. 14 M10473, NSUARB Order, E1 2023-2025 DSM Plan, November 8, 2023, page 2, item 5. 15 Ibid., item 6. Standardized Filing Framework
AI summary The text references regulatory documents and standardized filing frameworks, including a letter from the NSUARB and an order related to the DSM Plan. These materials are part of a regulatory proceeding involving EfficiencyOne and the NSUARB.
Table 2: PROGRAM DESCRIPTION TEMPLATE ITEM DESCRIPTION 1. OVERVIEW A brief description of the program intent, target market, and type of service or rebate. 2. OBJECTIVES Long-term objectives for the program. 3. OPPORTUNITY A summary of the...
AI summary The document presents a program description template used in regulatory proceedings, outlining key sections such as program overview, objectives, market opportunity, design, performance indicators, and low-income equity considerations. It also includes a section for comparing program alternatives within the proposed DSM plan.
4.2.2 DSM POTENTIAL STUDY EfficiencyOne will commission a DSM potential study in advance of each Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The DSM Potential study will identify DSM resources that are achievable over the planning horizon, and will in...
AI summary EfficiencyOne will commission a DSM potential study prior to each Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The study aims to identify achievable demand-side management (DSM) resources and inform the development of Candidate Resource Plans. The process is aligned with the More Access to Energy Act and involves collaboration with the NSIESO.
4.3 DSM RESOURCE PLAN DEVELOPMENT The Preferred Resource Plan identified in the IRP that will inform the development of a preferred DSM Resource Plan by EfficiencyOne, including analysis of alternate scenarios of DSM activity, in accordanc...
AI summary The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) provides directional information for Demand Side Management (DSM) that will guide EfficiencyOne in developing a preferred DSM Resource Plan, including analysis of alternate scenarios, following the Standardized Filing Framework.
Performance Indicators consist of: 25 E1 will propose Performance Indicators within each DSM Resource Plan. These performance indicators will be specific to the DSM resources proposed within each future Plan (e.g. performance indicator met...
AI summary E1 will propose performance indicators within each DSM Resource Plan, focusing on energy efficiency, demand response, and other DSM resources. Historical performance indicators include energy savings, peak demand savings, ratepayer benefits, and customer satisfaction. These metrics are reported by program and rate class, with a focus on low-income and equity communities.
Other Low Income & Equity Programming In accordance with Section 4.0, the Balanced Plan Approach, EfficiencyOne E1 will design and deliver programs and services that benefit low-income & equity customers. Nova Scotians not affected by the...
AI summary EfficiencyOne E1 is tasked with designing and delivering programs and services that benefit low-income and equity customers under the Balanced Plan Approach, as outlined in Section 4.0. The NS Power charitable donation does not affect Nova Scotians.
4.4.1 TRACKING EfficiencyOne E1 will track the energy and capacity savings resulting from each program. Tracked results will be used in quarterly reports. 26 M07151, NSUARB Decision Letter, Nova Scotia Power Inc. – DSM Cost Allocation and...
AI summary EfficiencyOne E1 will track energy and capacity savings from each program, with results used in quarterly reports. A reference is made to a 2016 decision letter regarding DSM cost allocation and recovery.
4.5.64.6.6 RATE AND BILL IMPACT ANALYSIS ENS E1 will file its historical Rate and Bill Impact Analysis (RBIA) by October 31st of each yearas part of each DSM Resource Plan. 33 The historical RBIA estimates the high-level, longterm impact t...
AI summary ENS E1 is required to file both historical and forward-looking Rate and Bill Impact Analysis (RBIA) as part of each DSM Resource Plan. The historical RBIA covers DSM activities up to the previous calendar year, while the forward-looking RBIA estimates the impact of proposed DSM activities.
Table 1: STANDARDIZED FILING FRAMEWORK ITEM DESCRIPTION 6.2 Payback Period & Considerations As per the NSUARB's 2023-2025 DSM Plan Order.13 6.3 Justifications for Measure Inclusion As per the NSUARB's 2023-2025 DSM Plan Order.14 6.4 Other...
AI summary The document outlines a standardized filing framework, including payback period considerations and justifications for measure inclusion, referencing the NSUARB's 2023-2025 DSM Plan Order. It concludes with a summary of items for which E1 is seeking approval.
4.3 DSM RESOURCE PLAN DEVELOPMENT Integrated resource planning establishes directional information for DSM that will inform the development of a preferred DSM Resource Plan by E1, including analysis of alternate scenarios of DSM activity,...
AI summary The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) provides directional guidance for Demand Side Management (DSM) to support the development of a preferred DSM Resource Plan by EfficiencyOne (E1), including the analysis of alternate DSM scenarios in line with the Standardized Filing Framework.
Attachment 1: DSMAG Round 1 comments [This attachment has been removed.] Attachment 2: Round 2 Modelling Assumptions (Excel file) Attachment 3: Round 2 Measure Level Technical Tables 1EE-Base (excel) Attachment 4: Round 2 Measure Level Tec...
AI summary The document outlines various attachments related to the Demand Side Management Advisory Group (DSMAG) Round 2 modelling assumptions, technical tables, and model outputs. It includes files related to energy efficiency measures, demand response models, and considerations of the standardized filing framework.
8. STANDARDIZED FILING FRAMEWORK In the Board's Decision on the 2023-2025 DSM Plan (M10473), the NSEB strongly encouraged the DSMAG to consider whether changes to the Standardized Filing Framework were required, noting that parties should...
AI summary The Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) has encouraged the Demand-Side Management Advisory Group (DSMAG) to consider changes to the Standardized Filing Framework, particularly in the context of the 2023-2025 DSM Plan and the 2026 DSM Extension Decision. E1 has engaged with DSMAG on this topic, proposing updates and incorporating feedback into revised versions of the Framework.
Round 2 Model Input Assumptions and Results Board Directives E1 Update • To continue its engagement with the DSMAG on the Standardized Filing Framework, a review of E1's "balanced plan", the relevant factors and weighing of factors for con...
AI summary This document outlines Round 2 model input assumptions and results, focusing on E1's engagement with the DSMAG regarding the Standardized Filing Framework. Proposed revisions to the Framework are included as attachments, with a streamlined version provided in Attachment 11.
10.2 PERFORMANCE TARGETS AND INDICATORS In each DSM Plan application, E1 proposes performance target metrics and indicators, to be considered and approved by the NSEB. Round 2 Model Input Assumptions and Results For the 2027-2031 DSM Plan,...
AI summary E1 proposes performance target metrics and indicators for the 2027-2031 DSM Plan, to be reviewed and approved by the NSEB. Metrics include energy savings, demand response capacity, and solar-PV generation. E1 invites comments from the DSMAG and anticipates consistency with past performance indicators, with adjustments for new DSM resources.
20 July 2016 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Objective 1 2. Background 1 3. Standardized Filing Framework 3 4. Demand Side Management Standards 16 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Glossary of Terms 3 LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Standardized Filing Framework 6...
AI summary The document outlines the structure and content of a regulatory proceeding, including sections on objectives, background, and standardized filing frameworks, as well as demand-side management standards.
Appendix: Standardized Filing Framework
AI summary This section introduces the Standardized Filing Framework, which is a structured approach used in regulatory proceedings to ensure consistency and transparency in the submission of documents.
19 M10830, NSUARB Letter, E1 2022 RBIA, February 24, 2023, page 5. 20 M06733, NSUARB Order, E1 2016-2018 DSM Plan, October 7, 2015, page 2, item 12. E1 will "provide one or more alternate scenarios of DSM budgets for the Board to consider,...
AI summary The text references several regulatory documents and orders related to demand-side management (DSM) plans and rate impact analyses. It includes references to NSUARB orders and a letter regarding the 2022 RBIA and DSM plans, including the requirement for E1 to provide alternate scenarios and rate impact analysis.
4.2.1 DSM BASELINE STUDY EfficiencyOne will commission a DSM baseline study in advance of each DSM Potential Study. The DSM Baseline Study will identify current stocks of electricity consuming devices in all market sectors.E1 will work wit...
AI summary EfficiencyOne will commission a DSM baseline study before each DSM Potential Study to identify current stocks of electricity-consuming devices across all market sectors. The study aligns with the NSIESO's integrated resource planning duties under the More Access to Energy Act and the Public Utilities Act.
4.2.3 INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLAN Nova Scotia Power's IRP develops a long-term Preferred Resource Plan that establishes directional information for DSM that assists NS Power in meeting customer demand and energy requirements, and environmenta...
AI summary Nova Scotia Power's Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) outlines a long-term Preferred Resource Plan that guides Demand-Side Management (DSM) to meet energy needs and environmental goals cost-effectively. The IRP informs the development of a preferred DSM Resource Plan by E1, with collaboration from the NSIESO, as mandated by the More Access to Energy Act.
Performance Indicators consist of: 36 E1 will propose Performance Indicators within each DSM Resource Plan for consideration and approval by the NSEB. These performance indicators will be specific to the DSM resources proposed within each...
AI summary E1 will propose performance indicators for each DSM Resource Plan for approval by the NSEB. These indicators will be tailored to specific DSM resources such as energy efficiency, demand response, and solar-PV.
4.3.4 DSM PROGRAMS E1 will propose DSM programs within each DSM Resource Plan. Investments in DSM programs reduce energy consumption through technology replacements and behaviour change. DSM programs are offered to the Residential and the...
AI summary E1 will propose DSM programs within each DSM Resource Plan. These programs aim to reduce energy consumption through technology and behavior changes, targeting residential and BNI sectors. E1 was directed to include PAC test results in its annual reports, as per NSEB Order M12249.
4.3.5 ENABLING STRATEGIES E1 will propose Enabling Strategies within each DSM Resource Plan. Enabling Strategies expenditures are classified into one ofmay include the following three categories: - Education and Outreach; - Development and...
AI summary E1 will propose Enabling Strategies within each DSM Resource Plan, with expenditures categorized into education and outreach, development and research, and other strategies. The allocation of participant and system benefit portions depends on the investment amount and rate class affected. A note suggests that approval of the COSS in the 2026-2027 GRA could alter these allocations.
4.4.3 VERIFICATION The UARB's NSEB's savings verification consultant provides a verification review of the evaluated savings. 38 M07151, NSUARB Decision Letter, Nova Scotia Power Inc. – DSM Cost Allocation and Recovery (E-R-15), (11 Apr 20...
AI summary The NSEB's savings verification consultant conducts a verification review of evaluated savings, referencing a prior decision letter from the UARB regarding DSM cost allocation and recovery.
4.5.24.6.2 QUARTERLY REPORTS ENS E1 will file quarterly reports with the UARB NSEB for quarters one through three of each year. The reports will provide quarterly status updates and service highlights, as well as 20 July 2016, Updated: [in...
AI summary ENS E1 is required to file quarterly reports with the UARB NSEB, providing updates on DSM program performance, including savings targets, investment results, rate class reporting, and recommendations from evaluators and verifiers. The reports must include variances, forecasts, and participation results.
4.5.34.6.3 AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ENS E1 will retain the services of an external financial auditor to prepare audited annual financial statements. These will be filed with the UARB NSEB in the second quarter of the following year. 20...
AI summary ENS E1 will engage an external financial auditor to prepare audited annual financial statements, which will be submitted to the UARB NSEB in the second quarter of the following year. The document references an updated version dated 20 July 2016.
4.2.3 INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLAN Integrated resource planning establishes directional information for DSM planning. The Preferred Resource Plan identified in the IRP will inform the development of a preferred DSM Resource Plan by E1, includi...
AI summary The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) establishes directional information for Demand Side Management (DSM) planning. E1 will develop a preferred DSM Resource Plan in collaboration with the NSIESO, in accordance with the Standardized Filing Framework and the More Access to Energy Act . The NSIESO is required to file the results of its IRP exercises with the Energy Board.
2. BACKGROUND On June 16, 2015, EfficiencyOne (E1), Nova Scotia Power Incorporated (NS Power), the Consumer Advocate, the Small Business Advocate, the Ecology Action Centre, the Affordable Energy Coalition, and the Industrial Group signed...
AI summary The document outlines the history and evolution of the Standardized Filing Framework for DSM applications in Nova Scotia, including its approval by the NSUARB and ongoing updates guided by the DSMAG. Key stakeholders include EfficiencyOne, NS Power, and various advocacy groups.
5. CONSOLIDATED ENDNOTES AND SOURCES - 1. M06733 – E1 2016-2018 DSM Resource Plan. NSUARB Order (October 7, 2015) approving the Plan, the Consensus Agreement establishing the Standardized Filing Framework; Performance Targets, Indicators,...
AI summary This section lists consolidated endnotes and sources from a regulatory proceeding, including matters related to Demand Side Management (DSM) plans, standardized filing frameworks, and the establishment of the Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (NSIESO) under the Energy Reform (2024) Act.
d by NSPI based upon the proposed Plan and results to date. Response IR-85: Please refer to EfficiencyOne's response to part (e) of IG IR-22. DATE FILED: May 28, 2026 E1 (Synapse) IR-85 Page 1 of 1 Request IR-86: Please refer to page 3 of...
AI summary The response to Request IR-86 confirms that EfficiencyOne (E1) provided the Standardized Filing Framework to the DSM Advisory Group (DSMAG) on February 27, 2026, and made revisions prior to filing the 2027–2031 DSM Plan Application. E1 intends to update the Framework after the Board's decision to align with regulatory requirements and stakeholder feedback.
ns current and aligned with regulatory requirements and stakeholder feedback. E1 will provide an updated version of the Framework, incorporating the approved changes, for future DSM Plan applications. (b) Please refer to Synapse IR-02, Att...
AI summary E1 will provide an updated version of the Framework aligned with regulatory requirements and stakeholder feedback. Definitions for terms like 'energy efficiency' and 'solar PV' are referenced in E1's 2027–2031 DSM Resource Plan Application.
(g) Please clarify which of these metrics are also indicators and/or targets. Are all of the indicators and targets included? If not, why not? Response IR-88: (a) Yes. As stated in Appendix F, page 5, Table 2: DSM Resource Plan Filing Cont...
AI summary The response clarifies that EfficiencyOne (E1) will provide metrics annually and cumulatively, both in aggregate and by DSM resource. It also mentions that the modified Program Administrator Cost (PAC) test is included in the updated Standardized Filing Framework, referencing Board decision M12282.
: "Primary cost-effectiveness screen at the portfolio level, discount using NS Power's WACC. Strategic electrification is assessed using a modified PAC that includes the incremental utility revenues…" (d) E1 did include portfolio-level GHG...
AI summary The document discusses the evaluation of DSM Plans, including the inclusion of GHG savings and levelized cost of saved energy as performance indicators. E1 did not include GHG emissions reductions as a primary metric, but plans to update the Standardized Filing Framework based on the Board's recommendations.
1 Request IR-89: 2 - 3 Please refer to 4.5 DSM Resource Plans (5-year cycle) of Appendix F – Proposed Updated - 4 Standardized Filing Framework on page 10. Please provide a draft schedule indicating when - 5 these activities would occur du...
AI summary A request is made for a draft schedule outlining the timing of DSM Resource Plan activities over a 5-year cycle, based on Appendix F's Proposed Updated Standardized Filing Framework. EfficiencyOne has prepared a response with this draft schedule.