Topic/Matter Intersection

Topic:"Transmission Planning" in M13173

Matter: Nova Scotia Independent Energy System Operator (IESO Nova Scotia) - 2027/2028 Proposed Expenses, Revenue Requirement and Fees Application
69 passages 1 document

Transmission Planning across all matters →

N-1Application - Redacted 69 passages
1.2 Background p. p. 125
among other things, mandated a transfer of certain system functions from the incumbent - utility, Nova Scotia Power (NS Power), to the not-for-profit independent system operator, IESO - Nova Scotia. - The proclamation of the MAEA contempla...

AI summary The text describes the phased transition of system operator functions from Nova Scotia Power (NS Power) to the independent system operator, IESO Nova Scotia, as mandated by the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). Phase 1, which commenced in October 2024, covers independent energy procurement, system planning, and generation interconnection. IESO Nova Scotia is currently preparing for Phase 2, which involves real-time energy dispatch. Key accomplishments in Phase 1 include the start of the first Integrated Resource Plan and various system impact studies and BESS facility commissioning.

1.3 Material Changes in the Application p. p. 125
centre, as required to fulfil - the organization's mandate under the MAEA, enable independent Balancing Authority - (BA)/Transmission Operator (TOP) operations, and create defined physical and cyber - boundaries - Phase 2B Introduces provi...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Board approval for capital costs associated with Phase 2A ($40.91 million) and Phase 2B ($8.08 million) of the Phase 2 Control Centre project, along with forecast amortization for Phase 2A. These phases aim to fulfill mandates under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), including enabling independent Balancing Authority/Transmission Operator operations and establishing physical and cyber boundaries. Phase 2C, which focuses on grid optimization and an independent Energy Management System, is being deferred to allow for further validation and refinement based on future operating experience.

Quarterly Reporting p. p. 125
Quarterly Reporting "IESO Nova Scotia is directed to file quarterly reports starting on May 15, 2026, including updates about the status of Phase 1 and 2 of the transition of the system operator functions from NS Power to the IESO, as well...

AI summary The text outlines the requirement for IESO Nova Scotia to submit quarterly reports regarding the transition of system operator functions from NS Power to the IESO. These reports must cover staffing, facilities, technology, regulatory compliance, and timeline or cost changes. Although the original reporting obligation stemmed from a concluded fiscal year's revenue requirement application, IESO Nova Scotia commits to continuing proactive reporting to the Nova Scotia Energy Board and intervenors during the ongoing implementation of the More Access to Energy Act.

2.2 Legislative Mandate and Business Plan p. p. 125
2.2 Legislative Mandate and Business Plan - The MAEA established IESO Nova Scotia as an independent, not-for-profit energy system - operator and assigned it responsibilities for electricity system planning, the procurement of - energy reso...

AI summary The text outlines the legislative mandate of IESO Nova Scotia as established by the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). It describes the organization's role as an independent, not-for-profit energy system operator responsible for electricity system planning, resource procurement, and transmission interconnection. The document details a phased transition of responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power, noting that Phase 1 (planning and procurement) is complete, while Phase 2 (real-time system operations) is ongoing. The 2027/2028 Business Plan serves as both an annual operating plan and a transition roadmap for these institutional changes.

2.3.3 Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access p. p. 125
2.3.3 Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access - The third enterprise priority is intended to improve how existing and prospective system users - connect to, participate in and receive information about Nova Scotia's bul...

AI summary The document outlines a priority to enhance engagement, transparency, and access for system users within Nova Scotia's bulk electricity system. Key activities include updating Transmission System Interconnection Procedures, completing interconnection studies, and revising Market Rules and the Open Access Transmission Tariff. These initiatives aim to support the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) by fostering competitive market development and efficient system planning. Associated costs are distributed across various categories, including technical resources, legal support, and capital investment for an interconnection portal.

2.3.4 Build External Trust and Shape Energy Policy to Benefit Nova Scotians p. p. 125
2.3.4 Build External Trust and Shape Energy Policy to Benefit Nova Scotians - The fourth enterprise priority supports the relationships, transparency and public - accountability necessary for IESO Nova Scotia to discharge its independent m...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia outlines its fourth enterprise priority, which focuses on building public trust, transparency, and accountability to fulfill its independent mandate. The organization intends to participate in regional and North American reliability activities, conduct required adequacy assessments, and engage with Mi'kmaq and other stakeholders. These activities are essential for effective planning, procurement, and market development. The requested funding covers stakeholder communications, Indigenous Relations Framework development, and public education to ensure informed participation and confidence in the organization's decisions.

3. OM&A revenue requirement p. p. 125
3. OM&A revenue requirement These expenses support the continued delivery of IESO Nova Scotia's existing planning, procurement, interconnection, regulatory and corporate responsibilities, while also providing for initial operation of the c...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia proposes an OM&A revenue requirement of approximately $14.76 million for 2027/2028, which is slightly lower than the 2026/2027 request despite an expanding work program. This consistency is attributed to completed transition activities and the capitalization of Control Centre project costs. However, a significant increase in operating costs is forecasted for 2028/2029 as the organization assumes real-time system operations, primarily involving the transfer of responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power.

2.5 Summary p. p. 125
2.5 Summary - The Business Plan and 2027/2028 Plan establish the operational basis for this Application. It - identifies the work required to continue performing the responsibilities already transferred to - IESO Nova Scotia and to impleme...

AI summary The document outlines that the Business Plan and the 2027/2028 Plan serve as the operational framework for the current Application. These plans identify the necessary work to maintain responsibilities transferred to IESO Nova Scotia and to implement the next phase of the Province's independent system-operator model. The proposed expenditures and revenue requirements are intended to provide the resources required to execute these objectives.

3.2 Proposed Expenditures - Phase 2 Control Centre p. p. 125
3.2 Proposed Expenditures - Phase 2 Control Centre - IESO Nova Scotia's proposed expenditures in this Application are exclusively related to the - capital work in progress costs of its Phase 2 Control Centre8 build-out (the "Project"). Thi...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) approval for $48.99 million in capital expenditures to complete Phases 2A and 2B of its Phase 2 Control Centre project. These expenditures, spanning four fiscal years (2026-2030), are part of a $75.4 million project to transition system operations. The project was informed by a value analysis by FTI Consulting and IBM to determine the most cost-effective independent system operator model for grid operations.

Requirements of the More Access to Energy Act p. p. 125
Requirements of the More Access to Energy Act - The More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) requires the transition of system operator responsibilities - from Nova Scotia Power Incorporated (NS Power) to IESO Nova Scotia. In accordance with the -...

AI summary The text discusses the requirements of the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA), which mandates the transition of system operator responsibilities from Nova Scotia Power Incorporated to IESO Nova Scotia. To fulfill these statutory obligations, IESO Nova Scotia must establish a control centre equipped with necessary personnel, systems, and business processes. The document references specific analyses, including the IBM Control Centre Options Analysis and the FTI IESO Nova Scotia Value Case Report, to justify the proposed expenditures for the Phase 2 Control Centre.

Phase 2 Control Centre p. p. 125
Phase 2 Control Centre - Following the successful implementation of Phase 1 in December 2025, IESO Nova Scotia - undertook a comprehensive assessment of options for establishing independent operational - control of Nova Scotia's integrated...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is pursuing 'Scenario 4 Enhanced Independence' for the Phase 2 Control Centre, following a comprehensive assessment of options for establishing independent operational control of the province's electricity system. This pathway involves establishing an independent control room space within Nova Scotia Power's Atlantic Data Centre and progressively transferring operational responsibilities. Scenario 4 was selected as the most prudent balance because it achieves high operational independence while avoiding the high costs of new construction and leveraging existing synergies with Nova Scotia Power systems.

Preamble p. pp. 37-199
Scenario 1 - IESO Lite: Scenario 1 represents the lowest-independence model. Under this approach IESO Nova Scotia would perform planning, monitoring and advisory functions while NS Power retained responsibility for real-time BA and TOP ope...

AI summary The text evaluates 'Scenario 1 - IESO Lite,' a low-independence model where IESO Nova Scotia handles planning and advisory functions while Nova Scotia Power retains real-time Balancing Authority and Transmission Operator responsibilities. While noted as a low-cost, simple implementation, the scenario fails to meet More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) requirements and long-term goals for operational independence. The document also defines technical components including day-ahead P×Q pairs, SCADA systems, Energy Management Systems (EMS), and the NSP optimizer (ECCPO) for resource dispatch optimization.

4 Scenario 4 p. p. 125
4 Scenario 4 Scenario 4 establishes a dedicated IESO Nova Scotia Control Centre at the Atlantic Data Centre. 6 Scenario 4 also provides the operating model through which IESO Nova Scotia will assume responsibility for the operation of Nova...

AI summary Scenario 4 outlines the establishment of a dedicated IESO Nova Scotia Control Centre at the Atlantic Data Centre. This project includes the physical facility, operational capabilities, business processes, and technological systems required for IESO Nova Scotia to fulfill its statutory mandate as an independent electricity system operator under the More Access to Energy Act. The scope encompasses responsibilities as a Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP), focusing on real-time supply-demand balance and reliable transmission system operation.

4 Figure 5: Core Capabilities p. p. 125
4 Figure 5: Core Capabilities CAPABILITY OPERATIONAL PURPOSE SCENARIO 4 PRINCIPAL SYSTEM APPROACH 1. SCADA & Monitoring Provides operators with real- time visibility into the electricity system so they can monitor system conditions and res...

AI summary The document outlines the core operational capabilities required for the electricity system, categorized by their operational purpose, approach (Shared, Transfer, or Build New), and principal systems. Key capabilities include SCADA and monitoring for real-time visibility, Energy Management Systems (EMS) for decision support, dispatch/redispatch for reliability, market management, operational forecasting, and intertie management for coordinating energy flows with neighboring jurisdictions. It also covers outage coordination, training systems, and reporting and analytics.

11 Control Center Build p. p. 125
11 Control Center Build 12 Control Centre Build includes the design, construction, fit-out, physical security systems, and 13 commissioning of t he IESO Nova Scotia Control Centre at the Atlantic Data Centre. This includes 14 t he dedicate...

AI summary The Control Centre Build involves the design, construction, and commissioning of the IESO Nova Scotia Control Centre at the Atlantic Data Centre. This facility is a foundational component for the transition to an independent system operator under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). It enables IESO Nova Scotia to independently manage real-time operations of Nova Scotia's bulk electricity system and assume Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) responsibilities, independent of Nova Scotia Power.

Phase 2A Workstreams p. p. 125
Phase 2A Workstreams (GRA) Governance & Regulatory - Market Rules & Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) Establish the governance, regulatory change management, stakeholder approval, and agreement frameworks needed to support the IESO NS...

AI summary The document outlines the specific workstreams for Phase 2A of a project aimed at establishing the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO NS). The workstreams are categorized into Governance & Regulatory (covering market rules, OATT, and NERC compliance), Technology & Communications, Control Centre infrastructure, and Operational Frameworks (focused on processes and people). These activities are designed to ensure regulatory compliance, cybersecurity, and operational readiness for the transition to a new market model.

3.4.1 System Planning and Procurement p. p. 125
3.4.1 System Planning and Procurement - IESO Nova Scotia system planning and procurement budget primarily consists of costs incurred - to fulfill its statutory object of carrying out Resource Planning and Transmission Planning as - well as...

AI summary IESO Nova Scotia is seeking to include costs associated with system planning, transmission planning, and competitive energy resource procurement in its revenue requirement. The costs cover managing multiple procurement processes prior to contract execution, which aligns with the most recent Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) and the Province's Clean Power Plan. IESO Nova Scotia asserts that these administrative costs are consistent with its strategic priorities regarding system reliability and stakeholder engagement.

NON-CONFIDENTIAL p. p. 167
NON-CONFIDENTIAL Project Key Activities (Updated) Estimated or Actual Completion MAEA Objects Generation Interconnection Processes -Complete Feasibility and System Impact Studies in alignment with the Generation Interconnection Procedures...

AI summary The document outlines the ongoing project activities for IESO-NS, focusing on generation interconnection processes, NERC and NPCC compliance, and reliability standards. Key activities include conducting feasibility and system impact studies for wind farms (Green Choice 1 and 2), performing transmission and resource adequacy assessments, and fulfilling reporting requirements to the Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB). These activities are conducted in alignment with the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) and include active participation in NPCC task forces.

Priority 1 - Complete the Successful Transition of Independent Grid Operations p. p. 167
Priority 1 - Complete the Successful Transition of Independent Grid Operations Key Activity/ Project Description Estimated Completion MAEA Linkage Independent Grid Operations Planning and Implementation Please refer to Proposed Expenditure...

AI summary The document outlines Priority 1 for the transition to independent grid operations in Nova Scotia, primarily involving the establishment of IESO Nova Scotia. Key activities include the creation of an independent control centre, obtaining NERC certification for Balancing Authority and Transmission Operator functions, and updating market rules and tariffs. The plan also encompasses technology enablement (cybersecurity and IT/OT systems), organizational change management for personnel transitioning from Nova Scotia Power, and the development of a new settlement system to support a competitive electricity market.

Priority 3 - Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access p. p. 167
Priority 3 - Strengthen System-User Engagement, Transparency, and Access Key Activity/ Project Description Estimated Completion MAEA Linkage Standard Generation Interconnection Procedures Revisions and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission...

AI summary The document outlines Priority 3 of a regulatory plan focused on strengthening system-user engagement, transparency, and access. Key activities include updating Standard Generation Interconnection Procedures to align with FERC Order 2023 recommendations, improving interconnection process functionality by Q4 2027-28, and establishing an updated market participant framework. IESO Nova Scotia aims to create structured collaboration mechanisms, such as a Market Advisory Committee and Participant Information Portal, to encourage new market entrants and improve transparency.

Section 371 p. p. 167
Interconnection Studies and commissioning support will continue beyond 2027-28 as part of ongoing work to facilitate new generation, storage, and load connections to the Nova Scotia transmission system. Depending on the determined scope of...

AI summary The text outlines the ongoing commitment to provide interconnection studies and commissioning support beyond the 2027-28 period. This work is intended to facilitate new connections for generation, storage, and load to the Nova Scotia transmission system. The timeline for full implementation may be extended depending on the defined scope of Interconnection Process Improvements, which may include the deployment of new software systems.

Priority 5 - Progress Important Regulatory Outcomes p. p. 167
Priority 5 - Progress Important Regulatory Outcomes Key Activity/ Project Description Estimated Completion MAEA Linkage 2027/2028 Revenue Requirement, Proposed Expenditures, and Fees Application Application submitted in Q3 2026/2027. Q1 20...

AI summary The document outlines key regulatory activities and projects for Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSPI) and the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS) under the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA). Key priorities include the submission and processing of revenue requirement, expenditure, and fees applications for the 2027/2028 and 2028/2029 periods. Additionally, it details the development and stakeholder engagement for new Transmission Generation Interconnection Procedures, with expected submissions to the Nova Scotia Energy Board (NSEB) by late 2026.

Project Work Plan and Schedule p. p. 167
Project Work Plan and Schedule Object Summary 9(a) exercise and perform the powers, duties and functions assigned to the IESO under this Act, the market rules and its licence; 9(b) enter into agreements with transmitters giving the IESO th...

AI summary The document outlines the statutory powers, duties, and functions of the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) as defined under the relevant Act. These responsibilities include maintaining the adequacy and reliability of the bulk electricity system, procuring ancillary services, coordinating power system planning, and facilitating a competitive electricity market. Additionally, the IESO is tasked with procuring various energy resources (including storage and renewables), forecasting electricity demand, and conducting independent planning for transmission and demand-side management.

Re: Government Support for IESO Nova Scotia's Phase 2 Plans p. p. 167
Re: Government Support for IESO Nova Scotia's Phase 2 Plans I am writing to confirm the Government of Nova Scotia's support for IESO Nova Scotia's proposed approach for the Phase 2 project and staged implementation timeline, including the...

AI summary The Government of Nova Scotia confirms its support for IESO Nova Scotia's Phase 2 plans, which include a staged implementation timeline and the transfer of electricity system operational control from Nova Scotia Power to IESO Nova Scotia by spring 2028. The Government supports repurposing Nova Scotia Power's data centre for IESO Nova Scotia's independent control centre to ensure cost-effectiveness and reliability. Additionally, the Government agreed to a $10 million line of credit increase to facilitate planning and procurement activities.

What it delivers: p. p. 180
What it delivers: - Establishes the independent IESO-NS control centre (ADC) - Begins BA/TOP operations using existing NSP systems - Creates secure physical/cyber boundaries - Builds operator capabilit1• and early credibility

AI summary The text outlines the initial deliverables of a project focused on establishing independent control center operations for the Independent Electricity System Operator - Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). Key objectives include establishing the ADC control center, initiating Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) operations utilizing existing Nova Scotia Power (NSP) systems, and creating secure physical and cyber boundaries to build operator capability and credibility.

Why it matters: p. p. 180
Why it matters: - Achieves the long-term "North Star" operating model and long-term customer benefits - Postpones enhancement capex, allowing design l o be based on real operation;:il experiences, including seeing full functionality of NSP...

AI summary IBM recommends that IESO-NS adopt 'Scenario 4 – Enhanced Independence' as the preferred operating model for Phase 2 of the transition to independent operational control. This move aligns with the More Access to Energy Act (MAEA) and aims to achieve long-term system value and reliability. The proposed phased implementation (2A, 2B, and 2C) is estimated to cost $75 million in capital over five years, with an expected net present value of $219 million and significant annual benefits starting in 2028/29.

2. Purpose of this Report p. pp. 180-182
2. Purpose of this Report This report has been prepared by IBM for IESO-NS to provide a clear recommendation on the preferred strategic approach for Phase 2 of the transition of BA and TOP functions from NSP to IESO-NS. The report is inten...

AI summary IBM prepared this report for IESO-NS to recommend a strategic approach for Phase 2 of transitioning Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions from Nova Scotia Power Inc. (NSP) to IESO-NS. The report serves as a public-facing document for internal decision support, government and stakeholder communication, and as a basis for future regulatory filings. It outlines the recommended delivery pathway, including expected benefits, costs, implementation timing, and risk/reliability management.

IBM's assessment established: p. p. 182
IBM's assessment established: - the preferred long-term BA/TOP operating model for Nova Scotia as Strategic Scenario 4 Enhanced Independence ; - the justification for selecting this model based on evidence and structured evaluation; - the...

AI summary The document outlines the findings of an assessment conducted by IBM regarding the preferred long-term Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) operating model for Nova Scotia. The assessment identifies 'Strategic Scenario 4 Enhanced Independence' as the preferred model. It provides a structured evaluation to justify this selection and proposes a phased implementation pathway (2A / 2B / 2C), specifically recommending Phase 2A as the initial implementation milestone.

Scenario 1 - IESO Lite p. p. 186
Scenario 1 - IESO Lite Scenario 1 represents the lowest-independence model. Under this approach IESO-NS would perform planning, monitoring and advisory functions while NSP retained responsibility for real-time BA and TOP operations. No ind...

AI summary The document describes 'Scenario 1 - IESO Lite,' which is characterized as the lowest-independence model for the IESO-NS. In this scenario, IESO-NS would handle planning, monitoring, and advisory functions, while Nova Scotia Power (NSP) would maintain responsibility for real-time Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) operations without establishing an independent control centre or operational systems. While noted for its low cost and simplicity, the model is deemed insufficient for achieving long-term goals regarding operational independence, transparency, and direct accountability.

Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence limited tactical investments nhanced Independence Enhanced Cap p. p. 186
Strategic Scenarios IESO-Lite Near-term planning role only Shared Operations Shared facilities and systems Minimum Independence limited tactical investments nhanced Independence Enhanced CapabiUty Full Markel Operations Ftt for future mark...

AI summary The document outlines five strategic scenarios for the evolution of the Independent System Operator (IESO) and Nova Scotia Power (NSP) relationship. These scenarios range from 'IESO-Lite' (near-term planning role with shared operations) to 'Full Market Operations' (full market evolution). The table details specific operational components—including Control Centre facilities, EMS/SCADA systems, dispatch responsibilities, and market mechanisms—alongside associated capital expenditures (CAPEX), estimated benefits, and implementation timelines for each strategic path.

7.1.1.1. Shared Components p. p. 194
7.1.1.1. Shared Components Shared components are capabilities where NSP continues to provide infrastructure, technical support, or hosting services during the transition period. These arrangements reduce implementation cost and schedule ri...

AI summary The text discusses the use of 'shared components' during the transition of operational authority to IESO-NS. Nova Scotia Power (NSP) will continue to provide infrastructure, technical support, and hosting services for certain capabilities, such as SCADA systems, which NSP owns and operates. This collaborative approach is intended to reduce implementation costs and schedule risks by avoiding the duplication of assets while ensuring continued operational effectiveness and reliability during the transition.

7.1.1.2. Transferred Components p. p. 194
7.1.1.2. Transferred Components Transferred components represent capabilities currently operated by NSP that are required for IESO-NS to exercise independent operational responsibility. These capabilities are transferred where direct opera...

AI summary The text defines transferred components as existing capabilities operated by Nova Scotia Power (NSP) that must be transitioned to the IESO-NS to enable independent operational responsibility. These transfers occur when direct operational control is essential for supporting BA and TOP functions, or when transferring existing ownership is deemed more effective than developing new systems.

Fig 8 below illustrates the technology operating model for Steady State 1, with most of the OT components either shared with NSP or transferred from NSP. p. p. 194
Fig 8 below illustrates the technology operating model for Steady State 1, with most of the OT components either shared with NSP or transferred from NSP. Base capablUtles Option selected for this capability Component I SCADA & Monitoring S...

AI summary The text describes the technology operating model for 'Steady State 1,' outlining how various Operational Technology (OT) components will be managed between Nova Scotia Power (NSP) and IESO-NS. Key capabilities such as SCADA & Monitoring, Energy Management Systems (EMS), and Training Systems will be shared or transferred. Specific tools for ECC Optimization, Operational Forecasting, Intertie Management, and Settlement are identified for transfer to IESO-NS, while new reporting capabilities will be built from the ground up.

4. NERC Compliance (process & documentation): p. p. 199
4. NERC Compliance (process & documentation): - Description: Includes compliance program and procedures development, audit readiness, and certification activities. This includes the work required for IESO-NS to be certified by NERC/NPCC to...

AI summary The text outlines the scope and basis for NERC compliance activities, focusing on the development of compliance programs, procedures, audit readiness, and certification. Specifically, it covers the work required for IESO-NS to obtain NERC/NPCC certification to perform Balancing Authority (BA) and Transmission Operator (TOP) functions. This involves aligning documentation with NERC CIP and reliability standards, with estimates derived from professional judgment, industry benchmarks, and historical project data.

The transition from the VIU model to IESO-NS p. p. 18
The transition from the VIU model to IESO-NS - ES.6 The newly created IESO-NS is an independent, non-profit organization currently entrusted with responsibility for planning and procurement and eventually reliably operating the province's...

AI summary The document outlines the transition of Nova Scotia's bulk electricity system from a Vertically Integrated Utility (VIU) model to the IESO-NS model. IESO-NS is an independent, non-profit organization tasked with planning, procurement, and eventual operation of the province's bulk electricity system. The transition is structured in two phases: Phase 1, currently established, covers planning, IRP processes, and procurement; Phase 2, planned for 2027/28, will involve day-to-day operational roles and transmission grid operation.

Benchmarking the roles, responsibilities and operating costs of an ISO p. pp. 18-20
Benchmarking the roles, responsibilities and operating costs of an ISO ES.8 In Chapter 2 of our report, we compare IESO-NS with a benchmarking group of ISOs in other regions. No existing ISO is entirely comparable with IESO-NS in its curre...

AI summary The report benchmarks the IESO-NS against other Independent System Operators (ISOs) to determine reasonable operating costs and roles. It establishes a general minimum fixed operating cost of $70-140 million per year for ISOs. The analysis highlights that many ISO costs are non-incremental, as they replace functions previously performed by Vertically Integrated Utilities (VIUs) or Transmission System Operators (TSOs). Furthermore, the report notes that cost scaling is not strictly linear with grid size but depends on specific roles, such as wholesale energy and capacity markets.

1. The transition from the vertically integrated utility model to IESO-NS p. pp. 25-28
1. The transition from the vertically integrated utility model to IESO-NS - 1.1 IESO-NS is the most recently founded ISO[10](#page-27-0) in North America, having been directed by the Provincial Government in 2024. IESO-NS was formed follow...

AI summary The text describes the establishment of IESO-NS, an independent, non-profit Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia, directed by the provincial government in 2024 following a Clean Electricity Solutions Task Force report. IESO-NS is tasked with planning, procurement, and eventually operating the province's bulk electricity system. The transition from Nova Scotia Power (NSP) occurs in two phases: Phase 1 involves planning, transmission planning, interconnection, and resource procurement; Phase 2, planned for 2027-2028, focuses on operational planning and system balancing.

Identification of the ISOs for benchmarking purposes p. pp. 28-32
Identification of the ISOs for benchmarking purposes 2.3 IESO-NS has several defining characteristics that influence our benchmarking group selection. We summarise those characteristics and the relevant ISOs in Figure 2-1 below. Source: FT...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for identifying comparable Independent System Operators (ISOs) for benchmarking the IESO-NS. It identifies two key characteristics for selection: peak load and utility structure. IESO-NS is characterized by a relatively small peak load (approx. 2.5 GW) and a system primarily composed of a former vertically integrated utility (VIU). Comparable entities identified include EirGrid, Transpower, EMA (Singapore), CAISO, ISO-NE, MISO, and IESO Ontario.

Unit CAISO ISO-NE MISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO EirGrid AEMO EMA Trans- power Nova Scotia p. p. 34
Unit CAISO ISO-NE MISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO EirGrid AEMO EMA Trans- power Nova Scotia Approximate people served millions 32 15 45 5 15 67 5 23 6 5 1 Transmission km 41,800 14,500 127,100 26,000 30,000 35,900 6,700 40,000 2,600 11,000 5,2...

AI summary The document provides a comparative overview of major electricity transmission system operators and independent system operators (ISOs) across different regions, including CAISO, ISO-NE, MISO, AESO, IESO Ontario, NESO, EirGrid, AEMO, EMA, Trans-power, and Nova Scotia. It tabulates key metrics such as population served, transmission infrastructure length, installed capacity, peak load, total energy consumption, employee counts, ownership structures, and operating costs. The data highlights the scale and operational scope of these entities as of 2024-2025.

Roles and responsibilities of the benchmarked ISOs p. pp. 34-35
nchmarking group and IESO-NS in [Table 2-2.](#page-37-0) In what follows, we first provide initial takeaways. After, we briefly introduce and discuss the different roles and responsibilities outlined.

AI summary The document introduces a benchmarking analysis of Independent System Operators (ISOs), specifically focusing on the roles and responsibilities of the IESO-NS. The text indicates that the following sections will provide initial takeaways and a detailed discussion of the specific duties and responsibilities outlined for these entities.

Table 2-2: Electricity sector role benchmarking p. pp. 35-37
Table 2-2: Electricity sector role benchmarking Role Responsibility MISO ISO-NE CAISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO EirGrid AEMO EMA Transpower IESO Nova Scotia Transmission planning \overline{\mathbf{V}} \overline{\mathbf{V}} \overline{\mathbf{V...

AI summary The document presents a benchmarking table comparing the roles and responsibilities of various electricity sector entities across different jurisdictions (e.g., MISO, ISO-NE, CAISO, AESO, IESO Ontario, NESO, EirGrid, AEMO, EMA, Transpower, and IESO Nova Scotia). It evaluates key functions including transmission planning, resource procurement, capacity markets, load forecasting, reliability standards, market design, and market operation. The analysis highlights the specific capabilities and limitations of each operator, particularly regarding market settlement, congestion management, and transmission ownership.

ISO-NE MISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO Transpower p. p. 45
ISO-NE MISO AESO IESO Ontario NESO Transpower Year 2024 2024 2024 2023 FY2025 FY2025 $m USD Salaries and related benefits 154 243 70 129 153 68 Outside services 25 81 7 15 79 7 Facility and equipment costs 4 19 4 19 Hardware, software main...

AI summary The document provides a comparative analysis of operating costs for several regional transmission system operators and independent system operators, including ISO-NE, MISO, AESO, IESO Ontario, NESO, and Transpower. It details line items such as salaries, outside services, depreciation, and maintenance. Crucially, it provides a scaled estimate of these operating costs adjusted to the size of Nova Scotia's grid, alongside cost metrics like OpEx per TWh and notes regarding regulatory fees and transition costs.

3. Anticipated benefits of an ISO p. pp. 47-48
3. Anticipated benefits of an ISO - 3.1 In this chapter, we describe the benefits and costs from the establishment of an ISO. The establishment of an ISO is a step in the liberalisation or restructuring of the electricity sector. - 3.2 Unb...

AI summary The text outlines the anticipated benefits and costs associated with establishing an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia as part of the electricity sector's liberalization. Key benefits include reduced bias, increased competition, innovation, and lower consumer costs through fair grid access and technology diversity. Conversely, the text acknowledges that unbundling a vertically integrated business introduces incremental costs, including staff and equipment expenses, and a potential loss of synergies between roles.

IESO role transition p. pp. 48-49
IESO role transition 3.4 The rationale for establishing the IESO was to create an independent body with enhanced focus on the system's energy requirements.[52](#page-48-1) The IESO transition is planned in two phases (as explained in more...

AI summary The document outlines the planned two-phase transition of roles to the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). Phase 1 focuses on long-term planning and procurement functions, while Phase 2 involves real-time operations. The transition aims to create an independent body to manage system energy requirements, reducing potential bias. While operational roles will transition from Nova Scotia Power (NSP), NSP will retain ownership of the transmission system. The report intends to evaluate the benefits and cost implications of these role transfers.

Phase 1: Independent planning and competitive resource procurement p. pp. 49-52
Phase 1: Independent planning and competitive resource procurement - 3.11 For the purposes of this section, we divide Phase 1 roles transferred to IESO-NS into core roles and supporting roles. We separately categorise more discrete, indivi...

AI summary The document outlines Phase 1 of a transition involving the transfer of roles to the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). It distinguishes between 'core roles' and 'supporting roles,' focusing on the benefits of independent planning and competitive resource procurement. Key benefits identified include long-term security of supply through cost discipline in competitive procurements and the facilitation of more efficient transmission investment decisions and non-wires alternatives due to reduced perceived bias and increased trust in the planning entity.

Table 3-1: Phase 1 benefits and underlying levers p. p. 52
Table 3-1: Phase 1 benefits and underlying levers Long-term security of supply Transmission planner (1) Shifting cost overruns risk ❷ Increased competition (2) Reduced resource investment cost from competitive resource procurement (3A) Red...

AI summary The document outlines the benefits and underlying levers associated with Phase 1 of a transmission planning initiative. Key benefits include long-term security of supply, increased competition, and improved timeliness. Specific levers identified include shifting cost overrun risks, reducing resource investment costs through competitive procurement, and accelerating capital expenditure deployment for both resources and transmission. It also highlights the avoidance of carbon costs through accelerated deployment and notes that the IESO-NS's independence supports its role in these initiatives.

Table 3-2: Phase 2 benefits and underlying levers p. p. 54
Table 3-2: Phase 2 benefits and underlying levers Direct benefits from Phase 2 Scheduler, residual energy system balancer and settlement Indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles from Phase 2 Long-term security of supply Transmission planner Scal...

AI summary Table 3-2 outlines the benefits and levers associated with 'Phase 2' of a project, categorized into direct benefits, indirect benefits on Phase 1 roles, and the scaling of Phase 1 benefits. Key benefits include improved operational efficiency leading to decreased production and avoided carbon costs, as well as increased innovation and diversity through reduced capital expenditures (CapEx). Additionally, the phase is expected to foster increased competition by facilitating greater entry into competitive procurement processes.

Phase 1 incremental costs p. pp. 54-56
Phase 1 incremental costs - 3.21 It must be acknowledged that certain costs are inherent to a transition of certain tasks from a VIU to an ISO. While many costs are likely to be comparable, e.g., many computing and software costs, some are...

AI summary The text discusses the incremental costs and potential disbenefits associated with transitioning certain tasks from a Variable Independent Utility (VIU) to an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia. Key issues include one-off upfront costs like real estate, duplicate software licenses, and redundant corporate functions. Furthermore, the analysis highlights a potential loss of synergies if Phase 1 is implemented without Phase 2, as separating the planner and operator roles may hinder efficient investment decisions and increase transaction costs due to reduced operational expertise in planning.

Phase 2 incremental costs p. pp. 56-58
Phase 2 incremental costs - 3.25 Much of the cost for Phase 2 falls into the same broad categories as Phase 1, but to a larger magnitude for one-off costs associated with the control room and other capital-intensive activities. The impleme...

AI summary The text analyzes the incremental costs associated with Phase 2 of a system operator transition, noting that costs are largely similar to Phase 1 but higher due to one-off capital-intensive activities like control room modernization. It highlights a tension between restored planning and operator synergies and the potential loss of operational synergies caused by unbundling asset ownership from operation. Specifically, unbundling may lead to increased transaction costs for activities like temporary line overloading due to information gaps and negotiation requirements.

Introduction p. pp. 59-61
ceived bias in the operator's role. The disbenefit from transitioning the system operator role for NSP to the IESO is the loss of synergies between the system operator and asset owner.[61](#page-60-0) - 4.2 [Table 4-1](#page-61-0) below sh...

AI summary The text discusses the business case for transitioning the system operator role from Nova Scotia Power (NSP) to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). It highlights a potential disbenefit in the loss of synergies between the asset owner and the system operator. The analysis evaluates the Real Present Value (RPV) of benefits versus the one-off and ongoing incremental operational costs of the transition for the 2026-2050 horizon, specifically considering assets like transmission and generation.

Category Cost Category p. pp. 62-64
Category Cost Category Generation CapEx J_]~ ' ' Transmission CapEx ¥ - (1) Shifting risk of cost overruns - (2) Reduced generation cost from competitive procurement ) financial disbenefit ( deployment x E Cap Accelerated (3B) - (7) Increa...

AI summary The text analyzes the impact of various factors on Capital Expenditure (CapEx) for generation and transmission infrastructure. It identifies specific benefits and disbenefits related to competitive procurement, accelerated deployment, system planning advancements, and control room improvements. Notably, it discusses the potential for lost synergies between planners, procurers, and operators. Due to high uncertainty and long time horizons, the analysis utilizes a high and low case methodology to create a reasonable range for each impact, focusing on the midpoint for results.

(3A) Reduced production costs from accelerated deployment p. pp. 67-68
(3A) Reduced production costs from accelerated deployment - 4.27 VIUs can often experience delays in the deployment of both generation and transmission projects. We assume that under the IESO such delays will be reduced. The assumed driver...

AI summary The text analyzes how the transition to an Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) model can reduce production costs through accelerated deployment of generation and transmission projects. Key drivers include streamlined regulatory approvals by removing the need for NSEB approval on specific expenditures and faster competitive procurement processes. The analysis suggests that production costs will begin to decline materially by 2028, with project advancements ranging from 1-2 years depending on the scenario, primarily driven by the integration of lower variable-cost capacity like wind.

(3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (financial disbenefit) p. pp. 68-69
(3B) Accelerated CapEx deployment (financial disbenefit) 4.32 As discussed above, for both generation and transmission, we can expect faster construction timelines and a faster reduction of production costs relative to the counterfactual V...

AI summary The text discusses the financial implications of accelerated capital expenditure (CapEx) deployment resulting from the creation of the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO). While faster construction timelines reduce production costs compared to the counterfactual Variable Independent Utility (VIU) scenario, they create a financial disbenefit due to the time value of money. Because costs are incurred earlier, their discounted present value is higher. This effect is expected to begin in 2026, with the first realized costs occurring in 2028.

(5) Loss of synergies from planner and operator p. p. 69
(5) Loss of synergies from planner and operator 4.36 Prior to the IESO, the planner and operator functions were combined under NSP. Separating these functions – if Phase 1 only was implemented - can conceivably create additional transactio...

AI summary The document discusses the potential negative impacts of separating the planner and operator functions, which were previously combined under Nova Scotia Power (NSP). The separation may create additional transaction costs and obstruct information flows due to the loss of inherent system knowledge. These factors are expected to increase production costs by 1-2% starting in 2029, as real-time operational constraints may no longer align with long-term planning.

(5) Regained synergies from planner and operator p. p. 69
(5) Regained synergies from planner and operator 4.39 Re-combining the planner-operator function regains the synergies explained in (5) in Phase 1 above. This simply cancels out the disbenefit above.

AI summary The text addresses the structural organization of the electricity system, specifically the re-combination of the planner and operator functions. It argues that merging these roles restores synergies that were lost when they were separated, thereby nullifying the previously identified disbenefits of a split structure.

(7) Scaling effect from independent system operation: increased entry in competitive procurement p. pp. 72-73
(7) Scaling effect from independent system operation: increased entry in competitive procurement - 4.44 In a Phase 1-only IESO, a dispatch run by the incumbent NSP may deter some participation of third-party competitors in IESO-led procure...

AI summary The document discusses the benefits of establishing an independent system operator (IESO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that separating the system operator role from the incumbent utility (NSP) reduces information asymmetries and conflicts of interest, which is expected to increase third-party participation in competitive procurements and lower capital costs for new generation and storage assets starting in 2027. Additionally, it highlights that control room modernization will enable more advanced system planning for transmission and generation by providing more detailed system information.

(12) Loss of synergies between asset owner and operator (disbenefit) p. p. 74
(12) Loss of synergies between asset owner and operator (disbenefit) 4.58 The separation of asset ownership and operation creates some lost synergies, as explained in Chapter 3. This is due to the change to a contractual interface (in whic...

AI summary The document discusses the potential disbenefit of lost synergies resulting from the separation of asset ownership and operation. Transitioning from an operational interface to a contractual one is expected to create friction, leading to increased transaction and information-sharing costs. These factors are projected to cause a slight increase in production costs, estimated between 0.5% and 1%, starting in 2027 when Phase 2 begins.

Benefits and costs of Phase 1 of the creation of IESO-NS p. p. 86
Benefits and costs of Phase 1 of the creation of IESO-NS 5.6 In this section, we describe Phase 1 core roles and benefits, supporting roles and benefits, as well as incremental costs of implementation. Phase 1 core roles: timelier and effi...

AI summary The document introduces an analysis of Phase 1 of the creation of the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS). It outlines the framework for evaluating the core roles and benefits of the initiative, which include facilitating timelier and more efficient investments in transmission and energy resources, alongside the identification of supporting roles and the incremental costs associated with implementation.

Transmission planner and long-term security of supply p. pp. 86-87
Transmission planner and long-term security of supply - A1.1 The creation of an ISO in Nova Scotia has been under consideration for well over a decade.[96](#page-87-0) In recent years, public opinion of NSP as a VIU with conflicting incent...

AI summary The text discusses the ongoing debate regarding the creation of an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that Nova Scotia Power (NSP), acting as a Variable Independent Utility (VIU), faces an inherent conflict of interest between its duty to provide reliable, affordable electricity and its obligation to generate profit for shareholders. This conflict may lead to biased system planning, where the utility might delay transmission upgrades to protect its core generation business or avoid costs due to rate pressures.

Independent transmission and resource planning p. p. 88
Independent transmission and resource planning - A1.11 A potential perception of bias may lead to denials or delays of installations for which the reliability benefits do outweigh the costs.[106,](#page-90-0) [107](#page-90-1) Rather than...

AI summary The text discusses the benefits of independent transmission and resource planning, specifically highlighting how an Independent System Operator (ISO) may be perceived as less biased than a for-profit utility. This perception can lead to faster approval processes and accelerated investment in necessary transmission and generation assets. Such independence is expected to improve system production costs by facilitating the quicker deployment of lower-cost generation and creating a more efficient balance between generation and transmission infrastructure.

Market design p. pp. 90-91
Market design - A1.17 Market design includes rules and mechanisms that govern trading and access. Market access is improved by aligned incentives to find capacity for new connections and timeliness of connection responses. Vertically integ...

AI summary The text discusses market design principles, emphasizing that rules and mechanisms must govern trading and grid access fairly. It highlights how vertically integrated businesses can create barriers to entry for competitors through pricing rules and physical grid access. Specifically, it notes that market designs favoring locational signals may be resisted by network owners as they reduce the need for new assets. Additionally, the text identifies potential conflicts of interest when incumbents like Nova Scotia Power (NSP) perform feasibility and interconnection studies, potentially deterring new generation and storage projects.

Benefits and costs of Phase 2 of the creation of IESO-NS p. pp. 91-93
Benefits and costs of Phase 2 of the creation of IESO-NS - A1.25 The IESO takes on real-time operations roles in Phase 2. Much of the inherent biases and perceived conflicts of interest in operations would be eliminated with independent sy...

AI summary The document discusses Phase 2 of creating the Independent Electricity System Operator Nova Scotia (IESO-NS), focusing on the transition of real-time operations to an independent entity. The primary benefit cited is the elimination of inherent biases and perceived conflicts of interest in system operations. Phase 2 is expected to amplify the benefits of Phase 1 by providing more efficient operations through control room improvements, including roles for scheduling, residual energy system balancing, and settlement.

Optimal use of resources p. p. 93
Optimal use of resources - A1.33 For IESO-NS, the clarity of focus, increased scrutiny, and reputational risk may also incentivize innovation and operational efficiency improvements ( quantified benefit 6 ). As discussed above, an ISO does...

AI summary The text discusses the potential benefits of transitioning the system operator role from a Variable Independent Utility (VIU) to an Independent System Operator (ISO) in Nova Scotia. It argues that an ISO lacks the conflicting incentives of an owner-operator, potentially leading to more impartial dispatching, reduced system costs, and minimized renewables curtailment. The analysis highlights that a VIU may sub-optimally utilize resources to favor its own assets, whereas an ISO can focus on long-term operational efficiency and optimal real-time dispatching.

More efficient transmission and resource investment p. pp. 94-96
More efficient transmission and resource investment A1.39 Taking on the operations roles in Phase 2 can further unlock benefits in the core Phase 1 planning roles. Any improvements in operational efficiency may in the long run unlock diffe...

AI summary The text argues that assuming operational roles in Phase 2 can enhance core Phase 1 planning by unlocking operational efficiencies. These improvements could lead to reduced resource investment needs, better utilization of existing transmission infrastructure, and more informed long-term planning. Furthermore, an ISO with advanced system operation processes can facilitate more efficient resource and transmission choices within the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP), promoting a level playing field for diverse technologies like wind, storage, and non-wires alternatives while supporting clean energy goals and reducing system production costs.

Table A1-1 Benefits and cost categorisation p. p. 96
Table A1-1 Benefits and cost categorisation IESO Nova Scotia Role Outcome Benefits (🌼 y quantified in Chapter 4, and corresponding benefit number) CORE Transmission planner and long-term security of supply ■ Reduced risks borne by consumer...

AI summary The document outlines the benefits and costs associated with the roles of IESO Nova Scotia across various phases. Key benefits include reduced risks of cost overruns for consumers, more efficient transmission and resource investment, and improved system expertise. It highlights 'Key Levers' such as timeliness, removal of perceived bias, and increased innovation. Conversely, it identifies costs related to the implementation of separation, additional staffing, reduced decision-making efficiency, and potential loss of synergies and increased transaction costs between asset owners and operators.

Transmission CapEx p. p. 96
Transmission CapEx - A3.5 Transmission CapEx was informed by NSP's annual Capital Expenditure Plans filed between 2020 and 2026. The most recent plan, filed in 2026, [122](#page-103-0) includes forecast spending through 2030. Our forecast...

AI summary The document outlines the methodology for forecasting transmission capital expenditures (CapEx) through 2050. The analysis utilizes Nova Scotia Power's annual Capital Expenditure Plans (2020-2026) to establish a historic base spending Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR). It distinguishes between base spending and non-base spending, noting that non-base investments typically occur 1-2 years before new non-thermal resources come online. Figure A3-2 provides a visual comparison of historic and forecast CapEx against the 2020-2030 ACE and FTI forecasts.

(1) Shifting cost overrun risk p. p. 107
uction cost per MWh, delay it, and multiply this by the same system demand trajectory: Production cost with delays = Average production costs with delay $/MWh × Total system demand without delay MWh - A5.11 For example, in our low case wit...

AI summary The text discusses the financial modeling of cost overrun risks and the impact of project delays on production costs. It outlines a methodology for calculating 'production cost with delays' by multiplying delayed per-MWh costs by system demand trajectories. The analysis compares the financial disbenefits of delayed capital expenditures (CapEx) and transmission projects against the benefits of accelerated deployment of production cost improvements, noting that the latter is of lesser magnitude than the former in specific scenarios.

(a) General Comments p. p. 110
r its 2026 assessment costs. - M12249 EfficiencyOne 2026 DSM Extension Application Application filed by E1 seeking approval to extend its DSM Plan for an additional year beyond the prior plan term. - M12282 EfficiencyOne New Benefit Cost A...

AI summary The Consumer Advocate (CA) provides an overview of its activities and participation in various regulatory proceedings for the 2025 calendar year. Key proceedings mentioned include EfficiencyOne's DSM plan extension and benefit-cost analysis tests, the Wasoqonatl Transmission Incorporated NS-NB Reliability Tie project, NSIESO's expenditure and revenue requirements, Eastward Energy's cost recovery amendments, and Halifax Water's general rate application. The CA also highlights its involvement in several formal and informal working groups regarding fuel adjustment mechanisms and demand-side management.

(a) General Comments p. p. 110
ental Law and El should not be approved, the SBA believes that the information that it requested through the IR process and Ms. Whitten's evidence was of assistance to the Board and other intervenors. - M12217 WTI NS-NB Reliability Interti...

AI summary The Small Business Advocate (SBA) provides general comments on its participation in various proceedings, specifically highlighting its involvement in the WTI NS-NB Reliability Intertie Project. The SBA notes that its evidence regarding project costs, inter-provincial risks, and blended Return on Equity (ROE) assisted the Board's analysis. The SBA emphasizes its commitment to holding utilities accountable for providing reliable, cost-effective services while prioritizing rate stability and affordability for small business customers.

Disclaimer: These summaries were generated by AI from the filings they describe. We take care to make them accurate, but errors are possible - and they aren't advice. Only the filings themselves are the record: if you're relying on something here, confirm it against the source documents or the Nova Scotia Energy Board's own record. Full disclaimer →