Nova Scotia Power - Application for approval of an Above-the-Line Tariff applicable to Port Hawkesbury Paper (PHP)
Application for approval of the Extra Large Industrial Dispatchable (ELID) Tariff, an above-the-line- tariff available to Port Hawkesbury Paper
The hearing itself
Hearings
-
M12661 oral hearing — Port Hawkesbury Paper above-the-line tariff
What's happened
Filing Timeline
-
23 Oct
DocumentPort Hawkesbury Paper re-filed its redacted response to Undertaking U-16 at the Consumer Advocate's request, with additions tied to the transcript wording, in M12661.
-
21 Oct
Document—
-
09 Oct
DocumentRedacted undertaking responses from NS Power (U-1 to U-15, a large cost-of-service-heavy filing) and PHP (U-16 to U-21) are now available in the Port Hawkesbury Paper Above-the-Line Tariff proceeding
-
06 Oct
DocumentNSEB issues 21 undertakings to NSPI and Port Hawkesbury Paper in M12661 Above-the-Line Tariff proceeding, all due October 9, 2026
-
29 Sep
DocumentSynapse IR-24 energy-demand spreadsheets and expert CVs for Musco and Cain now available in M12661 PHP Above-the-Line Tariff proceeding
-
28 Sep
Document—
-
22 Sep
DocumentNova Scotia Power filed its ELIADC Tariff 2022 Annual Report, reporting a minimum benefit payment of $3.83 million to other customers after unprecedented fuel price volatility negated calculated active demand control savings
-
21 Sep
DocumentNova Scotia Power filed evidence corrections clarifying ELID tariff application, COSS methodology, and historical interruptibility of Port Hawkesbury Paper
-
14 Sep
DocumentOral hearing opened in M12661 as parties deliver sharply divergent opening statements on the ELID Above-the-Line Tariff for Port Hawkesbury Paper
-
11 Sep
DocumentNSEB approves virtual attendance of PHP expert witness Mr. Gorman for September 22 hearing day in M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding
-
10 Sep
DocumentNSEB orders Port Hawkesbury Paper to provide reasons before witnesses can be excused from testifying in sequence at the M12661 oral hearing scheduled for September 21–22 and 28–29, 2026
-
09 Sep
DocumentPort Hawkesbury Paper confirms two witness panels with scheduling adjustments ahead of September 21–22 oral hearing in M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding
-
08 Sep
DocumentNova Scotia Power filed its witness panel list for the M12661 ELID Tariff hearing, designating four witnesses to appear in person
-
28 Aug
DocumentNSEB sets witness sequence and four-day hearing schedule for M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding involving Port Hawkesbury Paper
-
07 Aug
DocumentNSEB issues hearing logistics letter for M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding, confirming virtual appearance of six expert witnesses
-
04 Aug
DocumentParties confirm witness attendance arrangements ahead of ELID Tariff oral hearing in M12661
-
24 Jul
DocumentConsumer Advocate requests virtual appearance for expert consultants at Port Hawkesbury Paper tariff oral hearing
-
20 Jul
DocumentNSEB converts M12661 Port Hawkesbury Paper tariff proceeding to oral hearing, scheduling four hearing days in September 2026
-
17 Jul
DocumentConsumer Advocate and Nova Scotia Power stake out opposing positions on Industrial Group's request to convert M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding to an oral hearing
-
16 Jul
DocumentIndustrial Group and Small Business Advocate request conversion of ELID tariff proceeding to oral hearing, citing competing expert opinions, unresolved factual disputes, and novel tariff complexity
-
08 Jul
DocumentPort Hawkesbury Paper and NS Power filed reply evidence defending the proposed ELID Above-the-Line Tariff against intervenor challenges to demand allocation, interruptible credits, and the Dispatchable Rider framework
-
22 Jun
RIRSynapse Energy Economics filed responses to Round 2 Information Requests from the Industrial Group, Nova Scotia Power, and Port Hawkesbury Paper in the ELID Above-the-Line Tariff proceeding
-
19 Jun
RIRNSEB approves Synapse's extension request for IR responses in M12661 ELID Tariff proceeding, with Consumer Advocate responses to PHP and IG information requests filed same day
-
18 Jun
RIRBates White Economic Consulting filed responses to Round 1 Information Requests in NSPI's ELID Tariff proceeding, clarifying that the Power Sales Agreement disrupts cost recovery despite no identified inconsistency with the tariff proposal
The filings themselves
Documents
Key documents
2 files
- 100679 Hearing Order
- 100680 Notice of Paper Hearing
Exhibits
85 files
- N-1 Application
- N-1(i) Attachment 2 - 2026-2027 GRA CA IR-001 Att 05 with PHP Rate Design EO
- N-2 Evidence of Colin T. Fitzhenry & Michael P Gorman - Brucaker & Associates Inc. on behalf of PHP
- N-3 Evidence - PHP
- N-4 NSPI (BW) RIR 1 to 14 - Redacted
- N-4(C) NSPI (BW) RIR 1 to 14 - Confidential
- N-4(C)-(i) NSPI (BW) RIR 11 Att 01 - Excel - Confidential
- N-5 NSPI (CA) RIR 1 to 9 - Redacted
- N-5(C) NSPI (CA) RIR 1 to 9 - Confidential
- N-5-(i) NSPI (CA) IR 2 Attachment 3 - Excel
- N-6 NSPI (IG) RIR 1 to 31 - Redacted
- N-6(C) NSPI (IG) RIR 1-31 - Confidential
- N-6(C)-(i) NSPI (IG) RIR 7 - Excels - Confidential
- N-6(C)-(ii) NSPI (IG) RIR 13 - Excels - Confidential
- N-7 NSPI (NSEB) RIR 1 to 6
- N-8 NSPI (PHP) RIR 1 to 6
- N-9 NSPI (SBA) RIR 1 to 8 - Redacted
- N-9(C) NSPI (SBA) RIR 1 to 8 - Confidential
- N-10 NSPI (Synapse) RIR 1 to 30 - Redacted
- N-10(C) NSPI (Synapse) RIR 1 to 30 - Confidential
- N-10(C)-(i) NSPI (Synapse) RIR Attachments - Excels - Confidential
- N-10-(ii) NSPI (Synapse) IR 23 Attachment 1 - Excel
- N-11 PHP (BW) RIR 1 to 4
- N-12 PHP (CA) RIR 1 to 7
- N-13 PHP (IG) RIR 1 to 11
- N-13(C)-(i) PHP (IG) RIR 8(a) Excel - Confidential
- N-14 PHP (NSEB) RIR 1 to 2
- N-15 PHP (NSPI) RIR 1 to 13 - Redacted
- N-15(C) PHP (NSPI) RIR 1 to 13 - Confidential
- N-16 PHP (SBA) RIR 1 to 8
- N-16(C)-(i) PHP (SBA) Attachments - Excels - Confidential
- N-17 PHP (Synapse) RIR 1 to 5
- N-17-(i) PHP (Synapse) IR-2 - Attachment 1
- N-18 Materials from ELID Tariff Technical Conference
- N-19 Evidence - Intergroup Consultants (CA)
- N-20 Evidence - BW - Redacted
- N-20(C) Evidence - BW - Confidential
- N-21 Evidence - Synapse
- N-21-(i) Appendix A - Whited CV
- N-22 RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (BW) RIR 1 to 10 - (Filed as N-2 in Matter M12768) - Redacted
- N-22(C) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (BW) RIR 1 to 10 - (Filed as N-2(C) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-22(C)-(i) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (BW) IR-02 Att 01 - Excel - (Filed as N-2(C)(i) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-22(C)-(ii) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (BW) IR-06 Att 01 - Excel - (Filed as N-2(C)(ii) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-22(C)-(iii) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (BW) IR-07 Att 01 - Excel - (Filed as N-2(C)(iii) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-23 RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (IG) RIR 1 to 15 - (Filed as N-3 in Matter M12768) - Redacted
- N-23(C) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (IG) RIR 1 to 15 - (Filed as N-3(C) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-23(C)-(i) RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (IG) RIR-05 Att 01 - Excel - (Filed as N-3(C)(i) in Matter M12768) - Confidential
- N-24 RIRs filed from M12768 - NSPI (SBA) RIR 1 to 4 - (Filed as N-4 in Matter M12768)
- N-25 Evidence - Bowman Economic Consulting (IG)
- N-26 BW (PHP) RIR 1 to 4
- N-27 BW (SBA) RIR 1 to 2
- N-28 IG (PHP) RIR 1 to 8
- N-29 CA (IG) RIR 1 to 7
- N-30 CA (PHP) RIR 1 to 6
- N-31 BW (IG) RIR 1 to 14 - Redacted
- N-31(C) BW (IG) RIR 1 to 14 - Confidential
- N-32 BW (NSPI) RIR 1
- N-33 Synapse (IG) IR 1 to 6
- N-34 Synapse (NSPI) RIR 1
- N-35 Synapse (PHP) RIR 1 to 3
- N-36 Reply Evidence of Colin Fitzhenry and Michael Gorman, on behalf of PHP
- N-37 Reply Evidence of Bevan Lock and John Esaiw, on behalf of PHP
- N-38 Reply Evidence - NS Power
- N-39 Opening Statement - NS Power
- N-40 Opening Statement - CA
- N-41 Opening Statement - PHP
- N-42 Opening Statement - BAI (on behalf of PHP)
- N-43 Opening Statement - IG
- N-44 Opening Statement - Patrick Bowman (on behalf of IG)
- N-45 Opening Statement - SBA
- N-46 PHP 4-01, Intervenor Requests for 2026-2027 GRA
- N-47 2026-2027 GRA Intervenor Data Requests IG 5-12
- N-48 NS Power Evidence Corrections (Comment on IRs)
- N-49 NSP's letter from March 1, 2023
- N-50 Copy of Settlement DR PHP 4-01 Att 01
- N-51 PHP Aide to Cross - Synapse IR-24 Attachment 1
- N-52 Vincent Musco's CV
- N-53 Collin Cain's CV
- N-54 Response to Undertakings 16-21 - PHP - Redacted
- N-54(C) Response to Undertakings 16-21 - PHP - Confidential
- N-55 Response to Undertakings 1-15 - NSPI - Redacted
- N-55(C) Response to Undertakings 1-15 - NSPI - Confidential
- N-55(C)-(ii) Response to Undertakings 1-15 - NSPI - Excels - Confidential
- N-55-(i) Response to Undertakings 1-15 - NSPI - Excels
- N-56 Refiled Undertaking U-16 - PHP
Interventions
6 files
- 100692 Notice of Intervention - E1
- 100715 Notice of Intervention - IG
- 100726 Notice of Intervention - SBA
- 100755 Notice of Intervention - CA
- 100756 Notice of Intervention - IESO NS
- 100773 Notice of Intervention - PHP
Other documents
71 files
- 100679 Hearing Order
- 100680 Notice of Paper Hearing
- 100790 Participant List
- 101202 Email IG re: Requesting one day extension to file IRs
- 101203 SBA (NSPI) IR 1 to 8 - PDF
- 101204 SBA (NSPI) IR 1 to 8 - Word
- 101205 SBA (PHP) IR 1 to 8 - PDF
- 101206 SBA (PHP) IR 1 to 8 - Word
- 101208 Board letter re: IG Extension approval
- 101210 NSEB (NSPI) IR 1 to 6 - PDF
- 101211 NSEB (NSPI) IR 1 to 6 - Word
- 101212 NSEB (PHP) IR 1 to 2 - PDF
- 101213 NSEB (PHP) IR 1 to 2 - Word
- 101214 CA (NSPI) IR 1 to 9 - PDF
- 101215 CA (NSPI) IR 1 to 9 - Word
- 101216 CA (PHP) IR 1 to 7 - PDF
- 101217 CA (PHP) IR 1 to 7 - Word
- 101218 Letter NSPI re: IRs & Confidential treatment
- 101219 Confidential Undertaking
- 101220 NSPI (PHP) IR 1 to 13 - PDF - Redacted
- 101221 NSPI (PHP) IR 1 to 13 - PDF - Confidential
- 101222 Synapse (PHP) IR 1 to 5 - PDF
- 101223 Synapse (PHP) IR 1 to 5 - Word
- 101224 Synapse (NSPI) IR 1 to 30 - PDF
- 101225 Synapse (NSPI) IR 1 to 30 - Word
- 101226 PHP (NSPI) IR 1 to 6 - PDF
- 101227 PHP (NSPI) IR 1 to 6 - Word
- 101231 Bates White (NSPI) IR 1 to 14 - PDF
- 101232 Bates White (NSPI) IR 1 to 14 - Word
- 101233 Bates White (PHP) IR 1 to 4 - PDF
- 101234 Bates White (PHP) IR 1 to 4 - Word
- 101236 IG (NSPI) IR 1 to 31 - PDF
- 101237 IG (NSPI) IR 1 to 31 - Word
- 101238 IG (PHP) IR 1 to 11 - PDF
- 101239 IG (PHP) IR 1 to 11 - Word
- 101547 Email PHP re: RIRs and request for confidentiality
- 101550 Letter NSPI re: RIRs & confidential treatment
- 101741 Letter NSPI re: Technical Confrence materials filing
- 101746 Board letter re: Technical Conference date change
- 102054 SBA (BW) IRs 1-2
- 102058 NSPI (BW) IR-1
- 102059 NSPI (Synapse) IR-1
- 102060 IG (Synpase) IRs 1-6
- 102061 IG (InterGroup-CA) IRs 1-7
- 102062 IG (BW) IRs 1-14 - Redacted
- 102063 IG (BW) IRs 1-14 - Confidential
- 102064 PHP (BW) IRs 1-4
- 102065 PHP (Synapse) IRs 1-3
- 102066 PHP (InterGroup-CA) IRs 1-6
- 102067 PHP (Bowman-IG) IRs 1-8
- 102443 Email Board Counsel re: Extesion request for Synapse RIRs
- 102444 Email NSEB re: Approval for Synspse's RIRs
- 102802 Letter IG re: Request oral hearing
- 102804 Letter SBA re: Request oral hearing
- 102813 Letter CA re: Oral Hearing
- 102828 Email PHP re: Response to boards email re oral hearing
- 102833 Letter NSPI re: Response to oral hearing request
- 102852 Board letter re: Proceeding with oral hearing / hearing dates / further timeline dates
- 102931 Letter CA re: Virtual appearance request
- 103055 Letter IG re: Virtual attendance request
- 103056 Letter NSPI re: Confirms that none of its witnesses intend to appear virtually
- 103057 Email PHP re: Confirms that non of it's witnesses intend to appear virtually
- 103107 Email Board Counsel re: Virtual appearance
- 103138 Board letter re: Hearing Logistics
- 103368 Email NSEB re: Sequence of Hearing
- 103469 Witness Panel List - NS Power
- 103492 Email from PHP re witness panels
- 103507 Email NSEB re: Response to PHPs email about witness being called in certain order
- 103546 NSEB email re: Approved virtual attendance of Mr. Gorman (PHP)
- 103796 Undertaking List
- 104075 Email PHP re: Refiled Undertaking Response for U-16
Transcripts
5 files
- 20260921-1 Hearing Transcript — 09/21/2026 (MICHAEL WILLETT, ERIC FERGUSON, CRAIG MOWATT, DAVID STANFORD)
- 20260922-1 Hearing Transcript — 09/22/2026 (MICHAEL WILLETT, ERIC FERGUSON, CRAIG MOWATT, DAVID STANFORD, MICHAEL GORMAN, COLIN FITZHENRY)
- 20260928-1 Hearing Transcript — 09/28/2026 (BEVAN LOCK, JOHN ESAIW, ANDREW McLAREN, HAYITBOY MAHMUDOV)
- 20260929-1 Hearing Transcript — 09/29/2026 (ANDREW McLAREN, HAYITBOY MAHMUDOV, PATRICK BOWMAN, MELISSA WHITED, VINCENT MUSCO, COLLIN CAIN)
- 20261021-1 Hearing Transcript — 10/21/2026 (MICHAEL WILLETT, ERIC FERGUSON, CRAIG MOWATT, DAVID STANFORD)
Recordings
4 files
- 20260921-1 M12661 - formal hearing - day 1
- 20260922-1 M12661 - Formal Hearing - Day 2
- 20260928-1 M12661 - Formal hearing - Day 3
- 20260929-1 M12661 - formal hearing - Day 4
What's discussed — click to drill in
Topics
Rate Design
633 passages across 87 documents
Rates And Money
611 passages across 80 documents
Demand Side Management
584 passages across 75 documents
Rate Rider
456 passages across 102 documents
Tariff Design
405 passages across 92 documents
Cost Considerations
357 passages across 48 documents
Cost Recovery
295 passages across 66 documents
Energy Efficiency Budgets
263 passages across 45 documents
Rate Base
257 passages across 25 documents
Revenue Requirement
255 passages across 49 documents
Fuel Cost Adjustment
226 passages across 43 documents
Regulatory Approval Processes
210 passages across 75 documents
Capacity Costs
200 passages across 46 documents
Operating Expenses
182 passages across 11 documents
Energy Efficiency
179 passages across 34 documents
Distribution
177 passages across 4 documents
Depreciation Amortization
166 passages across 7 documents
Eliadc Tariff
165 passages across 54 documents
Cost To Customer
146 passages across 33 documents
Distribution Planning
135 passages across 9 documents
Generation Grid Resources
131 passages across 15 documents
Energy Efficiency Resource Assessment Model
127 passages across 20 documents
Transmission Planning
125 passages across 14 documents
Financial Instruments
122 passages across 8 documents
Renewable Energy
122 passages across 34 documents
Capital Expenditures
115 passages across 9 documents
Energy Efficiency Financing
109 passages across 16 documents
System Reliability
107 passages across 30 documents
Dcrr
97 passages across 36 documents
Accounting Policies
93 passages across 10 documents
Cost Deferral
83 passages across 23 documents
Affordability
72 passages across 25 documents
Regulatory Oversight
66 passages across 35 documents
Infrastructure Planning
61 passages across 12 documents
Corporate Adjustments
60 passages across 5 documents
Rate Smoothing Adjustment
51 passages across 24 documents
Asset Retirement Obligation
50 passages across 4 documents
Energy Storage
48 passages across 12 documents
Load Management
41 passages across 19 documents
Electricity Generation
40 passages across 10 documents
Energy Efficiency Resource Standards
40 passages across 7 documents
Debt Service Coverage Ratio
34 passages across 5 documents
Power Purchase Agreement
33 passages across 20 documents
Public Utilities Act Nova Scotia
30 passages across 25 documents
Accounting Standards
28 passages across 7 documents
Regulatory Compliance
28 passages across 18 documents
Customer Service
27 passages across 3 documents
Energy Management Information Systems
26 passages across 11 documents
Corporate Taxes
24 passages across 3 documents
Energy Efficiency Codes
23 passages across 5 documents
Stakeholder Engagement
22 passages across 16 documents
System Benefits Charge
22 passages across 7 documents
Forecasting Methodology
21 passages across 16 documents
Capacity Market Participation
20 passages across 12 documents
Legal Costs
19 passages across 4 documents
Taxes
19 passages across 4 documents
Energy Efficiency Conservation Agreement
18 passages across 4 documents
Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard Eeps
18 passages across 4 documents
Energy Usage Patterns
16 passages across 11 documents
Confidentiality
15 passages across 12 documents
Demand Side Management Purchase Agreement
15 passages across 10 documents
Information Disclosure
15 passages across 13 documents
Power Infrastructure
14 passages across 7 documents
Affordable Multifamily Housing And Non Profit Organizations Amf
13 passages across 5 documents
Grid Modernization
13 passages across 8 documents
Return On Equity
12 passages across 8 documents
Asset Management
11 passages across 4 documents
Transfer Function Cost Factor
11 passages across 4 documents
Demand Side Management Resource Plan
10 passages across 6 documents
Generator Interconnection
10 passages across 8 documents
Electric Resource Assessment Model
8 passages across 3 documents
Hearing Procedures
8 passages across 7 documents
Incentive Structures
8 passages across 7 documents
Resource Costs
8 passages across 6 documents
Billing Procedures
7 passages across 4 documents
Environmental Compliance
7 passages across 5 documents
Procurement Practices
7 passages across 6 documents
Renewable Electricity Regulations
7 passages across 6 documents
Cybersecurity
6 passages across 5 documents
Electricity Efficiency And Conservation Act Nova Scotia
6 passages across 4 documents
Financing Alternatives
6 passages across 4 documents
Program Evaluation
6 passages across 6 documents
Reasonableness Review
6 passages across 4 documents
Demand Side Management Advisory Group
5 passages across 2 documents
Compliance Legislation
4 passages across 3 documents
Customer Research
4 passages across 3 documents
Energyforward New Homes
4 passages across 3 documents
Evidence Requirements
4 passages across 4 documents
Integrated Resource Plan
4 passages across 4 documents
Multi Year Planning Cycle
4 passages across 4 documents
Securitization
4 passages across 4 documents
Boards Regulatory Rules
3 passages across 3 documents
Cap And Trade
3 passages across 3 documents
Cost Effectiveness
3 passages across 2 documents
Energy And Regulatory Boards Act
3 passages across 2 documents
Intervenor Participation
3 passages across 3 documents
Programs And Customers
3 passages across 3 documents
Prudence Reviews
3 passages across 3 documents
Surplus Return
3 passages across 3 documents
Advanced Metering Infrastructure
2 passages across 1 documents
Biomass Chp
2 passages across 2 documents
Comfit
2 passages across 2 documents
Contract Terms
2 passages across 2 documents
Electricity Efficiency And Conservation Restructuring 2014 Act
2 passages across 2 documents
Emergency Response
2 passages across 2 documents
Environmental Goals And Climate Change Reduction Act
2 passages across 2 documents
Equity Access
2 passages across 2 documents
Incentive Costs
2 passages across 2 documents
Legal Procedures
2 passages across 2 documents
Market Transformation
2 passages across 2 documents
Nova Scotia Greenhouse Gas Emissions Regulations
2 passages across 2 documents
Planned Outage
2 passages across 2 documents
Planning Reserve Margin
2 passages across 2 documents
Policy And Legislation
2 passages across 2 documents
Prudency Review
2 passages across 2 documents
Prudency Reviews
2 passages across 2 documents
Residential Demand Response Program
2 passages across 1 documents
2023-2026 DSM Plan
1 passages across 1 documents
2027-2031 Demand Side Management Preferred Resource Plan
1 passages across 1 documents
Affiliate Transactions
1 passages across 1 documents
Afudc
1 passages across 1 documents
Appeal Processes
1 passages across 1 documents
Audit Processes
1 passages across 1 documents
Budgets And Targets
1 passages across 1 documents
Building Regulations
1 passages across 1 documents
Carbon Capture Utilization And Storage
1 passages across 1 documents
Climate Adaptation
1 passages across 1 documents
Community Feed In Tariff
1 passages across 1 documents
Credit Ratings
1 passages across 1 documents
Distributed Energy Resources
1 passages across 1 documents
Fuel Adjustment Mechanism
1 passages across 1 documents
Homewarming
1 passages across 1 documents
Income Tax
1 passages across 1 documents
Indigenous Communities
1 passages across 1 documents
National Energy Code For Buildings
1 passages across 1 documents
Performance Monitoring
1 passages across 1 documents
Project Schedule
1 passages across 1 documents
Property Assessed Clean Energy
1 passages across 1 documents
Residential Programs
1 passages across 1 documents
Residential Solar Pv Program
1 passages across 1 documents
Standardized Filing
1 passages across 1 documents
Unplanned Outage
1 passages across 1 documents
Upfront Costs
1 passages across 1 documents